The Abbeville press and banner. (Abbeville, S.C.) 1869-1924, October 11, 1876, Image 2
The Press and Banner.
Wednesday, Oct. 11,187G.
DEMOCRATIC TICKET.
2*or Prrsiucnt.
SAMUKL ??. TILDKN, of New York.
Po r 17/v. I 'rr.fi den f,
TIIOS. A. HIsSl>liI('KS,of Indiana.
j-'frf S'tnte Larqr.
S.Ul'1, MC(iC)\VAN. of Abbeville.
T. U. HAUKKIt, of Chailvstou.
For f-'frrfrtr frorr. Third District,
\YM. WALLACE, of liiclihiiiil,
Fcr Governor,
WAftft ftAMlTOX, of Richland.
For Lieutenant Governor.
W. T>. SIMPSOX, of L:uihoijs.
For * I tlnrrey-Gen ral.
JAMES COXXElt, of Charleston.
J-)ir I'ntr&i roller- Gent rat.
JOHNSON H A GOOD, of Uurnwell.
tor Stoic Treasurer.
S. L. LEAPHART, of Kit hltirul.
For Seer'fan/ (\f State,
]{. M. SIMS, of York,
For Inxperio)'' General.
E. W. MOr.SE, of sum tor,
/or Superintendent of J^duratifni,
II. S. THOMl'SOX, of Hichhuiri.
For Conr/rea*. Third District.
1>. \Y. AIKEN, of Abbeville.
For Solicitor, Eighth Circuit.
J. S. COTHUAX, of Abbeville.
For the Senate,
J. C, MAXWELL.
For Jlottur of ffaprcxrntatices.
U. R, HEMRH1LL.
W. K. BRADLEY.
J. A. CONNER.
WILLIAM HOOD.
T. L. -MOORE.
For Sheriff.
J, Y. JONES.
For School Commissioner.
J. A. WTEU.
Fur L'Icr/: of fhr Court.
M. O. ZKIOLElt.
For Prohatr Judr/r.
J. FULLER LYOX.
for County Commissioners,
JiOJ}ERT JONES.
U. M. MADISON.
It. A. McCASLAX.
For (oronr'r.
? \v cnrHltAX.
L ? ' . J'w-.J ? .1 A*
Joint Discussion,
KU IT COL. HASKELL SAU> TO
COM". CIIAMIIKRLAIN,
This letter was delivered to Governor
O&iumberlain on L'Uth September, and lie
luts tailed to give a reply, although the
publication has been delayed to give
Jbiirii lull time:
Rooms State Ex. Committee.
Columbia, S. C., Sept. 28. ISTti.
To hi* Excellency Daniel II. Chamberlain,
Columbia, S. C.
" Sir.?I beg leave to render to you, in
liehalf of Gen. Wade Hampton and the!
ether nominees upon the State Demooratic
ticket, and iu pursuance of the
spirit manifested in tbe card i sued on
August by the State i democratic Ivxecutive
Committee, an invitation to attend
the Democratic mass meetings
which are being held iu succession iu ;
each county in the State. The order iu !
.which thev follow, together with tlu j
dates, appears in nearly a!l of the papers- i
tin the State. You are invited to bepres
-eut and to join in the discussion. You!
:fire<iware that the canvass is a warm one, j
.?nd that your party and your of-j
.firial course are charged with having in-:
rflicted great wrongs upon the people]
whose interests it was your duty to pro- j
mote. That is the nature of political I
discussion under such circumstances;
hut you are at the same time well aware,
that the people you are invited to ad- j
?lre*s are, by nature end by habit, qnut
and law-abiding, and that so far lrom
rudeness or violence, you will personally I
receive nothing but courteous treatment,j
however bitterly your political and of J
.Jicinl course may he as&iled.
You will call to mind that on 18th
instant I gave this iuvitation to you |
verbally, and your reply was that you j
appreciated the attention, but your
jHjiicy ti?r the campaign had not been
lixed ; that jjersonal matters required you
to go to the North ; that your absence
would be tor probably eight days, and:
you could not give y>>ur positive answer,
until after yo ir retur.i. I learned ves;
lerday that you had returned, and I beg I
Jeave, as I said, to formally extend to you j
this invitation, assuring you that if you
accept it your appearance before the
Democracy throughout this State will beto
yourself as Governor a'most pleasing
refuation of the slanderous charges
which constantly are published against
our party in some newspapers which
claim to be your political organs, aud
also in the Northern papers, backed by
the name of Senator Patterson or some
other person, who claims to be your
political friend and exponent. "We deem
?r. Him to vou and ourselves that these!
charges be either contradicted by your j
denial of them or looked into by your
going in person to ascertain the truth.
You do not hold the position of* candidate
only ; you are also Governor of
this State ; and while as a mere candidate
you may not be bound to correct charges
which your followers make against your
oppouents, though you know them to be
false, you are as Governor and candidate
bound by your gubernatorial pledge and
honor to prevent your followers using
the sanction of your official silence to
sustain these charges against your oppo- j
nents, when the charges allege the over i
throw of the peace and dignity of the;
State, which you are sworn to defend i
As instances of the class of slander-? to |
which I refer, I beg leave to cite the fol-1
lowing:
Washington, September 0. j
It is reported here, upon what is
deemed good authority, that parties in j
New York have agreed to ship Chamberlain
20,000 staud of arms to arm the;
blaeks in South Carolina. This is one!
/^Urtrv>koi?ltui.*o 4nnl?o r\ mi wmit i'mmH I
vi vuniiiuciiiviu o u Itrvo iv vumj iavci j
with the blacks and be renominated. J
The arms will be landed iu Charleston
on the 11th instant, the day before the
meeting of the Republican State Convention.
While here, Chemberlain was ve ry
bitter in his denunciation of the Sooth
Caroiina, whites, calling them Ku Klu.v
scoundrels. etc.?Neiv York Sun.
Wakhixotox, September f>.
Governor Chamberlain, oi'South Carolina,
has just returned from another
visit to this city to confer with the authorities
upon sending troops to that
State. The Governor was noisy iu his
denunciations of such men as Haskell,
Haoipton, Gary, ex-Governor Perry and
others., whom he charges are on the eve
of precipitating auothet rebellion. lie
make* the idle boast that he has proof
that liutler and Hampton were at the
head of the Hamburg riot, and lie ex-1
peete in less than two months to have
them tried. The Governor declared to
a prominent South Carolina politician ;
last o-ight that he was done with reform
talk,and hereafter the Legislature would !
find no barrier in him. The Governor!
hae fliade arrangements to have 20,000 <
gtand of arms seat down to arm i ho j
blacks. The arote will be landed in,
Otarleston .on the 11th instant, the day i
previous to the meeting of the Radical
iCinvention.?jYrw York World,
I ------- .
Yv asiiington*, September 20.
Senator Patterson arrived here tin?
morning from South Carolina to appl)
tor more help to protect the voters and
prevent the terrorism which extends over
the whole State. Governor Chamberlain
'and I niied States Marshal Wallace and
others will arrive to-morrow moru ng.^
Au old resident of Columbia told thei
Senator last week that he could not speak
to him on the street if he met him. Tbej
excitement and feeling is far worse than
it was in 1-SGO uud the days of secession,
and it is dangerous to even speak to a
Radical. Judge Cooke, who has acted
for some years with the Republicans,
; made a speeeh not long since advocating;
. the election of \\ ade Hampton and:
Governor Tilden, and excused himself
r 1 .1.. .... .... i
I by saying tliat lie was loiccu uu su lu
save his property ati?l perhaps his life.
The whole white male Democratic pop- j
: ulation is said to be completely armed, j
jand large consignments of rilles, re-1
1 vol vers and knives are received constant- j
ly. Yet no dealer will sell a Republican
even a kuif'e. The very boys are armed,!
and the boys of the military school at)
Columbia openly wear their revolvers;
belted around them. The Senator says
that full 20,000 men, armed and!
| mounted, are thoroughly patroling the'
' whole State under the direction and com-1
, maud of Butler, of Hamburg fame, and !
i these forces are not only armed, but!
'completely orgauized and drilled.
1 The people are reported as expressing j
! themselves openly in favor of a fight, I
1 and as saying that they don't care a ;
' for the United States, the troops, or the;
; North, but that they arc ready and aux- j
i ions to clear out all the troops thatGeu-j
; eral Grant can send. They say that if j
I they do have any trouble Governor Til- j
| den will carry Indiana and Ohio :n j
; October, and New York in November, I
! which ensures his election; the}' are!
i hound to elect Hampton or destroy thej
j State. Senator Patterson says that unless;
[they have immediate help no colored)
j man will dare to move or talk, much less I
i to vote, and if Indiana goes Democratic
, that South Carolina, North Carolina and
! Florida will follow, and there will be an
I outbreak which will almost be one of
| extermination of Republicans. Murders
! are done every day of which not a whisj
per reaches the North.?Xcw York Tri-!
brine.
j It is not my meaning that we should!
