Yorkville enquirer. [volume] (Yorkville, S.C.) 1855-2006, July 13, 1915, Image 1
ISSUED SEMI-WKEKL^ ^ _______
l. m. grist's sous. Pnbii.hen. } % c^aatjlg SJieicspape^: Jfor fhij promotion of <h$ political, ^oqtal, ^jrieultuqal and Commercial interests of the |eopt<. j
ESTABLISHED 1855. YOHKV1LLK, S. C., TUMSDAY, .) LILY 18, It >1.5. XO. r>(i.
MoDl
S-rmc
ILLlJ5TMriO%
CHAPTER V. |
While Griswold was grappling
th? nrohlt?m of escat-e. and I
planning to desert the Belle Julie at
the next landing, Charlotte Farnham
was sitting behind the locked door of
her stateroom with a writing pad on
her knee over which for many minutes
the suspended pen merely hovered.
She had fancied that her resolve,
once fairly taken, would not
stumble over a simple matter of detail.
But when she had tried a dozen
times to begin the letter to Mr. Galbraith,
the simplicities vanished and
complexity stood in their room.
Try as she might to put the sham
deck-hand into his proper place as an
impersonal unit of a class with which
society is at war, he previously refused
to surrender his individuality.
At the end of every fresh effort she
was confronted by the inexorable summing-up:
in a word of phantoms there
were only two real persons; a man
who had sinned and a woman who was
about to make him pay the penalty.
It was all very well to reason about i
It, and to say that he ought to be
made to pay the penalty; but that did
not make it any less shocking that
she, Charlotte Fhrnham, should be the :
one to set the retributive machinery
in motion. Yet she knew she had the
thing to do, and so, after many in- i
effectual attempts, the letter was written
and sealed and addressed, and rhe
went out to mail it at the clerk's office.
As it chanced, the engines of the
steamer were slowing for a landing
when she latched her stateroom door. 1
The doors giving upon the forward
saloon deck were open, and she heard i
the harsh voice of the mate exploding i
in sharp commands as the steamer
lost way and edged slowly up to the 1
river bank. A moment later she was i
outside, leaning on the rail and look- i
ing down upon the crew grouped about I
the inboard end of the uplifted landing i
stage. He was there; the man for <
whose destiny accident and the conventional
sense of duty had made her 1
responsible; and as she looked she
had a fleeting glimpse of his face.
It was curiously haggard and wobegone;
so sorrowfully changed that
for an instant she almost doubted his
identity. The sudden transformation
added fresh questionings, and she began
to ask herself thoughtfully what
had brought it about. Then the man
turned slowly and looked up at her as
if the finger of her thought had
touched him. There was no sign of
recognition in his eyes; and she constrained
herself to gaze down upon
him coldly. But when Belie Julie's
bow touched the bank, and the wait- 1
ing crew melted suddenly into a tenu- 1
ous line of burden-bearers, she fled
through the deserted saloon to her
stateroom and hid the fatal letter under
the pillows in her berth.
That evening, after dinner, she
went forward with some of the other
passengers to the railed promenade i
wViir?V* woa thft onmmnn PVAninc rpn
dezvous. The Belle Julie had tied up 1
at a small town on the western bank
of the great river, and the ant pro- i
cession of roustabouts was in motion, 1
going laden up the swing stage and returning
empty by the foot plank. I^eft
to herself for a moment, Charlotte
faced the rail and again sought to
single out the man whose fate she
must decide.
She distinguished him presently; a
grimy, perspiring unit in the crew
tramping back and forth mechanically,
staggering under the heaviest
loads, and staring stonily at the back
of his file leader in endless round; a
picture of misery and despair. Charlotte
thought, and she was turning
away with the dangerous rebellion
against the conventions swelling in her
heart when Capt. Mayfleld joined her.
"I just wanted to show you," he
said; and he pointed out a gang of
men repairing a slip in the levee embankment
below the town landing. It
was a squad of prisoners in chains.
The figures of the convicts were
struck out sharply against the dark
background of undergrowth and the
reflection of the sunset glow on the
river lighted up their sullen faces and
burnished the use-worn links in their
leg-fetters.
"The chaingang," said the captain,
briefly. "That's about where the fellow
that robbed the Bayou State Security
will bring up, if they catch him.
He'll have to be mighty tough and
well-seasoned if he lives to worry
through twenty years of that, don't
you think?"
But Miss Farnham could not answer:
and even the unobservant captain
of river boats saw that she was
moved and was sorry he hail spoken.
In nnv noth c\t norfnrmnnr?D thppn
is but ono step which is irrevocable,
namely, the final one. and in Charlotte
Karnham's hesetment this step was the
mailing of the letter to Mr. Galbraith.
Many times during the evening she
wrought herself up to the plunging
point, only to recoil on the very brink:
and when at length she gave up the
struggle and went to bed. the sealed
letter was still under her pillow.
Now it is a well accepted truism
that an exasperated sense of duty,
like remorse and grief, fights best in
the night watches. It was of no avail
to protest that her intention was still
unshaken. Conscience urged that delay
was little less culpable than refusal,
since every hour gave the criminal
an added chance of escape. The minutes
dragged leaden-winged, and to
sit quietly in the silence and solitude
of the great saloon became a nerveracking
impossibility. When it went
past endurance, she rose and stepped
out upon the promenade deck.
The Itelle Julio was approaching
a landing. The electric searchlight
eye on the hurricane deck was just
over her head, and its great white
cone seemed to hiss as it poured its
dazzling flood of fictitious noonday up
3d
15 EOT
'CDBIODB
CCPY/f/GffT BY O/AfiUJ 3CMBSt?*S 30*3
on the shelving river bank and the
sleeping hamlet beyond. Out of the
dusky underglow came the freight
carriers, giving birth to a file of grotesque
shadow monsters as they swung
up the plank into the field of the
searchlight.
