The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, November 05, 2003, Page 4, Image 4
FCC approves technology to
limit digital TV Internet piracy
BY JONATHAN D. SALANT
TIIK ASSOCIATED 1‘IIKSS
WASHINGTON - The govern
ment Tuesday approved an anti
piracy mechanism that will make
it harder for computer users to il
legally distribute digital TV pro
grams on the Internet. The goal is
to speed the transition to higher
quality digital broadcasts and en
sure such programming remains
free.
Broadcasters and the movie
industry had urged the Federal
Communications Commission to
take such action, while con
sumer groups said it will force
some people to purchase new
electronics.
Some people already share TV
shows and movies online, though
the practice is limited by the speed
of Internet connections — it can
take many hours to transfer high
quality copies.
But as Internet connections get
faster and broadcasters switch to
much clearer digital television,
the movie and television indus
tries fear consumers will put
high-quality copies of shows and
films on the Web that others can
download for free. This would re
duce the broadcasters’ ability to
sell the shows for syndication or
overseas.
The music industry saw CD
sales fall as free music sharing
proliferated on the Internet. It has
started to sue listeners who ille
gally distribute songs online.
The five-member FCC voted
unanimously to allow a “broad
cast flag” to be added to digital
programming to block broader
distribution on the Internet,
though the two Democrats on the
panel expressed some reserva
tions. Republican FCC Chairman
Michael Powell called it “an im
portant step toward preserving
the viability of free over-the-air
television.”
In its order, the FCC told mak
ers of digital television receivers
that by July 1, 2005, their models
must recognize the flag, an elec
tronic signal that broadcasters
can embed in their programs.
The commission said the order
applies only to electronics equip
ment that can receive digital
broadcast signals, not digital
VCRs, DVD players and person
al computers without digital
tuners.
“The FCC scored a big victory
for consumers and the preserva
tion of high-value, over-the-air
free broadcasting with its deci
sion,” said Jack Valenti, president
of the Motion Picture Association
of America.
Viacom, parent company of the
CBS television network, called the
decision a “historic step forward
for consumers.”
Consumer and advocacy
groups reacted just as strongly
against the decision.
“Having just given big media
companies more control over what
consumers can see on their TV sets
by lifting media ownership limits,
the FCC has now given these same
companies more control over what
users can do with that content,
leaving consumers as two-time
losers,” said Gigi Sohn, president
of Public Knowledge, a
Washington-based advocacy group
on technology and copyright
issues.
Congress already has told the
TV industry to switch their
broadcasts by 2007 to a digital for
mat, which uses computer lan
guage, from the current analog
format, which uses radio signals
sent as waves. After the switch
over, consumers who don’t sub
scribe to a cable or satellite ser
vice would need digital tuners, ei
ther inside a TV or in a set-top
box.
FCC officials said the flag
would not prevent consumers
from using existing or new DVD
or VCR machines to make copies
of TV programs. But the signal is
designed to make it more difficult
for consumers to then transfer
those copies to the Internet and
make them available to potential
ly millions of others free of
charge.
Chris Murray, legislative coun
sel for Consumers Union, the pub
lisher of Consumer Reports mag
azine, said consumers won’t be
able to use their old VCRs and
DVD players to play back pro
grams recorded on newer ma
chines that recognize the broad
cast flag.
“Technology always marches
on, but that’s normally because
new devices offer consumers bet
ter features and more flexibility
to woo buyers in the market
place, not because government
fiat has rendered a particular
technology obsolete,” Murray
said.
Under the FCC order, broad
casters will decide whether to add
the flag to their programs, includ
ing, if they want, news and public
affairs shows. Cable and satellite
operators must also make sure
that their systems transmit the
flag or use some other electronic
signal to prevent mass copying.
The FCC plans to consider
whether to allow cable and satel
lite companies to encrypt all digi
tal programs.
FCC Commissioner Michael
Copps said the decision did not go
far enough to safeguard viewers’
privacy.
“Improper use of the technolo
gies could arguably allow such
things as tracking personal infor
mation,” Copps said. “The broad
cast flag should be about protect
ing digital content, not about
tracking Americans’ viewing
habits.”
I
S.C. Democrat criticizes Dean
for Confederate flag comments
%
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
COLUMBIA - The former
chairman of the South Carolina
Democratic Party is criticizing
Democratic presidential candidate
Howard Dean for comments he
made about the Confederate flag.
The former Vermont governor
said last weekend in Iowa that he
still wants “to be the candidate
for guys with Confederate flags
in their pickup trucks.”
The comment riled former
South Carolina Democratic Party
Chairman Dick Harpootlian, who
said Tuesday it indicates Dean’s
lack of understanding of the
South. He sent a letter to Dean on
Monday, asking him to stop us
ing the flag “as a measure of dis
cerning independent voters in
the South.”
“As you spend more time in
South Carolina, I am sure you are
going to realize that the average
independent South Carolinian is
much more cosmopolitan than...
you seem to be willing to give
them credit for being,”
Harpootlian wrote. “The stereo
type of an independent
Southerner as a rebel-flag-waving
pickup truck driver is wrong.”
Dean sent a letter to
Harpootlian on Tuesday, saying
he did not intend to stereotype
Southerners and believes the
Confederate flag is a “despicable
symbol of racism, oppression.”
“I do not believe that one can
assign blanket stereotypes to
Southerners or any other group
in our country,” Dean wrote. “I
want people with Confederate
flags on their trucks to put down
those flags and vote Democratic,
because the need for quality
health care, jobs and good educa
tion knows no racial boundaries.”
The Confederate flag is a sen
sitive issue in South Carolina.
The flag was removed from the
Statehouse dome in 2000 and
moved it to its current locat’
at a monument on Statehou
grounds.
The state National Association
for the Advancement of Colored
People began an economic boy
cott of the state in 2000 that they
plan to continue until the flag is
completely removed.
...
5P
The Editor in Chief is responsible for all
operations of The Gamecock, USCs student
newspaper that is published three days a week
during the Spring semester. Duties include
overseeing editorial content, recruiting and
supervision of the editorial staff.
Applications and job descriptions are available at the Office of
the Director of Student Life, Russell House 115, or online at
www.sa.sc.ed u / studentmedia.
DEADLINE for completed applications is
Wednesday, November 12,2003 @ 4:00 p.m!
0 s. I
; For the USC vs. Clemson Game
, November 22,2003
^
Students may have their Id cards scanned to enter the lottery
on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, (November 10,11,121 from
9:00am-4:00pm in Room 205 in the Russell House. This will be
durinn student distribution for the Florida Game.
'I
A list will be posted of the students who will be eligible for a
ticket by 9:00am in the Russell House on November 17th. Students
can pick up their tickets on November 17, IS, and 19.