The Abbeville press and banner. (Abbeville, S.C.) 1869-1924, November 15, 1893, Image 3
?
"the d1spensvhy uw~
JUDGE WALLACE DECLARES IT TO BE
CONSTITUTIONAL.
Tho A nrioraon L'anor CNne [Mxdfl tho Oc
cat'on of a R:rl^inc Judicial Dplivfraiice?T?chnlc?l
01>J?ct?oua to 111* Plir?seolocy
of th? Act Dhinl<8?d,
Anderson, Nov. 8?In the ease of
the State vs John 0. O'Djnnell, indicted
for selling whiskey without a license
and keepin- a place where whiskey
is kept for s>:ile, etc., which was
called in the Court of Sessions Wednesday,
Judge Wallace rendered orally the
following decision, on motion of the
defendant's counsel to quash the indictment:
The question as to the constitutionality
of the Dispensary Act has been
much discussed in the State, and has
developed considerable diversity of
opinion in regard to it. Some able and
learned-lawyers hold one opinion and
others equally as learned hold a differ
ent opinion. I have my own opinion,
which I will proceed to announce without
hesitation or delay. The motion
was to quash the indictment, because
first the Act provided no punishment
n/-..1 r>?< uMthnnf- a ltr?nnq? T
1U1 OClllUt( ll^uui niuivuv V* WVM..W. >
may say in passing that the words
"without a license" contained in the
first count are mere surplus ige, and
that the offence charged is that of selling
liquor.
At common law crimes are divided
into two classes,namely, mala in se and
prohibita. To illustrate: We have a
statute declaring murder to be a crime
or rape or arson or burglary. These
crimes are described and punishment
is provided for them. They belong to
the class described as mala in se. When
the commission of an act is prohibited
by statute it belongs to the class of
mala prohibita. The commission of
an act prohibited by statute is an offence,
because it is a violation of law.
The offence charged is prohibited by
the Dispensary Act and thus to sell liquor
becomes a violation of the law
and is therefore an offence.
No offence created by statute is a felony
unless it Is so declared. Therefore
the selling of liquor in violation of
Section 6 of the Dispensary Act is a
misdemeanor and is punishable, if not
by any penalty provided in said Act,
then under the provisions of the statute,
Section 2,653, Revised Statutes:
"Section 2,653. In cases of legal convection
where no punishment is provided
by statute the Court shall award
3uch sentence as is conformable to the
common usage and practice in this
State according to the nature of the offence
and not repugnant to the Constitution."
I am, therefore of the opinion, and
so hold, that the offence as charged is
punishable under the section I have
just quoted.
The next ground was that Section 21
of the Dispensary Act,under which the
Indictment is framed, relates only to
me saie or aisinuuuuu ui uquvio ncp>.
by clubs or associations t jr the use of
the members. The section referred to
reads as follows: "Section'21. Every
person who shall directly or indirectly
keep or maintain by himself, or by associating
or combining with others, or
who shall in any manner aid, assist or
abet in keeping or maintaining any
club room or other place in which any
intoxicating liquors are reeei/ed or
kept for the purpose of barter or sale,
as a beverage or distribution or division
among the members or any club or
association, by any means whatever,
and every person who shall barter, sell
or assist or abet another in bartering
or selling any intoxicating liquors so
received or kept, shall be deemed guilty
or a misdemeanor and upon conviction
thereof be punished by u fine of not
less than one hundred dollars nor more
than Ave hundred dollars, and by imprisonment
in the county jail not less
than ninety days, nor more than one
year." It is clear that this section does
not confine its provisions to club3 and
associations, but includes the receiving
and selling of liquor in any "other
piacc.
The third and last grouhd, and the
main ground is that. 'he Diapensaiy
Act is unconstitutional, and the argument
under this branch is concerned
chiefly with the purpose ol' the Act.
aiid the question as to the police power
of the State.
There seems to be some confusion regarding
the distinction between the
Feberal Constitution and the S'ate
Constitution. Tbey are essentially different
in their nat ure. The Constitution
of the United States confers upon
Congress certain well defined powers,
and such other powers only a3 are necessarily
implied from such grant, and
wneu an fssue arises as to the unconstitutionality
of an Act of Congress
thefuestion is, "h^s the pywer
late on the subject matter of imo Act
been granted to Congress by t he Federal
Constitution V" On the otber hand
? ? iAn /\P C/%uf K PutaIi nQ ho.
IUC VUUOtltUblUU Ul uwuuii v?iv/auw uw
stows general legislative p^wer upon
the General Assembly with very few
limitations; and therefore, upon an issue
regarding ihe constitutionality of
an Act of the General Assembly of
the State the question is "has the power
to legislate upon the subject matter
of this Act been withheld by the State
Constitution."
On this point I have here an excellent
authority which I shall read: "The
people ot a State in creating by their
organic law a legislative department,
of government, confer upon it the
whole ?f their inherently sovereign
and uncontrolled power of legislation,
except in so far as they have delegated
this power in respect to certain subjects
and under certain res'ric? ions to
the Congress of the United States, and
except also in so far as they contemporaneously
impose checks and limits up
on the legislative authority, lience
the Legislature of a State may enact
any lav,(not infriDgiog upon the other
departnx^nts) of any character or on
any subject unless it is prohibited
either ID express terms or by necessary
implication <n the Constitution of the
United States or of that State. In
other wordsth3 constitutions are to be
considered as limitation upon the legislative
power of the State, not as
grants of pdwer (SEAm and Eng Encyclopedia
ofcLaw,<?.)