The footplank had been drawn in,
the steam winch was clattering, and
the landing stage had begun to come
aboard, when the two men whose duty
it was to cast off ran out on the tilting
stage and dropped from its shore end.
One of them fell clumsily, tried to
rise, and sank back into the shadow;
but the other scrambled up the steep
bank and loosened the half-hatches in
the wet hawser. With the slackening
of the line the steamer began to move
out into the stream, and the man at
the mooring post looked around to
see what had become of his companion.
"Get a move on youse!" bellowed
the mate; but instead of obeying, the
man ran back and went on his knees
beside the huddled figure in the
shadow.
At this point the watcher on the
promenade deck began vaugely to understand
that the first man was disabled
in some way, and that the other
was trying to lift him. While she
looked the engine-room bells jangled
and the wheels began to turn. The mate
forgot her and swore out of a full heart.
She put her fingers in her ears to
shut out the clamor of abusive profanity;
but the man on the bank paid
no attention to the richly emphasized
command to come aboard. Instead, he
ran swiftly to the mooring post, took
a double turn of the trailing hawser
around it and stood by until the straining
line snubbed the steamer's bow
to the shore. Then, deftly casting off
again, he darted back to the disabled
man, hoisted him bodily to the high
guard, and clambered aboard himself;
all this while McGrath was brushing
the impending crew aside to get at him.
Charlotte saw every move of the
quick-witted salvage in the doing, and
wanted to cry out in sheer enthuslusm
when it was done. Then, in the light
from the furnace doors, she saw the
face of the chief actor; it was the face
of the man with the stubble beard.
She could not hear what McGrath
was saying, but she could read hot
wrath in his gestures, and in the way
the men fell back out of his reach.
All but one; the stubble-bearded white
man was facing him fearlessly, and he
appeared to be trying to explain.
Griswold was trying to explain, but'
the bullying first officer would not let
him. It was a small matter; with the
money gone, and the probability that
capture and arrest were deferred only
from landing to landing, a little abuse,
more or less, counted as nothing. But
he was grimly determined to keep McGrath
from laying violent hands upon
the negro who had twisted his ankle
In jumping from the uplifted landingstage.
"No; this is one time when you
don't skin anybody alive!" he retorted,
when a break in the stream of abuse
gave him a chance. "You let the man
alone. He couldn't help it. Do you
suppose he sprained an ankle purposely
to give you a chance to curse him
out?"
The mate's reply was a brutal kick
at the crippled negro. Griswold came
closer. '
"Don't try that again!" he warned,
angrily. "If you've got to take it out
on somebody, I'm your man.
This was mutiny, and McGrath's
remedy for that distemper was ever
heroic. In a flash his big fist shot out
and the crew looking to see its lighter
champion go backward into the river
at the impact. But the blow did not
land. Griswold saw it coming and
swerved the necessary body-breadth.
The result was a demonstration of a
simple theorem in dynamics. McGrath
reeled under the impetus of his own
unresisted effort, stumbled forward
against the low edge-line bulwark,
clawed wildly at the tickle air and
dropped overboard like a stone.
The Belle Julie was forging ahead
at full speed. Clearing the intervening
obstacles in a hurler's leap, Griswold
raced aft on the outer edge of the
guards and jumped overboard in time
to grapple the drowning man when he
was within a few feet of the churning
wheel. The mate was terror-crazed
and fought blindly. There was no
time for trick or stratagem, and when
the thunder of the wheel roared overhead,
Griswold felt the jar of a blow
and the mate's struggles ceased abruptly.
A gasping moment later the
worst was over and the rescuer had
his head out; was swimming gallantly
in the wake of the steamer, supporting
the unconscious McGrath and shouting
lustily for help.
The help came quickly. The alarm
had been promptly given, and the
night pilot was a man for an emergency.
Before the little-used yawl
could be lowered, the steamer had
swept a wide circle in mid stream and
the searchlight picked up the castaways.
From that to placing the Belle
Julie so that the two bits of human
flotsam could be hauled in over the
bows was but a skilful hand's turn of
rudder-work, accomplished as cleverly
as if the great steamboat bad been a
power-driven launch to be steered by
a touch of the tiller.
All this Charlotte saw. She was
kioiniiik on hiipii lilt- iwu mrii nnc
dragged aboard, the big Irishman still
unconscious, and the rescuer in the
final ditch of exhaustion?breathless,
sodden, reeling with weariness.
And afterward, when the Belle
Julie's prow was once more turned to
the north. Miss Franham Hew back to
her stateroom with the letetr to Mr.
Galbraith hidden in her bosom and
clutched tightly as if she were afraid
it might cry out its accusing secret of
its own accord.
(To Be Continued.)
THE LAWYER ANDTHE PEOPLE
Civic Problems and How They Are
to be Met.
ADDRESS BV CHIEF JUSTICE GARY.
Able and Illuminating Discussion of
Serious Civic Problems and Wise
Suggestions as to How the Same are
to be Met?What the Lawyers May
Do in Behalf of the Public Service if
they Will Live Up to their Opportunities.
The principal address in connection
with the dedication of the York county
courthouse today, was that of the
Hon. Eugene B. Gary, of Abbeville,
chief justice of the supreme court or
South Carolina. This address conveys
a message well worth the while of
those who would improve existing
civic conditions, and the text of it is
hereby presented in full:
Mr, Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen:
Before proceeding to deliver the
message which we have brought you
today, we bespeak your permission to
make a few preliminary remarks.
