The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, June 25, 2003, Page 6, Image 6
Harry Potter books provide an easy escape from life
JOSHUA HANLEY
GAMECOCKVIEWPOINTS@HOTMAIL.COM
Harry Potter books are
fine entertainment, but
don’t forget newspapers
Children used to learn to read
so they could read the Bible.
Now they do it for Harry Potter.
Don’t get me wrong, I don't be
grudge them their fantasy; I've in
dulged in the genre by the back
pack-full almost since I could read.
But still, aside from any discus
sion of their literary merit, the
current craze concerns me.
It’s not the frenzied pitch of the
mobs that descended upon book
stores all over the world last
Friday night that is worrisome.
Believe it or not, this type of craze
over a book is nothing new, al
though modem technology allows
it to take place on a greater scale
than ever before. More than 150
years ago, there were riots on the
docks when the first shipments of
the next part to one of Dickens' se
rialized novels arrived from
England.
Now those books are on high
school summer reading lists,
which, ironically, provided the
only motivation many kids had to
read before Harry Potter.
If, as many hope, the series
sparks a new interest in the satis
fying recreation of reading, so
much the better.
I know the books are condemned
by many as shameless escapist fic
tion, and while I can't disagree, al
most all fiction is shameless es
capist fiction.
No, the only problem I have with
Potter is not so much a problem
with him as it is one with so many
of those who read about him. I am
concerned about the fact that more
children can name the headmaster
of Hogwarts than can name the vice
president of the United States.
I am concerned about the fact
that so many who say they don't
have time to keep up with current
affairs — which are directly rele
vant to their lives — are willing to
blithely hury their heads in an 870
page book.
I am concerned that so many
who can’t make it to the nearest vot
ing booth will stand in line for
hours to be one of he first to read
the latest Harry Potter novel.
As hungrily as people might
have devoured fiction in the past,
they rarely did so to the exclusion
of the events and issues that affect
ed their lives.
In contrast, many today turn off
the news and cancel their newspa
per subscriptions because it is all
just too depressing. Even the lives
of celebrities have ceased to pro
vide enough catharsis; the E! chan
nel can only dish out so many juicy
bits before we must look elsewhere
if we are to keep our heads in the
sand. And so we hide in Harry,
among other things.
Consider: until April of 1974, no
work of fiction had ever appeared
on the New York Times trade pa
perback bestseller list That month,
“The Sword of Shannara,” by Terry
Brooks, appeared there and leaped
to number one, where it remained
for five months. The book was the
first major work of fantasy to ap
pear since J.R.R. Tolkien's “The
Lord of the Rings,” and it marked
the beginning of the sci-fi/fahtasy
revolution.
. In many bookstores, the space
allotted to this genre is now almost
as large as that devoted to all other
fiction combined.
But what did people read so
much of before 1974? Histories?
Biographies? Certainly. Self-help?
Probably. Diet books? Maybe. Dr.
Spock's “Baby and Child Care”?
Unfortunately.
They read about things that mat
tered to them, subjects and issues
that impacted their lives. Why is it
that so few do now? Without rail
ing against modem public educa
tion, could it be that we are simply
too comfortable? Iraq is so far
away; Washington nearly as dis
tant. The nearest ballot box? Still
too far away for more than half of
the country’.
Not to say that all or only Harry
Potter fans are initiative-impaired
zombies; the ranks of muggles are
rife with the blissfully ignorant too.
If we can't put Potter do wn for a
moment and leave the La-Z-Boy to
put out small fires from time to
time, we will soon have to abandon
both to flee a house ablaze.
Joshua Hanley is a fourth-year
philosophy student.
IN THEIR WORDS
“Apparently some mean-spir
ited Republicans didn't include
tax breaks for those who pay no
federal income taxes in their lat
est round of tax cuts.”
STEVE SKUTNIK
IOWA STATE DAILY (IOWA STATE U.)
“What most of us have only
recently realized is that there
are hundreds, likely thousands,
of men who are looking to de
stroy us with every breath we
take. The peace that we find in
our everyday activities is under
attack, and it would take little
more than a sinister suitcase to
• destroy it all.”
NATHAN BORST
IOWA STATE DAILY (IOWA STATE l'. "
“Yet, while racial profiling
must be discouraged, we should
n't confuse itwith the legitimate
actions of law enforcement. For
patrols on the Mexican border,
it makes sense to target
Hispanic-looking individuals for
possible border violations?
And if officials are tipped a
white male is going to fire
bomb a black church, should
n't Caucasian males be scrut
inized more carefully? In the
end, these actions aren't con
sidered racial profiling; just
good police work based on
credible, specific evidence.”
WAYNE MA
DAILY ILLINI (D. ILLINOIS)
“There are some command
ments by which everyone at
tempting a long-distance rela
tionship must abide. First, a
relationship cannot work if
one person is always paranoid
that the other is cheating—al
though not actually cheating
helps too.”
GEMMA LEWIS
DAILY BRUIN <U. CALIFORNIA-LOS
ANGELES)
Agree?
Disagree?
Send letters to the editor.
Submission Policy
Letters to the editor should be less
than 300 words and include name,
phone number, professional title or
year and major, if a student. E-mail
letters to
gamecocKviewpoints@hotmail.com.
Letters will be edited. Anonymous
letters will not be published. Call the
newsroom at 777-7726 for more
information.
ONLINE
This week’s question
Do you think value-centered
management will help USC?
Vote at www.dailygame
cock.com.
Last week’s question
Do you think students should
be able to smoke in the
dorms? See other poll results
at www.dailygamecock.com.
NO WAY! 43%
NOT IF I LIVE THERE 20%
IF ROOMMATE AGREES 26%
OF COURSE! 4%
SMOKE: GOOD FOR YOU 7%
Winners and Sinners
USC ENGINEERING Finally, somebody’s doing
something about education in South Carolina.
^ MICHIGAN STUDENTS OF EVERY COLOR
r Supreme Court recognizes race as a factor in
education, but denounces mechanical fixes.
VCM Could drop foreign language programs
• like a bad outbreak of monkeypox.
m USC SPORTS Nothing going on here. No wins,
losses, or arrests.
Gamecock Quotables
“Some kids don’t know what
an engineer is... To some high
schoolers, an engineer is the
guy who drives the train.”
STEVE MCNEILL
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF MECHANICAL
ENGINEERING AT USC
“Implementation is kind of
tricky.”
JOHN SKVORETZ
DEAN OF THE COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS.
ON THE PROSPECTS FOR THE NEW VALUE
CENTERED MANAGEMENT BUDGETING
SYSTEM.
GAMECOCK CORRECTIONS
If you see an error in today’s paper, we want to know. E-mail us
at gamecockviewpoints@hotmail.com.