The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, April 23, 2004, Page 5, Image 5
Second USA Today editor leaves in fraud scandal
BY SETH SUTEL
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
A second top editor stepped
down from USA Today on
Thursday as the fallout from a
fraud scandal involving a former
star reporter spread. A third told
staffers he would be departing soon.
Hal Ritter, the newspaper’s
managing editor of news, submit
ted his resignation to publisher
Craig Moon on Thursday. He had
been in his current role since 1995
* and had worked at the paper since
it was founded in 1982.
Ritter’s departure came on the
same day the newspaper revealed
the scathing conclusions of an in
vestigation by three veteran jour
nalists into the work of former
star reporter Jack Kelley.
' The panel determined that edi
tors should have looked into con
cerns about Kelley’s work long ago
and that poor editorial oversight
and a “virus” of fear helped Kelley
n
continue his improprieties for
years. The newspaper’s top editor,
Karen Jurgensen, retired abruptly
in the wake of the scandal on
Tuesday.
Also, Brian Gallagher, the
newspaper’s executive editor, told
his colleagues at a meeting
Thursday that he would stay in his
current role long enough to make
a transition to the next editor, but
would not remain in that job for
the long term.
In a note that Moon distributed
to the paper’s staff, Ritter said his
departure will “make it easier for
my colleagues in News to contin
ue the job of making the newspa
per even greater.”
The panel’s review found that
Kelley committed many acts of
fraudulent reporting for more
than a decade, including fabricat
ing parts of at least 20 stories and
stealing at least 100 passages from
other news organizations.
The scandal has deeply embar
Z T : 71
rassed USA Today, the nation’s
largest-selling newspaper, and
paralleled a debacle last year at
The New York Times involving
former reporter Jayson Blair.
The panel’s findings, which
were delivered to Moon last week,
were detailed in a full page of ar
ticles in USA Today’s Thursday
editions, and a good portion of the
report was posted on its Web site.
The panel said USA Today’s poli
cies as well as routine editing pro
cedures “should have raised dark
shadows of doubt about Kelley’s
work, had his editors been vigilant
and diligent. They were not.”
Prior to Ritter’s resignation,
Moon said in an interview that he
anticipated making other person
nel changes, but had declined to be
more specific. He also said he ex
pected to keep Kelley’s wife, Jacki,
in her current position as the news
paper’s top advertising executive.
As for addressing the panel’s
concerns about a fearful culture
in the newsroom, Moon said: “I
think new leadership fixes that.”
Kelley’s work was held up to
others as an example, he was given
plum foreign assignments and
asked to speak to various groups
on behalf of the newspaper. He also
co-authored two books with USA
Today’s founder, A1 Neuharth.
Kelley, 43, resigned in January
after admitting to trying to deceive
a team of editors examining the
veracity of his work. A subsequent
review by. the outside experts
found that Kelley had engaged in
extensive fakery and plagiarism
dating back as early as 1991.
Until now Kelley’had stood by
his work, admitting only to at
tempting to deceive the initial in
vestigation. But Kelley acknowl
edged in a statement to the paper
through lawyers that he mad “a
number of serious mistakes that vi
olate the values that are most im
portant to me as a person and as a
journalist,” he said.
| f V ^ /«£,.
| Nostalgia **
K or
7 Nonsense? |
5 Should USC
$ print a
,£ yearbook? iA*,
t>W
Give us your opinion at ^
www.sa.so.edu/StudentMedia
L1
C{>/l4+t£l
AN HISTORIC RESIDENCE
Efficiency $525
One Bedroom $585
Two Bedroom $620
Rent includes all utilities and cable TV.
All rates quoted are month to month.
(Leases available, prices subject to change)
•
Located across from the
University Of South Carolina Horseshoe
and the State Capital, Cornell Arms
offers the premier location for
downtown living.
(803) 799-1442
1230 PENDLETON STREET
COLUMBIA, SC 29201
A FAMILY TRADITION AT THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA
( A premiere location (walking distance to USC)
Fully furnished apartments
USC Shuttle service to campus
Computer lab
Free movie rentals
Friendly management team
i, 2,3 and 4 bedroom apartments
Call 254-7801
for an appointment or visit us at
211 Main Street
(across from the College of Engineering)
Still looking? Better hurry - filling up fast!
a v
STERLING UNIVERSITY
Oaks
IHWH i
BB- 252-2634
^ 21 National Guard Rd.
Shuttle to (JSC
FREE Tanning
Pool & Hot Tub
Fitness Center