The Abbeville press and banner. (Abbeville, S.C.) 1869-1924, May 17, 1922, Image 1
Press and Banner
Istablished 1844. $2.00 Year. Tri-Weekly
Abbeville, S. C., Wednesday, May 17,1922
Single Copies, Five Cents. 78th Year.
lOMMITIEE WINS
TEST IN SENATI
EPUBLICAN TARIFF BLOC R?
VISED FOR MOMENT?MAR
GIN OF ONLY THREE VOTE!
ON CITRATE OF LIME ISSUE
TO TRY AGAIN.
Washington, May 16._-The sen
:e Republican tariff bloc, whicl
icceeded in having the finance com
ittee accept most of its tariff rate:
i products of the farm and ranch
as defeated today in the senate ii
s first test of strength against th<
>mmittee. The margin was onl;
iree votes, however, and le?aders o:
10 bloc expressed confidence tha
ley would be successful in futuri
forts as some of their group wen
>sent today or paired.
The test came on an ame-ndmen
v Senator Johnson (Republican) o:
alifornia to increase the committet
ite 6 cents a pound on citrate o;
me to 9 cents. The vote was 31 t<
"* "* " "I /
5, l < uemucrais juiiung mw
epublicans in opposing: the Johnsor
nendment.
After rejecting the amendment
le senate approved the committe<
lty of 18 cents a pound on citric
nd, the finished product of citrate
me. Senator Johnson had urgec
lat the duty on this 'be 20 cents z
ound. A proposal by Senator Kinj
Democrat) of Utah that the dutj
a. reduced to 5 cents a "pound wai
ejected.
Another fight over products oi
le Far West followed disposition oi
le citric acid the Democratic oppo&
ig the committee rate of 60 cent3 s
illon on olive oil in containers
feifehing not more than 44 pounds
id 50 cents a gallon on all other
ich oil. These rates were approved
fter the senate had rejected bj
rerrhelming majorities amend
ments by Senator Walsh (Demo
t) of Massachusetts to cut tnt
to the 30 cents and 20 cents
the Underwood law. The senatf
}so rejected an amendment by Sec
tor King to make the rates 50 cents
id 40 cents as originally proposed
the committee.
Supporting his amendment Sena
>r Walsh declared that no questior
|f protection could enter into th(
latter because the American pro
[ucers of olive oil in California ant
Lria?na could supply only about I
^er ?ent of domestic consumption
te eharged that this was an effor
plainly to increase the price of th<
brod?ct for the benefit of the pro
lucers in the two Western state
pd asserted that this works a hard
[hip on consumers, especially Ital
Ian-Americans in New York an<
kher Eastern cities.
"You are abandoning entirely th
Vid theory of protecting infant in
iustries," he declared. "You are nov
proposing to protect every man ii
^his country who produces one-hal
)f 1 per cent of any commodity use<
>y tke American people. You an
mine to such an extent that there i
>ound to be a collapse of the entir
economic system in this country."
Chairman McCumber dispute*
hat the duty proposed would work ,
lar-dship on any one.
SHRINE SPECIAL
The Shrine special train leave
Ajbberille tonight for Rock Hill an
the following will make up the pai
ty: David Wood, A. H. Leslie, Jot
W. Hale, E. tF. Arnold, J. L. Wilsor
p r Smmtenfhursr. W. F. Jones, R. E
Cox, J. K. McDorman, A. H. Rosen
berg, Arthur Rosenberg, H. C. Fer
nell, P. J. Leach, H. B. Wilson an
H. S. Howie.
NEW BOOKS AT LIBRARY.
The following new books hav
seen received at the Library: "Mid
light," by Octaveus Roy Cohen; "Th
Charmed Circle" by Alden Allei
Teweil, and "If Winter Comes" b;
s. m. nuicmsns?u.
[
ACT OF CONGRESS PROHIBITED
EXPORT OF PRODUCTS IN
5 WHOSE MANUFACTURE THE
CHILD LABOR LAW HAD
BEEN USED
Washington, May 16._-The child
labor law was today held by the su
preme court to be unconstitutional
and not valid.