In note 2 to above quotation occurs
the following: "The distinction
between the United States Constitution
and the State Constitution is that the
former confers upon Congress certain
specified powers only, while the latter
oonfers upon the Legislature all legislative
powers. In the one case the
powers specially grW.ed can only be
exercised, in the other all legislative
powers not prescribed." Citing People
va Flazcr. 4R N. Y.. 401: Page vs Allen,
58 Pa. St., 338.
Applying the doctrine j lat quoted,
which muse be recognized as sound
doctrine, the unconstitutionality of the
Dispensary Act must be mstld to appear
from some limitation contained
in our State Constitution itself . upon
the power of the General Assembly to
enact such a law.
No such limitation has been pointed
out to me nor am I aware of any such
limitation, either express or implfedr
Even if the power of the General Assembly
to enact the dispensary Uw
could be derived only from its police
power there can be no question that
under that power it would have ample
authority to restrict the sale or traffic
in liquor. The S'.ate has frequently
do^e so in the past by statutes intended
to resriilat-i and restrict the tariff in
liquor without question hs to its right
and authority so to do.
This Act declares m its title that such
is its purpose "An Act to prohibit the
manufacture and sain," etc. "except as
herein provided," and its provisions
undertake to accomplish that very
thnifr by numerous limitations such as
rpstrinfincr the olaces at which liquor
13 to be soFd, the hour at which i is to
be o>ld, persons to whom it
shall be ual i vrul to sell liquor, the
character ot r,he person by wno n it is
to be sold, the uot selling on credit the
prohibition as to drinking on the premises,
the limiting the amount to be
sold to purchasers, the written application
sigued by each purchaser aud other
restrictions that need not be mentioned
here.
It appears upon the face of the Dispensary
Act as it stands upon the statute
book that the purpose and primary
object of those who passed it wa3 to
diminish the sale aud consumption of
liquor and to decrease the evils which
are balieved to result from the liquor
tKonnhlin crnnil anH T fpf?l
l/l UUIO XV*. UHV puVAIV gUVM| _ .?v.
bound to say from my own observation
that the Act seems to be accomplishing
that beneficent object. On this ground
as it appears to me, it is without doubt
a proper exercise of the police power of
the S'.ate. It has been learnedly aregued
to-day that the purpose of the
Act was to raise revenue. But it i9 to
he collected from the Act itself that
theralsing of revenue is only incidental
to the main purpose *of the Act,
which, as I have already held, is to restrict
aud regulate the sale of an traffic
in liquor, and as I understand the
Chester cases exrel Hoover and ex rel
tiroeschels, our Supreme Court has already
decided that the Act in question
is an Act to regulate the sale ot liqoor.
Ia these Chester ca3es our Supreme
Court his said: "Having reached this
conclusion, that the said Act, (the Dispensary
Act,) being in effect an Act ts,
regulate thesail of spirituous liquory
tne power to ao waica is uuiycranu
recognized, it is quite clear," etc. 17 S"
E. Rep. 756.
Most of tb? argument against the
coBstitutionality of the despentary
Act made before me, and I may say,
elsewhere, seems to be directed moe to
the wisdom of the Act than to the
power of the General Assembly to pass
the Act.
The question is one of power andnot
of policy. As to the wisdom or the unwisdom
of Acts of the General Assembly
the Courts have nothing to do.
That is a question for the people. It is
proverbial that otirs is -a Government
of tbe people, by the people and for the
people, and it is for the people by the
ballot-box to correct mistakes in legislation
when they are satisfied that such
mistakes have been made by their representatives,
and|not for the Courts. It
has been argued that the General Assembly
has no constitutional right to
appropriate money to engage in business.
For all public purposes the power
of the General Assembly is absolute in
the' absence of constitutional provisions.
The same authority holds "the
powers of the legislatuie in disposing
or toe reveuueaoi tue oouue auu iwj uiocretion
relating to such disposition are
complete and unlimited in the absence
of constitutional provisions." (3 Am
and Eug Encyc of Law, 69)
The State is daily engaged in the sale
of phosphate rocfc to individuals for
revenuH. If the State can own phosphate
territory and sell the rock it can
purchase if necessary other phosphate
territory for the purpose of traffic in
phosphate. It is without question that
the State owns both real and personal
property and can dispose of it at will.
These instances I give to illustrate the
doctrine.
Holding the views I have herein announced,
I cannot quash the indict
rnent. 'fne motion to quash is therefore
overruled.
Cotrou Movement.
New Orleans, Nov. 10.?Crop
statement Jrorn Seotemoer 1 to November
10, inclusive: P>?rt rjc?Mpts 2 088,
583 b-?le9. against 1,910.432 las', year
a;,d 2,057,545 year beiore last.. Overland
to mills Htid Canada. 183,835 ^ales,
O?ui.,oi OOl Olfi orwl 3R9 91A [ntfri.ir
i M(U UUU WV- MA VI 4MV ?.
stock in ixccria of Seotemher 1st. 258,275
bales, against 198,428 and 200,024.
Sjuthern mill takiugs 174.310 bales,
against 100,890 anJ 151.201. Crop
brought ,mto su;bt during ^seventy oue
days 10 date, 2 705.290 bales, against
2,499,9G0 and 3,550 980. Crop brought
into sight for week, 392,520 bales,
a^a;nst 337 387 foi seven days ended
X ?vem ier 10 last >car, aad 462,081 for
ibe same timo year before la?t. Crop
f>r >uiht. for tne tirst ten days <>f N">vcmbrr,
557,410 bales, against 500,890 luBt
jear, and 588,020 year batore last.
Comparisons on these exports are made
ap to the corresponding date last year
aud year before and not to the close of the
corresponding week. Comparisons by
wteks would take in seventy-two of the
season last year, an J seventy-four days
year before last, as against ouly seventyone
days this year.