! take the paius to deny every error that!
! may appear in campaign speeches or
' , U..4. T mrtnn tknf tl'lion Cfoto.
UUU X UU 1X1 CUll luuu n uvu stuw .
meats appear as coming from yourself,
or from others who are robed with the
j dignity of office, which ought to attach
(importance and a credibility to what!
I they say, and when these utterances, as!
i in tlie instances above cited, are totally!
J false and atiect the character of the State,;
it is the duty, I respectfully submit, oft
; the Governor to deny theru. And if he1
I (the Governor) believe them to be true, |
i it is his duty to restore peace and order ;i
| aud to do so it is his sworn duty to call |
j upon the citizens to sustaiu him and en- j
j force the law. All these assaults arej
i made against the Democratic party.;
I Whatever may be our political error, in j
Iyour estimation, in belonging to that)
J party, we are none the less citizens oft
! ibis State, aud as such we have the right
to ask of you the protection which ini
your official position you alone can give.;
If there be terrorism and violence in;
the State, call upou us to suppress it, I
aud do not let the name of the State be!
* i* 1 i ? i 1 1
perverted 10 uisnouonioie pomn-ui i'u'-i
p?-:f- j
\ ou, ami uo one better, know tnat the!
white people of South Carolina arei
struggling as few people ever have done
to cast oil'a burthen of corruption and |
wrong such as yet fewer people have:
ever borne so long, In your own words, j
speaking of your own party:
"Keloim, if It was not of itself right,;
has become absolutely necessary, or the|
State will sink."
"The party has ever been going into
campaigns promising retrenchment audi
reform and never performing it."
"Matters cannot run for six years to
come as they have the past six years."
i "These figures" (speaking of legisla-j
tive expenses) "I may say are unparalleled
in the history of American legis-j
lation. It is'stcaliug pure and simple."
And, referring to the election of two |
Judges?elected, I may say, by the lead-1
iog ii.an now ou the ticket with you:)
"Their electiou has sent a thrill of horror j
throughout the State. * * * I look toi
their election as a horrible disaster."!
'Tne civilization of the Puritan and the!
Cavalier, of the Roundhead and the!
Huguenot., is iu peril. Courage, deter-:
miuatiou, union, victory,, must be uuri
watchwords."
| "No party can rule (his State that j
suppor.s Whipper and Moses. * * * *'
There is but oue way to .save the Rcpub- j
lican party in South Carolina, and that!
way is to unload Whipper and Moses
and all who go with them. * * * *!
Neither the administration at Washing-1
ton, with all its appliances?civil and;
military?nor all the denunciations of.
(he world heaped upon me, can save the!
Republican party here from overwhelm-;
ing defeat during this year, unless we;
can persuade the people of this State1
that such things as these judicial elec- {
tious will be uudoue and never by passi-;
bilitv repeated."
You know that the men who were the!
leaders, who conducted that election,]
and who perpetrated the wrongs of
which it was^a feeble expression, are|
the same men who control the ticket!
upon which your name stands, who de-j
vised your party platform, and are today
your political exponents. You know j
that it is against all tbis that ourunfor-j
tnnniP nwmlp am fctrnm'liiH': and vet
~ 1 I r?o c * # ? J's
you know full well that their elfort.s, <
although iu the warmth of canvass, nre!
orderly and within the law. Your manhood
compels you to approve our course,
but we do not call upon you for that.
As a candidate you are entitled to allj
benefits which can accrue from the meas !
ures which your followers (or, if you j
would permit me, I would sny your party |
leader.*, for your independent course wasi
very different,,) have adopt d. But asi
the Governor of the Stale you are called :
I upon to either contradict the assertion;
| that the law is overthrown and that tcr-1
jrorism prevails, or to suppress this law-]
ilessness; and it is our right that you |
call upon us before you appeal to the
| government of the United States. Our
(services are at your command, and
J whatever is our duty we are ready to
I do.
j To refcur. I beg ltave again to ex)
tend to you the invitation, and ask you
to communicate it to the candidates upon!
'your ticket, as it is meant for them asj
j well as for yourself. It is the wish ofj
I the Democratic party that you accept;
i it, for we are earnestly di sirous to remove'
: the bitterness of race feeling, which wei
| attribute to the prejudice- and erroneous!
views which have been instilled into the
I colon d race. And we honestly desire j
"peaceful and untrammelled discussion,
that the people may become eulightened '
on the issues of the day."
Your early rc^ly will be deemed a;
favor, and it such be your wish, preparations
will be made to receive you at the
first meeting that it shall be your pleasure
to indicate.
1 have the honor to be, very respectiully,
your obedient servant,
A.C. Haskeix,
Chairmrn Sfate Democratic Executive
Committee,
te # -
r i
GOV. fllA.IIiJF.ULAI.VS ANSWER!
TO vol.. II ASK KM..
Col.I'Mnia, S. October 4, 1^7'i j
; A. C. Haskell, Ksi]., Chairman l)cm-j
I oeratie State Kxeeutivc Committee, j
C'olumb'a, S. C.
I Sit:: ? I have received your com mil- |
! uieation (if the -Sth ultimo, covering
several matters connected with the political
canvass now in progress in this
State and the general condition of our;
public sid'airs. Von lirst invite me
and the nominees ort the republican)
*t:ite ticket "to attend the democratic!
nia-s meetings which are being held
in succession iu each county in the;
state." This part of your comnittni-i
cation would have hcen addressed
more naturally?and I trust you will;
permit me to add, more properly?lot
the cliniriiKin of the republican state
committee, whose function it is,as the
organ of that committee, to consider
and determine the methods and order,
of the canvass on the part of the republican
party. In answer, therefore,)
to your invitation, I am unable to say :
more than that I have informed the;
chairman of ttie republican state com- '
mittcethnt as soon as the duties of my I
office, which now imperatively require j
my presence at the capital, snim per-1
tilit it, I shall be ready to meet (ieneral
Hampton at any suitable points in
state, not in "democratic mass meet- i
imjs," but in mass meetings to be call-!
ed by both parties for the purpose of!
joint discussions, upon terms of per-!
foot equality in all respects of the political
issues now before our people.!
Von will doubtless receivc at an early
day a proposition of such a nature
from the republican state committee,
with such suggestions regarding details
as will commend themselves to your
sense of fairness and secure the objects
which you profess to seek i:i your invitation?the
removal of "the bitterness
of race feeling, which we (you) j
attribute to the predudicesawl erroneous
views which Jiave been instilled
into the colored race," and a "peaceful
and untrammeled discussion, that the
people may become enlightened on the
issues of the day." In saying this, II
am confident I faithfully represent also
the wishes and purposes of all my
associates on the republican state tick-1
et.
The remainder of your connminica-1
tion is occupied with statements ofj
what you claim to be the spirit and
; nf t li f> (IplllOCrftt- I
UIHJU 111/1/ itlJlt |SMi v.. ~
i ic party in the state, with a special cali
upon iiie "as governor and candidate,"
to contradict certain alleged statements
respecting the present coudition of the
state and the action of men who belong
to the democratic party, which
you call "slanderous charges," or to
"look into them by going in person to
ascertain the truth." You say that
"my appearance before the democracy
throughout the state will be to me as
governor a most pleasing refutation of
the slanderous charges which constant- j
ly are published against your party in
some newspapers which claim to be
my political organs, and also in the
northern papers, backed by the name
of Senator Patterson or some other person
who claims to be my political
friend and exponent." You say that
I am "as governor and candidate, j
bound by my gubernatorial pledge and !
honor, to prevent my followers using j
II.AominHnn nf m\r nffieml to
sustain these charges against my oppo-j
nents, when these charges allege the j
overthrow of the peace ami dignity of!
thestate which I am sworn to defend."
You present three examples of the
charges to which you refer, are taken
from the Washington correspondence,
respectively, of the New York Sun,
New York World and New York Tribune.