The. supreme court having held in
valid an act of congress which pro
?jhibited the exportation of products
^ | in whose manufacture child labor
F'
1 j had been used, substantially the
1 same law was re-enacted with an
-: excise tax of ten per cent imposed
sj upon the annual net profits of es
tablishments employing child labor,
t; Opponents of the law contended it
f j was an unconstitutional invasion of
2 the nolice Dowers of the states.
The decision of the court was rend
) | ered in a case brought by the gov
^ j ernment against the Drexel Furni
1 i ture company of North Carolina and
j was one of three case6 brought in
?j that state testing the validity of the
'! law, and in all of which the Uni
-1 ted States district court decided
- j against the government.
* j The Atherton mills . case from
1 North Carolina, brought originally to
test the constitutionality of the
child labor law, was dismissed today
Iby the supreme court. It sought to
restrain the znill from discharging
John W. Johnson, a minor whose
:ontinued emplyment would have
imposed under the law a penalty up
on the net annual profits of the
mill. Since the case has been pend
i i inc in the courts the minor reached
' I an age when the law would no long
LI er apply to hdm, and it therefore be
' came moot, other cases "being substi
|tuted hy the gvernment to teat the
I law.
M The supreme court announced to
| day that the case brought by the
government against John George
and others of North Carolina to test
the constitutionality of the child
labor act also would be dismissed.
BRADLEY NAMED
STATE BANK EXAMINER
Succeeds James H. Craig, Who Has
Resigned to Accept Another
Position
nu
pe
be
th(
ho
on
lo^
ins
mi
Lo
ye
Columbia, May 17.?Governor
Cooper yesterday announced the res
ignation of James H. Craig, state
bank examiner, and at the same time
announced the appointment of W. W.
Bradley to succeed Mr. Craig. Mr.
Bradley will assume his new duties
this morning.
Mr. Craig resigned to accept the
position of treasurer of the Tri-State gi\
Tobacco Growers' association of
South Carolina, North Carolina and
Virginia, a responsible position. Mr.
Craig will continue his associations
with the banks of this state in his
new work and his family will continue
to reside at Anderson.
Mr. Craig and Mr. Bradley have
been associated in the state banking
department for something more than
seven years. For nearly four years
Mr. Craig has been chief examiner
and at the head of the department.
Mr. Bradley, the new chief exam
iner, has served seven years as state
auditor and assistant examiner. He
expects to take over the new position
f.nHar
br
th<
th<
gr;
ha
til
tei
be
Mi
th
mi
ch
of
ot!
ho
br
E.
th
1.
th
1,
COTTON MARKET
fo
J*
cl<
l
Cotton on the local market today
ur
l
brought 20 cents. Futures closed:
gr
d
May
21.35
th
July ?
20.37
ra
October ? _
20.20
ge
December
20.08
mi
January
19.94
ho
e
Yesterday futures closed:
de
-
May __
21.23
sa
e
July ?
20.47
gr
i
October _ _ _
20.48
tei
y
December
20.44
M)
January
20.27
f
ILL BE IN RACE FOR GOVER
NORSHIP OF STATE__ STATE
SUPERINTENDENT OF EDU
CATION IN PRIMARY THIS
SUMMER
Columbia, May 16.__John E.
vearingen, state superintendent of
iucation, yesterday announced that
> would be a candidate for gover
r in the Democratic primary ttiis
mmer.
Mr. Swearingen is widely known
er the state, is recognized as a
an of ability and strength and the
inouncement of his intention to en
r the primary will be read with in
rest Some months ago, Avhen a
eeting of the county superintend
4-rm ?-C r\ -p A ?*f of n wqe
ILd UjL COiUtailUU VI bile Oi/C?CW
'ing held, a motion was made to
e effect that the superintendents
dorse Mr. Swearingen for- governor
r. Swearingen would not put the
otion while he was, in the chair,
it later it was stated and was act
upon favorably with some one
>e presiding. Since that .time there
ve been numerous rumors to the
feet that Mr. Swearingen would
row his hat in the ring, but while
had been asked many times
aether or not he would make the
ce, he withheld a definite reply,
ough his friends knew that he was
ving the matter careful considera
in.