A Quadruple Lyochluj*.
Nashville, Tenn., Nov. 4.?A special
from Fayetteville, Tenn., says:
Early this morning, on the farm of
Jark Daniels, near Lynchburg, Ned
Waggoner, nis son Will and daughter
Mary, and his son-in-liw Motlow were
found hanging to one tree. All the
parties are colored. The only cause to
explain their fate is that they were
supposed to have been implicated in
the numerous barn burnings which
have taken place in Monroe and Lincoln
counties recently. Tnere is no
clue as to the perpetrators of the deed.
Ned Waggoner was a rather large negro,
and it is suDposed the first attempt
of the lynchers was unsuccessful in his
case, as a broken rope with a hangman's
knot on it was found under the
tree near him and another one had
been Droeured from the well bucket of
a near neighbor, by which rope he was
found hanging. The bodies were discovered
by the driver of the Lynchburg
and Fayetteville stage soon after
daybreak this morning. The negroes
did not bear very good reputations
in the community, and although
there has been little talk in regard to
the matter, they were supposed to be
connected with the band of incendiaries'who
have recently been so plentiful
in this section.
PopulUto Whipped.
Topeka, Kin., N jv. 9.?Additi onal
returns from Tuesday's election swell
the Republican pluralities, and the
Populist so hopeful yesterday concede
that they have been badly defeated. Of
the thirteen JudgeSM hat were elected
Chairman lireidenthal. of the Populist
party claims only three, though he is
not williag to concede the l'Jih aad34tb
At Republican headquarters the following
summary of tne result based
upon returns thus far received is given
out: Straight Republican counties 45,
straight I'opulist counties 8, divided
counties 25, to be heard from 27. Republican
officers elected in divided
counties 105, Populist oilicers elected
in divided counties 5U.
THE HAMPTON LETTER. [
b
WHAT THE GREENVILLE NEWd MAS "
TO SAY ABDUT IT- p
There Is No Use an<1 Great Dinger Jn the P
d
Movement?Thi White People of the a
Slate Cannot A ftord to Divide. 1
a
Greenville, S. C., Nov. 8.?It is s
better to make opea and full confes
sioD. A man's sins will find him out y
and when he Is caught he had best d
own up. We hnd the Columbia Regis- ?
ler and the State from opposing stand- i
points calling 011 the Greenville News a
to sp^aK ouJ. on the matter of the or- f
eauizanon of national Democratic b
clubs in this Slate 'as suggested by ti
General Hampton in a letter to the n
State republished ^n this newspaper e
last week. Four fmt of Ave important n
Democratic daily newspapers of South r:
Carolina have spoken in favor of the h
scheme and "where is the Greenville a
News?" says the State. "Why this tl
strange silence of the Greenville tl
News?" demands the Register.
Well, the truth of it is the editor of c
the Greenville News ran away last a
week. When his esteemed coutempo- ti
raries were calling upon him for deliv- Q
erances regarding the organization of p
national Democratic clubs he was sit- a
ting on a log in the woods on the side h
of a mountain in Western North Caro- p
lina. It was glorious, too. A sky of D
wonderfully deep blue flecked with 0
still strips of transparent white cloud; 0,
the dreamy Daze or tne Indian summer; t]
air so crisp, so dellciously and delicate- 5
ly perfurmed with the aromatic sug- a
gestions of pine trees and hickory ti
leaves that every breath of it was long ^
drawn luxury. There were few sounds tl
to disturb the silence. The stream p
down in the darkened ravine babbled 1
and splashed idly and faintly and mo- tl
mentary glints of the clear water Hash- g
ed now and then as the thickly cluster- tl
ed, deep green laurel swayed noiseless* q
ly. The dry leaves rustled slowly as ti
they drifted down through the trees as C]
if lingering to say good-bye to the a,
companions that had swung and rus- c,
tied with them while all of them were ^
green and beautiful through the sun- a
shine and breezes of the dead, bright Sj
summer. Now and then the air was Q
filled with the distant drumming of a fi
pheasant or a squirrel could be heard
scampering through the leaves. There ai
was a riot of color everywhere?crim- t
sons, scarlets, browns, yellows, greens, i?
in bewildering-, gorgeous varieties and ^
blendings. _
With a dinner of mountain made
hominy and fried chicken, preceeded
by a taste of something which had
never yielded any of its sturdy strength
to the mercenary hands of a dispensa- ?
ry agent, and succeed by a tramp over "
a ridge or two and a briar wood pipe d<
filled with tobacco like flakes of gold, rr
the blue smoak of which drifted and o:
curled slowly away to mingle with the fi
haze, a man could sit in a place like C
that and be profoundly, magnificently ai
indifferent to politics, commerce and fi
finance and all cares and concerns.past, w
present and future, public and private, d
content simply to be living and im- ?
pressed with the general sensation that w
this is a pretty fail kind of a world f(
after all. He could idle there with idle- t(
ness made delicious by the fact that be fi
had been working from fourteen to
"* ?L a ( f KAnf o Kraal/* n
eigUlUOLI uuuia a UOJ niuuuuu a uioun v
a number of months, and allow a mind S'
which is usually struggling to consider ir
and remember a large number of ft
things at once to be so magnificently ai
vacant as to decline to remember r<
whether the right or left hand barrel t?
was loaded with buckshot, and to ac- tl
cept with cheerful lack of purpose the a
possibility of blowing an unhappy re
squirrel into rags or impotently pep- n
pering the impervious feathers of a 01
turkey with No. 6. Add to all this the is
delightful sense of wrongdoing, not so b(
acute as to be uncomfortable, but just H
strong enough to give zest to the occa w
sion?the splendid consciousness of si
having run away without asking leave ai
or license of anybody, after writing ad- p
vance editorials to be cut off and dum- w
ped into boles in the columns like oj
packing and liable co be inappropriate Ii
to events, and esteemed contempora- u
ries can understand how much they it
have to be envious of and how glad tl
the editor of the Greenville News is a
>.hat he ran away,even if he did return v
to find this newspiper beiog cla'uor- t<
ously called on for an opinion and uu
-u J - J -i rn
at?r suspicion or aoaging. xwu or
three days of absolute serenity anil indifference
and peace are worth taking
some chances aud suffering some seri- f
ous penalties tor.
