l. m. grist s sons, Publisher..} -1 #?milg gfirspaper: Jor (hi Promotion of the Political, f octal, ^griooltural and Commercial Interests of the people. { TKI^sN0^'c!,r[KK.vicK "t.AM k establishedl856. yorkville, s. c. friday, itay 20, lillo. isto. 40. C4 54 kJM IPZG BY EMERSC Copyright by Bot ^ CHAPTER XXVII. In the Cabin of Madam. Woman must not belong to herself; she is bound to alien destines.?Friedrich von Schiller. With an exclamation of surprise, the old woman departed from the door. I heard the rustle of a footfall. I could have told in advance what face would now appear outlined in the candle glow ?with eyes wide and startled, with Xllps half parted in query. It was the face of Helena, Baroness von Rltz! } "Eh bien! madam, why do you bar me out?" I said, as though we had parted but yesterday. In her sheer astonishment. I presume, she let down the fastening chain, and without her invitation I stepped within. I heard her startled "Mon Dieu!" then her more deliberate exclamation of emotion. "My God!" she said. She stood, with her hands caught at her throat, staring at mo. I laughed and * held out a hand. "Madam Baroness," I said, "how glad I am! Come, has not fate been kind to us again?" I pushed shut the door behind me. ^ Still without a word, she stepped'deep er into the room and stood looking at me, her hands clasped now loosely and awkwardly, as though she were a country girl surprised, and not the Baroness Helena von Ritz, toast or talk of more than one capital of the world. Yet she was the same. She seemed slightly thinner now. yet not less beautiful. Her eyes were dark and brilliant as ever. The clear features of her face were framed in the roll of her heavy locks, as I had seen them last. Her garb, as usual, betokened luxury. She was robed as though for some fete, all In white satin, and pale blue fires of . stones shone faintly at throat and wrist. Contrast enough she made to me, clad in smoke-browned tunic cf buck, with the leggings and moccasins of a savage, my belt lacking but prepared for weapons. "I see, madam," said I, smiling, "that still I am only asleep and dreaming. But how exquisite a dream, here in this wild country! How unfit here am I, a savage, who introduce the one discordant note into so sweet a dream!" I gestured to my costume, gestured about me, as I took in the details of the long room in which we stood. 1 swear it was the same as that In which I had seen her at a similar hour In Montreal! It was the same I had first seen in Washington! Impossible? I am doubted? Ah, but do I not know? Did I not see? Here were the pictures on the walls, the carved Cupids, the candelabra with their prisms, the chairs, the couches! Beyond yonder satin curtains rose the high canopy of the embroidery-covered couch, its fringed drapery reaching almost to the deep pile of the carpets. I Yet not quite the same, it seemed to me. There were some little things missing, just as there were some little things missing from her appearance. For instance, these draperies at the right, which formerly had cut off the Napoleon bed at its end of the room, now were of blankets and not of silk. The bed itself was not piled deep in down, but contained, as I fancied from my hurried glance, a thin mattress, stuffed perhaps with straw. A roll of blankets lay across its foot. As I gazed to the farther extremity of this side of the long suite, I saw other evidences -? i? thnnlll r 01 cnuuge. it ?n.-. iimvn. Helena vein Ritz, creature of luxury, woman of an old, luxurious world, exotic of monarchical surroundings, had begun insensibly to slip into the ways of the rude democracy of the far fmn% tiers. I saw all this; but ere I had finished my first hurried glance I had accepted her, as always one must just as she was. "Yes." said she at length, slowly, "yes, I now believe it to be fate." She had not yet smiled. I took her hand and held it long. I felt glad to see her, and to take her hand, it seemw ed pledge of friendship and as things now were shaping, I surely needed a friend. At last, her face flushed slightly, she disengaged her hand and motioned me to a seat. Rut still we stood silent for a few moments. "Have you no curiosity?" said she at length. "I am too happy to have curiosity, my dear madam." "You will not even ask me why I am here?" she insisted. "I know. I have known ail along. r You are In the pay <>f England. When I missed you at Montreal. I knew you had sailed on the Modeste for Oregon. We knew all this, and planned for it. I have come across by land to meet you. I have waited. I greet you now!" W She looked me now clearly in the face. "I am not sure," she said at length, slowly. "Not sure of what, madam? When you travel on England's warship," I smiled, "you travel as the guest of England herself. If. then, you are not for England, in Hod's name, whose r. ;..?n ^ "Whoso friend am I?" she answered slowly. "I say to you that I do not know. Nor do I know who is my friend. A friend?what is that? I never knew one!" "Then be mine. I.et me be your friend. You know my history. You know about me and my work. 1 throw my secret into your hands. You will not betray me? You warned me once, at Montreal. Will you not shield me once again? Come, can you betray a people of whom you can say so much?