Several time6 when he was asked
lether or not he was going to run
spoke of his interest' in the pulblic
hools and of the opportunity for
vice the office of the superintend
t of education gave him.
USTODY OF LOUISI
AWARDED
DGE GARY FILES ORDER IN C/
HE HOLDS MESCHINES ENTIT
CHILD COMMITTED
Judge Frank B. Gary yesterday
;d his order in the Habeas Corpus
>ce<Mling involving the eus'ody of
uise Clinkscales. The case was
ard by Judge Gary Saturday, a
mbcr of interested Lowndesviila
ople attending the hearing.
The text of the order reproduced
low will give the material facts of
; case as well as the rulings and
Idings of the Judge. The order,
litting the formal parts, is as fol
vs:
This is a habeas corpus proceeding
tituted for the purpose of deter
ning who shall have the custody of
uise Clinkscales, an infant ten
ars of age. The conditions that
re rise to the contention may be
iefly stated as follows: The wife of
AW o f l**l A
B Jjetll/iuiiei uicu a ouvii, uuie urei
j birth of this infant, and her
andmother, Mrs. E. C. Meschine,
s cared for her in every way un
the death of Mrs. Meschine about
i months ago. Whatever may have
en the conditions upon which Mrs.
sschine took the child, (and about
is there is some conflict of testi
jny) there is no question that the
ild was reared in the household
her grand-parents and no one
her than the members of this house
Id has contributed anything to her
inging up. After the death of Mrs.
C. Meschine about ten months ago
e child remained as a member of
e Meschine household, being cared
r by her grandfather, her two un
?s and the wife of one of these
icles. About two weeks ago the
andfather died. The appearance of
e child indicates most careful
ising. She manifested much intelli
nce and much affection for the re
lining members of the Meschine
usehold with whom she strongly
sires to live. They manifest the
me love for her. She is in the fourth
ade at school and is a regular at
ndant upon the Sunday Schools,
any of the citizens of the vicinity
the Meschine home attest the
SENATOR GOODING, CHAIRMAN
OF TARIFF BLOC SAYS HE
FINDS NONE ON FREE LIST.
AVERAGE ON FARM PROD
UCTS IS 23 3-10 PER CENT.
Washington, May 16.?All prod
ucts of the farm are on the dutiable
list in the McCumber-Fordney tariff
bill, Senator Gooding1, of Idaho,
chairman of the Republican agricul
tural tariff bloc, announced today in
the Senate.
"If any farm product is on the
free list, I do not know what it is,"
he said.
"If we find it we will put it on the'
dutiable list if it needs protection."
Senator Gooding said the average
' rate of duty in the bill on farm pro
! ducts was 21 3-10 per cent and called
! attention that only a few things pro
duced by the farmer were on the du
tiable list in the Underwood law.
The Idaho Senator declared that
jthe United States "ought to pretty}
near close its ports," to similar for-j
eign products when there was an
overproduction of staple farm prod
ucts. He declared that when there
was an overproduction of manufac
tured articles the manufacturers
closed their factories with the ap
proval of the public, but added that
the farmer could not cease produc
tion. He argued, however, that what
he described as the Democratic pol
icy of "free trade" would drive the
farmers to a curtailment of output. .
The tariff bloc chairman asserted
that "all this talk about tne McOum
ber bill being framed behind closed
doors is without foundation."
I CLINKSCALES
TO THE MESCHINES
ISE HEARD SATURDAY IN WHICH
LED TO REAR AND CARE FOR
TO PARENTS' CARE
I mnrnl rharflftpr nf t.ViP tmclps and
the aunt by marriage, and testify to
their fitness and ability to properly
look after the child.