You say that "these utterances,
in the instances above cited, are totally
false, ami aflcct the character of the
slate,*'and that if 1 "believe them to
be true it is my duty to restore peace!
and order, and to do so it is my sworn
duty to call upon the citizens to sustain
me and enforce the law,"
You proceed further to say that "1,
and no one better, know that the white
people of South Carolina are struggling!
as few people ever have done to cast off
a burthen of corruption and wrong,
such as yet fewer people have ever
borne so long," and you proceed to j
make extended quotations from for- j
mer remarks of mine respecting ourj
public affairs, and to say that the men .
who com milted the wrongs which Ij
denounced "are the same men who;
control the ticket upon which my
name stands, who devised my party
platform and are to-day my political i
exponents." You say that I "know I
that it is against all this that our un-l
fortunate people are struggling, ami J
I 1.- n/iif full \i-nll rluif, JluMl'l
ellbrts, although in the warmth of!
canvass, are orderly and within the j
law." You say that my "manhood j
compels me to approve your cour.se,"!
and filially you declare that "as gov-j
ernor of the state I am called upon to
either contradict the assertion that the;
law* is overthrown, and that terroism {
prevails, or to suppress this lawless- j
ness," and that "it is your right that I {
call upon you before I appeal to the
government of the United Staffs." j
I am pleased to observe and ae-;
knowledge the respectful terms iui
which your.statements and charges are j
framed, so far as they affect me. ;
riie.se statements and charges covcr in j
subs tit nee the whole field of our pros-1
ent political - controversy, together!
with the matters growing out of thai
controversy, and efiecting the pub-1
lie peace and the common civil rights j
of our citizens. In addition to your
direct call upon me, in your character j
as the official representative of the ;
democratic party, to express my views '
upon the matters presented by you, j
thenatureof your communication and i
the statements and charges which you j
make seem to compel me to speak. 1 '
do this with profound reluctauce.!
Not only will the expression of my i
views disclose how widely you and Ij
stand apart upon all the questions involved,
but it will, in my sober judgment,
disclose to the world a condition
of things inexpressibly disgraceful to j
the good name of our state. inougn.
General iiauipton is reported to liavei
said substantially, in recent public j
speeches, that I could not, by reason j
of my nativity, feel such an interest
and pride in the fame of South C.'aro- J
Una as becomes her governor, and,:
.though you may share in this opinion, j
I still venture to say to you that 1 \
have regretted deeply the receipt of;
your communication, because it. forces
me, while I hold my present high of-1
lice, to present views and convictions I
which, if correct, reflect infinite dis-1
credit upon a large portion of the |
people of this state. It is, however,
as your communication show, no new j
experience to me to find myself com-:
polled by a sense of duty to pursue a
course which has subjected me, not!
only as in the present instance, to the}
increased hostility of political oppo-j
nents, but to the suspicion and denun- j
elation of political friends. Jiut I j
profess to put my duty to the state]
above all other present considerations, j
and that duty, as I understand it, requires
me to reply to your communication
fully, plainly and fearlessly. |
SLANDKHOL'S Ctl AK(J KS.
With respect to the specific install-j
ces of "slanderous charges," which j
you cite from the New York papers,
let me first say that-the statements respecting
me made in the jS'toiand the'
World are wholly untrue and un-j
founded. Nothing remotely resem-;
bling what is there stated was everj
said or done by me. The extract from i
the Tribune, professes to give the views!
and statements of Senator Patterson, j
for which I am not responsible.
How far my views coincide with or differ
from those attributed to Senator'
Patterson will best appear in what i!
shall hereafter stale.
I shall now proceed to present my I
views upon the several mutters rela-:
tine: to<mr present political condition!
which are covered by your communi-'
cation.
Tin: ISSUE STATKI).
Your claim in substance is that I" am
the head of a party and ticket which :
represents and is responsible for a bur-!
den of corruption and wrongs* grievously
oppressive to the state; that!
my position upon that ticket is incon-j
sistent with my public record; that
the democracy, on the other hand,
are engaged i^ a political struggle
with the s-ole aim of freeing the state]
from this burden of corruption and,
wrongs, and that all your methods
and actions are peaceful and within I
the law. In support of your view of
riiy present position, you refer to myj
public denunciations of past acts of
tlie Republican party or its members. i<
Vou thus challenge not only my polit-j
ical integrity ami honor, but my per-j
soual consistancy as a public man.!
In order properly to meet your dial- 1
lenge, especially as to my personal
consistency. 1 must refer to the course
of events 111 this stale during the last
two years.
lilSVlKW or LAST TWO YKAIIS.
I was nominated and elected in 1R74|
as the candidate of tlx; republican
party, under pledges, both personal
and party, to reform the abuses
which then existed. Jn my inaugural
address I developed in detail
my plans of reform?plans which
met the earnest approval of thegeneral
public of the state without regard
to party. That I pursued the course"
there marked outearnesily and faith-1
fully as a claim which cannot be successfully
or even plausibly disputed.
[ found a considerable part of my|
own party opposed to my course, and j
thus my fidelity to my pledges and to j
* I . .. rt.t ..<> WAl/tlMlA IIU I Itllllal'cf/wul if" I
UIU Ciunc Ui n.lwnu,a.T 4 uimviciwwM it.f<
wus put to severe nn<l unexpected j
tests. Jt is not egotism but truth whicli:
leads me t<> affirm that I bore those
tests in a manner which' commanded
the praise of the friends of reform
throughout the state. The press of
this stu'e, the public utterances of its
leading citizens, every organ of public
opinion, will furnish the proof of j
this assertion. j\Iy record as governor
was elaborately reviewed in July last)
by the C/uirlcsion Ncich Courier?be-j
yond comparison the ablest, and, in aj
normal condition of affairs, the most!
liberal, democratic newspaper in this]
state or in the south?in a series of ed-:
itoriai articles founded on official and |
indisputable records.
AH u.urjii.irji.
Two results accomplished l>y the republican
convention have now been
presented. First, my renoinination
by more than a two-thirds vote upon
the sole and distinct issue of my reform
record ; second, the adoption by
the convention of a platform which
binds the republican party to reform
in general, and to reform in detail?a
plaiform which must meet the approval
of eveiy man who is familiar with
the present practical wants of the
state. J now present these two results
as a complete refutation of your
charge of personal inconsistency on
my part in accepting my present position
011 the republican ticket, as well
as a vindication and proof of the determination
of the republican party to
carry forward and complete the work
of reform, fcio far as these'two results
are concecncd, I do not know how my
policy and record as governor?which
disis commanded, as 1 have shown, in
its relations to reform, the cordial
praise ami appoval of almost every
man in your party?could have received
a more signal or satisfactory endorsement
by my own party. Looking
to these results 1113' position is one
of complete, fairly-earned, honorable
triumph. Jl is far belter than that?it
is an ample and remarkable triumph
of the great cause of governmental
reform in this state.
NOMINATION OK MR. ELLIOTT.
But there arc expressions in your
communication which indicate that in
your view the alleged inconsislancy
and dishonor of my present position
lip in my association upon the republican
ticket with certain other nofninees,
and especially with Mr.
Elliott, the nominee for attorney
-general. Of inv associates up- j
ilm ci.itu ni lw>r Hum !
Mr. Elliott, I know of no alleged!
public cause of complaint or tliM^alia- J
faction, except, that t\vo/>f them have
disapproved of my course as governor'
on certain party grounds, while IJ
ought not to omit to add that lu tlie
renomina lion of Mr. Cardozo as treasurer,
a gentleman who hafe'been my
conspicuous anil devoted friend and
supporter in every feature of my administration,
the cause of reform has
achieved another most notable triumph.
With reference to (he nomination of
Mr. Elliott, I am charged with indi-i
vidua! inconsistency and want of li- >
delity to reform because Mr. Elliott J
has opposed my course as gorernor iu
some important features and was strenuously
opposed to my rcuomination.
Itistrue that Mr. Elliott has differed
from me widely in some instances, and i
particularly in respect to the election
of Whipper as circuit judge and my
refusal to sign his commission. If it
be inconsistent and dishonorable for
me to remain upon the ticket for this
cause I think I can point you to simiUi
Imif'infiiK nf ili<l)<>iinr iiinmiL' those
who still command your support.
DEMOCRATIC "DISIIOXOK."
Governor Tilden was nominated by j
the democratic party as a professed >
hard money candidate on a professed
hard money platform. He is associated
on the same ticket with Governor
Hendricks, his most prominent opponent
for the nomination of president,
and the leading champion of soft money
and inllation. >io more pronounced
antagonism of views upon the
leading political issue, prior to their
nominations, could have existed ; yet J
we now sec Governor Tilden ami Governor
Hendricksadjusting themselves,
with a skill and success greatly satis-'
factory to your party at least, upon the j
same ticket and the same platform,;
and 1 hear no charge of inconsistency!
or dishonor against Governor Tilden;
from the democratic party. j<
Uut I do not choose to answer your!
charge with this retort alone. Whileh
it is true?and I think it due to my1-!
self to state the fact?that I did notapprove
of or aid in or consent to the
nomination of Mr. Elliott, it is also
true that Mr. Elliott, at the time of his
nomination and since, lias declared his
nil I mikI fordinl acceptance of the work I
of the convention in renominating me <
and in adopting the platform which
pledges the parly and its nominees to
thorough and specific reforms. The
causes of his nomination were not his i
opposition lo me or to reform, but his :
admitted ability for the position, his
long record of political service to his
party and a desire, as in the case ol ,
Governor Hendricks, to conciliate an J
clement of the party which hud been ,
defeated in my lenomination. J am
therefore, in no sense compromised or
dishonored in my character as a re for- ,
mcr by my association upon the same
ticket with Mr. Elliott. On the contrary,
I am entitled to all the conti- (
deuce ever bestowed upon nie in that .
respect, so far as my individual or personal
position is concerned, and I am r
entitled to all the increase of confidence
which conies from my Hiiccess]
in bringing my own party to endorse
me ami the entire policy of reform
which I have inaugurated and carried 1
on, and the consequent increase of my !
ability to serve that cause.