* "Ah. now you would try to tempt me from a trust which has been rel posed in me!" "Not in the least. I would not have you break your word wltit Mr. l'akenliarn: but 1 know you are here on the same errand as myself. You are to learn facts and report them to Mr. I'a keiiham as I am to Mr. Calhoun. Meantime, you have not reported?" "No. I am not yet ready." "Certainly not. You are not yet possessed of your facts. You have not yet seen this country. You do not yet know *4? A -HIT >N HOUGH SB M M >bs- Merrill Co. these men?the same savages who once accounted for another Pakenhem at New Orleans?hardy as buffaloes, fierce as wolves. Wait and see them come pouring across the mountains into Oregon. Then make your report to this Pakenham. Ask him if England wishes to fight our backwoodsmen once more!" "You credit me with very much ability!" she smiled. She dropped into a chair near by a little table, where the light of the tall _ "I wish," said she candles, guttering in their enameled sconces, fell full upon her face. She looked at me fixedly, her eyes dark and mournful in spite of their eagerness. "Ah, it is easy for you to speak, easy for you who have so rich and full a life?who have all! But I?my hands are empty!" She spread out her curved fingers, looking at them, dropping her hands, pathetically drooping her shoulders. "All, madam? What do you mean? You see me almost in rags. Beyond the rifle at my cabin, the pistol at my tent, I have scarce more in wealth than what I wear, while you have what you like." "All but everything!" she murmur eu; ail dui nome: "Nor have I n home." "All. except that my couch is empty save for myself and my memories!" "Not more than mine, nor with sadder memories, madam." "Why, what do you mean?" she asked me suddenly. "What do you mean?" she repeated it again, as though half in horror. "Only that we are equal and alike. That we are here <>n the same errand. That our view of life should be the same." "What do you mean about home? Rut tell me, were you not then married?" "No, I am alone, madam. I never shall be married." There may have been some slight motion of a hand which beckoned me to a seat at tiie opposite side of the table. As I sal. I saw her search my face carefully, slowly, with eyes I could not read. At last she spoke, after her frequent fashion, half to Inn self. "It succeeded, then!" said she. "Yet I am not happy! Yet I have failed!" "I pause, madam," said I, smiling. "I await your pleasure." , "Ah, God! Ah, God!" she sighed. "What have I done'.'" She staggereu to her feet and stood beating her hands together, as was her way when perturbed. "What have I done!" "Threlka!" I heard her call, half chokingly. The old servant came hurriedly. "Wine, tea. anything. Threlka!" She dropped down again opposite me, panting, and looking at me with wide eyes. "Tell me, do you know what you have said?" sin- began. "No, madam. I grieve if 1 have caused you any pain." "Well, then, you are noble: when look, what pain I have caused you! Yet not more than myself. No, not so much. I hope not so much!" Truly there is thought which passes from mind to mind. Suddenly the tiling in her mind sped across t<< mine. I looked at her suddenly, in my eyes also, perhaps, the horror which 1 felt. "It was you!" I exclaimed. "It was you! Ah. now I bc^in to understand! How could you? You parted us! You parted me from Klisabeth!" "Yes," she said regretfully. "I did it. It was my fault." I rose and drew apart from her, unable to speak. She went on. "Hut I was not then as I am now. Sec, I was embittered, reckless, desperate. I was only bcKinniiiK to think - I only wanted time. I did not really mean to do all this. I only thought ? Why, I had not yet known you a day ? ~ 1 ?%.* "I'O MJ ?||1 till llllll'f nor ner an iioin. i >...- .... than half a jest." "How could you do it?" I demanded. "Yet that is no mole strange. H??w did you do it?" "At tin- dour, that first night. I was mad tln-n nvi-r tin- wrmiR done to what I it 11?- womanhood I could claim for my own. 1 hated Yturrio. I hated I'akenham. They had t???tli insult*,| me. I hated every man. I had seen nothing but the bitter and desperate side of life s ?I was eager to take revenge even a upon the innocent ones of this world, seeing that I had suffered so much. I t had an old grudge against women, I against women, I say?against women!" i She buried her face in her hands. I r say her eyes no more till Threlka came and lifted her head, offering her a cup v of drink, and so standing patiently until a again she had dismissal. "Hut still it is all a puzzle to me. t madam," I began. "I do not understand." > "Well, when you stood at the door, my little shoe in your pocket, when you 11' I kissed my hand that tirst nlgTu^Hieir you told me what you would do did you r love a woman?when I saw something * new in iife I had not seen?why. then, in the devil's resolution that no woman > in the world should be happy if I could help it. I slipped in the body of the slip- f per a little line or so that I had writ- s ten when you did not see. when I was s In the other room. "Twas that took the t place of Van Zandt's message, after all! t Monsieur, it was fate. Van Zandt's let- I r I SKjgHP i H3B&HHBSIHI39Hn l( pBHMBftgra f WamasBSBWaumSHBSB MW^HH|HHE^H^KEH5MHiB9i SjSjkgiCBsJHRfl^^nHQ d p9BraijflGB^^^H^Mg?^HKra? a &jM|8KraNBHflSEraflgg{j|XH^H SiSNKm9BB^HHH^^9^^H||^BB SBiiiBKflaaHHEHlBwP^fstlAralin c! lf ?| wish?I wish?" c ter, without plan, fell out on my table. Your note, sent by plan, remained in the shoe!" ? "And what did It say? Tell me at once." e "Very little. Yet enough for a woman who loved and who expected. Only this: 'In spite of that other woman, come to me still. Who can teach you S' love of woman as can I? Helena.' I think it was some such words as those." ^ "I had not thought any one capable of that," said I. " "Ah, but I repented on the instant! I repented before night came. Ir. the ^ twilight I got upon my knees and pray- 1 ed that all my plan might go wrong? a if I could call it plan." But again I could only turn away to ponder. "See," she went on: "for myself, this is irremediable, but it is not so for you, nor for her. It is not too ill to be made ^ right again. There in Montreal, 1 thought that I had failed in my plan, ^ that you indeed