Edgefield advertiser. (Edgefield, S.C.) 1836-current, April 11, 1894, Image 2
THOS. J. ADAMS, PROPRIETOR.
EDGEFIELD, S. C., THURSDAY, OCTOBER 26, 1893.
_ - r-? -----
4>
VOL. LVIII. NO. 39.
The Whiskey Rebel
lion Quelled.
Governor Tillman Addresses tte
Troops ano1 Citizens.
?SS?MES CONTROL OFPOLICE
Threats to Kill the
Governor.
BAND-BOX SOLDIEES.
White Wiusreil Peace Xow Hovers
O'er the Scene-But the
Law Must and Shall
he Enforced.
On Tuesday morning last, at 10
o'clock the State troops were march
ed from their quarters in the peni
tentiary grounds to the State capi
tol, preparatory to dismissing them
to their homes. When they had
been drawn up in line in front of
the capitol, the Governor spoke as
follows :
Citizen-soldiers, Volunteers, and
Fellow Citizens :
South Carolina to-day is attract
ing the attention of the entire
United States. The situation here
is so grave and so anomalous that
Tt is proper for a clear and official
tatemftut to go forth, and that an
analysis of the causes, which have
brought it about should be given
to the public. As the Governor of
the entire people (for I have never
sought to be anything else) that
statement can best come from me.
You all are familiar with the oc
currences of the past four days
the conflict between citizens anti
officers of the law. You are aware
of the contention made by those
who are resisting the law-the dis
pensary law-that it is an invasion
of private liberty, that it is un
constitutional and that it shall not
be enforced. That contention
should not be settled, as I have al
ready said, by arms.
THE PRIVATE HOUSE MATTER.
Now let us look for a moment at
the consequences. If the claim set
forth that private residences shall
not be searched for whiskey, is
once admitted, it simply repeals
the dispensary law, and it repeals
it in an unconstitutional manner;
for if whiskey can be sold from
private residences, if a man's house
can be turned into a saloon, if a
private residence can be made a
bar from which whiskey can bfi
transmitted into pockets, or "hy
other means to regular saloons, and
we are not permitted to go in that
private residence, search for and
seize contraband goods, you can
readily see it is useless !.o pretend
to say that we have a dispensary
law. It is a law, was enacted by
the Legislature and it is on the
Statute books. I, as chief execu
tive, have sworn that the laws ol
this State shall be obeyed and re
spected ; and until the dispensary
law is repealed legally
SO HELP ME GOD
I will exert all the powers I have tc
see that all the laws are obeyed.
(Cheers.)
Now, gentlemen, we will not dis
cuss the reasons, whys and where
fores, and advantages and disad
vantages of the dispensary law
that will be a political issue in the
coming campaign, and you, the
sovereign people of South Caro
lina, will pass on it at the ballot
box.
THE DARLINGTON AFFAIR.
When, unfortunately, the colli
sion occurred at Darlington t
news was flashed from end of Sou
Carolina to the other that an ar]
ed mob (hundreds of men it w
said) were mounted, in pursuit
tho State's officers, charging the
with having wantonly provok
the conflict and murdered inuoce
citizens. How do the facts be
out the statement? The constabl
had discharged their duty, and hi
gone to the depot ; they had bei
sent to Darlington because the s
who were on the ground had bei
nearly mobbed the first day, hi
to desist from the execution
warrants and return to their hote.
and when the chief was orden
here with reinforcements, tl
mayor had allowed them to be i
suited, abused, and cursed to the
faces; an armed mob had brok?
into tho armory and stolen tl
guns of the military company, ai
the spectacle was presented of cit
zens seizing thc arms of the Sta
for the purpose of shooting dow
officers of the State. I ordered 01
the local company, and the capta;
telegraghed me he had recoven
thc guns; not trusting his cor
maud I ordered the Sumter cor
pany to go there ; when they r
ported everything was quiet I o
dered them to return home.