Whenever you or others present the
record of my denunciations of past J
wrongs done by the republican party :
in this state, you present that portion ;
of mv record of which 1 am most J
proud; for, while it is very easy to
float with the tide of party sentiment ,
ami action, it is some test of one's fidelity
to duty tOdenouncc the actions J
of one's party associates and defy their
opposition and hatred. I stand by
every word and syllabieof that record.
I wish the record were longer and!
louder, though, as it statins, i cnaiienge;
its comparison with that of any man J
in this state who now opposes me.
WIIIPPElt ANI) SIOSKS.
Your communication Jays special
emphasis, as supporting your position. (
upon the election of Whipper and ,
Moses, and you quote conspicuously ,
my denunciations of those elections. J
I reartirni every word you quote, and I .
further declare that what I then asserted
to be the only path of duty or safety
for the republican party has been
done. Whipper and Moses and all i
who go with them liava been repudia- i
ted and "unloaded." Their elections 1
have been defeated ami their threat- <
cued elevation to the bench of South .
Carolina lias been prevented. Moses .
has resigned, and Whipper has been it
compelled to seek the courts, wherein j
ninety-nine out of every, hundred of | J
the lawyers of this state regard hisj<
claim as destined to sure defeat. And (i
. i. t.. i ! i: K.. ! i
Illi* Illl!S UVUII m'UMHUiiniini uy uic iv- i
publican party ; Tor whatever I have |
done is chargeable to the credit of the i
republican party, which has now en- |
dorsed and renominated me. "('our- i
ago, determination, union, victory,":!
have been "our watchwords," and in I
that sign we have conquered. t
Such, sir, is my answer to your 11
charge of personal inconsistency and if
dishonor in ncceptingmy presentposi- f
tion on the republican state ticket, and
to your further charge that thcsuccees j
r>f that ticket would bo disastrous to
tlio interests of our people, I occupy
individually to-day u greatly advanced
position on the line 01 the great baltle
Hi' return), and I have behind me, t? > I lowing
my lead, the united republican
parly of this state.
DEMOCRATIC CLAIMS.
I must no\V examine your claim that;
the democratic party is engaged in thei
present canvass in asiiuplestruggle to,
throw oil' the burden of misgovern-j
nieut, and that nil your methods and
agencies are legitimate and peaceful. I
THK "COXSKItVATIVJi" POLICY.
You are aware that the present poli-j
cy of the democratic party in this state |
was earnestly opposed and its adoption :
deeply deplored by a portion of that I
party amounting to nearly a majority,!
and I am aware that that policy is still1
deebly deplored by many of the mem-;
bers of that party. The opponents of j
that policy embraced the leading and
only widely-circulated newspaper iui
the state, the Charleston A'twaand Cvu- j
ricr, as well as a great number of our j
most honored and experienced citi-!
/.ens, in all ranks and occupations of
oursocietv. If I were to call the roll |
of those names I think it would be
i in I In iiiniihi(>B nnil rpnn'ju>nt u vnst!
preponderance of tlitj talent, property,
political experience and breadth of
sentiment and view in our state. The
grounds of their opposition to the policy,
popularly called "the "straight-out"
policy, were dearly defined, and had
exclusive reference to the advancement
of the cause of practical reform in the
state. They knew arid recognized the
fact that the republican party embraced
a majority of at least twenty-live
thousand of the voters of the stme.
They knew and recognized the fact
that the colored race, who constitute
the larger part of the republican voters,
were attached to that party by
ties the strongest wnicn ever govern
men's political actions?the profound
conviction, whether mistaken or not,
that the great boons so recently conferred
on them?freedom and suffrage?were
safe only, in their full!
breadth and beneficence, under the I
protection of the party which had j
conferred them. They believed upon |
evidences too clear to leave room fori
doubt that for this cause no number of
these voters, sullicient to change the
relations of our parties, could be de-j
Inched from the republican party by
argument or legitimate persuasion or
otiier lawful methods of influencing
their political actiou. They recognized
in me one whose republicanism
was original and radical, but whose
course in the practical conductof public
a flairs gave assurance that I had
the true interests of all the people of;
the state as my guiding principle in
public life. Upon these grounds the j
men to whom [ refer counselled a policy
which subordinated the interests
of party to the good of the state.
Their policy contemplated, first, the
acquiescence of the democratic party!
in my nomination by the republican!
party, if that should taUo place, audi
such oilier of the nominees upon the
AtMil.li/Min cfofa J itu lit?:
unexceptionable; and, second, an effort
by all conciliatory and legitimate
means to secure a large minority of
representation for the democratic party
in both houses of the legislature,
and in all local or county officers. In
the May convention of the democratic
party this policy apparenly received
the support of a majority of the
convention. That it ottered the only I
prospect of the removal of the present J
race ami parly lines, ami the establish-;
mentof relations of confidence audi
co-operation in public affairs between j
the two races, was clear then and is j
clearer now.
T1IK "STK Hi I IT-OUT" POLICY. |
Opposed to this policy was the;
' straight-out" policy?the nomina-j
tion of entire democratic state and;
county tickets and the inauguration of
a purely ]>arty struggle. This policy]
was advocated by a class of men, the;
moat conspicuous of whom are well;
known as men of extreme views, with
strong proclivities toward violent1
methods and measures. It was
openly advocated as the "Mississippi
plan," and at the convention which;
adopted it General Furguaon, of Mississippi,
appeared sw} an honored guest
and filled the office of drill master in
the Mississippi tactics. This policy is
properly termed in this state the
"ViliruHelfl11 nnltm; mid whs also call
r ~? / ? - - <
eel by the editor of the Charfcs/onl
lVrwH and Courier the "aliot gun" policy.
Of the pmctfel details of this
policy I shall spiak 'i|tfreafU:r.
The policy was adored In the dem-:
ocratic state convention ia. August,!
and whs followed l*y ttye aoyuiooiiop of]
a full democratic state
apdoted under influences and $uspi-t
ces, it was advocated by arguments?, It f
has been curried out by methods audi
measures so exclusively and entirely;
partisan as to deprive the present dem-j
occulta canvass of all just ctaims to he|
what you claim for it?"the struggle
of the while people of South Carolina
to cast oil' a burthen of corruption and j
wrong;" and to warrant me in declar-j
ing it to be a struggle by the democrat- j
in party of .South Carolina to >rain po- j
litical control of the stale for the nuke;
r?f partisan power and advantage.'
The men who looked exclusively to!
reform, the argument which promised
the attainment of practical reform, J
the methods which arc warranted by a:
desire for the public good, all were op-'
posed to this policy. In saying this It
tun regarding the facts of the case1
without any reference to myself. Tliei
the democratic party of South Caroli-j
na were under no political obligation i
to me, but if the wish to have their,
present claim respected?that they are
moved by non-partisan motives inj
[.heir present course?they were under)
obligation to adopt a policy which did j
not, as does their present policy, array \
race against race and party against
party in a fierce struggle for political j
mastery.
DKMOCIt.VTIC "PEACEFUL." AGENCIES. !
I
I come now to your claim that inj
[lie present canvass all the methods
iiml agencies employed by the demo-!
eratic party are peaceful, orderly and!
rtithiu the law. Jn your communi-j
nation you especially assure me that if j
r accept your invitation "my appear-j
nice before the democracy throughout!
the state will be to me as governor a!
most pleasing refutation of the slanJerouscharges
which are constantly
published against your party." My
knowledge of the serious cast of your j
character forbids me to think tlmt you j
lire indulging in conscious satire or!
badinage in giving nie this assurance.;
Without expressing any doubt of thej
L;ood faitii of your present assurance, J!
I'ear that yourexpcrience in attending!
repuhiieau meetings has been wi'dely I
ilineient from mine in republican'
meetings where your parly have at-!
tended and.dcmamlcd an equal hear-!
ing. I shall. therefore, first call youn
attention to my personal experience in ;
this respect.
As I have already stated, during the!
months of July and August I made aj
canvass of a number of the counties ofi
the state. The object of this canvass, j
which was conducted almost wholly j
under my own auspices, was, first I lie t
advocacy of the election of llnyes and
Wheeler, and, scc:>nd, and more t spe-;
L'ially, a defense of my own course ?governor
and an appeal lo the republi
:*an party to stand by the cause of reform
in the coming state convention.