were married. You '( held yourself well in hand; like a man, ? monsieur. But as to that, you were ? married, for your love for her re- e j mained: your pledge held. And did not * I, repenting marry you to her?did not " I, on my knees, marry you to her that v night? Oh, do not blame me too much!" 0 "She should not have doubted," said a I. "I shall not go back and ask her 11 again. The weakest of men are strong K sometimes!" ^ "Ah, now you are but a man! Being s such, you can understand how ter- a ribly much the faith of man means for '' a woman. It was her need for you that 0 spoke, not her doubt of you. Forgive her. She was not to blame. Blame me! I* Do what you like to punish me! Now, t I shall make amends. Tell me what 1 e best may do. Shall I go to her, shall 1 s tell her?" h "Not as my messenger. Not for me." a "No? Well, then, for myself? That k is my right. I shall tell her how priest- a ly faithful a man you were. Come," I she said, "I will bargain with you, af- I ter all!" c "Any bargain you like, madam." "And I will keep my bargain. You c know that I will." "Yes, I know that." n "Very well, then. I am going back tn p Washington. s "How do you mean?" I "By land, across the country; the * way you came." f "You do not know what you say, n madam. The journey you suggest is v incredible, impossible." " "That matters nothing. I am going, t Anil 1 am going alone? No, you can <1 not come with me. I)o you think 1 would risk more than 1 have risked? 1 s Bo alone. I am England's spy: yes. s that is true. I am to report to Eng- n land: yes, that is true. Therefore, tlie more I see. the more I shall have to s report. Hesides, 1 have something e else to do." c] "But would .Mr. Pakenham listen to j your report, after all?" Now she hesitated for a moment. "I can induce him t<> listen." sne sjiiu. j "That is part of m.v errnnd. First. be- >s f??rc I see Mr. I'akcnham I am going t< t see Miss Klisabcth Churchill. I sliall j report also to her. Then I shall have ^ done my duty. Is it not so?" "You could do no more." said I x "Hut what liar (tain?" "Listen. If she uses me ill and will s not believe either you or me?then, be- v ing a woman, I shall hate her; and in ( that case I shall go to Sir Richard for , my own revenue. I shall tell him to ,, bring on this war. In that case. Ore- , gon will be lost to you. or at least bought dear by Id and treasure." v "We can attend to that, madam." said .. I grimly, and I smiled at her. although v a sudden fear caught at my heart. I knew what damage she was in position < to accomplish if site liked. My heart itood still. I felt the faint sweat igain on my forehead. "If I do not find her worthy of you. hen she can not have you," went on i ielena von Ritz. "But, madam, you forgot one thin,?. She Is worthy of me, or of any other nan!" "I shall be judge of that. If she Is , vhat you think, you shall have her? ind Oregon!" "But as to myself, madam? The >argaln?" "I arrive, monsieur! If she falls rou, then I ask only time." "I begin to see, madam," said I. "how I arge these stakes may run." "In case I lose, be sure at least I shall ay. I shall make my atonement," she < aid. I "I doubt not that, madam, with all I our heart and mind and soul." 1 "And body!" she whispered. The old ] lorror came again upon her face. She I Vtiwl/lararl T rll/1 nnt lrnnur U'hv Shp I tood now as one in devotions for a 1 ime, and I would no more have spoken j han had she been at her prayers, as, ] ndeed, I think she was. At last she i nade some faint movement of her i ands. I do not knew whether it was 1 he sign of the cross. I She rose now, tall, white-clad, shimicring, a vision of beauty such as that t art of the world certainly could not i hen offer. Her hair was loosened now i (l its masses and drooped more widely ' ver her temples, above her brow. Her 1 yes were \ery large and dark, and I j aw the faint blue shadows coming c gain beneath them. Her hands were t lasped, her chin raised just a trifle, 1 nd her gaze was rapt as that of some rnging soul. I could not guess of t hese things, being but a man, and, I i ?ar, clumsy alike of body and wit. t "There is one thing, madam, whicn re have omitted," said I at last, r What are my stakes? How may I l c "J . She swayed a little nn her feet, as dough she were weak. "I want," said he, "I wish?I wish?" The old childlike look of pathos came gain. I have never seen so sad a face, he was a lady, white and delicately lad: I, a rude frontiersman In camprimed leather. But I stepped to her ow and took her in my arms, and held er close, and pushed back the damp aves of her hair. And because a lan's tears were in my eyes, I have no oubt of absolution when I say I had een a cad and a coward had I not issed her own tears away. I no loner made pretense of ignorance, but h! how I wished that I were ignorant f what it was not my right to now. I led her to the edge of the little bed f husks and found her kerchief. Ah, he was of breeding and courage! 