Now when the constables got
the depot, two boys, stripplings,g
into a fight, ene got whipped ar
ran off and got reinforcements ar
came back with 25 or 50 men (u
don't know now many), armed
the teeth; they rushed down i
the depot and picked a quarr
with the constables; the collisic
occurred, men were killed on bot
sides, and tho fault cannot I
clearly placed yet, if it is ev<
clearly placed. Now the Mayor i
Darlington said that the taking <
the arras by the mob was fun
the same kind of fun we have see
s?sewhere in the State. The armj
ries were broken into here and tl
armory of Chester was broken inl
and some of the militia, have bee
in open mutiny against the Con
monder-iu-chief and have refuse
toohey orders; but, thank Goi
enough were left to respond to tl
call-enough of you old soldie
boys to realize tho danger, au
know that this govermeut is of tb
people, by the people and for th
people, and no oligarchy aha
ever rule it again. You responde
to the call of the Governor, an
are here to uphold the la\
(Cheers.)
THE MAYOR OF DARLIXGTOM
this morning, in an address, trie
to throw the blame elsewhere, say
ing I claim and exercise power t
other Governor or executive c
officer of the United States eve
exercised. I cannot undertake t
go through all the charges or es
planations he has made. I wi,
briefly show just what the facti
as stated from their own stanc
point'prove. These troops.
THESE BAND-BOX TROOPS
who have refused to obey order
i (laughter and cheers), these sol
diers turned politicians, and in
fluenced by political rancor an
frenzy have, by their action, am
the men in different places in thi
State, who have sent word b
Darlington offering assistante
, bave convicted themselves in . th
estimation of the world, and i
cannot be disproved that they ar
lynchers at heart. The informa
hon sent forth was that these me]
? were to be hunted down and lynch
; ed, and not one to be left alive
[ and when I ordered troops to g
i lhere to &top insurrection, to sto]
, this mob, restore law, protect lif
and property, and "let the law re
sumo its sway, they wouldn't obey
' The mayor said he had the righ
! to arrest; of course he did, but h
. had no right to send out a mob
. army undor no officer, without th
sheriff, or some regularly constitu
ted constable in charge of it.
Let us look at.
THE RIDICULOUS SIDE OF IT.
In some respects it has the ap
1 pearance of a big April fool.but iba
it occurred on the 30th of March
I say these men were advertisiui
. themselves to the world as lynch
ere, and that they intended t(
lynch these constables who wen
in the woods; none of them guilt}
of having started the row, they
' were galloping aud hurrahing ovei
? the country, sending for reinforce
. ments and all bearing arms, bul
. they have never fired a shot at ?
single constable. They waylaic
constables at the depots, but have
never seen one since the first fire
. (laughter), and it seems the^
? miWIH IM- lill Bil IMMM -
didu't want to find the constabl
If they were lynchers,as they ?
vertised themselves to be, w
didn't they lynch the man \vb(
they claimed originated the trc
ble, and whom they had in tb
power? They have slandered the:
selves by proclaiming that th
would lynch those who had caus
it, but would not lynch the m
whom they say did cause it.
TAE SCENE IN 1876.
Now, "gentlemen, it is proper f
me to rocall the scenes witness
here in 1876. Wehn South Cai
lina learned that troops had seizi
this State House, within two da
time this whole encampment ba
to the monument was black wi
indignant citizens I. was arno
them)., but they were all of o
mind. We were all brothers, 1
were all friends and Carulinia
and patriots. To-day we find t
State divided into two hoati
camps. Why? Simply because t
the minority are not willing to 1
the majority govern. The bo<
politic is disseased ; it is in a fev<
Why? Because in this city ai
in Charleston the people ha
taken to their bosoms.
A VIPER IN THE SHAPE OK A NE'\
PAPER.
which distills day by day pois?
into their system, and will not 1
the fever subside. They give r
credit for nothing. In thc
vocabulary Governor Tillman
side of the ledger is all debit ai
no credit. They try to stiug r
personally by abuse slander ai
misrepresentation. I wear a co
of mail which they have nev
pierced-that is an honest hen
desirous of bettering the interoi
of this State, and looking to tl
welfare of the whole peeple. B
fellow citizens this strained rel
tionship between factions
South Carlina must stop mu
cease, it cannot go on wi tho
precipitating civil war.