When the Queen of Sheba visited
King Solomon, she said, after listening
to his words of wisdom and seeing
the magnificent temple which he had
Just erected: "Behold, the half was
not told to me;" and, such is our condition
today, as we behold the new
and beautiful temple, which the people
of York county have wisely erected.
When the kindly and most highly
appreciated invitation to address you
on this occasion was accepted, we were
uncertain what should be our subject.
It occurred to us that we might
devote a considerable part of our alloted
time in discussing the battle of
King's Mountain, which, in its results,
was one of the great battles of the
world; but we found that there was
nothing to be added to the historical
information, which had been given by
great writers and eloquent orators on
several occasions, devoted to that subject.
It then occurred to us that it would
be well to give a sketch of the members
of your bar, which has been
famous from its earliest history, but
we remembered, at once, that we had
been forestalled by an eminent jurist,
who now adorns the supreme court of
South Carolina, and is adding new
laurels to those which he had won, as
an able and conscientious circuit
judge.
When the distinguished orator from
Virginia, Hon. John W. Daniels, delivered
the centennial address at
King's Mountain on the 7th of October,
1880, he commenced his oration
with these words:
"My Countrymen: Upon this spot
one hundred years ago, this day, was
a great battle of the people, fought
by the people alone.
"There was not a bayonet; not a
cannon. There was no martial music.
There was no gilded banner. There
was no chaplain. There was no ambulance
or wag;on. There was no general
officer. There was not a single regular
soldier in the army of victory. There
were men here, and they did a deed
for which all mankind should be
grateful, and which the ages will remember.
Before the battle, mothers,
wives and sisters lingered by the sides
of sons, husbands and brothers, assisting
in the last detail of slender
preparation, in giving the farewell
kiss that would grow in the hearths,
and send the electric thrills along
their arms on the day of battle."
There were men then, and we still
need those who are men, in solving
the great social, economic and political
problems that are now confronting
us.
Let us pray that:
"God give us men; a time like this
demands
Strong minds, great hearts, true faith
and ready hands;
Men whom the lust of office cannot
kill;
Men whom the spoils of office cannot
buy,
Men who have honor, men who will
not lie;
Men wno can stand before a demagogue,
And damn his treacherous flatteries
without winking;
Tall men, sun-crowned, who live above
the fog,
In public duty and private thinking."
The words uttered in regard to the
mothers, wives and daughters, who
assisted, in the battle of King's Mountain,
cause us to digress for a moment,
to mention another brave woman.
When Preston S. Brooks introduced
a bill in congress for the pension of
one of Edgefield's patriotic daughters,
who had lost her husband and
her three sons in the Mexican war,
he narrated the fact, that three centuries
ago, when border feuds were
common, a maiden born on the shore
of Lake Constance, had gone to seek
her fortune in Switzerland, and learning
by accident, in the family in which
she was residing, that an assault was
intended upon her native village,
under the cover of night, she took a
horse and swam the current of the
Rhine, and by her timely warning,
saved her birthplace and her people
from sack and slaughter.
An equestran monument was erected
in her honor, but her heroism
is to this day commemorated by a
memorial more touching. Each night
as the watchman goes his round, when
the hour of midnight arrives, he calls
aloud the name of her who, three
hundred years before, awoke the
sleeping inhabitants, and rescued them
from danger. The historian appropriately
says that the fame and memory
of that girl has given a tone and
spirit to the youth of that little town,
which is worth, in its defense, a battalion
of armed men.
Those who have read Ben Hur will
recall the mysterious manner in which
the three men from different parts of
the world met as if by Providence. It
has its counterpart in the manner in
which the scattered men of the wilderness
met at King's Mountain. It
seemed as if some masonry of the
woods had given the watch-word to
the dwellers?as if the lightnings had
t'uiivtryw lit uirui uir 9ik?9 uiatress
from their brethren, and the
wings of the wind had borne them an
answer.
When the flag of the Confederacy
was furled, Father Ryan in one of his
beautiful poems tells us that, "Out of
the gloom future brightness is born;
as after the night comes the sunrise
of morn."
Tradition tells u.? that out of the
gloom which we have mentioned, future
brightness was born by reason
of the fact that the men of York county
became the leaders of a mysterious
organization, which caused many
of them to leave the state for the
time being, in order to avoid prosecution
under the Federal statutes, but
that this organization struck terror into
the political leaders among the
negroes, and saved the state, eventually,
from negro domination.
When we behold the industrial
progress of your county, and realize
the grand work which Winthrop college
is doing throughout the country,
of which you and South Carolina have
just grounds to be proud, it is evident
that after the night has come the
sunrise of morn.
Permit me to say that it would be
an injustice to speak of Winthrop
college without mentioning in praise
the magnificent work of its president,
who has done so much to keep up its
high standard and usefulness. I need
not sa> that 1 refer to President I).
Ft. Johnson.
Allow me, in concluding my preliminary
remarks, to congratulate the
people of your county on the magnificent
temple which they have erected
to justice, and to say that the thanks
of the people are due to Hon. Thomas
F. McDow, who introduced the bill allowing
the people an opportunity of
voting on the issuing of bonds for
I building the new courthouse; also to
Senator W. H. Stewart, and Representatives
J. H. Saye and J. E. Beamguard
and O. L. Sanders, who assisted
in the passage of the bill. Nor can
too much praise be given to Hon. J. S.
Brice, chairman of the courthouse
!?????. 4 Mjkoovxa W Q
|| LUI11111 laaiuu,?anu ro?nn- oaro^ * ? .
I Wilkerson of Hickory Grove, and Jno.
I G. Anderson of Rock Hill, the other
I members of the commission, for the
faithful and able manner in which they
I have executed the trust confided to
I them.
The subject we have selected is:
The Lawyer and the People.
