The Abbeville press and banner. (Abbeville, S.C.) 1869-1924, August 12, 1896, Image 10
THEGOVERNOR REVIEWED.
HIS DEFIANCE OF LAW DISCUSSED DY
A CITY ATTORNEY.
Evanx, the individual, Liable l,o Arrest
Just as auy Other Citizen of the State
Who Violates the Law?The (loveruor
Not Entitled to Kingly Perogat Ives.
Florence, August 5.?City Attorney
George G. Thompson lavt week
addressed the following lette r to the
city council, in view of the recent action
of Governor Evans in defying
arrest fnr hrear.h nf the tieace here:
"Florence, S. Cm J uly 31, 189G.
To the City Council:
On last Friday, J. Gary Evans, who
holds the official position of governor,
of the State of South Carolina, and
Joseph H. Earle, a judge of the circuit
court of this State, each in his
personal and private capacity, and exercising
the right held by every citizen
of this State, was addressing in
public with this city, a large number
of citizens, each endeavoring in according
to his methods, to secHre Lbe
votes of the people of this county.
During the progress of this meeting
these two political contestants became
engaged in a personal combat. Hundreds
of men were present; some drew
pistols, others made ready for their
use, excitement ran high. One stray
shot by any excited spectator would
in all probability have precipitated a
riot and many lives might have been
sacrificed. The peace of the city was
jeopardized and its laws violated.
I was communicated with by the
mayor and advised him that these parties
could and should be arrested with
OUt regara lUCir urnumi inniuuua.
Warrants were accordingly issued
charging them with fighting and
breach of the peace. Joseph H. Earie
rendered ready obedience, but J. Gary
Evans resisted and defied the law. He
told the chief of police to take the
warrant back to the mayoi "with the
contempt it deserves," and that he
"considered it an insult" He informed
the mayor that he could not be arrested
; that the only way to reach him
was by impeachment. He threatened
to use the power of his office to protect
him fiom the consequences of the
broken law. He threatened to "take
charge of the mayor and the town,"
or words to this effect. We are left
to conjecture as to precisely what J.
Gary Evans meant by "taking charge
of the town." As interpreted at the
time by several of his constables, who
!ll. of iVlA of
were wiiu uilli ai? tug uuiv v* ?4av m?
tempted arrest, it was an unworthy
and unlawful threat to resort to the
metropolitan police. J. Gary Evans
was not arrested. He left the city and
has since boasted through the press
that the town authorities apologized
for the attempted affront to "his excellency."
I never advised that the governor
could be arrested, but then advised,
and still reiterate that J. Gary Evans
could and should have been arrested,
and that without regard to his official
position and without regard to consequences,
even if it required every man
in the city to accomplish it, and even
if it entailed penalty of metropolitan
police.
In his novel position, that he is
above the law, sound from point of
law or reason? From the standpoint
of reason such a position, in the expressive
language or The News and
Courier is "simply monstrous," and
coming from the person claiming the
exemption, can only be accounted for
on tne theory of total ignorance of
the first principles of republican govflmmmt
or such a diseased imagina
tion as approximates the condition of
our friends,the doctors would call "dementia
of egotism."
Such an exemption could only arise
under the common law or by statute,
including the constitution. The common
law can hardly be appealed to,
for no such office is known to it, for it
is a creatior? of the constitution. It
could arise from the common law on
tne theory of "kingly prerogatives,"
inherited from the sovereigns of Eng
land, and it seems that our governor
rests his case on this theorv, for he informed
the mayor that he could no
more be arrested than the "king (sovereign)
of England," or words to that
effect, forgetting at the moment of
this ridiculous assumption of "kingly
prerogative," that the doctrine of "the
king can do no wrong" has no place
among republican simplicity; that a
monarch the sovereignty resides in
the person of the king, but in a republic
tnis sovereignty abides in the people.
The constitution which creates his
office gives him no comfort in this remarkable
assumption. Article 2, section
14, article 3, section 14, and article
13, section 2, exempt at certain
times electors on the day of election,
members of both houses and volunteer
militia forces, from arrest, but is par-1
ticular in each case to expressly pro
vide that these exemptions shall not
apply to "treason, felony or breach
of the peace." Article 15, section 3,
provides that "the governor and all
other executive and judicial officer,
shall be liable to impeachment; but
judgment in such cases shall not extend
further than removal from office.
The persons convicted shall, nevertheless,
be liable to indictment, trial
and punishment according to law."
It is ODvious that this section does not
fix the time in which an indictment
may lie to after conviction on impeachment,
but only intends to prevent
a conviction on impeachment
being plead in bar to an "indictment,
trial and punishment according to
law." If this contention were true,
?Af olnnA
U1BU Llio guycruui wum u</|i
claim this immunity, but every other
"executive and judicial officer could
claim like exemption. Besides, if the
house saw lit to refuse to prefer
charges of impeachment for any offense,
or the offense was one for which
impeachment would not lie, then his
excellency, the governor, would of
necessity escape all punishment, because
the alleged pre-requisito of conviction
on impeachment could not be
shown- Thus is shown the utter absurdity
of such a contention. But it
may De urged that if the governor
could not be arrested and put in jail
, there would be no one to exercise the
' functions of his office and the people
would be without an executive head.