T.he father of the child has mar
ried again and now has a wife and
three small children. He was recently
convicted of violation of the prohi
bition law and remained in jail for
quite awhile being unable to pay his
fine. He secured his release by re
sorting to the pauper debtors Act.
Barring this, nothing is shown against
his moral character.
In determining what should be
done with the child, her welfare is
the paramount consideration. No one
' nas an aDsomte ngnc 10 ner cusiouy
that is superior to her welfare. In
determining what is best for the child
the Court is not unmindful of the
claims of parental feeling to consid
eration. In this case, however, those
feelings have not been fostered by
association with her, and by doing
for her in her helpless state. But on
the other hand others than the fath
er have been permitted to perform
those services for her. These ser
vices inevitably created strong ties
of love between the child and those
who have cared for her and who are
still caring for her. In view of the
strong and intelligent preference as
exhibited by the child for those who
are caring for her, and her indiffer
'ence to those who are now seeking
to get possession of her, I think it
would be cruel to disturb the happy
relations now existing. Perhaps the
father will be better prepared from
a moral standpoint and from a finan
cial standpoint than he now is to
-??? ll/l n o eV?A cVlAlll/1 K O PpT.
I CttJ lllid ClliiU do OliC Otiv/uxu I/WI A V*
haps, her environment will be such
that her welfare will demand that
other disposition be made of her. If
such time should come, the Courts
will be open to those interested in
changing her situation, and the Court
presumably will act as it now seeks
to act, with an eye single to the wel
i
NO PARTICIPATION
BY UNITED STATES
i
INVITATION TO TAKE PART IN I
SECOND ECONOMIC DISCUS
SION TO BE HELD AT THE HA
GUE DECLINED IN MESSAGE
FROM STATE DEPARTMENT.
Washington, May 16.?The state
department made public last night the |
text of a message to Ambassador (
Child at Genoa declining the invita- (
tion to participate in the new Euro- |
pean economic conference at The |
Hague. i
"This government," the American 1
communication said, "is unable to i
conclude that it can helpfully partic- j
ipate in the meeting at The Hague ]
as this would appear to be the con- (
t'nuance under a different nomen- .
clature of the Genoa conference and ]
destined to encounter the same dif- -
ticuities n tne attitude aisciosea m ]
the Russian memorandum of May 11
remains unchanged."
The "inescapable and ultimate
question," the American note said,
"would appear to be the restoration
of productivity in Russia, the essen
tial conditions of which are still to be
secured and must in the nature of
things be provided within Russia her- ,
self." !
The state department communica- (
tion said the American government!
"has always been ready" to join
other governments in arranging for
"an inquiry by experts into the eco
nomic situation in Russia and the
necessary remedies." Such an inquiry
it was added could deal appropriate
ly "with the economic prerequisites"
for restoration of Russian produc
tion, without which a sound basis for
credits would be lacking.
In conclusion the American com
munication renewed 'the offer to give
serious attention to "any new pro
posals issuing from the Genoa con
ference or any later conference," but
added that the suggestions for the
meeting at The Hague in view of the
Russian memorandum lacked "the
definiteness which would make pos- ^
sible the concurrence of this govern
ment in the proposed plan."
FOUR BISHOPS NAMED
BY THE METHODISTS
Elected on Five Ballots During Day.
Fifth Ballot Declared "No
Election"
Hot Springs, Ark., May 16.__Af
ter taking five ballots which result
ed in the election of four of the five
bishops to be named at this time,
the 19th quadriennial conference of (
the Methodist Episcopal Church,
South, recessed this evening until
tomorrow when the next ballot will
be taken.
Theee men were elected bishops at
today's session :Dr. J. E. Dickey,
Griffin, Ga.; Dr. W. B. Beauchamp,
Nashville, Tenn.; Dr. Sam R. Hay,
Houston, Texas, and Dr. H. M.
Dobbs of Anniston, ,Ala.
Drs. Dickey and Beauchamp wont
over on the second ballot, receiving
1Q4 onri 909 votps. resDectivelv. Dr.
Hay was elected on the third bal
lot with 191 votes, whil? Dc. Dobbs
won on the fourth with 256 votes.