It was not a general party canvass
under party auspices. The meetings
ivere called at my request or suggestion
ind for the purpose of hearing ine up>n
the question chiefly of a-fomi in
the state. '
MEETING AT AIMJKVI M.E.
At thedate of the Newberry meeting
1 was undcrengafiemcnt to address
i similar republican nteeiiiijur at Abbe-i
v.*i11 e court house on the?2dof August.'
Dn tlie return of Judge lloge and M r.
lillson frotu Newberry on the 1Mb of
August, they .strongly advised Ihe
ibaudonnient of the meeting; at Abbeville
in view of their experience at
Newberry, and especially on account
>f a violent and threatening harangue,
nade at the depot at Newberry on t In?
innitninir nl' tlwi (n 11 Imilll <?f his '
miliums, by Colonel J). \Vyatt Aiken. j,
L replied that I .should keep my en-;
jagement at Abbeville from a sense ofi|
niperative duty to my republican ;i
'riendH there. Unwilling to allow mej
ogoalone, these gentlemen gallantly;
onsented to accompany me on the 21st J1
o Abbeville court house. "Onarriving jj
it Abbeville, I found our republican i
"riends, as at Newberry, firmly eon- j
zinced that if we held our meeting, ,
irudence would compel us to allow i
the democrats to occupy half the time,
mid even tlieu they were greatly apprehensive
of trouble. An arrangement
was accordingly entered into Ly
which three speaker* from each party
were to take part in the meeting, Ai
the hour appointed we proceeded to the
phice of meeting where we found the
republicans assembled, after the manner
of ordinary political meetings.
As soon, however, as the republicans;
were assembled, companies of moun-j
ted white men, marching in martial!
order, and under the command of
officers or persons who gave orders
which were obeyed, began to pour over
41... l.tll i,f 11, > ofoml nrnl fnl
IJIl.' lllll 111 UIMIK WA UiC ^k(VUl? MUM ww,
take their places* at the meeting. At I
this* time L s#at beside (Joneral MoGow-j
an, and we agreed in onrestimate that!
there were from eight hundred to onCj
tiionsand mounted white men present, i
They came, as 1 know, from Edgefield
county, and as I was informed, from;
Newberry, Anderson and Laurens*!
counties, as well jus from Abbeville |
county. When fully assembled they
covered more than one-half the space}
around the stand, besides entirely eu-|
circling the whole meeting with J
mouuteh men. I spoke first. In the)
course of my speech, 1W response toi
loud and repented cries from the white}
men, "how about Hamburg"? "Tell
us about Hamburg," I replied, "yea, T,
will teii you about Hamburg," where-j
upon 1 saw a sudden crowding to-,
wards tbestaud by the mounted white'
men on my right, and heard distinct-j
ly the click of a considerable number'
--' i,. 1 fvilnnoli
Ill A n?o iwiumicu ujr v/utwuvi
D. Vyatt Aiken in a speech filled to j
overflowing with the spirit of intoler-j
anee and violence. With his tbou-j
.sand mounted and armed partisans
cheering him on, he shouted to the five i
or six hundred colored republicans "if
you want war you can have it?yes,
war to llie knife, ami the knife to 'the
hilt." With a thousand armed white
men drinking in his words, lie singled
out one colored man in the crowd for
special personal denunciation. Turning
to me he charged me personally!
with complicity in sending arms clandestinely
to' Newberry to arm the
blacks against the whites, with abso-!
lute falsehoods in relation to the Ham-:
bury massacre and the calling for,
United Htates troops, and declared
over and over that the white leaders,
must be held personally responsible
for all future misgovernnient by the I
republican party. Later in the day'
Mr. Jillson while speaking was so!
greatly interrupted by the white men!
that he was unable to make a connec-i
ted speech or to pursue his intended;
line of argument. After the meeting'
was closed, and while the colored re-1
publicans were carrying a United1
.Slates llag past the public square in the
village, an ellbrt was made by a parly j
of mounted white men to snatch it
from them, fifteen or twenty pistols
were discharged in the air, and a gen-,
era! riot was thereby made imminent.,
IIKMOCKATII' . ISIKMi C'M*Its.
I next call your attention to another statej
of lads licsiriiif,' upon your claim Hint the
nrescnt democratic canvass is condnclcil liy
agencies which are peaceful ami within tlie
In w. I refer now to the armed or^on Iza- i
tions which no under Hie mimes of "ririe
clubs," "satire clubs" and "artillery clubs."1
of the exact extent of those organ izatious,
your information is doubtless much more1
iingile than mine; hut 1 think I am warranti-il
in sayins that such organizations exist in
every county ill the stale, ami I hat in many,
if uol moM.nt the counties they embrace a
lame majority of the white men between the
ordinary limits of nan for military duty, as ;
well as a large numtier hotli below and above
such limits. That these organizations are'
armed, oflicered, drilled to 11 considerable ex- i
lent al least iu the manual and military!
movements appropriate to the clmracier of!
liieirarms and organizations, and obey the!
orders of their olHcers, is clear In many rases,
and is |>.obably true in all cases. That I hey
have appeared in public on a numbcrol' oeca; '
moms in various parts of the stale, ami recently
here in ('olumbia, with their arms and uuiier
command of theirotlicers, is well known.!
I hat thej serve as the basis of political or-j
gatiizai ion, and under the command
and control of their olfieers engage
in political duties and work, is equally
ccar. In fact, a leading feature ofi
i'ho present democratle slate canvass is the
constant attendance upon the democratic,
meetings of these clubs, aciinsj in their or-,
piuized character nml capacity, iu no in-,
staticeof such ciubs organized since iJecember
I, l>7t, has authority for tiieir formation
or existence been given by the governor, nor
iil'i? liny siii-!i omani/anons reporieu m miii
nlllcially in* in any munnei auihori/.cd or rccofinlaed
l?y him as lonum# any pail of the
military loree of the stale. The existence ol';
a few military clubs organized for professcdly
social purposes. many luolilii.s since, was
ligntlc known to tjie ^i?*t.'rnor; hut ??dde from 1
those eases (lie whole system of military or- {
gatiixaiiou now referred to has no oitlcial J
nuclei ion or recognition from the goveriior
of the stale. So Ions; as these Organizations
retained t heir character as social
ciuiis little importance was naturally ut-|
l:icln?(l to tlie ?|lteslloll of their legality, lie-1
eentainl present events, however, ami the
use now made ol these organ i?.nlioas as a I
|iromincnt agency in the democratic canvass,!
jiive jiuhlic Importance to their character. |
i". IfiJ^TA?CE.S Of ACT I.' A I. VtOt.KNCK. |
i proceed dow to direct your intention to
dwVrfcciH'es in our s.uto which
mave tin.* pK'seni. canvass, mid
CPfieclftily tojv* clnilii tli!il all your nielli'cxl*
are peaceiui, o)'.U;rIy and wiiiiin the law.
t U E II ATffftTTRM JlA.ViACKK.
Tne massacre at flamhurt; occurred July S, I
u month prior to I no opening ol the demo .
entile canvass. I will state some oi the undisputed
lacts of this massacre. Those w ho
committed the massacre were while demo-i
ciats; those who were massacred were color- |
cd republicans. fussing over all that occur- |
led hciere I lie lime when resistance or show!
oi resistance to the while democrats had j
ceased. 11 is a laet, us well itulliciiltcalfd iiml
undeniable ns the assassination o. !' t;>itlonl?'
Lincoln, that live unarmed republicans. |
while lielil as captives by u huge body 01 i
armed white democrats, were deliberately t
and wantonly Khot to death by their white
ocmocrulic ^e.i|.'ois. 11' lliu facts of he rioti
uereailiiiillt.il to show that both pailics!
were e?|iial!y responsible lor Its origin a ml;
ei|iially engaged lu its progress from beginning
to enii, the uniid|>Cacli;ii>Sc laet would j
remain thill tlvc colored repuljlleans, alter
tne riot was cmled. were butchered by a ham! j
of whitedemocrats. intention uud motive,
w In n not expressed in language, liiusi bejudged
of hy acisaud circumstances. Applying
this tot to the Hamburg massacre, toe
conclusion seems to he that color mid political
pariy hail mttch to do in prompting the
massacre, it Is significant, too, tliut the mas-'
sane occur red in ti see t ton of our State in;
winch tiie present "straighi-oui" deuiociaticlanvass
took its rise,and where it lountl its !
inosi elllcient promoters in all its eat'lcr!
rtai.es. 11 is in vain to seek to evade liteju>i'
it mi awful responsibility lor these municr* ny <
nsMMimi? that i bo colored republicans iu,
llauibiiig bad mallreateil, iiisttlleil ami exits J
perilled liie white democrats beyond cmlurance.
if this be concoilcd, the fact remains tlmi
the live colored icptiblieinis who were uiiiehcred,
together wtin their companions, were!
completely overcome and in the complete
riisloiiy of the w tnie dciuoerats who biuclieicillneni.