Article 4, Section i) of the constitution
;j "T- naccL nf fho tpmnnriipv
proviutw: m , ?
disability of the governor the lieutenant
governor shall perform the duties
of the governor." Thus it will be seen
that in case his excellency should be
come temporarily disabled by preferring
to go to jail rather than pay a
small fine of a few dollars, the peo
g; pie's government would not go tc
ruin for want of an executive head.
It is no doubt true that ilie g.)ver
nor, in exercisiug the political functions
of his ottice, is beyond the reach
of the courts, but "in his person he is M
subject to judicial control, as other
citizens." Eighth American and English
Encyclopedia of Law (lirst edition,)
1406. Hl
The warrant in this case was not 1
against the governor, but against the }
person of J. Gary Evans.
If the contention of the governor
were doubtful, I still maintain that he tu
should have been arrested, as the only he
way to settle a disputed point of law w
of this kind is by resort of the courts, ca
and the courts could not settle it with- Tl
out obtaining jurisdiction of his per- de
son by arrest. If such could by any ca
possibility be the law, then it should fr<
be iudiciallv determined, and give the
people a chance of changing it to con- vi
form to republican institution. m<
Surrounded by his myrmidons gath- mi
ered about his person as rumors of his St
arrest reached them, John Gary Kvans rei
has outraged the laws Lie has swofa to he
see enforced; he has brought the gov- Mi
ernmeut of this city into contempt in ]i'i
th<> eyes of all brave aud free people Sp
who have not learned to "bend the sai
supple hinges of the knee," and until at
it is wiped out a blot rests upon her nu
fair name forever. It has always been gr
the boast of our people thai "all men pe
are equal before the law;" that there th
are none too high to escape its punish- m
ment, and none too low to forfeit its 6,(
protection. ^ If this precedent is allow- by
ed to sianu, nerearter any numoie ce
citizen, arrested without apology and bli
dragged before our tribunals, can just- es,
ly complain that our boast is false, ra
and throw in our teeth the accusation en
that "all men are not equal before the ch
law." be
I submit both the soundness and m<
justice of my advice to the considera- ov
tion of the city council, to whom I am ca
responsible. Respectfully, ho
Gkorok G. Thompson. fa<
Upon receipt of this communication wi
the city council adopted the following rij
resolutions: th
Resolved, by the city council of th
Florence in council assembled: an
1. That we have absolute confidence I
in both the justice and legality of the wl
advice of our city attorney on the oc hii
casion of the recent attempt to arrest th
John Gary Evans. sil
2. That the action of the governor wf
iu escaping arrest by representing to wi
the mayor that be was not subject to be
arrest, was unworthy of the governor pa
of this great State.
3. That we assure the mayor that wt
he will ever have our heaaty co-oper- thi
ation in every effort in his power to co
vindicate the laws of this city and I s
bring all offenders to feel its force th<
and without regard to their official tei
position. 18!
4. That the communication of the an
city attorney, with these resolutions m<
be given to the county and State press fa]
with requests of publication. an
lai
The Cost of Bicycles. w{
In ad justing the fire insurance loss
caused by burning of its salesrooms I r
and stock ?f wheels on hand of one of on
the largest and most popular bicycle re;
manufacturing companies in tbe q,
United States, the fact developed that Sp
the cost of one hundred dollar machines
was but nineteen dollars at the is
factory. The public is asked to pay
one hundred dollars for a wheel which toi
is manufactured at a cost of but nine- mi
teen dollars, a profit to the manufac
turer of over 4UU per cent. me pur- 0f
chaser is told that it costs a lot of bo
money to sell the wheels, which might sp
be and still leave several hundred per gr
cent, profit for the poor manufacturer, su
The day is not far distant when bi- fie
cycles will be sold in hardware and th
other stores, like lawn mowers, at a its
price nearer twenty-live dollars than
one hundred. There may be other Sp
goods manufactured which cost but
one-fifth of the price they are sold for,
but the public certainly is not aware "J
of the fact.
Riot Near Charleston- Sp
Charleston, S. U., Aug. 4.?There wl
was a riot at a negro picnic held at ev
Mouut Pleasant, just across the river 6a]
from here, today. Some negro vend- ey
ers on the grounds were violating
town ordinances. They were ar- m'
rested by negro deputy marshals and
the riot was started by their friends. vl(
Knives and pistols were used freely r?'
onrl civ mon roprft mnw ftr Iftsa sflrirms- Stl
ly hurt. The ringleader of the riot aB
had his head.crushed inkby one.of the
marshals, and he will probably die. P*
The other injured men are Marshal ^
Edmund Jenkins, Henry McNeil, 1
i Prince Simons, Jack Gethersand an aj?
unknown negro. These men were ?'