There is no doubt that we are face
to face with political conditions and
changes which may have a profound
effect upon the political future of our
country. We will enumerate some of
I the causes that are tending to bring
about such a result:
First Delay in the administration
of justice, and the resort to technicalities
by which justice is frequently
denied and defeated.
This can be remedied by the cooperation
of the bench and bar, on
the one hand, and the legislature on
.
vs.
Ml '
n
HON. EUGENI
Chief Justice of the Spren
the other, in giving to the presiding
judge full discretion as to all matters
except the substantive law, which
do not affect the merits of the- case. It
is only necessary to adopt in the main,
the English practice in this respect.
The judges should not be required to
allow the time of the court to be consumed
in the argument of technical
objections, nor should appeals be allowed
from his rulings in this respect.
Second. The failure of the legal
profession to take a more active part
in solving the great questions that
affect every person throughout our
country. (We will hereinafter discuss
this question more fully.)
Third. The fact that the interests
exert an influence not only in congress,
but in every state legislature,
which is frequently disastrous to the
rights of the people. The people feel
that the interests exert aa undue Influence,
especially in the appointment
of Federal Judges.
Fourth. The fact that, to a large
extent, governmental affairs are administered
by the bosses of political
machines, that do not reflect the wish
es 01 me peopie.
In sparsely populated neighborhoods,
the neighbors knew each other, and it
was easy to make actual selection of
the men they desired to elect to office.
Every candidate was well known to
the voters, and when elected, was well
aware of the wishes and opinions of
his constituency. Communities whose
elements are homogeneous and whose
interests are simple, find no difficulty
in transacting the affairs of government
in an informal and simple manner.
But those simple days have passed
awav. The people of the communities
from one end of the country to the
other are no longer homogeneous;
their interests are varied and their
manner of life complex and intricate.
The voters are largely strangers to
each other. The elective items on the
voter's ticket have become too numerous
to be dealt with by the individual
voter, and consequently are dealt with
in the mass, by a new system?the
system of political machinery which
is controlled by the bosses.
Time will not permit us to show the
progressive manner in which this new
system has injuriously affected representative
government.
Fifth. The fact that so long as the
interests control congressional and
state legislation, and influence the appointment
of officials, the anticipated
benefits arising from the initiative,
referendum and recall, will be practically
valueless, as the interests will
immediately take steps when the election
results in favor of the people to
render its result nugatory and ineffectual
by other legislation.
We recognize this as the most important
of the enumerated causes,'
and desire to emphasize it as strongly
as possible During the war between
the states, the genera', who was in
command of a large tody of troops,
noticed that a battery of the enemy
which had not been located, was playing
havoc with his soldiers. He commanded
that the location of the battery
be immediately ascertained, but
without success. He gave another
nrdpr lnit nirnin the b.atterv could not
be located, though its deadly work still
continued. At last he commanded that
all his troops should turn their attention
in that direction, and the deadly
battery was located in a clump of
trees and was soon destroyed.
This battery of the interests that
is destroying representative government
must be destroyed, even if every
element of the electorate has to be
culled into requisition for that purpose;
otherwise there will be a revolution,
which was prevented, perhaps,
for the time being, by the elec1
tiou of Mr. Wilson as president of the
United States.
In this connection, we wish to impress
upon the voters the great importance
of co-operation, which is
strikingly illustrated by the following
oriental legend:
i "There was a king who had three
sons. A princess became the king's
ward, and as her guardian he had the
right to bestow her hand in marriage
upon whomsoever he should choose.
Each of the three princes besought
their father to give the hand of the
princess to him in marriage. The
king told them that he would bestow
her hand upon that one of them who
proved himself most worthy. The
ability to discover something new and
wonderful was considered in that
country as the highest evidence of
merit.
"One of the princes found a magic
rug with such power that if a person
stood upon it and wished to be elsewhere,
it would Instantly transport
him to the desired spot.. The second
discovered a magic apple with a perfume
that would instantly restore to
perfect health any one who was sick.
The third found a magic tube, which
enabled any one who looked through
it to see a person or object wherever
it might be.
"The third prince suggested that
each look through the tube and desire
to see the princess. Whereupon they
saw her lying upon a couch, with the
royal family standing around her,
weeping, and realized that she was
dying.
"The princes then stood on the rug
and were instantly at the side of the
princess. The prince of the apple
held it before the dying princess, and
she was at once restored to health, and
thereupon each demanded her hand on
the ground that he had saved her life.
"The king then replied, 'Each of
you are right. The really great and
good works of life are done by no one
man nor one class of men, but only
by the co-operation of many; some
other test must be tried.'"
WWaBmrni
Ijjljf^^^ ^B||^i^ I |j| ?|
| M
2 B. GARY -%
^ ? - /- i ~? ii?
ne uoun 01 oouin curunna.
The moral we wish to illustrate Is
that no one man nor any one class of
men can accomplish the desired result;
and that only by co-operation of those
who love their country more than
they do wealth, can representative
government be continued and a revolution
avoided.
Sixth. The power of a few men to
accumulate in an exceedingly short
time, large sums of money from all
parts of the country, that may be
used in such a manner as to affect
and influence the affairs of the government,
Keeps the public mind uneasy
and the affairs of government in a
chaotic state, as such trusts are public
in their nature.
We quote the following words of
Mr. Wilson, president of the United
States, in one of his addresses which
throws light on -this question:
"One of the powers we fear is the
control of our life, through the vast
privileges of corporations which use
the wealth of masses of men to sustain
their enterprise. It is in connection
with this danger that it is
necessary to do some of our clearest
and frankest thinking. It is a fundamental
mistake to speak of privileges
of these great corporations as if they
fell within the class of private right
and of private property. Those who
administer the affairs of great Jointstock
companies are really administering
the property of communities, the
property of the whole mass and miscellany
of men, who have bought the
stock or the bonds that sustain the
enterprise. The stocks and the bonds
are constantly changing hands. There
is no fixed partnership. Moreover,
managers of such corporations are the
trustees of moneys, which they themselves
never accumulated, but which
have been drawn together out of private
savings here, there and everywhere.