This newspaper would do nearly anything
for General Hampton and would ,
work its heart out to serve him because
he is well worthy of all the honor ^
and love this State can give him. It has y
a very strong brotherly affection for its vi
contemporaries with whom it has 8<
fought shoulder to shoulder in a weary ol
discouraging up hill fight for what it a
and they believe to be right. We be- VJ
lieve the motives of General Hampton fc
and our contemporaries are righr, but t|
their judgment in this matter In our b(
view altogethar wrong. In tbe propo- ..
sition for the organization of a "na- Jf
tional Democratic party in this State "
outside the present Democratic organ- bl
izaiton we see Imuch evil and no good. P1
It means, so far as we can under- T
stana, a spin amoug me wuntj peupie,
which is the calamity most of all ca- a
lamlti?s to be dreaded and resisted, di
Suppose 35,000 men should be organ- gj
ized as national Democrats. There y
would yet be a majority of 10,000 against ^
them. If a majority of the white peo- jpie
can be organizad as national D.emocrats
there is no need for the organization
because they can win in the *
regular primaries. We can not make
a minority win without calling in the
help of the black vote. The Greenville
News would rather have Tillman Gavernor
for ten or iifteen years oy white ri
votes than to have a government com-, di
posed entirely of men of its own selec- ft
tion chosen by the help of colored vot- ^
ers. So long as white men rule, how- vj
ever serious or expensive their errors ^
may be. there is always hope of improvement,
always a time to look to
when common sense and conscience ,
will bring a change for the better. Ex- ?
perience has taught us that when the
colored vote rules or is influential that di
matters steadily become worse for the &
whites. Which ever race has control la
will use its power for its own interests tt
and the interests of the two races here hi
are sharply opposed in very many re- lii
spects. We have the kindest feelings
for the colored people but we do not
want ;o see them exchange places with
the whites. T
Ti ere is a race question and a race is- ?
sue nere. Cover and twist it as we {
maj it is at the bottom of all our poli- 1)1
tics. White men ought to stick to and b
stand by their race through thick and ei
thin, rue Democratic organization a
here is the white man's organization, ic
We intend to stay and labor in it until LJ
the bulk of the white people desert it. ?i
Then we will be free. If the evil o:
time comes?which may lleaven for- CJ
bid?when the Democratic party in t{
South Carolina is dead and we have to
choose between Populists and ltepubli- *'
cans we will go with the Republicans ^
as a choice between evils and will do it
straight and without disguises or mor- *
iflcationB. because the negro will then
ave the balance of power and it will
e simply a fight for his vote. If we
ave to scuffle for negro votes we
rould rather do it for the Republican
nrfv than fnr the PoDuliat nartv.
Let all of us South Carolina white
eople stay snd stand together. Let us
o our fighting among ourselves and
ccept the results and swallow our
ledlclne like men without calling in
ny other race or anybody from outide
to interfere. We are of the same
ind and stock. Our fathers and brothrs
nave mingled their blood for the
tate, have loved, hoped, suffered and
led together?Tillnaanites and antis,
alliance men, Ocalaites and Cleveland
)emo3rats. We have factions enough
od bitterness euough now. Let us rerain
from doing anything to make a
ad matter worse, to make our mlsfornoes
and troubles fatal to us. Let 11s
lainiaio our race puwrr iu wu^cunai
lections, burablv trusting that the Allighty
in His good time will set us all
ight, show us all where our mistakes
ave been and restore peace and unity
mong us. So long as we are together
here is hope for that. When we divide
hat hope will be gone.
The thing for uz to do is to cultivate
harity and toleration among ourselves
nd to discourage any new splits or facIons
or causes of quarrel. For the
]en who nave for their own selfish purosei
stirred strife and for the many
nd various squirts and chumps who
ave perverted good principles and puroses
to lift themselves to power and
lace we have no respect. The masses
f the people, however, are good and
3und and honest, if they are wrong
lev are not the first people who have
utted themselves into" headaches
gainst the hard wall of their own mlsikes.
The Greenville News will never
elp in or submit to any attempt to use
ae colored vote against any white peole
until tbey try to use it against us.
f there is to be a split let it come from
3e other side. Let the Populists be*
in it, and then on their heads will be
le responsibility and the coaseuences.
Meanwhile we will make our
ghtsandsay our say inside the Demoratic
party as now organized and will
ccept tbe action of Its majority, not as
ontrolling our opinions b*it as governour
action and position in the reular
elections. An organization outde
the present organization will find
o recognition anywhere and should
nd none.
General Hampton is an honest, pure
nd patriotic gentleman. So is Judge
[askell. In this matter we cannot fol>w
General Hampton any more than
re could follow Judge Haskell in 1890.
-Greenvill News.