We of the majority facii .n a
NOT TO BLAME.
I deny that we have done anythii
except in accordance with the In
and the constitution. These m<
who have opposed us, and are sti
opposing us must come to the
senses and realize that if Dem
cracy is to govern in this count]
they have got to submit to the ru
of the majorety. These two new
papers are like a thorn in the fle?
which continues to fester, Th?
will not let the wound which wi
caused in 1890 by the displac
ment of the old order of thinj
and the establishment of the ru
the of people, heal. They.
KEEP OFEN THE SORE,
they pour poison in it, and UK
are encouraged,to do it, aided ai
abetted in doing it by thos?> wi
are forever and eternally blamii
1 me with it. Well this patient
like a maniac ; there is a powdi
magazine not far off, he has
lighted match and is straining a
i his nerve to reach it. The collisio
in Darlington produced a flam
but it was gas aud not powde
mostly newspaper lies, lt flashc
abroad, flashed a light that i
i luminated the State and the Unite
States, based on falsehood. Tl
people listened with bated breat
i for a reverberation of the repo
; for the explosion expected to fo
i low the civil war which was pr
. dieted. It didn't come, and it wi
not come ; it cannot come beean?
. thc people aro in the saddle an
will continue to remain tlier
i
, (Cheers.) These.
MEN WOULD DESTROY THE STATE.
. in their bitterness and anger,
, thereby they could destroy me an
; through me the rule of the majori V
j It has been sent abroad all ovo
. this State and the Uuited S'ate
; that my life is daily threatens
. that such and such men are off';:
ing to go to Columbia to kill m
One prominent citizen has ha
the temerity, or rathor the folly t
tell Mr. Ye Idell-of my ow
? county-he came to Columbia wit
f a shot gun Friday.
r TO KILL GOVERNOR TILLMAN.
3
? I will not give his name, because
? do not care to advertise him bi
5 can do it when ^necessary. Th real
- ened men live longest ; a barkin
' dog does not always bite. Ther
never has been one moment whe
. I felt the least uneasiness for m
; personal safety. My life is no
i worth much to me, hut is worth a
[ much as any other matt's and rath
i er than deseit ray post to m;
i enemies by leaving the executiv
. Mansion where ycu had placed m
, I would bave gone out of it a
? corpse. (Cheers.)
Who is doing all this?
THE BLAZING ELEMENT.
the match which is trying to reach
the powder, is the barroom men,
the whiskey men and those who
are egging them on, encouraging
them are the rulers of the old
oligarchy whom we overthrew in
1890 at the ballot box. This row
which has broken forth is a politi
cal frenzy ; the blood that has
been splilt is an offering to the
Moloch of whiskey; they claim
and declare Uiat the State shall not
i control the whiskey traffics, that
they will resume their iniquitous
trade, debauch our households,
; destroy lives, furnish poison to
: the people and make them kill
: one another, and they will repeal
i the dispensary law by saying they
! can seli whiskey from their resi
: deuces. Shall this demon who
: has already had four or five vietims
; have any more? One negro at
Spurtanburg a white mau at Well
ford and three men at Darlington,
1 killed. I do not intend for him
i to have any more If I can help it
he has had enough. In God's
name as a statesmen and as a
? leader of enlightened public
opinion
I SHALLNOT BUDGE ONE INCH
' from tho position I take that this
is the people's government and
' the people shall rule it. (Cheers.)
Now, gentlemen, you may
imagine in asserting this, that I
j am going to aggravate the trouble
, that in claiming the right to
search privare residences I will
? cause an outbreak. I will tell you
what I am going to do.
