The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, November 17, 2000, Page 3, Image 3
.Court: Hand recounts allowed
■ Florida high court's ruling means
Palm Beach, Broward counties can
continue counting votes by hand
by Ron Fournier
Associated Press
A1 Gore won a fight Thursday to
quicken the pace of manual recounts in
Florida as he struggled to trim Geoige
W. Bush’s 300-vote lead before the Re
publican secretary of state certifies the
marathon White House race Saturday.
GOP lawyers asked courts to stop the
^lounting and “the disintegration” of
America’s presidential election system.
The vice president laid the ground
work to keep fighting for public opinion
if he fails to pull ahead of the Texas gov
ernor by Friday at midnight—a prospect
senior advisers said was likely.
“The choice really is whether the
voters are going to decide this election
by having every vote count or whether
that process is going to be short-circuit
ed without all the votes being examined,”
Gore said in a radio interview.
The Florida Supreme Court later
handed Gore a modest victory, autho
rizing officials in Palm Beach and
rsrowaru counties iu recount uanots uy
hand. The effort, wliich officials said will
take about six days, had been stalled on
order of Secretary of State Katherine
Harris.
The ruling did not say whether any
votes found in the recounts can be added
to Gore’s totals.
Within minutes, Palm Beach elec
tion officials decided to start recounting
Thursday night. After two full days of
counting in 86 of 609 precincts, Gore
had gained 21 votes in Broward Coun
ty on the state’s southeast coast.
Bush supports the secretary of state’s
weekend deadline and wants a declara
tion of a Florida winner after the last
overseas absentee ballots are due Friday
at midnight.
“Once these votes are counted, we
will know the final result of Florida’s
election and the nation’s election,” Bush
campaign chairman Don Evans said. “Win
or lose, this election will be over.”
Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, who thus far
has been unable to deliver the state for
his brother, agreed: “Saturday morning
we’ll know who won the state.”
Gore’s attorneys asked a state judge
in Tallahassee to have hand recounts
rolled into the election totals, even if the
vote-counting isn’t finished by Friday
night. They argued that Harris, a Bush
supporter, acted arbitrarily when she re
fused to update vote totals with the re
sults of manual recounts after a Tuesday
deadline.
Bush looked to a federal appeals court
in Atlanta to shut down the canvassing
altogether, calling manual recounts in
accurate and prone to political miscliief.
Both sides said the case could be head
ed to U.S. Supreme Court.
“Eight days after Florida’s presi
dential vote, the entire nation is wit
nessing the disintegration of a process
that was designed to elect America’s pres
ident,” reads the Bush brief in the fed
eral appeal. “The Florida manual recount
process is being used to eliminate any
possibility of an orderly, rational and fi
nal end to the election. ”
The federal court also agreed to con
sider a related case filed by three Bush
supporters from Brevard County. They
claim their rights are being violated be
cause their counties are not recanvass
ing votes by hand.
Broward County sheriff’s deputies
took custody of 78 tiny bits of paper
after Republicans demanded that the
scraps be held as evidence of potential
ballot tampering. The paper, from the
holes in punchout ballots, was placed by
police in an envelope marked, “Crime.
Found Property.”
Joked elections supervisor Jane Car
roll, herself a Republican: “Let the chads
fall as they may.”
Later, a lawyer burst into the
county’s hurricane emergency center
and served subpoenas on startled coun
ty election officials. “The nation is watch
ing you, ” said Republican activist William
Scherer, who filed a lawsuit on behalf of
fellow attorney Steven Stoll.
About 100 protesters, from groups
including the NAACP and the Sierra
Club, gathered at the West Palm Beach
counting station, where the canvassing
board was waiting for court guidance be
fore recounting. The crowd chanted,
“Hand count” and “Every vote counts.”
Some held signs that read, “Honk
. for dimples” — a reference to not-quite
perforated ballots.
The vice president began the day 300
votes behind Bush in Florida, with about
2,600 overseas absentee ballots to be
counted Friday night. Gore has hoped
the additional hand recounting would
vault him ahead of the Texas governor
in the race for the state’s 25 electoral
votes and the White House.