Fired on oar Flsz>
New York, Nov. 7.?Tae Herald
rints a dispatch from LaLiberted stat
ig that by the alleged orders of Presleat
Vasquez and by the express comland
of the commissioner of the port
? Amapola, seven cannon shots were
ed after the Pacific Mail steamship
osta Rica, flying the Stars and Stripes,
3 she steamed away, because she relsed
to surrender Policorgo Bonllla,
ho recently led a revolution In Honuras,
but was defeated by Yasquez.
[e was a passenger on the Costa Kica,
hich sailed from CoriQto, Nicaragua,
>r Guatemala. United States Minis?r
Baker was on the Costa Kica when
red on.
Washington, Nov. 7.?The adIces
received by the Department of
Date irom cue scene 01 mu iaau nuuuic
1 Honduras are to the following effect:
[inister Baker boarded tbe Costa Rica,
a American ship, at Corloto (in Nicaigua),
for Salvador. Tbe ship en>red
a port of Honduras, aid while
lere the authorities of the governient
demanded of the captain tbe surmrler
of Borilla, a citizen of Honduis,
who was a passenger on thestiip,
i bis way to Guatemala. Borilla, it
i understood, bad been engaged in
>me insurrectionary movement in
[onduras, for which a criminal charge
as pending against him. After the
lip bad received her clearance papers,
ad wbile she was leaving the
ort, six or seven shots were fired,
hether directly at her or in front
f hsr the bring ber to not is clear,
n conformity with the departmental
3age, there is no hint of the Secretary's
itentions in the matter. If, however,
le usual course is followed, thedepartlent
will probably wait for full adices
before taking any action looking
) redress.
This Ifst'it Cotton Or?p,
Washington, Nov. 10. ?The cotton
iturns ot the department of agriculturl
r the month of November do not inde?
' " ~ ?P??1 a /! kn? r?Ain^ on (-Kaii
1LU a ui^u late ui y io.u, uuu pvmu laiuoi
> a diminished crop, a? compared with
lat ol 1892, which was less tnaa any of
le last decade. The causes of the light
ield have been heretofore reported,
iz, drought, excessive moisture in pome
actions aud ravages of insect enemies
t the plant, and some other causes of
limr importance. Local estimates
ary in range from one-fourth to threemrths
of a full crop. The weather
lruughout the entire cotton belt has
een generally favorable to picking and
le department is advised that owing to
lis fact a large part of the crop has
een successfully secured, a condiderable
ortion of which has been marketed,
'he Indicated yield as averaged from
>unty estimates, apparent errors estln?TA?iA?Aft
1/4Q Q nAnn/lo rvar onro
laicUf avciajco nu.u ^vuuuo nviU)
istributed by States, as follows: Virinia
152, North Carolina 174, Sooth
arolioa 142, Georgia 136, Florida 82,
Jabama 148, Mississippi 143, Louisiana
75, Texas 151, Arkansas 174, Tennesje
138. As severe frosts have not
et been general, it Is possible that rented
expectations may be exceeded.
A Convicted Murderer.
Charleston, S. C? Nov. 4.?Gabel
Grayes, tbe negro brute who mursred
young Frank Thompson and set
re to his mother's house near Palmetto
Lines some time ago, has been conicted
and sentenced to be hanged. The
mrder was a most outrageous one and
ublic indignation was considerably high,
bortly after tbe commission of the deed
(atective W. F. A. Hollaad, ol the
oath Carolina Railway Company, un?
srtook to work up the case, and after
deal of bard work found bis man. Hoi*
md went to arreBt Graves one nigbt in
le city and came very near being killed
imself. Witb the assiitance of tbe pose
the su3pcct'd man was arrested and
Indians on a Hald
Deminq, N. M., Nov. 10.? Fitty
'omicbi Indians on Wednesday sacked
alomas, Mexico, lour miles below tbe
order. Tbe ludians are scattering
ands who survived the massacre in tbe
jgagement with Diaz's soldiers last
[ay. bince then they have been roamig
in the mountains. In the raid on
alomas tbey fired oj the custom house
uards, numbering thirteen, killed one
[' the guards, rifled the custom house,
irryinguway twenty-five carbines, pisj>18,
800 rounds of ammunition and
200 in money. They appropriated
rovisions and other supplies Irom the
cures. One ot the marauding band was
illed in the engagement.
OUR CONGRESSMEN.
HOW THEY STAND AS REGARDS BUT
LER AND TILLMAN.
Some Interntlng Gossip About Smth
Carolina Representatives In Congress?
Senators Batter and Irby Not In Ftiyor
With President Cleveland.
Washington, Nov. 8?The first
chapter In the history of the political
AtvAV\fa In (J/MifV* PonnHno OA fol? Qa tVlOTT
uvcut/O iu uuuuu uaiunuatau mi oq wuvj
are affected by what haa been done or
is doing in Washington, ends with the
cIobo of the extra session, and we can
form some|opinion now as to the drift of
events. It has been known for some
time that one of the most important
factors in the next political contest in
that State would be the contest between
Governor Tillman and Senator
Butler for tbe United States Senate,
and much of that has been going on
here has had more or less bearing upon
that contest.
Senator Butler at the beginning of
this Administration from his long service
here and personal popularity had
a very potential influence in securing
offices for his friends, and these appointments
were made apparently
without regard to any influence upon
South Caroliia's politics. Senator Irby
does not seem to have succeeded in
making any favorable impression, and
his late course in practically allaying
himself with the most bitter opponents
of the Administration has, of course,
-1 A. 1 ~ ? _ aP U4n /1AIMM
ucairuyeu uuy puDSJuiuujr ui mo uuiug
anything in the direction of getting
offices for his friends or partisans.