The first and fifth ballots were de
clared "no elections" as none of the
candidates received the required ma
jority of 189 votee.
The fifth ballot was not completed
until this evening. Dr. H. A. Boaz,
president of Southern Methodist
university, Dallas, Texas, was high
with 143 votes and C. E. Goddard of
Nashville was second with 140. Dr.
mission sprrrf^tarv. I
VJUUUttlU 10 livmc ?
fare of the child.
The prayer of the Petitioner is re- j
fused, and the Sheriff is hereby di- 1
rected to return to Mr. and Mrs.
Morrison Meschine and Reynolds Mes
caline the said Louise Clinkscales.
They are charged with her proper
i-earing.
HARVEY WILL NOT
ENTER PRIMARIES
?i?
YOT IN RACE FOR GOVERNOR
OR LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR.
BUT FEELS HE OWES IT TO
STATE TO DEVOTE HIS TIME
TO NEW OFFICE.
Columbia, May 16.?In response
;o an invitation from Governor Coop
;r to come to ^Columbia for a confer
ence, Wilson G. Harvey, of Charles
ton, Lieutenant Governor, spent yes
terday here taking up with the Gov
ernor many matters connected with
the Governor's office. While he had
no announcements to make at this
time, as he feels that such state
ments should emanate from the GoV
rvrrmr T.ioiifonnnf.dnvornnr Homnn
-- 9 ?V%.VV..?..V MV.VAMV* VVJT
stated that he thought it wise for
him at this time to state his position
with reference to going into the pri
mary this summer.
"My business obligations in Char
leston for the next several months,"
lie said, "coupled as they will be with
the official duties incident to the
Governorship would preclude me
from expending the time and money
necessary to a State canvass and
campaign for the Governorship, con
sequently I will not be a candidate
for Governor in the forthcoming
campaign. In reaching this determi
nation I have had to curb a natural
inclination so to do. and to denv the
kind urging on the part of many
friends whose interest and kindness
and offers I so much appreciate.
"The announcement made by me
a few weeks ago that I would be a
candidate for reelection for Lieuten
ant-Governor was made with the firtn
determination on my part to stand
tor the office on my record aricfitaake '
i State canvass for the office, if I
:ould have secured the office by an
louncing myself and not making the
:anvass. I desired it, otherwise I did
lot care for it.
"It is needless to say that in the cir
:umstances which have since mate
-ialized I will not now be a candidate
:or LieutenantXJovernor."
' !>1
When asked if .he had made any
irrangements looking to appoint
nents, Mr. Harvey said that while
lothing definite had been determined
ipon, it would be his policy to con
;inue in service the present clerical
:orce in the Governor's office. The
jest interests of the State he felt
vould be served by hariag those fa
niliar with the duties remain in of
ice during the months to co*e.
ABBEVILLE INVITES HEROES
3f the Gray to Meet Here Next
Year.
The Abbeville Chapter of the U.
D. C. has extended an invitation to
the Confederate Veterans to meet
in Abbeville in 1923. The invitation
was endorsed by the city of Abbe
ville and by all of the public orga
nizations. It was extended through
Mr. J. M. Gambrell, ex-officio Com
mander of the Abbeville Post, <who
went to Darlington yesterday to at
tend the convention.
Mrs. Lucy Thomson and Mrs. W.
A. Harris have been busy this week
making arrangements for tne enier
taimment of the veterans in case
Abbeville's invitation is accepted
There is an appropriation of $700
from the state that will be available
and with what has been promised in
town we should Ibe able to give ther
old soldiers a rousing good time.
The City of Greenville has also
extended an invitation for the next
meeting to be held in that city.
ATTEND EPISCOPAL COUNCIL
Wm. M. Barnwell and J. Townes
Robertson are representing the Ab
beville church at the Episcopal
Council which met yesterday
morning at St. Philip's church in
Charleston. This is the on? hundred
and thirty-second Council of the
Diocese of South Carolina and many
matters of importance will be con