'resently, her voice rose steady and lear as ever. "Threlka!" she called. Please!" When Threlka came, she looked losely at her lady's face, and what she ead seemed, after all, to content her. "Threlka," said my lady in French, I want the little one." I turned to her with query In my yes. "Tlens!" she said. "Wait. I have a ttle surprise." "You have nothing at any time save urprlses, madam." "Two things I have," said she, sigh ig: a little nog irom unina, enow oy c aine. He sleeps now, and I must not t Isturb him, else I would show you how t ively a dog Is Chow. Also here I have I jund a little Indian child running \ bout the post. Doctor McLaughltl r as rejoiced when I adopted her." a "Well, then, madam, what next!" t ?"Yes, with the promise to him that t would care for that little child. I want a omething for my own. See now. i !ome, Natoka!" t The old servant paused at the door, 'here slid across the tloor with the si- 1 ?nt feet of the savage the tiny figure i f a little child, perhaps four years t f age, with coal-black hair and beady r yes, clad in all the bequilled finery r hat a trading-post could furnish?a i ttle orphan child, as 1 learned later, i . hose parents had both been lost in a i anoe accident at the Dalles. She was t n infant, wild, untrained, unloved, i nable to speak a word of the lan- < uage that she heard. She stood now ( esitating, but that was only by rea- i on of her sight of me. As I stepped t side, the little one walked steadily | ut with quickening steps to my satin- i lad lady on her couch of husks. She ook up the child in her arms ! low, there must be some speech be- 1 ween woman and child. I do not know 1 xcept that the Baroness von Ritz ( poke and that the child put out a ' and to her cheek. Then, as I stood t wkward as a clown myself and not t mowing what to do, I saw tears rain gain from the eyes of Helena von titz, so that I turned away, even as i saw her cheek laid to that of the r liild while she clasped it tight. * "See, then," she said; "here is my f otnpanion across the mountains." 1 Again I began to expostulate, but < iow she tapped her foot impatiently i a her old way. "You have heard me 1 ay it. Very well. Follow if you like, > listen also if you like. In a day or > o, Doctor McLaughlin plans a party t or us all far up the Columbia to the < nission.s at Wallatpu. That is in the t alley of the Walla Walla, they tell 4.?of of flilo n/1rr,. r.f thn Dlun M.itltl. L in , ju.il nv nun ruftf \n uiu i?iuv~ c ains, where the wagon trains come i lown into tills part of Oregon." v "They may not see the wagon trains o soon," I ventured. "They would carcely arrive before October, and io\v it is but summer. r "At least these British officers would a ee a part of this country, do vou not 1 c omprehend? We start witliin three , lays at least. I wish only to say that j lerhaps?" 1 ( "Ah, I will be there surely, madam!" "If you come independently. I have f leard, however, that one of the mis- I denary women wishes to go back to 't he states. 1 have thought that per- t laps It might be better did we go to- ti ;etiler. Also Natoka. ANo Chow." ^ "Docs Doctor McLaughlin know ol our plans?" "I am not under his orders, nmnileur. I only thought that, since you vere used to this western travel, you ould, perhaps, be of aid in Retting lie proper guides and vehicles. I should ely upon your judgment very much nonsieur." "You are asking me to aid you in our own folly," said I discontentedly, but I will be there; and be sure also nil can not prevent me from following -if you persist in this absolute folly, t woman?to cross the Hockies!" I rose now, and she was gracious enough to follow mo part way toward the door. Wo hesitated there, awkwardly enough. But once more our I hands met In some sort of fellowship. "Forget!" I heard her whisper. And I could think of no reply better than I that same word. s To be Continued. r __ t iHisccllaiicous iSnulitui. J COTTON ON HIGHER BASIS. p v Lewis W. Parker Tells the Mill Men to 1 Arrange Accordingly. d Over 800 delegates, representing ev- r ?ry cotton manufacturing and produc- f Ing state in the country, were gathered t in the Academy of Music at Charlotte li ast Tuesday morning when President ? L. W. Parker called the American Cot- I ton Manufacturers' association together In the city of its bi: th. Mayor Hawkins welcomed the delegates happily h ind T. H. Rennle of Pell City, Ala., res- v ponded in kind. Interest in the morn- f ng hinged on President Parker's an- r lual address, in which he took a pro- p lounced stand against illegal specula- fl Jon, li "Owing to a new price level in cot- c ton buyers and customers must be d iwakened to a realization of the n lecesslty of high cost of cotton goods." ii rhis was the declaration made today h jy Lewis W. Parker, president of tiie g \merlcan Cotton Manufacturers' as ">- t< Jatlon, In his address to the organiza- o ion which began its annual convention ti tere today. Mr. Parker asserted that c 'gambling on a cotton exchange is just tl is bad, in every particular, as gam)llng in any other form, and should 1< >e prohibited by law." I He recommended the passage of g esolutions approving the policy of the n >111 now in congress known as the h Scott anti-option bill. k In speaking of the increase in the II )rice of cotton, Mr. Parker said "it c< nust be admitted on our part that j< i portion at least of the unfortunate E esults of the past year is due to our- is lelves. Throughout last summer and t< arly fall manufacturers as a whole esisted the advance of the raw ma- fi erlal which was consequent upon the w ihortage of supply. We apparently tl vere slow to appreciate how short in- o leed was the supply and were much c jehlrnl in this respect the speculative h dement which foresaw conditions s; nuch better than we did." o Speaking of the increased price of e cotton, Mr. Parker declared that "cot- a on must be expected to be upon a o ligher level of price than it had beer b n times past and even the relatively g sigh price prevailing during the last s all and winter and now prevailing is a jot out of proportion to other agrl- s mitural products and to the great li nass of manufactured articles, many of t< hese having risen in value, as com- o jared with conditions of thirty years igo, 100 per cent; whereas cotton to- u lay is not above GO per cet^t higher t< han what may be termed its normal C >rice in times past. g "It must therefore be recognized," \ he speaker continued, "that a new e irice level In cotton Is both proper and s lecessary and that we must bend our E mergles, not In the effort to reduce tl his price level, but to convince buyers c >f its necessity and propriety and of r he necessity for a consequent rise in he price of manufactured products, n place of bending our energies to- e vurds the depression of prices of the b aw material, the thoughts of all of us, h ts manufacturers, should be and must c >e directed towards acquainting buy- e rs and customers with the conditions s iffecting us, awakening In them a real- h station of the necessity of a higher v muf n/if inn rrnnilu " ??