? IN THE INTEREST OF PEACE.
t I am going to tell the State to
. morrow in a proclamation-the re
> vised statutes of South Carolina
' are a mine of strength, wealth, and
t wisdom for a Governor who will
search^ thorn..^.ujLeu/prAft-^them;
? What would I have been able to
do if I had not been able to con
trol the railroads and telegraph,
' preventing them from reinforcing
the insurgents and sending abroad
I lies to inflame the people? There is
r ANOTHER SWORD OF DAMOCLES
- which the law places in my hand
f to suspend over those insurgents
3 or people who are pressing for this
- law to be annulled without proces?
i by the Legislature; and to-morrow
f I shall cut the thread which hoi (IR
3 that in suspension and use it, and
- that is section 519, which gives me
3 power in an emergency to take
3 charge of the police. We have had
the spectacle presented of the offi
cers of the law opposing officers of
the law; those who have been
>r sworn to support the constitution
' and the laws, disobey them, and
3 aid others in disobeying them. Il
* the mayors and city councils dc
9 not make the police do their duty.
r I intend to see that the police dc
1 their duty or I will discharge the
' last man of them. (Cheers.) A
1 voice: That's the way to do them
!' I intend, as I say, to control thc
' State in the interest of law and
" order ; I
1 WILL NOT SURRENDER '10 ANY MOI
R or any whiskey element. If the
2 dispensary law is good and proper
1 and the people want it, they shal]
. have it, and those who don't want
. it must, take it. (Cheers.)
1 Until the result of the new move
3 is seen I shall confine tho duties oi
\ the constables to watching the rail
}< roads and seizing contraband whis
key, and to watching the police
seeing that they do their duty, anc
report to me whether they are do
f ing. If they don't obey my ordert
?1 strictly, if the authorities of the
_ towns don't co-operate, then I shal!
r call the Legislature of South Caro
3 lina together, and I will have the
[ power given the Executive to re
.. move these men and appoint othen
i# in their stead who will obey the
I law and enforce it. (Cheers.) We
0 will continue to search private
?j houses where contraband liquors
h are supposed to be, with warrants
when necessary. We are obliged
to do this as long as it is the law :
it is the law until repealed.
1 A voice : Why don't you obej
t the law yourself?
Gov. Tillman : In what rospeel
g have I not obeyet it?
e Cries of "Shoot him," "Shu!
a up."
y Gov. Tillman : Silence men, and
t koop quiet. It is true if the Legis
s laturo is assembled in extra 6ost>ior,
- it will cost moue}', but money is nc
y object when the rights and the lib
o ertiesof the peop'o aro involved,
D So there is an extra session in
sight to enact a metropolitan police
bill for all cities and towns unless
they co-operate with the executive
and remove this trouble.
In conclusion I will say
TO THOSE "WHO ARE OPPOSED
to this - law to submit, to quit, to
cease their opposition ; they must
cease it. We are not going to sur
render a good law because they are
opposed to it. I propose to uphold
the law. I have never done any
thing to aggravate tho situation;
I never; will. I cannot, I will not,
I dare not allow the minority to
come forward and say this is a bad
law; w? dont want it and will not
obey it; you cannot enforce it. If
this law is thus annulled, then any
law can.be similarly abrogated by
a minority, and all law become a
farce. We have thousands of other
good men besides yourselves who
are ready to respond. The people
of South Carolina must govern the
State, and those who are in rebel
lion must get out of the road, be
cause the train is on the track; I
have go? the throttle in my hand
as Governor; I am going in on
time, so help me God. (Cheers.)
EVANS READS AN ORDER.
j
At theicon^usion of his address
Gov. Tillman turned and
entered the capitol. Col. Mixon
brought the troops to a carry, and
the judge advocate general then
proceeded to read as follows:
GENERAL ORDER NO. 10.
The emergency requiring the as
sembling'of hoops at the capital
no longer exists and the colonel
commanding will return them to
their homes by the nearest practi
cable route on the first outgoing
train. The commander of each
company of militia and volunteers
will give a certificate to the rail
road conductors of the number of
men transported and the point to
which they;.go, which wi'l be a
voucher to the railroads for pay
mander-in-Chief in the name of
the State extends thanks to the
gallant and patriotic soldiers and
citizens, who at a moment's notice,
dropped their various avocations
and pursuits to respond to his call.
Their action is a stinging rebuke
to those companies which failed to
do their duty [in this crisis when
civil war and anarchy seemed to
stare us in the face. It shows to
the world, however, when the
masses of the people uphold tho
government treachery and mutiny
cannot overthrow it.