Since Senator Butler has cast in his
fortunes with tbe enemies of the Administration
on the silver question he
has naturally weakened the claim
whicb otherwise he would have had
upon it, and it is doubtful now whether
he will secure the appointments to
office of those whose principal claim
lies In the jfact that they are partisans
of his and that their appointment
would promote his re-election, and as
that seemed to be the principal ground
upon which it was expected he would
secure the appointment of Mr. Ferry as
collector of internal revenue the
chances of Mr. Ferry's appointment
seem to have very much diminished.
I think that in all appointments of
this nature it will be the policy of tbe
Administration to put in office men
whose fidelity to Democratic principles
as interpreted by the Democratic Administration
leaves no room for question.
In all such appointments it seems
likely that,the opinion of Congressman
Brawley will be most potential, as his
views on public questions are in thorough
accord with those of the Admin*
istration, and it cannot be charged
against cm, as it hub ueeu agamst
many now stand by President
Cleveland, that his views have been
adopted for the purpose of securing
public patronage, as he stands today
precisely upon the ground that he occupied
long before the nomination or
election or President Cleveland. So
far as the chief public offices are concerned,
therefore it appears to be certain
that the Administration will put
on guard none but Democrats of unquestionable
integrity, politically and
otherwise.
The attitude of the different members
of Congress from South CarollDa
towards the Administration is somewhat
complicated. It will be remembered
that early in the spring there
were several interviews between members
of the delegation and the Postmaster
General on the subject of the
postoffice appointments. All of the
mem hereof Congress from South Carolina
participated in these interviews,
except Mr. Bra w ley and Mr. McLaurin,
who were not present thereat. The
mo9t determined fight seemed to be
against Mr. Latimer, who, as the author
of the May resolutions, seemed to
be a good target. Of all that has been
said and done with respect to the postoffices
in his district it would probably
be impossible to tell the story. It wa?
found that a number of the men whom
be had recommended to office were
charged with being Populists, but it
seems that the question as to his right
to control these appointments was
never finally settled against him until
within the last few weeks, when the
publication of his letter in the Colum
bia Register seems to have given him
a coup de grace.
Mr. Strait seems to be practically in
the same boat, as Mr. Latimer and
himself seem to have taken occasion
more than once while in South Carolina
to proclaim their hostility to the
Administration.
Mr. Sbell seems to have no difficulty
practically in securing the appointments
of such postmasters in his district
as he has recommended. He has
adopted the policy generally of recommending
parties who are acceptable to
the communities to be served, and in
all such cases his recommendations
have gone through without question,
and the same is true to a large extent
with respect to Mr. Talbert; and lately
It appear) that Mr. McLaurin Is in the
same boat with the two last named
Congressmen. Senator BuMer has endorsed
all the recommendations of
Messrs. Sbell, Talbert and McLaurin.
The appointment of Mr. Waddill as
postmaster ot. Darlington nas caused
a great deal of comment here as it
seems to Indicate some sort of an alliance
between senator Butler and Mr.
McLaurin but it may be that it has not
the significance which has been given
to it. It is said that WaddiU is now a
Butler man though originally a Tillmanite.
As it appears to an outsider,
however, it would seem that in so far
as the postofflce appointments are concerned
there are some grounds for the
belief that there is some understanding
of a friendly nature between Senator
Butler and Messrs. Shell, Talbert and
McLaurin. Time will show what this
amounts to. It is no longer a secret to
any one that Congressman Shell is an
active friend of Senator Butler's and
will in all probability, be on bis ,?ide
In the pending contest.
Mr. McLaurin has therefore been
ennsldered a strone friend of Governor
Tillman, and It is generally thought
that Congressman Talbert has no particular
love for the present Uovernor.
Whether the friendly relations here of
these three Congressmen with the senior
Senator will result in a similar alliance
in State politics remains to be
seen, but there is no doubt whatever
that Messrs. Irby, Latimer and Strait
are adherents of Governer Tillman.
Congressman Brawley so fir as appears,
has not joined either combination.
Taking the ground, early in the
Administration, that none but Democrats
of unquestioned fidelity to the
party should be appointed to any public
office in South Carolinn, he has not
*\An{fi/\n Knt ha Kqd
swervou 11ULLI luat puoiuiv/u, uuu uo uag
not been disposed to Interfere with any
of the Congressmen in the patronage
of their districts, except in so far as he
has been compelled to protest against
certain appointments on the ground
that the persons named were more in
sympathy with the Populist party than
with the Democratic party, and in all
such cases he has presented to the departments
auch objections as the people
affected desired 10 present.
Inasmuch as this position of inde
-- - * ?.
pendence between the two rival candi- f
J-i-- ' ?*? njflA f/v ?An/\wffl kflf I
liai^b UdS ^IVCU lioo LU lupuiuj buau
Congressman Brawley has some intention
of becoming a candidate for the
United States Senate I have asked him
whether or not he had any such intentions.
He assures me that he has not;
that he did not contemplate being a
candidate under any circumstances.
He thinks that his attitude on the fl- ,
nancial questions is not popular at
this time in South Carolina, and is not
likely to be so, and as be has no inten ,
tion of changing it for the purpose of
obtaining office, he does not intend to
become involved in the contest. He '
says further that in case any sound |
Democrat will stand for election in his
district he will retire at the end of his
term. I
To sum up the whole situation
among the "Reform" Congressmen as
It appears here it would seem that
Messrs Latimer and Strait are for Governor
Tlllmin, that Messrs Shell and
Talbert are against him, and that Mr.
McLaurin's attitude is- somewhat
doubtful and if Waddill's appointment
has the significance generally attribute
ed to it it may be expected that those
persons whom he recommeds for office
will be Butler men. As having some
bearing on the situation it may be noted
that, when Bryan was leading the
filibustering against the repeal bill,
most of the South Carolina "Reform"
Congressmen were with the handful of
Populists that were supporting him.