cut with razors by the rioters. A de- 91'
[tachmentof the Chicora Rifles, of the >Q
Mount Pleasant Naval Reserve, were tu
called out and the riot was quelled. eD
Six of the ringleaders of the mob were Wl
arrested and lodged iu jail, and there **
will probably be a number of other C1^
arrests tomorrow. ^
$7
Burled Alive. (I]
Indianapolis, Aug. G.?Prof Boone, tv
a well known hypnotist, put J.J. to
Wyatt under his mysterious influence m
yesterday and announced that he di
would bury his subject and bring him as
to next Friday, after an interment of
three days. Wyatt had previously tb
consented to the arrangement and the tb
burial took place at Fail view park ai
last night at 10:30 o'clock, a tube be tb
ing passed down to where he lay. He qi
was buried 4 feet under the ground ei
and a guard was placed at the grave, ct
Shortly before noon today Wyatt m
came out from under the influence fc
and realizing ins situation, Degan cn
screaming like a wild man. lie was h;
hurriedly dug up, and it was some o!
time before he could be could be b<
cooled down. He protested against a d<
second interment, but Prof. Boone vi
soon got him under control and Wyatt
was again put down in the earth, tl
The experiment is attracting much at- n
tention. c<
p
liaby'H IIend Bitteu (>11?. if
Chillk'OTHk, Om Aug. G.?Eddie cl
Hurd, the two-year old son of Manager
liurd, of Hayenbeck's menagerie, E
was killed by a lion yesterday after- n
noon. The menagerie was on exhibi- n
tion at tbc fair grounds and a two-year- ft
old lion was tied to a state near me ti
entrance to the tent. The lion be- t<
longed to Jim (Jorbett, the prize figh- n
ter, and was not regarded as feroci- sj
ous. While liurd and his wife were e
in front selling tickets for the after- tl
noon performance little Eddie was d
4i.? .-..I nu.^ ?
piaying iii LUC iruu i no vunu y>
loo near the lion and suddenly the ani* n
; mal sprang upon bim and iu an in- a
, stant the child's head was in tho lion's
mouth. Hurd rushed to the scene I>
frantically, but the head had already q
t been severed. The animal was then h
. in a high state of ferociousness and it
, took severe clubbing to pet him into si
his cage. K f,
THE PEOPLE AROUSED. *
ol
'LAURIIVS DEBATE WITH HORR IN
THEGOLDCOUNTRY.
.1"
u
i9 Stirs the I'aopio Up On tlie Free Sliver pj
Matter-lie Wa# Given an f.ninusiaNiic ^
w
deception by tbe Crowd OutTbere.
The Hon. John L. McLaurin has rerned
from Franklin, Ohio, where A
j went to debate the money auestion
ith Mr. Horr, the leading gold advote
of the northwestern country. E
lat Mr. Mclaurin fared well in his
bate with the famed gold Gghter Wl
n bo seen from the following taken ^
jtn the Ciacinn&ti Enquirer: [J1
lion. J. Ij. McLaurin of Bennettslie,
S. C., member of congress, *n
amber of the ways and means com- "r
ittee and ex-attorney general of his
4L. : I i 1 ~ __ I i
?ic, was me vjrioson yesieruuy, -
turning from the great debate he W!
Id with Hon. Roswell Q. Ilorr of ^
ichigan, the gold champion, at
anklin, Warren county, Ohio, bj
eaking of the great controversy he 9?
id: "1 was most agreeably surprised
the reception I received and the
imber of silver people present to Pc
eet me with enthusiasm. I had ex- ?a
cted to encounter an iceberg, but on tri
e contrary, I found a multitude of ac
y way of thinking. There were co
>00 people present and I could tell 7?
' the applause and cheers that I re- hi
ived that I had fully half the assem- Pe
ige with me. We made five speech- if
, and during one of mine some one
ised a picture of Bryan in the audi- at
ce and thousands stood up and er
eered and it was fully ten minutes be
lore i couia proceed, it was a grand
seting of the people, and after it was an
er Mr. Horr suddenly departed in a a.E
rriage and I could not leave for an tii
iur, the crowd gathered thick and cr
it about ine to shake my hand and I otl
,11 pledge you my word that my '?
jht arm is so sore from hearty shakes
at I can hardly lift it today. All **?
is I attribute to the cause I advocate
d the straightforward way in which *h
presented it. Mr. Horr got mad J"
len I pinned the shortcomings of
3 party down to facts. I quoted P?
em from Senator Sherman's strong ^
ver speech made in 18G9, when he
is a poor man, and contrasted that J*
th utterances since he has grown to *?'
a millionaire and lives in a marble ^
lace.
"I told them that those marble "
ills could not shut out from his ears P?
s murmurs of disapproval and dis- .
ntent occasioned by financial policy. riJ
ho wed them from statistics how in Pe
eir district in 1880 the number of
a j? r> j x _ Arc
lani rarmers was Z4 per cent.; in
90 it had increased to 38 per cent., s?
d 40 per cent, of the farms under
jrtgage. Prices of products were
lling all the time, it taking more '
d more wheat and corn to get a dolr,
and it is only a question of time
len 15 per cent, of the citizenship ^
11 own all of the rich Miami valley.
?ad them something from the rec
is of the Ohio legislature, a joint ije
solution adopted when General ^
osvenor, now a gold advocate, was Qt
eaker of the house of representatives ju
something they had forgotten. It ^
history, and here it is: _j
"Joint resolution relative to the res- q(
ration of the silver dollar to its for
er rank as lawful money: <pj!
