The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, January 14, 2005, Page 8, Image 8
wusc
DESK
ttnSiSUH ;
m83
Before the Dawn Heals Us (Mute)
Generally, I do not take the time to lambaste albums.
I’d rather spend my time singing praises than decrying
faults. Reviewing should be positively-charged instead
of geared towards destruction. But never before have I
felt such a profound, unavoidable disappointment as
that which came with hearing M83’s sophomore album,
“Before the Dawn Heals Us.” Indeed, the album title
seems to allude to better days ahead, but it is difficult to
find a single silver lining surrounding this incredibly
tragic folly of a record.
It’s truly saddening to witness genius wane before
your very ears, but compared with their debut, “Dead
Cities, Red Seas, and Lost Ghosts”, this new effort fails
on virtually every front.
M83’s debut garnered heaps of critical acclaim as
one of 2003’s best albums. It even justified the creation
of a new genre called “screen-gaze,” which draws from
My Bloody Valentine’s relentless waves of sound but
incorporates a new electronic/synthesizer-based
element.
Like My Bloody Valentine’s classic “Loveless,” this
French duo’s first batch of songs were as comforting as
they were disquieting, like a welcomed punch in the gut.
That record truly conjured a virtually unparalleled sense
of beauty and wonderment.
Swirling synthesizers and ambient guitars evoked the
splendor of gazing upon the majestic sight of an
untouched glacier. Highly dramatic yet entirely
substantial, the music of “Dead Cities” created a highly
cinematic landscape through sound.
So it is with a great sadness and heavy heart that I
declare this new album one of the greatest misfires in
indie-rock history.
An easy scapegoat would be the addition of organic
vocals to nearly every song. In fact, much of the singing
sounds like the worst moments of Journey. I assume the
group was not comfortable enough with the quality of
their instrumentals to leave well-enough alone.
Previously, their songs had exuded the power that
only the best instrumentals should exhibit — the ability
to craft a mood and elicit an emotional response without
the use of words to construct meaning.
Granted, the decision to employ vocals is the main
culprit in this album’s downfall, but to blame that alone
would be unfair.
The songs on “Before the Dawn Heals Us” are poorly
structured, and the album suffers from the same forced,
scatterbrained organization. The infuriating stop-start |
routine of the track simply denoted by a “*” will drive
fans out of their minds.
Celestial, quiet, and pensive build-ups and oceanic
washes of sound have been replaced with herky-jerky,
overly melodramatic song structures that are sadly never
as satisfying as they once were.
In nearly every song, there are glimpses of brilliance
that infuriatingly never fulfill their promise. The key
difference between the songs here and on M83’s debut
is that the new pieces lack the sheer overwhelming
emotion that made “Dead Cities” such a moving
album. “Before the Dawn Heals Us” lacks a certain
ufibridled emotional punch that it is striving for so
diligently.
Is this record a sign of creative bankruptcy or just an
incredible misstep along the road to greatness? Only
another album, the aural equivalent of a written apology,
will tell.
By Jordan Redmond
WUSC MUSIC DIRECTOR
»
Jamaicans opposed
to exhuming Marley
., .mm w
PHOTO COURTESY OF THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Bob Marley used his music as a voice for the Jamaican people, especially those living in the Kingston
trenchtowns. Marley’s widow wants to move his body from Jamaica to Ethiopia.
■ Reggae icons
widow plans to move
body to Ethiopia
By STEVENSON JACOBS
THE.ASSOCIATED PRESS
KINGSTON, Jamaica — Jamaicans
reacted angrily Thursday to plans by
Bob Marley’s widow to exhume the
reggae legend’s remains and rebury them
in Ethiopia, an African country holy to
Rastafarians, saying it would rob the
Caribbean island of its national heritage.
The news ignited radio call-in
programs and Internet chat rooms in
Jamaica and aroun4 the globe, with
most people coming down strongly
against moving the remains of the
singer, who died of cancer in 1981 at age
36.
One university professor said such a
deed would meet “serious hostility.”