Both sides believe that a majority of
the overseas ballots will go to Bush. Fur
ther complicating Gore’s political situ
ation, top advisers said Thursday the slow
going recounts were unlikely to produce
enough new votes to overtake Bush by
Friday at midnight.
The prospect of trailing Bush at
the deadline intensified Gore’s fight in
the courts of law and public opinion. A
recent poll showed that seven out of
10 Americans said a winner should be
declared once the overseas ballots are
added to the totals.
The Democratic strategy: speak ear
ly and often to defend hand counting—
and attack Harris.
Vice presidential candidate Joseph
Lieberman said voters must witness a
“reasonable and just conclusion” to
the election.
Asked on an ABC radio show if
the election was being stolen from him,
Gore said, “I would discourage -use of
that word because, again, however it
comes out, we’re going to come behind
the winner.”
Aide to German
chancellor quits in
soccer club scandal
by Tony Czuczka
Associated Press
BERLIN — Germany’s transportation
minister quit Thursday under pressure
from his own Social Democrats to dis
tance the party from his role in alleged
ly funneling illegal donations to a soccer
club he ran.
The accusations against Reinhard
Klimmt threatened the credibility of a
governing party that has relentlessly crit
icized former Chancellor Helmut Kohl
and the opposition Christian Democrats
for a party financing scandal over the past
vear.
If Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder said
Klimmt, who was fined $12,000 by a
court this week, wanted to avoid be
coming a political embarrassment. “And
you have to respect tliat,” he told TV re
porters.
The party announced Klimmt’s de
cision shortly after Volker Neumann, a
Social Democratic lawmaker heading the
Kohl investigation, urged him to step
down.
“We came to power claiming high
er moral standards than we expect from
the others,” he said in a radio inter
view. “So it is up to us to draw the con
sequences.”
Schroeder appeared to stay on the
sidelines as the Klimmt scandal grew, but
he accepted his aide’s resignation after
days of pressure from his party and —es
•'jcially irksome for Schroeder—its ju
nior coalition partner, the Greens. The
government named Kurt Bodewig, a
deputy transportation minister, to take
over the ministry.
Klimmt said he had hoped to hang
on but tliat “my decision has made things
easier for all involved”
A court in the western city of Trier
ordered the fine Monday, saying Klimmt
helped fake sponsorship contracts that
brought about $270,000 in illegal dona
tions in the 1990s to the FC Saaibruecken
soccer club in his home state of Saarland,
near the French border.
The donations were made by a com
pany that runs hospitals in the state, where
Klimmt has considerable political influ
ence. Prosecutors said, however, that they
found no evidence that Klimmt had used
his political influence to shield the do
nating company’s hospitals from state
budget cuts.
Klimmt, 58, initially accepted the
fine in a deal to have prosecutors close
the case. But he changed his mind
Tuesday after Social Democratic leaders
uiged him to fight for his reputation, leav
ing open the possibility that he would
face criminal charges.
Social Democrats uiged him to step
down from his post so that there
wouldn’t be even an appearance of im
propriety.
The Christian Democrats accused
Schroeder of dithering.
“The whole back and forth was pret
ty bad,” the party’s secretary-general,
Laurenz Meyer, said on ZDF TV.
“Schroeder saw this coming for weeks
and should have been prepared.”
In office only 11 months, Klimmt
was the third Cabinet member to go since
Schroeder and the Social Democrats won
power in September 1998. The most
prominent other departure was that of
flamboyant fomier Finance Minister Os
kar Lafontaine, a fellow Saarland politi
cian and longtime friend of Klimmt who
quit in an unrelated power struggle with
the chancellor.
Group ‘disappointed’
with Catholic bishops
by Richard N. Ostling
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — The American
Jewish Committee said it is “deeply
disappointed” with a Wednesday pro
nouncement on the Mideast peace
process from America’s Roman
Catholic bishops because it did not
call upon the Palestinians to “fully
respect the religious liberties of its
citizens.”
The Jewish group, long active in
significant discussions with the Vati
can and U.S. Catholicism, noted
that Palestinians have desecrated Jew
ish holy sites, including an ancient
Jericho synagogue and the tomb of
Joseph, and said some Muslim reli
gious leaders had urged “attacks on
Jews worldwide.”