"Resolved by the general assembly ^
the State of Ohio, that common ^
>nestv to the taxpaver. the letter and
irit of the contract under which the stf
eat body of iudebtedness was as- .
med by the United States, and true .
lancial wisdom,each and all demand V
e restoration of the silver dollar to
former rank as lawful money. ^
Q. H. Grosvenor, .
teaker of the house of representatives. ,
"H. W. Curtis, ?"
"President of the Senate.
Adopted April 24, 1877." J"
"I read them from James G. Blain's *T
eeches in 1877 and 1880, extracts ?.
lich I would like to see printed
ery day. Here is what Mr. Blaine
id in the senate iu 1880 on the mon- *
question: kJ
' 'On the much vexed and long- ^
ooted question as to bimetallic and ^
oaometaluc standards, my own
ews are sufficiently indicated In the
marks I have made. I believe the
uggle now going on in this country da
id in other countries for a single en
ild standard -would, if successful, en
oduce widespread disaster in and Pi
roughout the commercial worlds, ou
le destruction of silver as money, pP
id establishing gold as the sole unit an
value must have a ruinous effect SC:
i all forms of properly except those f0
vestments which yield a iixed re- be
mi in money. Those would be t}?
lormously enhanced in value and jn
U1U guiu it ui&prupuriiuuuwj auu uu- CO
ir advantage over every other SDe- se
as of property. If, as the most reli Si
>le statistics affirm, there are nearly w
',000,000,000 of coin or bullion in w,
e world, very equally divided be- tr
reen gold and silver, it is impossible tfo
strike silver out of existence as dj
oney without results that will prove w
sastrous to millions and utterly dis- ai
itrous to tens of thousands. it
"I believe gold and silver coin to be
ie money of the Constitution; indeed
ie money of the American people,
iterior to the Constitution, which b<
ie greit organic law recognized as te
lite independent of its own exist- ol
ice. No power was conferred on M
mgress to declare either metal should V
at be money. Congress has, there- hj
ire, in my judgment, no power to d<
^monetize either. If, therefore, silver tt
as been demonetized, I am in favor se
f remonetizing it. If its coinage has ir
aen prohibited, I am in favor of or- It
ering it to be resumed. I am in fa- la
or of having it enlarged.' tl
"I told them that I was glad to know a<
lat there was one great daily paper w
orth of the Ohio river that had the h
aurage and honesty to stand by the c<
eople in this great supreme struggle, c<
ie Cincinnati Enquirer, and they tc
lieered me to the echo." n
Mr. Teasdale, an enthusiastic young w
emocratic silver man and a tobacco w
lanufacturer of Franklin, W8S so
luch pleased and impressed with Col.
tcLaurin's speech that he came on to .
lis city with him and persuaded him ^
> return later in the campaign and ^
lake more speeches in Ohio. Ke ^
iys it was the greatest triumph he ^
ver witnessed on the hustings, and ^
jat Horr, angered and battled in the J
ebate, turned to abuae the south, ?.
Utrt nnnrttton j t*i? 1 w?ii 1j 1 o nil /lu.
rilJCU Ilia UpjWUVUtt I1M1VUCU MUU vtu
ounceii as a dodging of the issue and ^
want of argument. 81
Col. McLaurin came here from
forth Carolina, and in reply to a
uery as to how that State would go, si
esaid: ji
"You may go to sleep with the as- tl
urance that the Tar Heel State is safe J
or Bryan by 25,000. There is no tl
i ' ' .f-.- l-?
>ubt about it whatever."
"How about your State, South Carina?"
.
"Oh, it is all one way there; you
jar nothing but silver. Bryan's ma rity
will run 50,000 to 60,000 easy.
nless there is a complete change in
lblic sentiment Bryan will sweep the
unt.ry. Watson won't be in the
ay."
THE WHISKEY REBATES.
Reformer Who Wanta to Know the Troth
About It.
i t 7. n i
aiior l,uLuuiuia xwywitrAt
the campaign meeting in Barnell
I saw that Mr. Duncan stated
atMixson had said that Tillman, or
at Governor Evans said he had,
illed his pockets with rebates." I
a a Reformer and was among the
st to espouse the Reform cause and
cept B. R. Tillman as its leader,
am a Reformer from principle. I
as actuated from a law of justice to
ip over on the side of the masses and
imand their rights. I wanted to see
r ttiA irAton /\f MAAnlA ilinf nn vr nio n
wwcavi tucucupiobuabaujr iuau
uId hold office if he was honest and
telligent enough to fill the position,
ior to 1890 it had almost reached that
>int where pedigree was the only
ssport to office and positions of
jst. It was the love of country that
tuated me then and it is the love of
uatry that actuates me now to ask,
is, to demand of Mr. Mixson, who is
mself a recipient of wages from the
ople of our State, to answer in full
the charges against Governor Evans
cited and preferred by Mr. Duncan
Barnwell are false in toto or whethany
part of the charges be true. I
lieve Mr. Mixson will give the an'er
without faltering and without
iy attempt to evade, and such an
iswer the people demand. This is no
ne for men in public trust to hide
lme, 11 crime ojllsis, ixsuiujjudu ujr
hers, when we have plenty of Rermers
in the State who are pure
ough and sufficiently competent to
1 any position. We are not depennt
on any men for party sake. If
e charges are without foundation
en Mr. Mixson has already waited
d long and should be glad of an oprtunity
to give his public denial. I
)uld not ask this question but for the
st that it has been published that
dr. Mixson was on the stand" when
ey were preferred and did not deny
Bra then and there. Besides they
ai : j ~ _ m
ar on me pnue 01 uur pari./ wucu
is charged that "Tillman filled his
ckets with rebates."