"What is necessary in order to rectify
the whole mass of business of this
kind is that those who control it,
/vwtiwftKf nhontro thnlr unint nf
3IIUUIU CIIVI1C1J VIIHIIQV V..V..
view. They are trustees, not masters,
of private property, not only because
their power is derived from a multitude
of men, but also because in its
investments it affects a multitude of
men. It determines the development
or decay of communities. It is the
means of lifting or depressing the life
of the whole country.
"They must regard themselves as
representatives of a public mind.
There can be no reasonable jealousy
of public relation in such matters, because
the opportunities of all men are
affected. Their property is everywhere
touched, their savings are
everywhere absorbed, their employment
is everywhere determined by
these great agencies. What we need
therefore, is to come to a common
view which will not bring antagonism,
but accommodations. The programme
'of parties must not be programmes of
enlightenment and re-adjustment, not
revolutionary but representative. The
processes of change are largely processes
of thought, but unhappily they
cannot be effected without becoming
political processes also, and that is
the deep responsibility of public men.
What we need, therefore, In our polltics
is an instant alignment of all men
free and willing to think and to act
without fear upon their thought."
We will state a few reasons why
the people will not get relief from
direct legislation, whether by the initiative
or referendum.
The trouble with unorganized action
lies in the fact that it is inevitably
spasmodic and intermittent.
The people grow tired of direct legislation
when the novelty has worn off.
The laws do not represent the whole
electorate, but that part of the voters
which impelled either by public or
private motives, takes an interest in
the affairs of state.
In one of the cantons of Switzerland.
a serious attempt was made
some years ago to amelorize the force
of this objection to the referendum, by
imposing a line upon every voter who
failed to appear at the polls.
The polled vote increased as a result;
but the real aim of the law was
not achieved, for many of the voters
who came to the polls under the spur
of this compulsion rendered perfunctory
|>erformance by dropping black
ballots into the box.
Ours is a government of laws but
every one should keep always before
him the fact that no law is effective
unless there is the rieht kind of man
behind it. In tropical America there
ere manv republics whose constitutions
and laws are practically identi
cal with ours, yet some or tnem nave
throughout their governmental career
alternated between despotism and anarchy
and have failed in striking
fashion at every point, where under
like conditions, we have succeeded.
The difference was not in the laws
or the constitutions, for they were the
same. The difference was in the men
who made up the community, in the
men who administered the laws, and
In the men who put in power of the
administrators. It is indeed, with us,
that the people shall be the masters,
and one of the vital needs is, that
they shall show self-mastery, as well
as the power to master their servants
and to see that the right kind of man
is behind the laws.
Constitutional limitations are adopted
as much for the protection of the
rights of the minority as of the maInrltv
anil likewise to Drotect the
people against their own action, until
they have had time to give due de- t
liberation to any suggested changes r
in the organic law. t
The training of the lawer makes his t
co-operation especially valuable in ex- o
plaining to the people the effect of t
suggested changes, and in providing 11
efficient remedies for the evils that (I
confront us. c
Public opinion in the United States t
was never better informed, never v
more intelligent, never more eager to r
make itself felt in the control of gov- n
ernment for the betterment of the d
nation, and yet it was never more r
helpless to obtain its purposes by o
ordinary methods. In order to assert s
its right to representative government, ti
free trom the control and influence of u
me interests, it has to resort to con- s
vulsive, agitated, almost revolutionary h
means . to have its way. It knows P
what it wants. It wants good men in tl
office, sensible laws adjusted to ex- a
isting conditions, conscience in affairs, tl
and intelligence in their administration.
But it is at a loss how to get P
these, it flings itself this way and h
that, frightens this group of politi- 11
cians, hopes, protests, demands, but
cannot govern. c
Men sometimes talk as if it were tl
wealth of which we were afraid, as ?
if it were jealous of the accumula- o
iion of great fortunes. But such is w
not the case. The people have not the tl
slightest Jealousy of the legitimate ?