The whole number of Bryan's followers
was about twenty three, and after a
few votes Messrs Shell and McLaurin
dropped away from him.
There are no indications as to the
result of the contest for the vacant
Judgeship of tho United States Circuit
court, but it may be regaraea as toier- >
ably certain that the .appointment will i
not be made before the 1st of Decern- I
ber. .It is said that the very active i
campaign for this office that is being <
made has excited some unfavorable i
comment in high quarters. The name (
of Judge Hudson will be strongly ,
pressed for the District Judgeship in
case of Judge Simon ton's promotion,
but there are a number of Charleston 1
aspirants for the honor, some of whom !
have very strong bacKlng, and it is impossible
to say to whom it would fall.
An influential gentleman from South
Carolina who was here last week In <
connection with the matter is reported
as insisting that . the appointment
should not go to Charleston in the event
of Judge Simonton's promotion.
?News and Courier.
For the Canal Crlmat
_ Charleston, S. C., Ntiv. 8.?A 1
Spartan Durg special says s pee ay aua
terrible punishment vjaa meted oat to a
negro named Bob Kennedy, about 20
old, at Gaffney last night. About du9k 1
a married white woman and her little
girl vyere hurrying home from the busi- !
ness portion of the town, when in a narrow
lane near their house a negro suddenly
grabbed the woman, threw her
down and began to choke her. Her
bcreams aroused a little boy not far off.
He ran out and saw the negro, who ran
away as soon as be saw the white boy.
He ran oft without completing the assault.
The white boy followed him and
taw him enter a house sot for away.
He then called to some neighbors, who
went to the house- and saw Kennedy
sitting by the lire with his shoes off and
put out of the way. One negro in the
bouse said Kennedy had beeu there for
three hours, another stated that he bad
just come In. He was ordered to get
bis shoes, which showed that they had
just been in the mud. He was carried
oucand bis tracks corresponded exactly
with the ones where the woman was assaulted.
The white boy icentifled him
as the maa- he saw run away and enter
the house. He was kept under arrest
until about midnight, when he was carried
out to the slaughter pen and hanged.
The people were the more incensed because
a week or two ago as three lit le
girls were going to the Cooper Limestone
Institute, from 'xaffney, a negro
unknown to them came out (rom the
, woods, seized one and began to drag
ber back into the woods. The other two
ran and screamed and the dummy came
along just then and tho negro became
alarmed and released the girl, who escaped
frightened nearly to death. They
believe that Kennedy made the assault
on the little child. He confessed to the
assault on the white woman.
The Fair a Failure.
Columbia, S. C., Nov. 11.?The annual
Fair of the South Carolina Agricultural
and Mechanical Society for
1893 has come and gone, and the officials
say it is a failure in point of attendance
as compared with former
years. Some of the reasons for this
have already been stated, such as the
hard times, discrimination of the railroads,
etc., but there are other large
reasons that have not been mentioned.
One reason is the want of energy and
enterprise on the part of the society.
The society did next to nothing in ad- '
vertising the Fair and inducing people i
to come here and bring their exhibits. !
The next reason is the indifference of
the people of Columbia towards the
Fair. They did not commence to do (
anything until the Fair was almost on j
hand, and then fell far short of what ,
might havo been done. The people of
Augusta and the managers of the Exposition
have been alive and at work
for the event for months. Delegations 1
were sent to Chicago and Washington '
in the interest of the Exposition, and 1
the State and surrounding country 1
? tt i n foroofoH in fhtti r Til*'- I
YVOIC !LlU:UOUtJ luiuivuubu *** vuv*? ? .?
position, and went to work to interest |
other people in every possible way.
There wes nothing of that sort done
in tbe interest of the Columbia Fair.
The effect of it is easily seen. People
love novelty and amusements, and in
this day of competition they are going
where the greatest attractions are offered.
It has been a matter of common
remark during this week that if
the Fair Society and the people of Columbia
do not wake up and do more in
the interest of their annual fairs they
will soon be things of the past. If the
people of Columbia and the Fair Society
had taken the same interest and
worked for their Fair as hard as the
colored people are working for their
Fair it would have been a magmflcent
success?Register.
Atrocious Assassination.
Laurens, S. C., Nov. 4.?A dreadful 1
tragedy occurred near Goldville, in this <
county, last night. J. Dorrob Hairstorn
was assassinated while at supper I
with his family. Some unknown party l
lired a load of slugs into his stomach ]
thrmirrh an nnan flnnr ITfl flipd in tif- ,
teen minutes. Hairstou's duelling <
was burned last summer by incendi- j
aries, and two negroes, Wade Cannon
and George Bowers, were convicted of
the crime and executed in September. 1
Hairston was the prosecutor. It Is 1
conjectured, that revenge may have
been the motive for his assassination.
A negro tenant on Hairstou's place,
named Iteeder, has been arrested on 1
suspicion, but it is said that there is 1
not yet a strong case against him. 1
Hairston was a good citizen and was I
well connected. It is thought here that J
a lynching is not unlikely if the mur- (
derer is discovered and captured. Only i
meagre details, however, have been re- ]
ceived here.?State. j
.
"
. i
RECEIVED WITH SURPRISE.
:
What Is Said Abjnt Oar DefMt
In Washington.