< Mr, Parker declared that "it is fol- I y for any manufacturer to claim that ii le Is not interested in the manipula- a Ion of tile cotton market or that lie Is o lot Interested in the effect upon the h aw material of exchanges whose n nethods tend toward the manipulation A if the price of the raw material. There c s a relation between the price of con- p ract on the exchanges and the actual I: irice of spot cotton, owing to the great e 'Xtent of those operations on the exhanges. Our experience in the past e las been that, with a very few excep- a Ions, we are not able by any means to d lurchase our raw material at the price L ndieated by the exchange. v "The very lives and fortunes of too s, nany of our fellow men," said Mr. b Jarker, "are affected by the manipula- o ions of prices of an agricultural pro- n luct on the exchange for our govern- d nent to sit idly by and see manipula- s Ion In price without raising its voice t'i igainst it and seeking to prevent it. g iii my inmii u uuh hick ........ tl >e action by tiic government to protect \\ ntcrcstcil parties if the exchanges will tl lot themselves regulate their contract p 10 as to be fair to both buyer and sell- j >r. and If they will not so regulate their ontraots to take much less, if not, in- g leed, to prohibit altogether that man- p nidation of prices which we so recently v lave seen it is absurdity when prizes tl rary as they do on exchanges without ti eference at all to the natural condl- c ions of supply and demand and with- a mt reference to the prevailing price of pj he actual commodity." S Following his address a handsome p fold medal, expressive of the esteem ti n which he is held by the association, s vas presented President Parker. The Profits of the Mines. n In magnitude and Importance the si nining industry ranks second only to 0( igr(culture among the foundation inlustries of the United States. It now ontributes over $2,000,000,000 an- ' uially to the national wealth, as com- 11 tared with $7,fi00,000,000 from agri- (1 ulture; but it contributes 65 per cent . if the freight trattic of the country, is eomnured with only 8 1-2 per cent 0 rom agriculture. Its manufactured ? iroducts in 1 !i?7 amounted to a total if $4,318,508,66 1, and the wages paid o the men engaged in such manufac- " ure amounted to $863,558,487, as p igainst $735,101,760 paid to those en- j, raged in agriculture. . . The mineral industry is increasing ' n its complexity and importance w vith relation to the other branches I' >f industry. In addition to Its con- p rihution of G5 per cent of the total n ight traffle of the country, it reI'lires more than 3,000,000 men to do " lie work connected with the mining, handling and treatment of the mineral p iroducts, 1,000,000 of whom work in . he mines; it is the basis of the arger portion of the nation's varied t< nanufacturing interests and of its r< applies of heat and light. The production and consumption f mineral products are now increasng so rapidly that the value of the h iroducts of tiie mines for the current p lecade will lie nearly two and onelalf times that for the preceding decide.? Harper's Weekly. ? MAKES PRESIDENT EXPLAIN. racts Disclosed by Stenographer Creates Embarrassing Situation. The sensation of the Balllnger3inchot investigation last week, was a itatement by P. W. Kerby, a stenogapher of Secretary Ballinger's office to he effect that the letter which the resident gave out last September, exexonerating Balllnger of the Glavis harges, was written by Assistant Atorney General Lawler and Mr. Ballinrer himself. The stenographer knew rhat he was talking about, because he lad written the letter from Lawler's lictatlon. The effect of Kerby's statenent was such as made it necessary or the president to write a letter exilalning the whole business. The presdent's letter, which was addressed to Senator Knute Nelson, chairman of the nvestigating committee is as follows: "May 18, 1910. "My Dear Senator Nelson: In the learings before the committee to inostlgate the interior department and orestry service, reference has been nade to roy decision upon the comilaint and charges of L. R. Glavis, lied with me on the 18th of August ist, against Secretary Ballinger and ertain other officials of the Interior epartment. The majority of the comlittee have decided that my action n this regard was not within the jursdiction of the committee to investlate. In spite of this ruling, references o the matter have crept Into the recrd. For this reason, I deem It proper o write you and state, with such acuracy as my memory permits, what he facts are. "Glavls's statement and charges were ?ft with me by him on August 18, 1909. turned them over to the attorney eneral, who happened to be in the elghborhood, and he made notes upon is reading. We both had personal nowledge in respect to Secretary BalInger's attitude toward the Alaska oal claims, which was the chief subset of innuendo and complaint, for Mr. nitieu ai me siari u wouiu nave cnaea " he whole hullaballo at once. The oplnon is general here that all the magni- bl ude which has been given to the In- a< ident Is entirely due to the fact that he original charge that this was (lone vas denied and that a mystery has >een made of what did occur in the reparation