accumulation of weath. Everybody Ji
Knows that there are many men of
large means and large economic power c:
who have gained it not only by legiti- tl
maie methods, but in a way that de- f<
serves the thanks and admiration of &
ihe communities they have served and a
developed. But everybody knows,
also, mat some of the men who con- d
trot tne wealth and have built up the a
industry of the country seek to control a
politics and also to dominate the life o
or commen men in a way in which no 8
man should be permitted to dominate, b
iii tue ilrst piace, there is the notorious
operation of the bi-partisan d
political machine, which does not V
represent party principle of any kind, li
but which is willing to enter into any a
' combination, with whatever group of b
persons or of politicians, to control
..lie omces of localities and of states P
and of nations itself, in order to main- ri
lain the power of those who direct a
it. This machine is supplied with its P
xunds by the men who use it, in or- P
der to protect themselves against H
legislation which they do not desire, n
1 ana in order to obtain the legislation r
which is necessary for the prosecution 1<
of their unlawful purposes. o
The methods of our legislatures n
make the operations of such machines ii
easy and convenient. For very little ti
of our legislation is formed and effected
by open debate upon the floor, s
Almost all of it is discussed in com- \
mittee rooms, and passed without de- z
bate. Bills that the machine and its
backers do not desire are smothered b
in committee; measures which they do tl
desire are brought out and hurried it
through their passage. It happens p
again and again that great groups of b
such bills are rushed through in the 8
hurried hours that mark the close ot y,
the legislative session, when everyone 8;
is withheld from vigilance by fatigue, t<
and when it is possible to do secret p
things. s
I When we stand in the presence of n
these things, and see how complete a
and sinister their operation has been, y,
we cry 014}. with no little truth that 0
we no longer have representative gov- ti
ernment. e:
In late years the government has p
frequently been qMled upon to take u
part in quelling strikes that are the f]
manifestations of a revolutionary t<
spirit in the industrial field. Presl- y,
dent Wilson realizes that there are cl
three parties interested in a strike? t<
the government, the employer and the y,
employee, and it appears that he in- d
tends that justice shall be done be- t<
tween the employer and the employee, n
and thai the rights of the public shall n
be protected. Any other policy would, }i
in a short time, lead to revolution. n
Those who assume the control of the h
great, industrial interests have a terrl- s,
ble responsibility resting on their s
shoulders. h
Several years ago, there was a strike t<
in England. There was in conse- tl
quence a sympathetic strike in New a
Zealand, which was distant about n
1,200 miles from England. After the e
employees and their families were al- p
most reduced to a state of starvation,
and after inflicting great financial g
loss to their employers, they surrender- c
ed. There were men on both sides in n
that strike who determined, if possi- t
ble, to prevent a like recurrence of s
distress and financial loss. The vie- c
tors instead of gloating over their q
victory went to their employees and ex- n
pressed their deep sympathy, and sug- n
gested that they agree upon a plan p
that would do justice to all parties 0
concerned. The employees entered n
into the spirit of the suggestion. The fj
parties agreed upon a man for gov- e
ernor, whose ability and ideas of jus- w
tice to all were above reproach or sus- b
picion. a
The ablest men and those who were s
non-partisan, were elected as repre- a
sentatives. They realized that in all ji
strikes there are interested parties, f(
the employer, the employee and the a
state. The employer has an interest h
in the business on account of the 0
profits; the employee in order that t]
he might make a support for him- n
self and his family, and the state in ti
order that the health, morals, educa- 8
tion, finances and general welfare of f,
its citizens might be protected. It a
was made the law of the land that the c
amount of compensation to be award- a
ed the employees should be determin- tl
ed by a committee, cons'iting of an a
equal number selected by the em- a
ployers, the employees and the gov- r
ernment, and that no change should t<
be made in the compensation, nor jj
should there be a strike during the p
time specified by said committee; c
that after the expiration of said time, q
the employer, or employee might pe- i{
tition for a change in the rate of com- d
ponsation, but that the work should fl
not stop in consequence of said pe- n
tition. The employer was also re- tl
quired to see that the places where p
the work was performed were kept in 0
a sanitary condition, and every safe- v
guard used to protect the rights of tl
the employee as a citizen. c
The government also requested the e
rich who owned lands as hunting re- e
servations in New Zealand, but re- f
mained citizens of foreign countries, h
to sell their lands to the government 1
for a fair valuation, in order that it d
might, in turn, sell a certain number t
of acres to each citizen, who was re- e
quired to secure the purchase money t
by a mortgage on the land sold him, c
at a low rate of interest. The idea
was that there is a higher order of p
citizenship, when the people worship o
God under their own vine and fig tl
tree. tl
Who can tell the beneficial results c
that may have flowed from this timely tl
action? f<
The desire of the interests to con- si
trol legislation and influence the ap- h
pointment of officials in large measure v
from their opinion, that the great industries
which have come into promt- h
nence in the last few years, need pro- \
tection which they fear will not be
accorded them, unless they take an s
active part in governmental affairs, n
There is no necessity, however, for y
nis apprenension, ana as soon as ine
nterests change their policy volunarily
in this respect, or the people
'orce them to mak > the change, the
greatest danger to representative
government will have passed.
The duties which the lawyer owes
o the state or body politic, arise
rom the fact that he is an officer in
he judicial department, which is one
>f the three co-ordinate branches of
he government, and, as such officer,
te is under the moral obligation to
lse his best efforts to render effectual
ind successful the administration of
he legislative and executive depart nents,
as the three branches are so
nter-dependent that a failure to adninister
properly tne legislative or
sxecutive departments ulll neceesariy
hamper and reder less effectual
he judicial branch.
In the language of another:
"A lawyer is an officer of the
:ourt8, and, as such, owes them various
duties. But the courts compose
>ne of the co-ordinate branches of
he government. Hence the duties
t Vin swv 1? ? a n i n /l i ro otlif
> w cu IIIO wui 10 CM c luuii cv.ii/ uncu
o the state and nation. But there are
nar;v other duties that the lawyer owes
lirectly to the state. The ordinary
itizen is under certain obligations to
he state, and a failure to keep, or a
wilful violation of these obligations,
enders the offender liable to punishnent.
Upon admission to the bar the
iuties and obligations of the citizen
emains, and the duties and obligations
f the lawyer are added to them. The
Late has, through, one of its agencies,
he courts, conferred upon the lawyer,
pon his admission to the bar, a new
tanding in the community in which
e lives. It has granted him new
owers and privileges. It is proper,
herefore that it should exact greater
ccountability from him, than from
he ordinary citizen.''
We desire to make clear and emhasize
the fact that the duty of the
Lwyer as a citizen is paramount to
hat which he owes his client.
There are numerous and various
riticisms against certain members of
he legal profession, who, it is clalmd,
have been active in the destruction
f representative government, and
'ho by the use of technical objecions,
have delayed the administration
f the law, and defeated the ends of
iistice.
We will quote only three of such
ritici& os?two of which are made by
hose who stand high in the legal pro?ssion,
and the third by one of our
reatest scholars, who expresses great
dmiration for our profession.