The Jewish group said “these ob
scene words and deeds simply cannot
be tolerated.”
The bishops said the Mideast peace
process must be revived, and for the
first time endorsed “establishment of
an internationally recognized Pales
tinian state” as well as Israel’s right
to exist “within secure borders.”
A 1989 policy statement spoke
only of a Palestinian “homeland.”
Cardinal Bernard Law, who chaired
the drafting committee, said the change
was “rhetorical” and continued the
substance of the previous declaration.
The bishops also advocated full
independence for Lebanon and “with
drawal of foreign troops,” but the Jew
ish committee noted they avoided
mention of Syria by name.
The bishops’ busy Wednesday ses
sions also discussed doctrinal limits
for church-related colleges and hos
pitals. Other social statements de
manded sweeping changes in The na
tion’s criminal justice system and said
the U.S. Supreme Court allowed vir
tual infanticide in its June ruling on
late-term abortions.
The meeting’s most dramatic mo
ment occurred when lay professor
Daniel Finn of St. John’s University
in Collegeville, Minn., told the
bishops that their new policy to
control who teaches what about reli
gious subjects in Catholic colleges cre
ates potential for the worst “open con
flict between bishops and theologians”
in a century.
Under Vatican prodding, bish
ops voted last year to require that all
religion teachers receive an endorse
ment from their local bishops. Hie hi
erarchy is now uying to decide how
to implement that.
Finn said his colleagues nation
wide believe the impending system
will violate due process, cause legal
snarls and undermine the credibility
of Catholic academians. There’s con
siderable confusion over how much
power the bishops will exercise.
Archbishop Daniel Pilarczyk, who
chairs the bishops’ committee on the
matter, said it’s strictly up to a col
lege what to do with a teacher minus
the mandate. He said a bishop can an
nounce that a theologian lacks the
mandate or inform the college but “he
doesn’t have the right or the power
to say, ’You get fired and you don’t.’”
The hospital issue involves
Catholic hospitals that merge with
non-Catholic facilities and whether
they must forbid abortions and other
practices that violate church teach
ings. The decision on hospital policy
will be made next June, when the bish
ops also hope to set final rules for en
dorsing college theologians.
On abortion, the bishops declared
that the Supreme Court’s June deci
sion to throw out Nebraska’s ban on
so-called partial birth procedures
means “even the killing of a child
mostly bom alive is protected,” which
“has brought our legal system to the
brink of endorsing infanticide.”
During discussion, Archbishop El
den Curtiss of Omaha, Neb., cited the
presidential election as evidence of
the need for bishops to do a better job
educating their flocks.
“The last election, yet undecid
ed, indicates a majority of Catholic
people still do not make abortion the
priority,” he said, an apparent refer
ence to the many Catholics who vot
ed for Vice President A1 Gore, an op
ponent of a ban ‘on late-term abortions.
Texas Gov. Geoige W. Bush support
ed banning the procedure.
Exit polls indicated Gore got a
slight majority of the Catholic vote.
A 38-page decree on crime reaf
firmed the hierarchy’s opposition to
the death penalty, though polls indi
cate a majority of U.S. Catholics dis
agree. It also said punishment
should be used only to protect soci
ety and rehabilitate criminals rather
than expressing vengeance.
LAPD convictions could be the first of many
BY LINDA DEUTSCH
Associated Press
LOS ANGELES— Guilty verdicts
(ptainst three officers in the city’s largest
police corruption scandal could set the
stage for further prosecutions.
“Although these cases are difficult
to prosecute, this demonstrates that we
should not ignore them,” Police Chief
Bernard Parks told reporters Wednesday
after the officers were convicted of con
spiracy and other crimes. “Our investi
gations have not concluded.”
It was the first trial resulting from
the scandal in which officers from an
elite gang-fighting unit of the Police De
partment’s Rampart station are accused
of framing innocent people and in some
cases beating, robbing and shooting them.
Sgts. Brian Liddy, 39, and Edward
Ortiz, 44, and Officer Michael Buchanan,
^P, were found guilty of conspiracy to
T!ostrucl justice and filing false police re
ports. Officer Paul Harper, 33, was ac
quitted of all chaiges.