of the letter of September di 3. e. The similarity between the coneluions of the president's letter of Sepember 13, and those of the Lawler o< nemorandum Is at once explained by ^ he declaration of Mr. Taft that he bi liscussed the matter fully with Mr. E -awler, set forth his own conclusions, md directed Mr. Lawler to prepare a etter for him to sign embodying them. c< "** a< A CONTINGENT ASSET. a othing in the charges upon which s Ir. Ballinger or the others accused t ould be found guilty of either incom- r etency, inefficiency, disloyalty to the t iterests of the government, or dlshon- d sty. I "In the discussions of the second a vening Mr. Lawler, who was present li t my suggestion, discussed the evience at some length. I said to Mr. ,awler that I was very anxious to rite a full statement of the case, and ^ et out the reasons for my decision, ut that the time for my departure n a long western trip, occupying two lonths, was just one week from that t ay; that I had some six or seven set s peeches to deliver at the beginning of f hat journey, and that I could not t ive the time to the preparation of such h detailed statement and opinion as I c ould like to render In the matter. I d herefore requested Mr. Lawler to pre- t are an opinion as if he were presl- P ent. y "During the 8th, 9th and 10th I n ave such consideration to the Glavls r ecord as was consistent with preious engagements, but paid no atten- a Ion to the speeches. On the 9th I o degraphed the attorney general to v irnio to Beverly, in ordet that I might j< nnsult with him in respect to the case, n le arrived there Saturday afternoon. 1< eptember 11, and, pursuant to an ap- n ointment made by telephone, he came ii i my house early on Sunday morning, a eptember 12. Delivered Lawler Opinion. " "He then delivered to me the draft l1 pinion prepared by Mr. Lawler, and e aid that he had an opportunity, on ^ imiing from New Yoik, to read the ^ nswevs of Mr. Ballinger and others. s iallinger had very early in the admin- f Jtration consulted us both in regard e 3 them. li "Within two or three days after the t ling of the charges In a meeting at c hlch the secretary of the treasury, tie attorney general, and the secretary 1 f the-navy were present, a full dis- F usslon of the Glavls statement was r ad. It resulted in a general conclu- P Ion that jealousy between the bureaus C f the Interior department and the for- 'N stry bureau probably explained the v ttltude of the interior department f fflcials, but that the intimations of li ad faith by Glavls against Mr. Ballin- v er and the others required that the e tatement be submitted to them for \ nswer. Accordingly, copies of the t tatement were sent to Secretary Bal- a nger, to Assistant Secretary Pierce, r 3 Commissioner Dennett and to Chief s f Field Service Schwartz. "Mr. Balllnger was at Seattle, but c pon receipt of the charges he came p o Washington to prepare his answer. 1 >n Monday, September 6, Mr. Ballin- .c er reached Beverly, accompanied by s Ic. Lawler, the assistant attorney gen- c ral of the department of justice, as- b igned to the interior department. Mr. b iallinger sent to my house on that day b he answers of the various persons i oncerned, together with a voluminous J ecord of exhibits. I Found Charges Baseless. f "I had a conference with him the q venlng of the day he came, Septemer 6. and then on the following even- c ig, September 7. I talked over the c harges with Mr. Balllnger the first r venlng, and asked such questions as t uggested themselves, without intimat- 1< ig any conclusion, and said that I t . ould examine the answers and the c ecord and would see him the next day. t sat up until 3 o'clock that night read- v ig the answers and exhibits; so that b t my next conference I was advised f f the contents of the entire record and 1 ad made un my mind that there was then said to him that I made up my u lind as to my conclusions and had r rafted part of my opinion, but that wished him to examine the full rec- ^ rd before I stated mine. He took the a hole record away. >' '"During the day I examined the raft opinion of Mr. Lawler, but its 30 " ages did not state the case in the way ' i which I wished it stated. It con- v lined references to the evidence which n ere useful, but its criticism of Mr. ^ inchot and Mr. Olavls I did not think proper or wise to adopt. I only used few paragraphs from. it. containing 8 lerely general statements. 11 "The attorney general returned in * ie evening with notes of the examina- * on which ho had made and reported ) me the conclusions which he had cached, wnicn were in sunsianuni aturd with my own. We then discussed ie matter at some length particu- n irly some points of law which were 1 ivolved, and took up the opinion hich I had finished and made a num- i er of alterations; and as tin* result of p that discussion I determined the final II form which I employed, and signed the U same on Monday, September 13. The conclusions which I reached u ivere based upon my remarks on the record, and were fortified by the oral inalysls of the evidence and the conclusions which the attorney general n ?ave me, using the notes which he had nade during his reading of the record. [ was very sorry not to be able to em- T sody this analysis In my opinion, but :lme did not permit. I therefore, directed him to embot* In a written statement such analysis and conclusions as he had given me, file It with. :he record, and date it prior to the date if my opinion, so as to show that my ^ decision was fortified by his summary >f the evidence and his conclusions herefrom. Sincerely yours, William H. Taft. c< 'Hon. Knute Nelson, Chairman, Com- P mittfee to Investigate the Interior a Department and Forestry Servic, U. Ci S. Senate." g Denial a Tactical