One ot your democratic oiaio-s!
has sought lo cover this vast mine with the
pteaol Air. fitirke for the Ante a an cotoui.sis [
?"1 pardon something to the spirit of i iuct - [
iy.?' l-stil the Auierican colonists necilcd inn
atlvocate to ae<|ttii lliem of wholesalu mm - !
dels, nordidiMr. littrko stilly his lips uuli|
ltie atrocious pica thai win.ion butchery ofi
unresist lug prisoners con id bo condoned in '
the name ot libcriy.
T11K CIIAIU.KsTON ItlOT.
On the niubt of .September titli n notoeetirretl
in the elly ol l.'harlesiou. 'i iit? most trust- I
wortliy inioiinntion seems lo fix flic chief!
responsibility lor causing this riot upon the)
republicans. Jei'taluly such is my present
tiei|ei. The riot continued for some hours,
iiiulgreatly endangered the livss, ane proper
ly of the cil izciis ol ( hnrlcMnn. J I. *ns in-,
excusable and it isitracciiil. Jitil it was sub-;
tilled by the republican nulhoritie-s. It was'
attended by no slaughter; it was followed!
by no butchery, li is now, as I am credibly i
informed, an open secret that (lie one man j
whodicd from wounds roceivcd in Ibis not;
tit fijlI t'll Mtv III>U\IIIK uu ini'ii.KM mttv <>^ . v,
reived his woiimi Iroin u iin-dirccteii shot)
roin tiic jdsioi i>r u ileiiincriilii: friend, amitlmi
the single policeman who was wounded,
Miiivivd I on i liie mi mi: cause. Tlii! rioi was!
i he result oi hifcil ]ioi11iesll excitement' and
was an exhibition oi the dasiariiiy spirit ui j
]><>ti11c:iI intolerance. It lias laHleiieU a!
nioody blot ihat caused it.
THE KM,KNTON lUOT.
Anil now coiiltiisiim; the ineunidH ami cirrutiisiauccs
and result* of I his riot wiiti the
llaiiil'iu'K liol, I a*lc your attention to a
mittc recent occurrence whleli is called the
Kl lemon I lot. Though litis noi oceurreil:
ehietly oil the Hull oi September ahd luo ui'ee j
or lour days foliowintj, u has been >id!> >?? > ?>
u|? lo 1 lie*prc>cul Li nits to obtain a iii't mull
i i-itiUTicil report ol its orit ui mid ror sc.
i i i i.tin ^enc a I facts and some spc-udc dcia-s 1
a i*. imwi'vi' . known. Ilsoii.-in was an si*- j
- miii uyoii a w nut! woman in iiie course of mi
.. t in pied i oboe y other house hy two lie-'
1.1 i.t ?. l ine of liie alleged lonueis w as in rc??
I. and wlillii In the custody of ins cap to s[
vi,.- Mini. Out of these occurrences grew iue
iioi. hi the conduct of theeolored peoplsen
auediu or conneeteil with the riot, 1 will;
iioi >iH ak w illi conluleiice, lest my present j
imoimai aiii suoilld be loll ml to (ilve a too fa- |
Miiabie acciiiini. It is certain that n lorceof.
aimed whin; men was speedily iisst-mtiled j
i tin the miirounding country l'roiu h Ui.vj
nunc of Ihii iy miles and more.
iin the iMhaiid IMtli this force amounted to j
noi ir-s than six or cij;hL hundred luen, uM j
n ineil. under i.il.cers, company niiil nenera*. I
but assembled by no lawiiil authority, ami!
act i n;t li ml er no ui Willi ordes. On (lie niorii-1
in-ii, (lie llltli the arrival upon the scene of!
a ruiiip.iiiy of t'niled Slates troops c.iescii '
liie dispei'sim; i,I these rioters. '1 ne ie?u'n!
of I Ins riot are slated hy General Jcuiis.m j
ila^ood. one of the nominees on your state;
1 < !? 1*1. to I'f two Willie men llllll UIIIIUI III \
mio-ed nun killed. My oilier informal oil
reduces tin' while turn killed to one, unit lit- ,
creases ilie 11inu'n*r of colored men killed io|
Ibrty or til'ty. That. nearly nil the colored j
men killed were not killed while resisting the i
r.xccution of the law or any legal process, or!
while violating tlie peace or threatening or |
,il tempting any violence, isn fact established
l?y clear proof. They were shot down wner-'
ever found; Iti Ileitis ami woods, oil highways I
iiml in cjibins, along the railroad truck and at 1
Ihe railroad stations.
J give you an account of (lie murder of Simon
P. Cokcr, a member of the present legislature
and u delegate to tite ruecnt. republican
uonventlon in Columbia, as related to me by
[in Intelligent a ,d trustworthy eye-witness of
Lhe sccne, a person well known to me personully.
While sitting In the car of the railroad
train at Kllenton, on the ll'th ultimo, my inrormunt
saw Colter walking unarmed in company
v illi several armed while men. O'ker's
manner Indicated that he <l!il not consider
himself a prisoner or in danger, as lie was
talking freely with the white men who aeeoni|>anlcd
hlin. Cokerand tliose who accompanied
him proceeded to a piazza in front
of a store at Kllenton .station and sat down
for a few moments, but soon proceeded to a
large tree standing about thirty rods from the
spot where my intorinnnt stood, Coker still
appearing unconcerned. While standing under
this tree the white men suddenly stepped
away from Coker about six paces, and. turning
tired a volley Into his body. He Instantly
fell, whereupon several of the party advanced
towards his body and tired upon It a second
time. My Informant also meniiorntas a fact
that he saw N. A. Patterson, a democratic
trial Justice of Barnwell county;-walking in
company with Coker at Kllenton station at
the time first abovestated. Coker, It now appears,
had been enticed from his home to Kllenton
upon some false pretense of a Bum-1
mons to answer a criminal charge.
The killing of colored people in connection j
with tlie Kllenton riot extended far and wide,
ami was kept up for several days, in truili. I
my information leads me to believe that it j
cannot be said to have ceased now. Persons!
living in the vicinities named vouch to ine j
personally for the truth of t hc?e, among I
many other, instances of murders of colored
men in liarnwell comity,growing out of the
Kllenton riot.
On the "-Mill of .September several colored
men were picking cotton near Klko, among
whom were two refugees from the vicinity of
Klltmlon. Kight or ten whlto men rode into
the Held and nred< upon these refugees, killing
one and wounding the other. The dead
Dixijr was currieu uiiu iiiruwu into it swamp,
whcro U wiw found on the 2-Hli by Trial .justice
lilaek.of JVlucltville.and Captain Kcuslu,
of the United States garrison at Uiackvjlle.
On the night of the 21th, n party of white
men vii>i tea the house or u colored man about i
seven miles from Hlackvillc, and took out a
colored man who was :i refugee Mom near
Kllenton. This refugee hits not been seen or;
iieurd of since.
Uu Sunday, .September 21th, two colored
men escaping from the vicinity of Kllenton
passed a church near Allendale while the
white people were ut church. They were pursued
by white men from the church, and
overtaken ut the cabin of a colored man ut
early evening. One was shot and died of his
wounds at 'J o'clock that night,|and tho other,
though wounded, escaped.
These are but. few of the"outrages which I
fully believe havebeen committed by white
democrats, members of the democratic rifle
clubs, upon colored republicans In i.'arnwe.ll
county alone. More than forty colored and
white refugees arc reported to me as under
the protection of the United States troops In
their camp at lilackville at this time,
I present these facts to you as a portion of
the evidence now In my hands and within
my knowledge, which refutes your claim that
t he methods and agencies now employed by
the democratic party arc peaceful, orderly
and within the law.
The present armed organizations which
constitute the effective force of the democratic
party, as well as its chief agency in Its canvass,are
manifestly a menace to thepeacc of
the state and the rights of the members of
tho republican party, because those organizations
arc unlawful in their origin, unlawful
in their aims, and aggressive and law-bmiking
in their conduct.
DKMOCRATIO ,,PROTKf,TIOJ?\"
I come now to your demand that If I believe
that lawlessness and terrorism prevail in the
state I should call upon you ami your party
to suppress it, before I appeal to the government
of the United Stales. I am familiar
wltli tills demand. I have beard it here and
have heard It abroad. It is made the occasion
of constant reproach that I am governor of
the state and yet cannot and do not preserve
the public peace. fieneral Hampton and his
followers arc seek ing to profit politically by
uttering this reproach and declaring their
easy ability to maintain tiie pe:tce of the
state. I shall answer your demand with perfect
plainness of speech. The reason I cannot
ami do not maintain me pcaeo t?i me state
ami suppress lawlessness ami prevent terrorism,
is solely, because the democratic party
art? tlie authors of the disturbances of the
peace, the lawlessness and terrorism which
tliey now reproach me with and demand that
I shall allow or Invite them to suppress. (|ul
eusiodes custodier ?