Washington, Nov. 8.?The result y
of the election has been received with
surprise by all political parties here. <
The unexpected happened io so many
instances, that in no case were the pre*
dictions of Democrats. Republicans or
Populists verified. The chief surprise
of the Democrats arises not from the
fact that they were defeated, bat that
the defeat was so general in all doubt*
t'al states, and the Republican majority
so overwhelming. A grain of com fort
is accorded tbeaa In the defeat of
Lhe Populists in Virginia, aod the election
of O'Ferrall to the governorship,
but the blows have been so crashing
in the states of New York, Massachusetts,
New Jersey, Ohio and Iowa that
Bven the success m Virginia Is hardly
paraded as a triumon. Expressions
From nearlv all the prominent Demo
cratic leaders at the Capitol, as indicated
in tneae dispatches several days
ago, showed that the Democrats were
prepared for defeat in those states where
the free coinage element Is strong and
tbe disappointment over the passage of
the repeal bill is intense, but it was hard*
[y expected that in the "sound money"
3tates of New York and Massachusetts
the Democratic Majority of the past
would be so ruthlessly mowed down and
the careful efforts of perfect organization
avail so little. Despite this, however,
all the prominent Democratic leaders
unite in ascribing the ; general defeat
throughout the country to two causes?
the dissatisfaction of the. agricultural
classes over the financial question, and
bbe widespread apathy ot disappointed
office seekers who have failed to reallza
the fruits of the last Democratic victory.
En tbe state of Ohio alone, was the tariff '
question the prominent theme of discos- '.
3ion, McKinley and Neal so emphatical- - "
ly reoeatmg tne declarations 01 ineir par*
ties ia this respect. Bat here, too, the
Democrats are rooted by the same ex- ?
orable Republican majority. In Iowa,
the defeat of Boiea is important, not
that it means a Republican governoi
in that state and a Republican United
States senator next winter but that it
practically removes Boies from the list
of Western candidates for the Presidency
in '96. The judgnent of the
party leaders here approved the first
declaration of Governor Baits last
summer, that he would not be a candidate
for governor at the fall election,
and when he finally reconsidered and
came out in the reace for a third term,
it was felt that he had everything to
lose and little to gain from the campaign
that was to follow. It was recalled
that even the popular Foraker,
was nnable, in Ohio, to stem the popn- x '
iar sentiment against a third term, and
when the Republicans of Iowa reproach
edthe Democrats with departing from
c it- i: 1 At
one ui mo uiruiuiu piiuvipiw vi nuw
party in nominating a man for a third
term, they presented their opinions on
the defensive practically from the very
beginning. The Poppliste still contend
that later returns will show that their
party has made a far better showing
in various states than is conceded them
in the earlier dispatches.
In Virginia they succeeded in terror*
izing the Democrats for the last two
weeks, bnt tbe leaders of the .latter
party rallied from their panic in time
to make unprecedented efforts to get
out tbeir full vote, and it looks as
thongb tbe Populists would liave stood
a much better chance tor victory by
making a still fight.
The Populist senators and Eepabllcans
who are in the city, are anxious*
ly watching the latest ne*s from Nebraska
and Kansas, and expect cheering
news from tbe official returns.
Tnere is one element of defeated Democracy
tbat reviews the general Republican
victory with a philosophic resignation
tbat amounts almost to sat istaction.
This element comprises the
free coinge Democrats who have so
bitterly reproached President Cleveland
for forcing ibe repeal bill through Congress,
and who for weeks have been
predicting tbat tbe administration's dislnvnit.v
Ln the Democratic National
platform would be rebuked by a crash- '
ing defeat in all tbe great states' elections
this tall. These men now point
to the Democratic deieat as the result
ot the party's departure from Its faith
in tbe recent extraordinary session,
and are already preparing, to coax tbe
majority back to the good old orthodox
iaitb when the regular session convenes
in December.
Chairman Bland will introduce his
free coinage bill at the first bill day
of the session, and the free coinage men
are expected to be a unit in demanding
its prompt consideration.
The President did not show that intense
interest in the returns last night
that would have indicated a confidence
in Democratic victory. Early in the
evening the President went oat to bis
country home instead of remaining at
tbe executive mausion, as is usuai ou
election nights, and the returns he received
were only those of sufficient Importance
to be telephoned out to Woodley
by Private Secretary Thurber, as
tbe latter received .them from the telegraph
wire at the White House. Several
members ol the Cabinet drore out
to the President's cottage in the evening,
but none of these gentlemen have 30
far given any expression of the causes
-hat led up to tbe general defeat.
The President was doubtless undis:ouraged
by the Democratic defeat as he
ias constantly repeated to those members
of his Darty who have been predicting
Democratic deteat as the result ot
the administration financial policy, that .
they would vindicate their party and
ihow that the majority was right in d?manding
the immediate and uncondi/\t
ikaSharmtn opf:
wiuuai icpai vi uuw wuwi?nDlsoaeyed
Orders.
Toledo, 0., JNcv. 10.?Foar persons
were killed in a collision near Bradnor,
Dhio, twenty' tour miles from here, last
svening on the Columbus. Hocking
Valley and Toledo railroad. The east
Dound Columbus express, which left
lere at 5:20 p. m. crashed into a north
sound freight in a dense fog. The dead
ire: L. H. Jones, engineer of tho passenger
train; Fireman Jones, of the passen;er
train; James R. Gresh, express
nessenger on passenger train: Engineer
Kerlio, of the freight train. Trainnen
disobeying orders was the cause.
Searching; Freight Cars.
Charleston, 3. C., Xov. 10.?In belalf
of the State constaolea, Mr. Whaey
has just procured orders from the
United States court granting authority
:o search two cars on the tracks of the
Pq?"a1 *no roilaratr anano^hA/1 rtf
containing liquor. Pnis rnafeea the
?i*hth seizure since last Friday. All
liquor captured in that time is worth
probably $1,500.
t