B. R. TILLMAN,
Govern'r and Commander-in-Chief.
Governor Tillman during the
? afternoon issued the following
proclamation which speaks for it
self and will become operative
to-day.
; PROCLAMATION.
i STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA, )
EXECUTIVE CHAMBER. >
I Columbia, S. C., April 3, 1894. )
WHEREAS, Section 519 of the
General Statutes of this State de
clares that "The Governor shall
have authority, whenever in his
i jndgment it shall be necessary, tc
arm the constabulary and in anj
emergency to assume the sole con
' trol of the whole or any part ol
! the municipal police in cities and
i incorporated towns, and to author
' ize the chief constable of the State
: or any deputy chief constable tc
command assistance in the execu
! tion of process, suppressing rio tt
: and in preserving peace." and.
Whereas, it is made the dut)
. of and the powor is given said
> police to enforoe the statute knowe
I as the "dispensary law," but thal
. instead of obej ing thc require
1 me nts of said law, the said police
. except in a very few towns, have
1 been an obstruction and are ae
. tive abettors of those who arc
! defying the law ; whereas, undei
? the same statute the Governor ie
; given power to appoint State con
! stales for thc purpose of its enforce
? ment; and whereas, the rcbelious
1 and lawless element of society have
1 hounded and insulted these ofiicen
'land sedulously educated the pub'
i lie mind to resistance, causing
I several encounters, resulting it
bloodshed between constables anc
' illicit whiskey sellers, producing
intense excitement and danger tc
: the peace and welfare of the State.
Now thareforo. I, Benjamin R
Tillman, Governor of the State ol
South Carolina, do issue thia mv
' proclamation giving full ant:
. official notice to tho municipal au
1 thorities of every city and incor
. porated town in the State of Soutl:
' Carolina and to the police au ci
marshals thereof, that under the
i powers given me by said Sectios
519, the emergeecy contemplated
baa arisen and does now exist, and
that I do hereby assume sole con
trol of the whole force of muni
cipal police and marshal? ot the
several cities and incorporated
towns of the State.. They are here
by ordered to enforce all laws on
the statate books, together with all
municipal authorities not incon
sistent with the purposes of the
proclamation. As soon as the
emergency which is now upon us
shall no longer exist I will re
linquish control and restore the
former status.
By the Governor.
B. R. TILLMAN,
Governor.
J. E. TINDAL, Sec of State.
A Xotablc Accession.
At the Aiken county comference
of reformers held last week, Sheriff
Holley, hitherto a conservative,
gave in his adherence to the re
formers. He was introduced by
Dr. R. H. Timmerman, a worthy
son of a worthy sire Hon W. H.
Timmerman. The following is
Mr. Holley's speech :
Mr. Holley was greeted with ap
plause. He said in substance:
I have been a farmer since I was
big enough to crawl. I have been
associated with the people of Aiken
county many years, and I have
lived pleasantly with them and
they have honored me, though I
have differed with them somewhat.
Believing that records are interes
ting, I haye preserved a copy of
the ticket I voted ou the 30th of
August 1S92.
I voted for the list of delegates
beaded by D. S. Henderson-the
Sheppard ticket; for Congress,
Robert Aldrich, for Solicitor G. D.
Bellinger; for Senator, John Gary
Evans. The balance of Mr. Holley's
ticket was mainly made up of Re
formers.
I endorsed the_call to get a^car>
didarcn^irm?
did what I promised. The time
Tillman first spoke here I was one
of a committee to meet him. I
found I had a little prejudice
against him-thought he was sim
ply after au office. I was not en
tirely sure I was right in opposing
him. I never told any man not to
vote for him. I have five boys,
and they all voted for him.
I believe Governor Tillman has
made some mistakes, but no man
has ever encountered the the op
position he has and done so much
under so many difficulties. I have
followed his career closely because
I wanted to find out if I was right
i in my course. It is the hardest
? thing for a man to confess being
in the wrong. That is the trouble
with this country. I believe all
should come up and acknowledge.
I have not been badly wrong
after all. I have not flopped. 1
balieve I am on the right side
uow.