To entrust the protection oftho?e who are
to-day endangered l>y the present disturbances
to the armed, mounted, unlawful,
democratic rifle clubs, would, in my sober
judgment, be as unnatural nml unfaithful in
me as to sot kites to watch doves, or wolves
to guard sheep.
Actual lawlessness Is, In my Judgment, and
upon the evidence before me. prevalent today
in several counties and sections of the
state,and I believe, upon tlie best attainable
evidence, that It has already resulted In the
killing of from forty to fifty defenseless and
unresisting republican voters. Terrorism, resulting
from lawlessness and violence, extends
far more widely; nnd in support of this
statement, I repeat here the remark made to
me two days since by a white democrat who
had crossed the country from t lie vicinity of
nubbins' station, throiiirli Harnwell county to
I'.lack well, that "he did not see a 'nigger'
man anywhere." Hut when. In view of this
la wlessness and terrorism,you and vourasso*
elates mock me with the demand to nut it
down by calling 011 the white armed democrats
who arc the authors of it. I answer that
you are welcome to the political advantage
such a demand may give you, but I shall
yield to no such demand so long as I hold the
o lice of governor.
Von know, as 1 know, that the republican
voters of t his state are not organized for successful
resistance to the Regressions of the
democraticrirte clubs. You know.as I know,
liutl to call ution the colored republicans
niunr iu ^ii|?|'i v.^s? in in i4v? Hint iui I ??i - .
Ism would hn to Invite or precipitate n eon-|
tlict. the result of which would he to Increase, I
ruther than suppress, the lawlessness and terrorism
which now exist. In such an emergency
my only reliance tor effective physical
force must he upon United States troops. I
have struirgled long and hard to avoid a resort
to this agency. I have hoped against
hope llmt a sober second thought would come
to those who govern the democratic, party
strong enough and Just enough to relieve ni*e
from the necessity of action which must indict
great temporary injury upon the material
Interests of the state. Rut I nm invented
with large and extraordinary powers hy the
laws of the Ktatw to meet extraordinary emergencies.
The executive of the United States will do
Ills duty, and 1 shall do mine; and It shall be
seen by the world whether the right to a
peaceful and free ballot by the citizens of this
state, conferred and made inviolable by the
constitution and laws of state and nation
alike can be trampled underfoot by any combination
or party of men in this state. The
people of this suite know that I am not a
rash or unjust man, t lint I am tender of every
private and public interest and right; but
they know also that I am accustomed to doiug'my
duty, without haste but without fear.
I have doubtless wearied you, sir?I certainly
have wearied myself?in setting forth
the various matters which were essential to
my reply to your communication. The statements
of facts herein made all rest upon actual
evidence now before me, the sources of
which I should have here stated if I had not
been compelled, In order to secure the evidence,
to given solemn promise. In many instances.
not to make known the sources.
In conclusion, 1 have only to renew my
Acknowledgements for the resneclfnl form of
your communication, nnd to express tlu* hope1
Hint I lmve followed your example in that regard.
and that the pence nnrl prosperity "of]
South enrol Inn niny l>e speedily restored and i
perpetually maintained.
I nave the honor to he, very respcetftilly, |
your obedient servant.
I>. It. CHAMBER LA IX,
Governor of South Carolina.
Mm to tie People of tie Unitefl
Mi.
CHAMBERLAIN'S PROCLAMATION!
NUL AND VOID.
The Saddle od the WroDg Horse.
The Shot Rebounds to Strike thej
Shooter's Heart.
Republican Judges to the Rescue--j
South Carolina's Fair Fame Vin- j
dicated --Constitution on the
Side of the Rifle Clubs.
1TE A D Q U A RT12 RS
State Dem. Ex. Committer,
Columbia, S. C., Oct. 7, 187(J.
To the People of the United State*:
Jn a period of profound peace,
wilh the laws unresisted, and the
process of the courts unopposed,
the Governor of South Carolina!
has by proclamation declared that!
in ilie Counties of Aiken and Barnwell
it has become impracticable to '
enforce by the ordinary course of
judicial proceeding tho laws of the '
State, and that it has become nee- j
eflsaiy for him as Governor "to call
forth and employ tho military force
of the State 10 enforce the execution
of tho law." He has also al- j
leged that certain combinations exist
contrary to law in all tho Counties
of the Slate, which are engaged j
in promoting illegal objections and
in committing open acts of lawless- ,
no?s and violence, and ho has '
threatened to declare martial law
and to suspend the writ of habeas
corpus.
The charges preferred by Governor
Chamberlain against the citizens j
of tha State are as false and libel- (
ouh as his threatened usurpation is
tyranica 1 and unwarranted ; and
his extraordinary proclamation can
be explained only upon tho asstimp- i
lion that Governor Chamberlain,
wilh a similar disregard of law and
fact, is determined to resort to the \
most extreme measures to prevent (
the otherwise certain defeat of him
self utid his corrupt party. \
There have been disturbances in
Aiken County, non-political in their
character. They have long since
ceased. All the parties 1'or whom (
warrants w^re issued havo prompt- |
ly surrendered Ihemselves to the'i
law. Perfect peaco and the pro- (
loundest quiet prevail. 2so armed J
combinations hinder tho processes ]
of the courts, and tho Republican |
County Convention last week held i
a continuous pcssion of two day* I
without molestation. The distilr- I
buncos in Barnwell werojRcpubliean <
in their origin, beginning in tho resiotance,
by an armed band of ne- I
groes, of tho arrest of a robber for l
whom a warrant had been duly is- I
sued. The band toro up a railroad, i
wrecked d train, fired upon and
wounded tho Sheriff of the County,
and wero dispersed by a so-ealU 1
i%/l anma/1 a(' irki'tao tir a Knrl 1
CU ill 11J CU UillIU ui ** UV/ IIUU \
been summoned by tho Sheriff as a <
posse, with the sanction of the i
Jmlgo of tho Court then In session. ;
This posse after performing their I
dut'es quietlj' dispersed. So far
from opposing the law, tho whole <
pcoplo desire the prompt despatch. <
of business in tho courts, and the I
enforcement of tho law by tho civil I
arm.
The white people throughout the |
State have volunteered their ser- !
vices to tho Governor to maintain I
the law, and he has refused them in I
a libellous communication, intended i
solely to furnish a pretext for yie j
introduction pf Federal troops, to i
be placed under tho control of irre
sponsible and unscrupulous officials, i
to overawe the people and control '
the election. J
The Democratic nominees in sev- i
enteen of tho thirty-two Comities in
the State have held meetings, attended
by thousands of citizens of t
both races and parties. Tho Republicans
have held meetings when and
where they pleased, and not a singloactof
violence has vet occurred. 1
On tho 18th ultimo, tho Democratic
Executive Committee invited the
Republican canvassers :o a joint discussion
at their meetings. The invitation
was renewed on tho 28th
ultimo, and accepted by the Republican
Executive Committee on he
5th instant, upon tho usual torms.
The proclamation of the Governor
is utterly at variance with the action
of the ExecutivoCommitt.ee of
his own party. Tho latter acquiesces
in free discussion. Tho former
in effect suppresses debate and
substitutes" armed forco for free
r?|jv-ci:u.
We assort earnestly. with ft full
sense of our responsibility, that no
condition of things exists in the
State which justifies ho extraordinary
a proceeding on the part of Governor
Chamberlain. Its solo object
is to irritate and provoke collisions,
which may bo the excuse for an appeal
to tho administration of the
United States to garrison the Stale.
in L..II 1.^
>y e rsuuii ciiuiioti vui ptuj/ic tv juwserve
the peace, obey tho laws and
calmly await tho day of their deli
veraiicofrpm this wanton despotism.
To tho people of tho United"
States we submit our wrongs, confidently
relying on their wisdom and
justice to rebuko this daring attempt
to regulate the ballot by the
bayonet and crush the liberties of a
people.
A. C. HASKELL,
T. B. FttASER .
JOHN URATTON,
J. D. KENNEDY,
J. A. UOYT.
11. O'NEALE. Jr..
State Democratic Executive
Committee.
General Hampton to the Supreme
Court Judges.
Sumter, October 7.
Dear Sir: In view of the grave
charges mado by Governor Chamberlain
against the Democratic parly
and their mode of conducting
tlio present canvass in ms leuer 10
Colonel Haskell, charges declaring
that the Slate is an armed camp
and that our meetings are attended
hy organized armed bodies, may 1
ask yon as a Republican and as the
Chief Jnstice of the State, to say il
in your observation these churges
aro borne out by I ho facts of the
case]? You saw to-day one Hof the
largest meetings wo have held, and
you can, thcreforo speak from experience
and personal observation,
i havo been through seventeen of
the counties of the State and I have
addressed. I am euro, at least one
hundred thousand people, and can
say with perfect truth, that I have
not seen one single armed?body of
men, nor has any disturbance occurred
at one of these vast meetings.