Error. The publication of the Kerby state- e; nent has aroused more interest here c< n the Ballinger-Pinchot controversy han any other episode connected with ;he matter. It.was evident at once e< lpon a comparison of the Lawler mem- b jrandum with the Taft letter of Sep- P ember 13, that the White House dellal of Saturday afternoon was a tac- d' leal error. The full text of the Law- ? er memorandum, as submitted to the 01 c< nvestlgatlng committee by Attorney g leneral Wlckersham yesterday aftertoon, did undeniably support the dec- jj aration that the president had die- y ated his own letter himself. But just nr is undeniably It showed that Mr. Taft ol ised the memorandum in dictating hat letter. , Several paragraphs he used vertatlm, notably one dealing with "the tl esponsibility of cabinet positions," a ind the qualifications of Mr. Balllnger or the office of secretary of the in- a, erior. The conclusions reached by the fc (resident also agree with those set M orth by Mr. Lawler, although Mr. Taft xpressed them in somewhat different c, anguage. The internal evidence of the ci ise of the Lawler memorandum id Inly ontestible. 0] This was at once apparent to admin- lr stration officials and to friends of the I11 resident. There was much talk of the natter here Saturday. Secretaries f)( Cagel and Dickinson, with Attorney tl Jeneral Wickersham, went to the *' 61 Vhlte House Saturday afternoon and rere in consultation with the president or several hours. It was announced p, ater in the afternoon that a statement pi vould be forthcoming early in the vening which would clear up the ^ rhole matter. But the preparation of e| he letter required more time than was bi .t first expected, and It was not until ai learly 11 o'clock that it was finally is- f|! ued. a] This letter for the first time does C( ilear up Just what happened In the ^ reparation of the letter of September 3. At the same time it bears out the re iharge that has been made constantly s* Jnce the publication of the letter ex- n inerating Mr. Balllnger, that it had . een prepared upon material furnished 01 >y the men under accusation. The presdent's use of the Lawler memorandum te s fully explained by the statement of dr. Taft that he himself asked Mr. Vl R< >awler to draw up that memorandum or the very use to which he subseluently put it. tl As a matter of fact, this Is a pro edure common to all the government C( ifflcers, and if that fact had been ad- fa The Court Didn't Appoint a Receiver to Administer It. is A woman's way of getting around ?j rouble, especially her ability to an- ti wer a question without giving any in- rt ormatlon, is well known, particularly o the members of the bar that have hi lad occasion to cross words with her o< n the stand. A woman with a well leveloped sense of humor once foiled he persistent attempt of W. G. Cha- a( in. late editor of the American Law- jn er, to elicit information in supple- gi nentary proceedings. He tells the sto- P< y of the failure himself. "I bad been admitted to the bar but uj short time and was a fair specimen in f the average theory stuffed, practice c< S? 'anting, law school graduate. How ^ oyously were the commands of the ct managing clerk obeyed! Here was the pi aoked for opportunity to demonstrate cc ny ability In the noble art of search- ^ rigly examining a recalcitrant witness, th . woman! |r "Of the two, I fancy, however, that ^ t was the lady who was more self- e\ assessed when {he proceedings open- p? d. She was a dressmaker and had re ieen sued for debt by a dry goods irm. The examination dragged its m low length along, revealing no assets, ci ntil finally came the omnium gatheurn query asked as a finisher. b( '"Have you any property of any si Ind or nature, real or personal, or ny right or interest in property that tr ou have failed to mention?' di "Perhaps it was my tone she dis- tr Iked. At any rate, her eyes snapped. (Veil, I've got what perhaps you tr wouldn't call an interest, but it's al- tii nost as good. It's an expectation. re se lust I answer?" in " 'If you please.' I was encouraged, tii " 'Well, you see, it's this way. I've tli ot two sisters, and both of 'em have C!l or flurried finely. Now, neither one of ty hem begins to be as good looking as ta am.' "'Yes.' She had me puzzled. V( " 'Well, I really don't see why I cc: houldn't have the same show.' *v "It is needless to say that there was w o receiver appointed to administer slJ liis 'asset.'"?Chicago Record-Herald, th , m , m at it'fr Paraded grief arouses little sym- _ athy. IEMOCBATS IN CONVENTION. armonlous Meeting Confined to Routine. RIMARY RULES REMAIN UNCHANGED. here Was Debate on the Question of Restricting Primary Election Privileges to Registered Voters, and an Effort to Have the State Convention Elect State Chairman, But Both Propositions Failed, olumbla State. Thursday. After a fight of two hours In coinlitteea and nearly three hours on the oor of the house, the state Democratic onvention last night killed two Imortant changes suggested In the rules nd constitution. These changes were: 1. Requiring that the same qualiflrtf Innu nKfaln In f hn nrlmorv ou In t Ho eneral election. 