, Yes, I was prejudiced against
Tillman, but I am here to say he
I was right and I was wrong-here
to say he can always be found true
, to what he says.
Ben Tillman has not stirred up
a hornets' nest but a nest of yel
I low jackets.
Mr. Holley then made many
pointed, sensible observations or
, matters of finance, covering
j mortgages, etc. He said he favored
a dog tax of $1, which should gc
? to the public schools. He believed
there was unfairness in theexemp
, tiou of certain enterprises from
I taxation. He had heard of cotton
, factories being exempted, bul
never of sawmills; he was verj
glad tho railroads had been com
pelled to pay their taxes ; he said
, the abuse of tho officers of the law
known as "spies" was abominable
? No human language was too vile tc
. apply to these constables. The
? good people are not in sympathy
with this abuse.
Tho Dispensary law is one of thc
, best laws ever put on the books
> I have watched its operations
; closely and am thoroughly con
vinced. I hope I shall never live
r to see open barrooms again. Thif
, expression was tremendous!)
I cheered.
I am not hunting office. I have
) good friends, many friends on the
otherside. They aro prejudiced.
I believe I am right becuase 1
? believe Tillman has done us sr
. much good.
I The chairman said: Sherifl
. Holley, are you with the Reform
. movement, heart, soul and body?'
, Sheriff Holley; -'I am with
1 them for all I am worth."
Then there was tremendous ap
i plauso.
BUTLER IN DARLINGTON.
SOME SAPIENT REFLEC
TIONS BUT VERY
ILLOGICAL CONCLUSIONS.
A Very Startling Position for a
Military Man to Take.
FLORENCE, April 3.-Senator
Butler says :
"I have come down from Dar
lington where I have been the past
twenty-four hours. As far as I
could learn everything is perfectly
quiet and the civil authorities pre
pared to discharge their duty. It
seems that a number of State con
stables or spies ae they are called,
had been to Darlington for the pur
pose of ascertaining if there was
any contraband whiskey. In the
search they made, they were sup
ported by the mayor and civil au
thorities of Darlington, as there
was not the slightest resistance to
this enforcement of the dispensary
law; on the contrary the people of
Darlington co-operated with the
enforcement. This was prior to
Thursday, March 29. It appears
the forc^ of constables or spies
was increased on that day, by a re
inforcement of about eighteen
men, armed with Winchester rifles
and pistols. Why this reinforce
ment of armed men should be sent
into a peaceable, law-abiding com
munity where there had been no
resistance to law, I cannot under
stand, and I think the authorities
will have difficulty in explaining
it. It also appears that this armed
band were about to retire from that
community where they had .not
.been .mole s ted-or disturbed,... wjben
a personal difficulty arose between
two young men at the railroad sta
tion where these spies were. This
difficulty, from what I can learn,
was an entirely personal matter be
tweeu the parties engaged and
in no way connected with the
execution of or resistance to the
dispensary law.
"One of these armed constables,
McClendon by name interfered in
this private difficulty. A citizen,
Mr. Norment, at the depot on busi
ness, made some remark, and there
was an inter-change of epithets be
tween him and this,man whereupon
the constable opened fire upon Mr.
Norment, with the remark, 'G-d
d-n it, boys, let her roll.' The
firing then became general be
tween the armed constables and
the few persons who appear to have
been at the station by accident or
on business. The result of this
firing was that two unoffending
citizens were slain, one constable
killed and this man McClendon
badly wounded, and several oth( r
citizens, among them the chief of
police, who was trying to preserve
order, were several times wounded.
"The people of Darlington, natur
ally indignant at the extraordinary
and violent measures adopted by
the authorities of tho State, were
outraged, and upon the informa
tion of this emute at the station
they set out and pursued the men
who they rightly thought had com
mitted a wanton and unprovoked
murder upon two of their best citi
zens. They pursued these men, I
take it, as long as there was a pros
pect of arresting them, and, we
must assume, bringing them to
justice for what they considered an
unprovoked homicide. As a proof
of their conservatism, the wounded
man, Mr. McClendon, who had shot
Mr. Norment, was taken to the jail
and there protected from further
injury, although the people of that
town were greatly infuriated at his
conduct.