I, as a Reformer and citizen, have a
rht to ask these question and the
ople of this State have a right to
lowif Governor iSvans made such
itements. We take them as an inlt
and if they are false Mr. Duncan
ould be made to hold up.
R. P. Stackhouse.
Oswego, S. C.f August 4, 1896.
Alabama Goes Democratic.
Birmingham, Ala.. Aug. 5.?Furer
returns from Monday's election
ow that Johnston and the Democratticket
have carried forty-one counts,
while Goodwyn, Populist, has
enty- two. Three counties, Pike,
illan and Tallapoosa are close and
doubt. It is about a stand off in
ese. Jonnsion &omciai ana esumaimajorities
amount to 48 873, while
xxlwyn's majorities are 9,205, leaver
Johnston's net majority at 39,448.
le official canvass of the vote Satury
will, it is thought, not vary from
ese figures. For the Legislature
Ler reports show that the House
mil seventy-four Democrats, again
ten members, twenty Populists and
c doubtful. In the Senate the Demrats
have elected thirteeu members,
e Populists three and one is in doubt,
lis gives the Democrats over threeurths
of the Legislature. John>n's
majority of the white counties
nearly 10,000 not including the
ack Belt which is calculated to dis>se
of the charge that Goodwyn was
icted but counted out. Conservare
Populist leaders assert that if it is
own officially that the white coun
is elected Johnston they will sup>rt
Bryan and Sewall in November,
her wise they will go for Bryan and
ataon, believing in the latter event
at Johnston got elected by fraud.
Terrible Retribution.
St. Joseph, La., Aug. 5.?Some
ys ago a respectable white woman
jplojed as a domestic in a prominit
family on the border of Franklin
irish, was sent across Tensas River
l an errand, and failing to return in
oper time the family became alarmed
id seat parties in search of her. The
arching party after several hours
und the dead and horribly mutilated
kly of the woman in the woods parilly
concealed by brush. The most
tense excitement followed the dis very,
and in a short while the whole
ction was aroused and in the saddle.
nninfaH t/> fl nrhilA iMmn
to piUlV/U [A/IUWVU ?v W TTU??W > w? r
ho had been seen near there. Dogs
ere used and in a few hours the
amp was run down. He confessed
at he had outraged and then mur ed
her. The crowd bound the
retch, staked him to the nearest tree
id after burning body and riddling
with bullets quietly dispersed.
After tlie Dispenser.
Columbia, S. C., Aug. 7.?The State
)ard of control showed a desire yesrday
to "crawl the log," so to speak,
: Dispenser Stevenson of Winnsboro.
ention was made in the reports of the
Tmnsboro meeting that Stevenson
ad taken an active part in howling
Dwn some of the speakers. From
le appearance of things now it would
em that his overzealous action is goig
to make him a man without a job.
. seems that lie either forgot the circu
ir letier sent our oy ine ataie ooara
iat none of the dispensers were to be
itive in politics, or disregarded it
ilfully. As a result, instructions
ave been sent to the county board of
Diitrol of Fairfield for all the facta in
>nnection with Stevenson's actions
) be laid before the State board at its
ext meeting. This will be a test of
hether the board means a thing
hen it says it or not.?State.
Three Boy* Drowned.
Roanoke, VaM Aug. C.?Three boys,
aines Poage, Wiley Lutlwig and
Uarence Berry, aged 12, 14 and 15
ears, respectively, were drowned toay
in Roanoke River while bathing,
hey were unable to swim and got beond
their depth. A number of
therboys were iu the river at the
me and gave the alarm. The bodies
rere recovered by a li.shing party u
bortlime afterward.
Killed In a Church.
Omaha, Neb., Aug. 5.--Lightning
Lruck the Bohemian Catholic church,
jst at the close of mass at 9 'clock
lis morning, instantly killing Mrs.
os. Zepyra, a widow, and injurying
aree other women.
MIXSON TO HUBBELL.
HE MAKES A STATEMENT ABOUT THE
REBATE MATTER.
Ro-lt?rates the Statement That Hubbell
Offered the Rebate?A Little More Insldes
History of the Dispensary Is Given.
Columbia, S. C., Auf. 7.?The fol
lowing communications explain tnemselves:
To the Editor of The State:
In your issue of July 28th you quote
from Barnwell, S. C, under date of
July 27th, as follows:
''It was develop:d today that State
Liquor Commissioner Mixson had
been offered $562 50 per carload in rebates
by the representative of the Mill
Creek Distilling Co.?Mr. Hubbell."
