The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, January 12, 2004, Page 18, Image 18
'Wrong’ endings have ruined
several recent blockbusters
BY JAMIBERNARD
NEW YOKE DAILY NEWS (EHT) ’
Movies have happy endings
(thq hero finds true love or a.suit
case stuffed with cash) and un
happy endings (the hero dies in
the course of doing something
valiant). There are also endings
that are just plain wrong because
nothing in the film supports the
conclusion. These endings cheat
audiences.
Several recent films — “Bad
Santa,” “The Last Samurai” and
“Something’s Gotta Give” among
them — have flagrantly wrong
endings. (Warning: this column
is chock-full of spoilers.)
In “Bad Santa,” Billy Bob
Thornton plays a drunken, wom
anizing, child-hating burglar who
moonlights as Santa Claus so he
can case department stores for fu
ture break-ins. The funniest mo
ment is when the cops shoot him
in the back as he is trying to be
nice to a kid for once. A hail of
bullets cuts him down as he
crawls along in his Santa suit,
outstretched hand holding a cud
dly toy.
This Santa is so bad it is fitting
he should die, despite his change
of heart.
Instead the movie cuts to a hap
py ending with Santa’s voice-over
reassuring us that he survived the
“Butch Cassidy”-like gunfire. The
movie thus pretends to have a
“happy” ending, even though this
Santa is far from reformed.
In “The Last Samurai,” Tom
Cruise plays a burned-out
American military adviser who
embraces the samurai code of hon
or, even though that way of life is
about to hit the historical dustbin.
He and his newfound samurai pal
(Ken Watanabe) wind up as the
only survivors on a battlefield.
In the Japanese tradition,
there is nobility in failure, and
the samurai does the correct
thing under the circumstances
—he commits seppuku, the rit
ual (and honorable) act of sui
cide. But Cruise’s character
seems to forget the samurai
values he so recently em
braced. He walks off the battle
field unscathed.
Audiences may not want to
see America’s No. 1 box-office
star kill himself, but the char
acter’s arc would be better
served by a noble suicide after
a life lived in guilt and misery.
“Something’s Gotta Give”
sets itself up as a bracing anti
dote to movies in which an old
er guy gets the younger babe.
Here it’s a middle-aged di
vorcee (Diane Keaton) who is
the protagonist, and she has a
choice of two suitors: a lecher
ous Jack Nicholson or a re
spectful Keanu Reeves.
If this movie really wanted
to turn things upside-down, it
would end with Keaton in the
arms of the younger man, not
running at the last minute into
the arms of the ambivalent
Nicholson.
“The Lord of the Rings: The
Return of the King,” my fa
vorite movie of 2003, does not
have a wrong ending, but sev
eral endings. I wouldn’t go so
far as to say it hedges its bets,
but it gives audiences too
many options of how best to
remember Frodo and his
friends.
AN HISTORIC RESIDENCE
Efficiency ' $525
One Bedroom $585
Two Bedroom $620
Rent includes all utilities and cable TV.
All rates quoted are month to month*
(Leases available, prices subject to change)
Located across from the
University Of South Carolina Horseshoe
and the State Capital, Cornell Arms
offers the premier location for
downtown living.
(803)799-1442
1230 PENDLETON STREET
Movie. Review
r PHOTO SPICIAL TO THE GAMECOCK
Julia Roberts plays a liberal teacher at an all-female college in “Mona Lisa Smile’. The film
provides a unique perspective on gender barriers in the mid-twentieth century.
‘Mona Lisa ’ addresses equality
amidst biased 1950s academia
“MONA LISA SMILE”
*★★★ out of
BY MEG MOORE
TIIK (JAMECOCK
Julia Roberts’ character,
Katherine Watson, has come to
Wellesley, Mass., in pursuit of a
dream.
Having harbored a long-held
hope to one day teach at presti
gious Wellesley College, she
leaves her position at liberal
minded Berkley and accepts a job
with Wellesley’s art history de
partment. So long So. Cal., hello
uppercrust New England. Tossed
into a conservative world where
tradition still defines one’s educa
tion and expectation, she quickly
learns that it will take more than
from-the-textbook lectures to en
lighten and change minds.
The women that live and learn
amidst the ivy-colored walls of
Wellesley lead privileged lives.
With their prim appearances and
Harvard boyfriends, they epito
mize the future of the conserva
tive upper class.
Played by a cast of notable
young stars including Julia Stiles,
Kirsten Dunst and Maggie
Gyllenhaal, the Wellesley girls
clearly aim to assume their par
ents’ blueblood traditions and
roles. Yet they remain definitive
college students, strong-minded
and determined to succeed at
whatever it is they are pursuing.
Much to Professor Watson’s
dismay, success, to many of the
students, means marrying rather
than pursuing a career. Society
has engrained in them the neces
sity of becoming a homemaker, a
faithful wife and mother.
America’s future, in Watson’s
eyes, is all too focused on the out
dated values of America’s past.
Roberts’ chair acter goes so far
as to accuse theWellesley stall u
running a “finishing school”
rather than a college. Yet, in her
feminist zeal Katherine Watson
fails to realize that not all of these
young scholars want the life that
she envisions for them.
The aim’s attack on the 50s era
views of a woman’s role in society
is balaiced by its assertion that
equality also entails supporting
those vho do choose the tradi
tional jath.
Seeiringly critical of Wellesley
ideals, tae film does use the school
as an arti-model of changing fem
inist idols. Clearly, however, so
cial atttudes remain the subject
of the name's criticism.
The jrls that graduate in 1954
are chaining, well-rounded ir-1^
viduals vho appear to have t P
oughly njoyed their years at the
all-femae school. They emerge at
the filmS end as women well pre
pared fo; a successful future—re
gardlessrf what sort of roles they
are enccaraged — or choose — to
pursue.
Robers’ character ultimately
undergffis the biggest change.
She is fiially able to see beyond
her libeal, California-bred no
tions of ?hat it takes to be an in
dependflt woman. She educa
tionallyexpands her students’
minds a; they encourage her to
reevaluae her own ideas. There
is a whoe lot of learning going
on — abmt art, about values,
about drams. ^
“MonaLisa Smile” uplifts f
invigoraes — and yes, is a deti
nite chic lick. Although it has its
contrivel moments, the movie
succeeds .t portraying the 50s era
woman n>t as a simple-minded
housewif, but as an intelligent,
idealistic ndividual forced to jug
gle confomity with the push to as
sert her e<uality.
Commentsm this story?E-mail
gamecockjatures@gwm.sc.edu
! The Stadium
\ Restaurant
Home Cooking Away From Home
(Under New Ownership!
New additions to menu.
Fresh Vegetables Cooked Daily.
Mention this ad and receive
a FREE Tea with Meai!
Home cooking:
Fried Chicken, Pork Chops, & BBQ
and Much More!
www.thestadiumrestaurant.com I
799-4445 |
1100 Bluff Hoad
Hours: Monday - Friday: 7 - 2:30 |
WHAT IS YOUR DREAM?
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
WANTS YOU!
HAVE YOU REGISTERED YET FOR
THE 6th ANNUAL USC MLK
DAY OF SERVICE?
DON'T DELAY...REGISTER TODAY!!!
11am - 2pm
JANUARY 12-15
Greene St./Front of Russell House
http://www.sa.sc.edu/ocsp/
Email: uscmlk@yahoo.com
Phone: 803.777.5780
Fax: 803.777.7396_
We’ve got
your
ticket +
/foodS
\ Fashion^
.Fun
al roads :
ead to,/ ^