"I think it may be safely asser
ted that there is not a more law
abiding, inteligent community
anywhere in the United States
than the two counties of Darling
ton and Florence. Now. it does
seem to me that if I had been
Governor of the State of South
Carolina I would have felt it to
be my duty, upon being informed
of the occurrences at Darlington,
have gone promptly to the scene
of the disturbance aud assured the
people of that hitherto law-abiding
community that they should have
fair play. I think if Governor
Tillman had done this matters
could have been composed in 24
[lours, and whoever should Been
proven to be in fault would have
been made amenable to the law. In
stead of that he issued a proclama
tion denouncing thc good people
Df these two counties as insurgents
and insurrectionists and ordered
the military of the State to camp
upon them.
During my stay at Darlington I
vas deeply impressed with the
anxiety of both the citizens and
the military to keep within the
limits of the law. I advised as far
as I had the right to advise, that
under our form of government the
military be subordinate to the
civil power, and the use of the
military arm was only justifiable
when the civil authority was prov
ed to be powerless and paralyzed
and, I think, if Governor Tillman
had or could recognize this Con- '
etitutional relation of the two
powers of our goveanment, he
would avoid many of Jthe blunders
which he has made. There are
two ways to execute any law. The
one by wisdom and conservatism
and fairness, and the other by
harshness, violence, and au over
bearing diregard of the citizens.
I need not now express any
opinion in regard to the dispen-.
sary law, but I may say that, in
my judgement, the Governor is
attempting to enforce it in a harsh
violent and ill-advised manner.
He ought to know that the Anglo
Saxon race, particularly in our
day and generation, will not sub
mit, beyond a certain point to be
harried and repressed and pursued.
The Constitution of the United
States and of the State gurantees
the citizen against unreasonable
searches,and is nothing there in the
dispensarylaw that I know of,which
justifies an invasion of this sa
cred right. Governor Tillman must
not imagine from the patrotic
submission of the people in the
city of Charleston, where he seems
to have practically unchallenged
sway in the harsh execution of this
law, that the people outside of that
city, less accustomed to the res
triauts of municipal government,
will quietly submit to invasion of
their righ ts and it would be prud
ent on his part to go slow in the
rigid enforcement of a \ery un
popular law.
"I should not be understood as
encouragingjin the slightest degree
lawlessness or resistance in any
form to lawful authority. The peo
ple of Darlington and Florence, as
a rule, have not resisted the lawful
authority. There may be exception
al instances, as there are in every
community, but they do not justify
the wholesale denunciation which
he seems to have put upon them.
From what I observe in both these
counties there has not been the least
excuse or justification for ordering
the military to these points. He
has done so at an enormous expen
se to the taxpayers of the State,and
of course, he will have to look out
for that.
"While in Darlington, I advised,
as far as I had the right to advise,
that] the friends of the deceased
who were killed in the emute at
the railroad station, go before the
trial jvstice, make affidavit charg
ing the accused parties of the
offence which they thought they
were guilty of. demand the issu
ance of a warrant, let the same be
placed in the hands of a duly au
thorized constable or citizen, or
where the accused has fled the juris
diction of a warrant, that it be
sent to the sheriff of the county
where they are found,endorsed and
served by him, so that the parties
might be arrested according to law,
required to appear, give bond and
answer to the charges in the due
course of judicial administration.
If resistance should be made to
the constable of the trial justice,
and he should fail to make the ar
rest, he should be required to en
dorse such failure on the warrant,
and then, and then only, the civil
authorities should call on the mili
tary to act as a posse for the arrest
of the accused.
"I see by tho papers that Gov
ernor Tillman, in a note to Capt.
McCaughrin of the military
company, has stated that'the duty
of the soldiers, and thc militia are
soldiers, when called into servive
is blind obedience to orders from
his superior, and not to question
them in any way,' To my mind
this proposition is simply mon
strous, and is not true. No officer
is bound to obey the orders of his
superior when thc order issued is
illegal. Nothing is better settled
in military law than that. Suppose
CONTINUED ON SECOND^PAGE,