If Commissioner Mixson says I ever
offered him directly or induectly a
dollar in any shape whatever he states
what is absolutely false.
The Mill Creek Distilling Co.,
Geo. Hubbell, Secretary.
Columbia, S. C., Aug. 5.
WHAT M1XS0N SAYS.
Columbia, S. C., Aug. 6, 1896.
To the Editor of The State:
In your issue of today you have a
card signed Mill Creek Distilling Co ,
Geo. Hubbell, secretary, in which he
concludes as follows: "If Commissioner
Mixson says 1 ever offered him,
directly or indirectly, a dollar in any
shape whatever he states what is absolutely
false."
I have been drawn into this matter
very reluctantly and had hoped that ,
the matter had blown over and I
would not be required to say any thing,
but as a man who is jealous of his hon 1
or and one who is not afraid to resent
an insult, I am forced to make the
following statement of facts:
I have been connected with the dispensary
since the first conception of
the scheme and was in charge under ]
Senator Tillman's direction when the j
building was being put in fix for bob- (
tling, Mr. Traxler, then the commissioner,
being at his home
in Timmonsville, quite ill with
a ?? m
typnoia lever. iiuer mr. xrax
ler's recovery and return, I was retained
in the capacity of superintendent,
which position I held until Mr.
Trader resigned, and 1 was honored
with the appointment.
During my term as superintendent
I naturally discovered that the bulk of
the whiskies bottled by us was purchased
from Mill Creek through Mr.
Geo. Hubbell, who was frequently
down here. I also discovered that in
making these purchases Mr. Hubbell,
or Mill Creek, I should say, was re- '
quiring and being paid an interest on 5
them after 30 days, each 30 days call- ]
ing for more or bigger interest.
On being appointed commissioner in
January, 1895, and being in possession
of these facts of interest-bearing accounts,
and not intending relieving 1
Mr. Trailer till Feb. 1st, I commenced
to look around and see if 1 could not |
do something better for the State and
save, at least, the thousands and
thousands of dollars being paid in in- <
terest to Mill Creek. About Jan. 20, <
some 10 days or perhaps more before J
I took charge, Mr. Hubbell showed up ]
and was anxious to a&certain if I in- ]
tended to continue the trade with him. -j
My reply was, "That depends." He ,
asked, "Depends on what?" I replied,
4 On you; I want the same whiskies or J
belter, at the same prices or less with
5 per cent oH' as discount or rebate." '
He seemed to be utterly dumbfounded
and exclaimed: "Do you want tbe
earth V' I replied, "No, but this 1
want, and this I intend to have." He i
went on to say that my proposition was
one that he nor no one else could en- ,
tertain and wanted to know if I had "
calculated the 5 per cent. off. He inquired
when I would be in the market I
tor purchases, and upon being told
that it would take several days after
Feb. 1st to make the transfer, he asked
? - tho nnwhwAq if T should
UiD agaiu iui vuw , M
need anything before he returned in
February. I told him, "Only on my 1
terms."
On assuming the duties, Feb. 1, I
very soon discovered that I needed
some Bourbon whiskies and wired
him: "Same whiskey, same price, 5
off; send me X and Bourbon."
I received a wire in repiy: "Will
ship at once." A few days after this
I received a letter saying: "Your telegram
ordering Bourbon received, and
knowing from its being a wire thai
you were in need, we hasten to make
shipment, but we cannot give you tbe
terms, &c." I immediately wired
him: "Order cars back; won't receive
them only on my terms." in a lew
hours I received a wire: "(Jars too
far advanced to order back; receive
them on your terms." lu due course
tbe cars arrived and we?-e received.
Bill for same cawe iu witli 5 per cent.'
off and was paid.
I do not recollect when nor bow often
Mr. Hubbell came to see me in tbe
lew months that followed before ibe
following occurred:
He asked me to tase him into the
sample room and show him mo XXX
rye that I was purchasing. 1 did so,
and while in there alone, ne and X, he
offered me his XXX rye at tne same
price he had formerly sold it to the
dispensary with the interest on, lor
the same price per gallon, 10 per cent,
discount; and, if my memory serves
me correctly, he made the folio wing
calculation there and theu: (Jost$2.2a
per gallon.; 10 per cent, ott', rnakea
22$ cents per gal.; 50 gallons 10 a Dar
? 1 f'l Kqkih?Iq (/? <1
rei makes $11.25 ana i>v, " car
makes $5G2.50- I said, Wi y
put this discount on the invoices a
Jet it show up regularly ?" He replied
that he could not do so; that he was a
member of the trust, but for me to
pay the invoices at the regular mice
of $2.25 per gallon and he would return
me the 1U per cent, off in cash.
This I refused to do and no purchase
has been made from him by me.
These are the facts in the case and
includes all I have said as lo Mr. Hub
bell's otter to me. If he imysauy part
of it is untrue he is a liar
F. M. Mixson.
Lutlrieu & time* are Vuur Aleu.
If you want to buy a One piano direct
Irom factory, and without paying
middlemen's profits, write the wellknown
Southern Music House of Ludden
& Bates, Savannah, Ga., about it.
