The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, August 19, 2004, Page B4, Image 18
First version of film exorcised
By JOE NEUMAIER
KRT CAMPUS
If it were possible for a movie to
go through a long dark night of the
soul, “Exorcist: The Beginning”
would still be suffering. The latest
film in the demonic-possession
series has had four directors, three
credited screenwriters and was
made not once but twice.
That last, historic event occurred
because Morgan Creek
Productions, which financed the
project, fired director Paul
Schrader after he completed his
version and hired Renny Harlin to
start again with a new script and a
mostly new cast. In both versions,
Stellan Skarsgard plays Father
Merrin, who battles a demon in
1947 Africa.
Harlin’s “Exorcist: The
Beginning,” distributed by Warner
Bros., opens Friday. Schrader’s
version may never see the light of
day.
“It’s obviously a tough situation
— this is a prequel to the most
famous horror film of all time, as
well as a remake of a movie that
was made but wasn’t released,”
Harlin said. “The challenge was
always to come up with something
new and surprising to an audience
that probably wasn’t even born
when the original was made. And
let’s face it: There’s nothing we
can do that is more shocking than
what the first movie did 30 years
ago.”
In fact, it was the nearly $40
million made by 2000’s reissue of
“The Exorcist” that put this fourth
entry on the fast track. (The 1973
Oscar-winning smash had been
followed by two bombs, 1977’s
“Exorcist II: The Heretic” and
1990’s “The Exorcist III.”)
The prequel was conceived
when best-selling novelist Caleb
Carr (“The Alienist”) found a script
by William Wisher called
“Exorcist: Dominion” at the
Morgan Creek offices in the late
1990s. Carr was eager to rewrite it,
fleshing out the story of the young
Father Lankester Merrin (played by
Max Von Sydow in the '73
original) and his encounter with a
possessed boy in a Kenyan village
during the years after World War
11.
“It was not a special-effects fest
— my script was about the terrible
things that people can do to each
other,” said Carr. “There was
nothing magical in it, even during a
final confrontation in which the
devil beats up Merrin.”
Carr’s script _ which was going
to be directed by horror director
Tom McLoughlin (“Friday the
13th Part IV: Jason Lives”) _
attracted actor Liam Neeson, who
wanted to play Merrin. Neeson’s
interest, in turn, attracted veteran
director John Frankenheimer,
which forced McLoughlin’s
departure. The movie was
ramping up when Frankenheimer
left the movie due to ill health. He
died of a stroke in summer 2002.
Neeson left the project shortly
after.
“When John died, I was
resigned to the movie going south
— I just didn’t think it would go
south in such an incredibly
complicated way,” said Carr. “If
the producers had said right away
that they just wanted to do a
Saturday-matinee creature
feature, that would’ve been a lot
simpler.”
Instead, Schrader was brought
on board, even though he had a
decidedly different vision. Carr
disagreed with Schrader’s hiring,
saying it was “a poor matchup of
artist and material.”
Schrader, however, says that his
first major studio film since l?82’s
“Cat People” was a natural fit.
Raised a strict Calvinist, Schrader
has often dealt with the struggle
between his characters’ inner
demons and their struggle for a
higher sense of purpose. He wrote
the screenplays for Martin
Scorsese’s “Taxi Driver,” “Raging
Bull” and “The Last Temptation of
Christ”; his director credits include
“American Gigolo,” “Affliction”
and “Auto Focus.”
“I actually thought I was a
pretty good choice,” Schrader said.
“The script was a variation on my
PHOTO COURTESY OF KRT CAMPUS
After four directors and completely starting over, "Exorcist: The Beginning” finally makes it to theaters. Izabella Scorupco stars in Morgan
Creek Productions' prequel to "The Exorcist.”
themes: Father Merrin loses his
faith, encounters the Devil, and
gets his faith back in the face of its
extreme opposite. I didn’t want to
try and (make) a horror film. The
fact that there were potential
disagreements (with colleagues) in
this scenario didn’t make it any
different than any other film.”
Schrader finished shooting in
February 2003. Though there was
some discussion of the movie “not
being scary enough” as it was being
made, when he turned in a cut to
executives at Morgan Creek, they
deemed it devoid of thrills. After
talking to Carr about possible
rewrites, the producers decided to
fire Schrader and remake the $35
million film from scratch rather
than do reshoots.
“This has not happened to
anyone before. It is without
precedent,” says Schrader, who
contractually must refrain from
making disparaging statements
about the new film or Morgan
Creek.
“By the time they talked about
making the film scarier, the mold
had pretty well been cast,” he
notes. “That’s why it ended up
being remade: They had to go back
and change the premise.”
With Schrader gone,
screenwriter Alexi Hawley was
hired to do a rewrite, and Harlin
(“Die Hard 2,” “Cliffhanger") was
chosen to deliver something more
traditionally “Exorcist”-like.
“I think Morgan Creek thought
they had made the wrong film even
before they saw my final cut,”
Schrader said.
Despite requests made through
Warner Bros., Morgan Creek
executives did not make themselves
available to discuss Schrader’s
“Exorcist.”
Harlin said he had some
hesitation about taking the job.
“When Morgan Creek wanted
flashy stuff and spark and
excitement, I said, 'I’m not going
to do that to another director’s
movie. I’d rather remake it from
scratch.’
“I was sure they’d never talk to
me again, but a week or two later,
they said, 'We think your idea is
exactly what we should do.’ And I
thought, ' Oh my God, what have I
got myself into?’ But if I’d been
offered the opportunity to make it
to begin with, I would have said yes.
“So we started over. And as
usually happens, people in
Hollywood started rumors. But I’m
very respectful of what Schrader
did. He had his vision, and the
producers wanted something
different.”
i ve r s i t
O M M O N S
I apaBTnenTS
edroom starting at $305/monih
2 Bedroom starting at $440/month
• Utility package available
New Computer Lab
• Now offering semester, 9 month
& 12 month leases (spaces limited)
• Fully furnished apts w/washer
& dryers
rolley route to campus Mon-Pn
Sat t0-4pm
Sun 1 -4pm
II: (803) 939-044
alarm systems • Sparkling swimming pool & hot Cab <■ ugh
teri/js&aurt • Basketba'J court • Volleyball • 24hr. fit +-ss center
• Clubhouse area w/gas grill • Came room