At the outset we desire It shall be
istinctly understood that the discusIon
of this question is Intended to be
pplicable, in a general way, throughut
the United States, and without
pecial reference to the bench, the
n rvM iVia n/mnlo r\t Gnutb rV)l*nltnQ
at Ui Lite |A7V|/IC ui uvutu V*1I1?H
Our first quotation is from the adress
of Chief Justice Stafford of
Washington, D. C.f which was devered
before the South Carolina Bar
ssoclation in 1908, and waa published
y order of that association.
"See how wealth almost monoolizes
the legal talent. A moment's
eflection will suffice for you to name
score of lawyers of commending
owers, in the pay of enormous cororatlons?one
moment. Now, take
ve and count over for me, half as
lany of equal force and fame who
epresent the people in their life>ng
struggle, with these vast and
vershadowing interests. Let a young
van at the bar display great ability?
istantly he is clapped under a reliner.
"When Chatham made his first
peech in the house of commons,
Vaipole exclaimed: 'We must muzle
that terrible Cornet of Horns.'
The retainer is not a bribe. It
i an honest fee. I do not impugn
Fie motives of those who take it when
: comes. It is a flattering, insidious
rize. I know wealth must have
rains to serve it; it is entitled to
uch service. I am not arraigning
realth. My lamentation is that there
hould not be more to hear the call
3 the other side, to stand as chamions
of the people, unfettered by any
uch alliance. The questions we
lust meet hereafter relate to wealth
nd especially to the framing of laws
rhich may regulate the distribution
f it. Should all our lawyers be relined
by wealth? How can we lessn
the inequalities of life, and not imair
the principles of property and
iw? That is the problem that conronts
us. How can wealth be forced
> pay its share of taxes? How shall
^e give the poor man's child even
hance in life? How get for him who
>ils a few free hours of sunlight
rith his family, an hour or two eacn
ay to cultivate his mind? How see
> it that these ponderous soulless
lachines, to which indeed we owe so
luch, do not become in the end very
uggernauts, crushing manhood, wolanhood
and childhood to the earth?
low shall we counteract, with wholeume,
hopeful laws the blind, dervn
i xl n nr affnrfu g\t iho ci Qr.t \XI h ORP
undred hands may soon And swords
> fight with? These are the questions
hat face us. How shall we ever
nswer them with safety if every
ian, as soon as he has mastered law
nough to be of use, foresakes the
oor and strikes hands with the rich?"
Mr. Taft, ex-president of the United
tates, and ex-president of the Amerian
Bar association, who has done
lore than any other man in the
Inited States towards raising the
tandard of the legal profession, thus
learly showed at the meeting of the
inference on the Reform of Crimial
Law and Procedure, that he does
ot think the legal profession has
Toperly discharged its trust: "One
f the strongest influences for looseess
in the conduct of criminal trials,
i my judgment, has been the presnce
of lawyers in our legislatures,
rho have sought to abate and limit
y statute the power of the Judges,
nd to take away this source of repect
for their rulings, which is so
pparent in every English court of
ustice. What I believe to be an unuunded
fear of judicial tyranny, and
n unreasonable distrust of judges,
ave led to statutory limitations upn
their power in the conduct of
rials in criminal cases which have
lade the trial by Jury in this counry,
and especially in the western
tates, an entirely different institution
rom what it was understood to be,
t the time of the adoption of our
onstitutions. In many states judges
re not permitted to comment upon
lie facts at all. They are not even
llowed to charge the jury after the
rguments of counsel, but they are
equired to submit written charges
o the jury upon abstruse questions of
iw, with no opportunity to apply the
ractlce concretely to the facts of the
ase, and with the result that the
uestions, both of law and fact, are
ITgeiy leil IU lue umuiuitu aim UIIisciplined
action of the Jury, inuenced
only by the contending arguments
of counsel. The restraint that
he judge in the course of a trial 1moses
upon the manner and conduct
f counsel in an English court, is thus
'holly wanting, with the result that
here seems to have been a substantial
hange in the code of professional
thics governing counsel, and in the
xtremes, to which counsel, in the depnse
of their clients, seem to think it
m entirely proper for them to go.
'heir conduct makes neither for the
ignlty of the court nor for the elevalon
of the ethics of the bar, nor the
xpediting of criminal procedure, nor
nr the reasonable punishment of
rime,
"These circumstances reduce the
osition of the judges from that place
f power and usefulness, occupied by
he English judges to one in which
ho trial is largely conducted by the
hief counsel for the defense, and
hose present in court are made to
?el that the question at issue is not
i> much whether the defendant vioited
the law as whether the judge is
iolating it."
President Snyder of WofTord col?ge,
in discussing the subject, "The
lajesty of the Law," said:
"It is a depressing thought to conider
the low estate to which this
oble profession has fallen in recent
ears in the public mind. It has
(.fit? urotui pilHUipitTB U1 jUBlltv cum
equity are lost in the tangle of confusing
trickery and complicated technicality.
Outstanding leaders of the
most intellectual of all professions,
seemed to develop along lines on which
men who ought to be the very high
priests of Justice hold their brains as
purchasable commodities for the
causes that even threaten the integrity
of human society, and in their
hands the machinery of the law is expertly
manipulated, to postpone and
defeat the known ends of justice.