“Has Rita lost her mind?” P. Chin
wrote in a letter published Thursday in
Jamaica’s most widely read newspaper,
The Gleaner. “Bob loved Jamaica. He
Wouldn’t have made it his home if it
were otherwise.”
Speaking Wednesday in Ethiopia’s
capital, Addis Ababa, Rita Marley said
she was working on bringing her
husband’s remains to his “spiritual
resting place.”
She said the reburial would occur
a
after February celebrations in Jamaica
and Ethiopia marking Bob Marley’s
60th birthday and has the support of the
Ethiopian Orthodox Church and
Ethiopian government officials.
“We are working on bringing his
remains to Ethiopia,” said Rita Marley, a
former backup singer for her late
husband’s band, The Wailers. “It is part
of Bob’s own mission.”
The announcement brought
immediate controversy and confusion.
In Kingston, the Bob Marley
Foundation, a charity headed by Rita
Marley, denied reports of her statement
in Ethiopia, and a spokesman for the
family later issued a statement quoting
her as saying that Jamaica “will remain
the resting place for Bob Marley for the
foreseeable future.”
A Cuban-born Jamaican citizen who
now lives in the West African country of
Ghana, Mrs. Marley, 58, has had an
uneasy relationship with her adopted
Caribbean homeland, where some
complain she has exploited her late
husband’s image and music for
commercial gain.
Popular host Cliff Hughes voiced
opposition to moving Marley’s body on
his nightly show on Jamaica’s Power
106 radio.
“The Marley family is going to have
to convince me that this is what Bob
wanted,” Hughes said Wednesday.
“He’s part of Jamaica’s national
heritage. With the greatest respect, he
belongs to the Marley family, and he
belongs to the people of Jamaica.”
Born in 1945, Marley grew up in the
gritty shantytowns of Kingston and later
shot to global stardom with hits like “I
Shot the Sheriff” and “No Woman, No
Cry.” His poignant lyrics promoting
social justice and African unity made
him an icon in developing countries.
Marley was given a state funeral and
buried along with his Gibson guitar and
bible in a marble mausoleum at his
birthplace of Nine Mile, a rugged
hamlet in the green hills of northern
Jamaica that’s popular with tourists. A
statue of Marley graces the entrance to
the national sports stadium in Kingston.
Mrs. Marley said her late husband
would be reburied in Shashemene, 155
miles (250 kilometers) south of Addis
Ababa, where several hundred
Rastafarians have lived since they were
given land by Ethiopia’s last emperor,
Haile Selassie.
Rastafarians worshipped Selassie as
their living god, a belief based on the
prophecy by Jamaican civil rights leader
Marcus Garvey that a black man would
be crowned king in Africa.
A devout Rastafarian, Marley’s lyrics
were laden with references to the faith,
whose followers preach a oneness with
nature, grow their hair uncombed into
dreadlocks and smoke marijuana as a
sacrament.
Rupert Lewis, a political science
professor at the University of the West
Indies in Kingston, said Marley is a
crucial part of Jamaica’s identity and
that any attempt to move his remains
would be met by “serious hostility” on
the island of 2.6 million.
“The people would not allow that
body to physically leave Jamaica,” said
Lewis. “He’s a focal point of the
Jamaican identity. What it means to be
Jamaican is inherently bound up in Bob
Marley.”
Others saw no problem with the
idea.
“She feels he wants to be in Africa?
Go ahead,” broadcaster Allen Magnus
said during his morning program on
radio RJR. “She has the right. It’s her
husband.”
This isn’t the first time that Rita
Marley has created a stir. While
promoting her autobiography last year,
she was quoted in Britain’s Daily Mirror
tabloid as saying that Bob had raped her
once. She later said she was
misinterpreted, but the remarks angered
many of the late singer’s faithful.
The latest uproar comes less than a
month after Marley’s estate announced
plans to lobby the government to make
the revered artist a national hero,
Jamaica’s highest honor.
It begins on the streets.
It ends here.
Check out the Daily
Gamecock starting
Tuesday!
www.dailygamecock.com