They are your men. They manufacfurvii
<tm nam 1 nililan Xr Pataa niann
buiu kUU Uw T? ^MWVCI ^/JUUV/I
They own an interest in the great
Mathuahek Piano, sold by them for
twenty-tive years past. Tney control
almost the entire output of the factory
and have just opened large wholesale
warerooms in New iforK City.
They sell from factory direct to purchasers
and save purchasers all intermediate
prohts. They are your men.
Read their latest advertisement in to is
issue and write them either at Savannah,
Qa., or New York City. ,
- '\<r. . - v-. ' .> ,i
Jf
The trustworthy care for the Whiskey,
Opium, Morphine and Tobaooo Habits.
For farther information address The
Keeley Institute, or Drawer 27, Columbia,
3. 0.
A
BUSINESS
OPPORTUNITY
doesn't always mean a cbance
to get Work. It's a txulneaa
opportunity to have a chance to
save money on the necessities
of life. Yon can find a chance
like that at our store.
We are now offering
WELCH A EASONS PERFECTION
FLOUR
Superfine Quality at f4.60 barrel
Beet Patent Flour at 4.25 barrel
(Jholoe Family Flour at~..? 4.00 barrel
\
BEST GRANULATED SUGAR
In 100 pound sacKa at -6c pound
La smaller quantities at ~..-5>^e pound
GOOD GRANULATED SUGAR
[?224 pound sacks at 4^c pound
[a 100 sacks at ..4#c. pound
[n smellier quantities at 8c . pound
BIUJS
At 40, 50, 64, 70 and 80 cents a peck.
GOOD TOMATOJW
[n 2 pound cans at ...5o a cin...tiOc a dozen
a 3 pound cans at ...6c a can...72c a dozen
PURB LARD-BEST QUALITf.
SO pound cans per can 93.00
50 pound cans per can 1.20
10 pound cans per can -... 76
5 pound cans per can .. 40
3 pound cans per can 25
COMPOUND LARD.
10 pound cans per can 12.75
SO pound cans per can 115
[0 pound cans per can...?.................. 70
5 pound cans per can 35
3 pound cans per can 25
3ood Rio Coffee 18c pound
Best Rio Coffee - 20c pound
Higher grade Coffees at very reasonable
)rloe*.
CANNED MEATd CHEAP.
3omed Beef 1 pound cam 10c
Jorned Beef 2 pound cans 20o
Roast Beef I pound cans . 10c
Roast Beef 2 pound cans 18e
Potted Ham, small cans, 5c otn, 60o dozes
Potted Ham, lor ge cans, 10: can, 91.00 doz.
Potted Tongue, small, 5c can, 50o dozen
Dried Beef, Armour's, l pound, 18c can,
|2.0u dozen,
Dried Beef, Aimiur's, % pound, 10c can,
|1.20 dozen.
Teas at 25' 50, 75 and 91 00 pound. Kvsry
style and variety.
We make It to )?ur advantage to buy
r'our Groceries of us* Try u*.
Get a copy of our Prices List, it Is a
iaudy and newsy little biok..,
WELCH & BASON,
UNIVERSAL PROVIDERS,
185 ?n1187 Meeting and 117 Market ttts ,
CHARLESTON, S C.
Advice to Mothers.
Wo ta*e pleasure la oalilu* your auea
Hon to a teinedy so long needed la carrying
cblldreu safely through tbe critical
stage of teething, it Is aa incalculable
blesslag to mother aad cnud. if you are
disturbed at night wltb a sick, frettui,
teething child, use Pitts' Carminative, it
will give luaUut relief, aad regulate the
bowels, and make teething safe and easy,
it will cure Dysentery aud Ularrtuea.
Pitts Carminative b au Instant relief for
oolic of Infanta. It will promote digestion,
give toue and euergy to the stomach aud
bowels. Ibe sick, puuy, suffering child
will soon become the fat aud frolioaiug Joy
of the household. It Is very pleasaut to
the taste aud ojly cost 25 cents p?r bottle
Sold by druggists aud by
THE MURRAY DRU(i CO
(Viliimhia H PI
BARGAIN LIST
I ha ye in stock, id th kou^Ii repiir, n
following second band Engines and Bollei
One 12 H P Portable Tozer Engine and b
One U H P Portable Tozer Engine and i
One 0 H P Portable Tozer Engine and ?
Oqo OUF Portable Tozer Engine and ?
One tjHP Portable Oneida Engine and
One 12 H P Portable 0 & G Cooper A Co
One 8 H P Beml-Portable Ames Engine i
One 7 H P Semi-Portable Weod, Taber &
Tnese Engines and Boilers bave bee
Works, and are In aB (rood condition as It
ing to bave your order, I am, Your
Always in stock, a full Hue of TOZ El
prlcea. REPAIRING OF ALL KINDS 1
IBS
IA $25 Cooking Stove 11
I
with a coMPurrs ourrrr iw Bj
ONLY $12.00. S
Delivered to your railroad #!>**>
all freight charges paid. Read tkii
description carefully. This spl?Mttft
Cook lug Stove U No. 8; ha* fear ft
inch pot holes; 16x16 tack oret; )ft
lucli fire box, 24 inches hifh; Six*
inch top; nice smooth naatief. 1
have had this (tore made tor mg
trade, after my owu idea, oombiaiag 1
all the guod point* of all OMcttaa
priced ?t.,tves, and leaving oat tfca
objectionable featuree.