'Democracy is simply losing faith in
the law and the lawyer, and the demand
for the recall of judges and of
legal decisions is only a symptom of
its protest against conditions as they
are, and a prophesy that one day it
is going to take matters into its own
hands, if the lawyer will not. If a
layman may modestly venture an
opinion, it would be for the common
good, now and in the long run; if the
profession of the law would re-adjust
its ethical standards to meet the new
conditions, simplify legal processes,
free them from the dead hand of
worn-out traditions, cut the enveloping
net of needless technicalities, in
which, to the outsider, justice appears
too often to be strugglipg in vain to
escape, and hasten the movement of
the machinery of the courts. One
thing is sure, the common good demands
some sort of reform to maintain
the majesty of the law, and it
it does not come from within the
profession itself, it is going to come
from without it."
In every age, the lawyer has played
a conspicuous part in shaping the affairs
of state; and in certain countries
the legal profession has taken
rank among the orders of nobility.
r-> * I ?Vi..
r rum me luunccnui wnu ?j, uie
bar of France constituted an order of
nobility, known as Noblesse del la
Robe, until the French revolution in
1789. The magistrates, who, as members
of the parliament of Paris, represented
the feudal court and council
of the ancient kings, were selected
from this order. Thereafter in 1804,
Napoleon decreed the re-establishment
of the order of advocates, assigning
as a reason that it was "one of
the most proper to maintain the probity,
delicacy, disinterestedness, desire
of conciliation, love of truth and
justice, an enlightened zeal for the
weak and the oppressed, which are the
essential foundations of their profession."
Among their privileges in Rome, the
advocates were exempt from many
burdens imposed upon others.
After ceasing to practice their profession,
they were admitted to the
order of counts of the first rank.
Ex-Chief Justice Parker of New
York, who is an ex-president of the
American Bar association, concludes
an address as follows:
"In closing I would emphasize anew
the thought that, as the lawyer finds
himself the beneficiary and heir of
great privileges, which yield commanding
opportunities, it is more incumbent
upon him than upon any other,
to recognize that those privileges and
powers impose obligations from which
there can be no escape, as, indeed,
there ought not to be, except by
meeting and welcoming them in the
completest sense possible. If, at any
time, it shall become apparent that
the sanctity of the ballot is either
threatened or assailed; if the administration
of the law, whether civil or
criminal, becomes either lax or careless;
if the evils in Industrial movement
manifest such power that they
threaten monopoly, or put popular
rights in peril; if the executive, the
legislative or the judicial branches of
our system shall, either by design or
accident, tend to trench unduly or
dangerously, upon the rights of any of
the others, the one man who should
resent and resist the dangers thus
threatened, is the American lawyer.
The traditions of his profession, the
execution of the high trust confided
in him, the example set him by great
leaders through many generations, all
demand that he should exercise tht.
greatest watchfulness, and show the
highest couraga"
In speaking of lawyers' responsibility,
Chancellor Kent well said:
"The responsibilities attached to the
profession and practice of the law are
of the most momentous character. Its
members by their vocation, ought to
be-fitted for the great public duties of
life, and they may be said to be exofficio
natural guardians of the law,
and to stand sentinel over the constitutions
and liberties of the country."
It was a lawyer who wrote the
Declaration of Independence, promulgating
the freedom and equality of all
men before the law, and their Inalienable
right to life, liberty, property and
the pursuit of happinesa
The groundwork and cardinal principles
of the Federal constitution
emanated from the brain of the lawyer.
In the Fifth and Sixth amendments
to the same constitution, which
were passed at the first session of
congresa providing for presentment
before the grand Jury, against being
twice put in Jeapordy for the same offense,
against the defendant being
compelled to be a witness against himself,
against the citizen being deprived
of life, liberty or property without due
process of law; against private property
being taken for public use without
just compensation; providing that
?'?' 1 -MMitlnno the flraUMd
id criminal |/iuocvuhivii0, ?-?
shall have the right to a speedy and
public trial by an Impartial jury of the
state and district wherein the crime
shall have been committed; to be informed
of the nature and cause of the
accusation; to be confronted with the
witnesses against him; to have compulsory
process for obtaining witnesses
in his favor, and to h&ve the assistance
of counsel for his defense, are rights
which now seem as if they had always
been enjoyed by the people, but the
framers of these two sections knew
that there was not a right therein
mentioned that had not been denied
the people in the past, and that had
not been bought at the price of the
patriot's blood.
We have faith in the legal profession
and in the people, and firmly believe
that they will yet co-operate to restore
representative government.
A curious novel appeared in the literary
world a few years ago, to which
its author had given the peculiar
name of "She."
It contains a weird description or
English travelers landing upon the
savage coast of Africa where they
found marks of a rast civilization.
There was the ancient stone wharf
imbedded in the mud, and there was,
also, the long-forgotten canal.
It tells how they struggled up the
lonely river, and across the morass
of the city of Kor, then in ruins.
Those of you who may have read the
story will recall, no doubt, the vivid
picture of the deserted and crumbling
Temple of Truth.
Within its inner court was a statue
of the goddess, who once had innumerable
worshippers.
On a pedestal there was a magnificent
marble globe, upon which stood
a sculptor's dream of female loveliness.
A veil was over her face, and her
hands were extended in supplication.
There it stood, divine amid the desolation,
silvered in the moonlight which
softened while it illuminated every
outline- and thus it had stood for agefl.
truth beseeching the world to lift her
veil.
In conclusion, our prayer is that
when the Judges, the lawyers, the
Jurors and witnesses, are called upon
to administer the laws as a sacred
trust in the beautiful temple which
you have.this day dedicated, they may
never forget that Truth is ever beseeching
the world to life the veil from
her eyes, in order that the sword of
Justice shall avenge all wrongs, and
that only the right shall prevail.
George de Collgny of New York, who
started thirty-five months ago from
Bangor, Me., to sing his way around
the world for a prize of $2,500, is now
on the last lap of his Journey. He
has traveled more than 30,000 miles.
Another contestant is now a prisoner
of war in France. The other two have
disappeared.