2. That the convention hereafter elect le chairman of the state Democratic icecutlve committee instead of the immlttee, as at present. There were other matters brought up nd discussed but It was around these vo propositions that members worka for or against and discussed In lobles and on the streets. On the first * roposed change there was a roll call, m the second the vote was viva voce. Then there was a resolution conemnlng the United States attorney eneral for his recent action In prose- * utlng certain cotton dealers and also immendlng United States Senator mlth for his stand In the matter. Everything else was routine and armonlous. In fact It could not have een called anything but harmonious. Pith the exception of some remarks lade last night on the Stevenson reslutlon there was no feeling. The State Chairman. The fight as to the right of the conentlon to elect a chairman of the state icecutlve commitee Is familiar with lose who have followed the discussion t the meeting of the state executive immlttee. The Chesterfield delegaon was instructed to urge a change nd W. F. Stevenson of that county >ught for a change at the meeting of le committee and on the floor of the invention. It was on the floor of the invention that there was some dlsission between Jas. A. Hoyt of this ty, editor of the Record, and Mr. Steenson. Mr. Hoyt having stated local' that the proposed change was a fight n Gen. Jones because of the latter's iterest in the Seminole company, beig a director In that concern. This luse Mr. Stevenson denied and Mr. [oyt afterwards said that he was resnnulhlo fnr the nrtlplp nnrl thmiirht lat it was a personal fight on Gen. :>nes. The defeat of the proposition ided the incident. The Primary Matter. The fight was on article six of the irty constitution with relation to the rimary elections. The McMahan resolution upon which le discussion was directed, in part rovided that after the words "at this ection," etc., strike out "who have ?en residents of the state 12 months id the county 60 days preceding the . rneral election," and to insert in lieu lereof the words, "whose names shall ppear on the registration books of the )unty and who when they offer to ate shall make oath that they are regtered electors of said county." Mr. [cMahan's resolution was the minority sport of the committee. There were iveral other resolutions along the ime lines. But the adoption of the (port meant the defeat of all. When the convention was called to rder last night, Mr. R. I. Manning, lalrman, read the report on a number f matters submitted to this commute. A resolution urging all Democrats to ate not only in the primary but in the sneral election was adopted without Iscussion. The resolution called attention to le fact that there should be a large ate for Democratic congressmen to a away with usual contests before the mgressional committee and also the ict that Jury commissioners have a rger field to select Jurors. The unfavorable report on a propos1 resolution urging the general assemly to pass stricter game laws was Jopted without discussion, as was the nfavorable report urging certain naonal aid for good roads. f.Andamni Wickersham. A substitute for a resolution introuced by the Anderson delegation, consuming the efforts of Attorney Gen al Wlckersham in prosecution of cutin "bulls," was adopted. The resolution: "Be it resolved, That the state Dem:ratic convention does hereby consmn the efforts of Attorney General rtckersham in his prosecution of the nil leaders In the New York Cotton xchange without proceeding against ie bear leaders, and we commend our mior senator, E. D, Smith, for his aeon in protecting the interests of the itton farmers of the south." The following resolution was then iopted on motion of Mr. Stevenson by rising vote: "Resolved, by the Democratic conention of South Carolina, That the empathy of this convention be, and hereby, extended to our senior sentor, the Hon. Benjamin R. Tillman, in Is recent illness and that this convenon wishes him speedy and complete istoration to health and strength, listing that he may soon be able to (sume his duties In that body where e has so ably represented the Dem rats of South Carolina for 15 years." The Platform. The platform was then read and lopted without discussion: "The Democrats of South Carolina, i convention assembled, express their atiflcatlon that the signs of the times lint to general dissatisfaction with ie administration of the government / the Republican party, and congratate the representatives of our party congress on the approval given their >urse in the recent elections in Masichusetts and New York, at which epublicans were defeated and Pemoats sent to the congress in their ace. The people of all sections are milng to realize that the Republican irty stands for special privileges at ie cost of the multitude, and that irough the favoritism shown to the usts by tariff legislation the country now suffering from conditions which ake the cost of living so high that ren the Republican congress is compiled to institute an investigation. "The only substantial and lasting lief Is to be found in the adoption of le historic Democratic doctrine deanding a system of tariff duties sufflent to raise revenues adequate to the omonical administration of the govninent. Material reductions should ? made in the tariff upon the necesties of life. "The protective tariff makes possie the combinations which are called usts and only by revision of tariff ities downward can the growth of the usts be checked. The failure of the epublican administration to enforce le civil and criminal laws against the usts demonstrates anew the obiigaons of that party to the trusts which nder it Impossible for the country to cure relief from that source. Favorg publicity of all campaign contribuL?ns, the Democratic party throughout ie country enters upon me coming nnpaign for congress this fall as the tly agency to which the people can irn with the expectation of genuine riff reform and genuine trust regula:?n. "The Democratic party has long faired the imposition of a tax on in mes as a just method of taxation, hen fairly levied and collected, and e favor such a tax. "Believing with Jefferson in 'the ipport of the state governments In all icir rights as the most competent adInlstratlon for our domestic concerns id surest bulwark against anti-repub(Continued on Second Page.)