Beyond all doubt tit* beat NT*, ft
Cooking Stove made, for the yrUa
Kitted with 2 pota, 2 pot WTW?,'l
skelluta, l griddles, 3 baktog mm.
i jotota of pipe, 1 elbow, 1 eolisr, 1
lifter, 1 scraper, 1 oak* poliak, 11ns
tea kettle, 1 shovel. We waak to
make customers and frieada la iwij
pan vi uiu oouui, tor we pary?a
?>f introducing our fcuaineaa to amw
people, and to renew our ?|-in'n1
ance with old friends.
W* will ship this splendid Caafcftag
ituvc ?nd the above deseribW ?M
u> an; depot, all freight afcaoBa
paid, (or only $lS.OO wk?e m
cash oomea with the wiar. TMfc
?to*? is a ifood oh, wall made, aaA
111 <tv* entire satisfaction. Oar
ihusiratad catalogue of FmiKaa^
ana Baby Carriafea aaUaa
ir?e. Addreea
I~i ^ .^XX>0STT,
1 W, i'.cioii) antrrr, l.uau8TA,
J
? If you Went a Fine Pleno ?
I Prom Factory direct and all 1
p Intermediate Profits aaved 4
: LDDDEN & BATES:
? They ha?a sold Plane* the South Knoa ^
? 1870 and are (till at it,
A They don't get old-foey{ih or tired, bni a}. ?
|T ways keep at the bead of the procession. ' _
i J They hare fnat opened Wholesale Head* z.
B qaarteriandWareroomainlTew York City. M
A They manufacture the Lndden 6c Bate* m
_ Piano and alao own an internet in the grMt _
Mathuahek Piano Factory, vttbooottal
? of nearly its entire output. ^
t They Supply Purchasers direct from m
z Factory at wholeanle Price*, tboa _
% earing large intermediate profits. ^
? They will eare you $W to $100 on a Plana. %
m They are your men. Write them, either at ^
_ 8arannah. New York, or any of their Sooth. _
B em Branch Houses. 4
? f UDDEN & BATES, ?
L# 91 & 93 Fifth Ave., N. Y. ?
Mala House, - - Savannah, Qa. J I
_ Branahet-Macon, Columbus, WaycroestGa.1 2
Jackaonrille.Fla.; Mobile, Ala^j NewOrleana; W J
) Columbia, 8. 0.; Charlotte, Raleigh, N. 0. 4 . \
IITHERE j
I i Fiepmttot that cm ocmpare i I
| fig with Hilton'a Life for the lire* BS I
| ^ ud Kidneys, la iba aUdam |H J
I W of Ita actios and the oertalnt> I I
] of Its effects, b? the relief cntd H? I
I O care ?* I>7Bpeps1a and Indira* Bn j
I *9 tion, and all their ittaiilii Hfl I
I Bfc iMfc M sick headache, I I
M soeiretomach, wantof appetite, j
I Jb etc., and aa a regulator la B I
I 52 Habitual OonKtipaUoa. A few H I
I fS doeea^wUl tell something of Its H I
I fjffl mattta. Xoneedofalongeoa?H 1
?$3 tUme^ coarse before its ben*- Bf
I fifl flu became apparent. B '
IS TRY IT, AND Etfll
I $?2a?i ' CONVINCED. g
J H^ld wiiOJesale by
|The Murray Dru.. Co.
I COLUMBIA, H. 0 I
I AND I
I Dr' H" ?a6r' t-'barlpston, S 0
COTTON
I GINS.
Complete planing systems contracted foi
With Thou, a a tSlevator, Lint Kiud Battel y
Condenaer, Self-paoMug Revolving Cox
Steam Cylinder Fre-sea aud all improvements
(or an up to d*te 1896 i?lanary Buy
no other uutil you grt prices on the
Thomas.
KNGINKH,
BOILEKS,
?A\Y WiU.b, ' j
OA.NE MILLS,
KICK MILLS,
UKlSt' MILLS'.
Write for JPrlt'w.
V. G. Badhuru,
COLUMBIA. 8. c.
JOHN A. WILLIS,
j*M ...
JUANLFf LIUhliii OF
Tozer Engines.
J
*
dpkiatii 3<iiQ.^ ai utj an.i c.miple'.H, the
ra:
loller Price |500 (Jasli
toller Price :wo Cash
toller .Price 301) Caab
toller Price U9U Caab
Boiler Pi Ice "280 (Jas b
Eagiae md Bol.er Price 2J0 OttsD
ind Boiler Price Cash
Morse Engine & Boiler Price -'40 Cabtt
in thoroughly overU?uleU *u>t tested ?i my
is possible for second band Jobs to be. dups
respectfully,
JOHN A. WiLLId. Columbia, S. C,
Ei ENGINES AND BOILBHl Write tuf
PROMPTLY EXECUTED. I