My solicitude for the good name
of our State, will, I trust, be a sufficient
excuse for my calling your attention
to this matter. " .Requesting
an early answer.
I am. very respectfully.
Your obedient servant.
WADE HAMPTON.
To Ilis Hon. F. J -Moses,
Chief Justice.
repi.y ot chief justice moses.
Sumter, S. C., October 7, 76.
My Dear Sir: I am just in receipt
of your note and at once reply
to the same. For the last three or
four months I have not been in any
of the Counties but thoseof Sumter
and Richland. Within that period
I have been present at only two p<>-<
.'itical meeti- gs?one held by the Jie-I
publiean party and the other to-day 1
at this place by the Democrats.
Although I was at the latter but a '
short lime, I was for the greater
part of the day in the streets, with
every opportunity of observing the
behavior and demeanor of the large '
concouise which the occasion had 1
brought together. The collection 1
consisted of citizens on foot and
horseback. I saw in no instance 1
iioy exhibition of arms or any bo- 1
liavior inconsistent with the strictest <
propriety. At the Republican i
meeting to which 1 have abovo referred,
there whs no attempt at interruption.
1
I shall require very strong evi-('
Jence to satisfy me that South C'aro- !
lina is an armed camp. I Icnowj1
nothing which would lead mo so to I
conclude. For myself 1 do notj
know of anything which would |
make me doubtful in any partof the!
:>tate of enjoying the same security!
which I feci attached to mo under j
my own roof. |;
I trust tho day is far distant ]
ivhen violations of the peace in ouri1
jwn borders will require the inter-;1
t'cTcneeof any arm more potont than |!
Lhat of th? law. i1
Very respectfully yours, , t
1\ J. MOSES. If
;i
1eit.y of associate justice wil- [
la tin. I ]
In reply to letters from A. C. i
Haskell, Chairman of tho Demo-1
. ratic Ex'tivc Committeo, Associate
Fustiec Willard, * .Republican, of the
Supremo Court, writes: J.
"Columbia, o. u., Uctoucr <, lb?t?.; j
To Col. A. C. JfanJcr/l: { i
J)eaii Sir?Your note of this:'
late is beforo me, asking an cx-:'
iression of my views as to the ex-!I
stance of rancor and manifestations;',
jf violence in the character of the 11
Democratic canvass of this Slate. <
[ am unable to throw much light en!'
Lhis subject, for two reasons. In J'
Lhe first place, I havo boen absent^
1
from the State for tho last three m
months, and only a week has pass- H
id since my return to this city. 9
In the second placo, my ideas of H
the character and responsibilities of H
.he judicial office, have led mo at ail
Limes, to abstain from participating H
in political action, and accordingly B
I have little information, except flj
that derived from pnblic rumor and HE
;he newspapers, of what has trans- H
? ..ndinninirt T ran
pireu at pojuiiui KUbiiww..^.,
jnly say that I have witnessed H
nothing beyond the circumstances H
;cnerally characteristic of an cxci- 9
:ed political canvim flfl
I have seen no violence. On tho fl
contrary, as far as I have had interjourxe
with gentlemen'of your par- H
fcy, I have observed Jess disposition H
to excited statement and personal BE
bittemoss, than, during any of tho H
previous political campaigns'of this H
State. I sincerely hope that tho H
fears of many, that the lawless por- B
:ion of the community will bo por- H
mi tied to disturb the poaee and in- H
are tho good name- of. tho State, H
ire groundless. . H
I am satisfied that it is the inten- H
tionof the leading men of yonr par- H
ty to prevent sncli a state of things, H
iud I believe they-hovo the ability H
to do so. H
V'.'vy rcspcctfully, your obd't sy't, H
A, J. WILLARD.
reply Of CfttCUJT Jl'pge T. J. BB
MAC]i?T E
Circuit Jndge T. J. itackcy (Hop.) D
telegraphs as follows;. B
Ouesteu S, C., October 7. H
To A. C. Hazkeli, Chairman Stato 96
Democratic Committee, Columbia,', S, B
In reply to your Inquiry of this
date, I would state tlm.t peaco and
order prevail thronghout tho limits
of the Sixth Judicial Circuit, embracing
the ftmr counties "of York,
Chester, Fairfield and JjUncastcr.
In this Circuit no armed organic
zalions obstruct judicial proceedings,
and no resistance has been of-.
Sored to the due execution of legal
processes.
In charging the Grand Jury at
York on last Monday, I stated that
if any citizen, whatever might ho
his race, color, or party, had boon
threatened with loss of employ*
meat, or put in terror, becaunO of
his political opinions, he should
make complaint before the .Grand
Jury, or in open Court, and the law
whonld be putin motion to sustain
him in the free and untrammelled
exercise of all his rights of citizenship
The grand jury, consisting oi
nine white and six colored citizens,
reported unanimously on last
Wednesday night that no organizations,
either armed or otherwise,
having for their object the exhibition
of force to control tho free
cxerciso of the elective franchise,
existed in that country, and no complaint
charging tho existence of
such organizations had been made
to them.
Tho same is true of each and cv
? ? * - !i. / I ^
ery county in mis circuit, mo only
cone of political intimidation that lias
transpired in this ?H*<*nit was
tried at York on last Thargdaj*, tlio
defendant being one Edw. AltvDonald,
charged with threatening tho
life of ono llenfy Lowry, also colored,
because ho had joined u Democratic
club, and had declared his
purpose to voto the Democratic
ticket.
The jury consisted of six Republican
colored citizens and six whilo
men, one of whom is also an avowed
Republican. The piisoner was
ably defended by W. B. Williams,
Esq., himself a candidate on tho
Democratic ticket. The jury were
charged by me that they were the
solo judges of the evidence, and
that the guilt of the prisoner must
be established beyond a reasonable
doubt to warrant i conviction,
They rendered a verdict of guilty,
and I sentenced tho prisoner to
three months in jail?tho lowest
penalty prescribed by law for tho i
offense. I have traversed n?ony
Counties in tho Stute canvassing for
Hayes and Wheeler, and in favor of
Chamberlain for Governor, during
tho past sixty days, and I have nowhere
seen an attempt on the part
:>f any portion of tne population to
suppress the sight of free speoch b.C
armed violence. I solemnly protest
against 'he proclamation of Governor
Chamberlain as absolutely
false, in so far as it imputes to tiio
inhabitants within tbo limits of this
Circuit any purpose to obstruct tho
ordinary course of judicial proceedings
or to resist in any.manner tho
duo execution of tho laws for lho
protection of life, property or tho
rights of citizenship ; and I havo
good and sufficient reasons to believe
and do believe that the sni<l
proclamation is equally-false, in imputing
such insurreetiona. y pu?*p.?so
to tho whilo population in the other
circuits of this State I regard the
proclamation as symbolizing fitly a
I'oxmiilnliln r<Anunipiif>r itirni list. flin
rights of the people having for its
object the carrying of this State for
L). II. Clxwnberlain and his candi<irites,
which conspiracy is further
typified by a Board of State; Canvassers,
or Election iJutnrri.ing
Board, the majoritjr o'** whose members
are candidates on Governor
Chamberlain'? ticket and by ninetysix
Commissioners/of Election in
the several Counties, seventy of
whom are Chamberlain's declared
partisans, and of .which hist number
some forty afr? County Treasurers
and Auditors or Triftl Justices, holding
lucrative offices'' by his appointment,
and removable from otlice at
his pleasuro or aro known to him as
declared candidates for office endors
ing his ticket* who unseat themselves
if they make a declaration of
tho election which seats the candidates
opposed to Chamberlain and
his ticket. The rifle clubs that ho
has ordered disbanded are in tho
main organizations chartered under
the Act of the Republican Legislature
in 1S74, and all of them aro
acting but in the assertion of tho
right of tho peoplo to keep and
uear arms, guaranteed against infringement
in tho second article of
intendment to the Constitution of
.ho United States, and all assert
,heir loyalty to the Union, and obclience
to its laws, and respect and
iphold the flag.
T. J. MACKEV.
fudgo of the Sixth Judicial Circuit
ot South Carolina.
Grand !>? .? at the Centennial.
Philadelphia, Octobers.?It is proposed
to conclude the State day observ
all the Governors of the States and
rerritories on the 10th of November or
lpon a later day at which the outgoing
uid incoming Presidents of the United
states will be present. Arrangements
are in contemplation for combining
the State of \ irginia with that
if Maryland on the 19th inst, the day
i>f the grand national tournament.
Accommodations for seating 100,000
persons will hn provided within tiio
grounds near George's llill.