All four still face internal police hear
ings on those and other chaiges, Parks
said. Eighty cases have been brought
within the department as a result of the
corruption probe centered in the city’s
Rampart neighborhood. Many remain to
be heard.
“There are cases we’re very inter
ested in,” Parks said of prospects for
criminal action, singling out an attempted
murder charge against Officer Nino Dur
den.
Durden, who is awaiting trial, is
accused of shooting and paralyzing a
handcuffed suspect. He was a former
partner of Rafael Perez, the disgraced
ex-officer whose allegations started the
scandal last fall.
Perez turned informant in exchange
for leniency after he was caught stealing
$1 million worth of cocaine from a po
lice evidence room.
He was expected to be the top pros
ecution witness until he demanded im
munity from murder allegations — now
recanted — made by an ex-lover. The
jury was already deliberating when Sonya
Flores said she made up the story about
bodies buried in Tijuana, Mexico, be
cause Perez had spumed her.
Without Perez, prosecutors were
forced to rely on gang members with
credibility problems and police officers
who said they knew little if anything
about the chaiges.
“The first case was a test case and
the prosecution passed the test. But
there’s no guarantee they will pass the
test in the future,” said Laurie Leven
son, a professor at Loyola Law School.
City officials have estimated it
may cost as much as $ 125 million to set
tle lawsuits resulting from the scandal,
which has already resulted in the dis
missal of about 100 criminal cases taint
ed by police testimony. Dozens of offi
cers have quit or been fired or sus
pended.
Lawyers for the convicted officers
said they would move for a new trial.
They claimed their clients were pre
judged as guilty before the trial began.
“I was defending an officer that had
already been found guilty in the minds
of, not only these jurors, but the pub
lic,” said Oritz’s lawyer, Barry Levin.
Ortiz, 44, said he was baffled by the
verdicts.
“I still believe to this day that we
are innocent and that we did our job to
keep the citizens of L.A., keep the streets
safe from all the gangs and all the
crime that’s going on out there,” he said.
The Superior Court jurors, who de
liberated for 18 hours after a monthlong
trial, said they were not influenced by
the publicity swirling around the case.
“There’s good cops and there’s bad
cops,” jury foreman Victor Flores said.
“A lot of us on the jury felt that they just
didn't happen to cover themselves enough
and they never thought it would come
back to haunt them.”
‘There’s good cops and there’s bad cops. A lot of us
on the jury felt that they just didn’t happen to cover
themselves enough, and they never thought it would
come back to haunt them.’
Victor Flores
Jury Foreman
News Briefs
■ Clintons say Good
Morning, Vietnam
BANDAR SERI BEGAWAN,
Brunei (AP) — President Clinton
was" flying to Hanoi Thursday night,
bearing his promise of “a new page in
our relations with Vietnam.”
He is the third U.S. president to
visit Vietnam, and the first since the
fall of the South and reunification un
der Communist rule. Lyndon B. John
son went to Vietnam twice as presi
dent and Richard M. Nixon once, in
1969.
First lady Hillary Rodham Clinton
arrived in Hanoi ahead of her husband,
flying in Thursday from Israel, where
she delivered a eulogy at the funeral of
Leah Rabin, widow of former Israeli
Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin.
■ Israeli rockets kill
German doctor and
injure 10 Palestinians
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli heli
copters rocketed Wfest Bank taigets,
including offices of Palestinian leader
Yasser Arafat’s Fatah movement, be
fore dawn Thursday, killing a German
doctor and wounding 10 Palestinians in
a further escalation in the worst
Mideast fighting in decades.
Also Thursday, an 11-year-old
Palestinian boy died of injuries sus
tained a day earlier in a clash with Is
raeli troops in the Gaza Strip, bringing
the death toll to 221 in seven weeks of
confrontation. The vast majority of
those killed have been Palestinians.
Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak
brushed off criticism at home that the
army’s response to Palestinian shoot
ing attacks was not tough enough.
■ Tidal wave hits
Papua New Guinea
PORT MORESBY, Papua New
Guinea (AP)—A huge earthquake
shook the Pacific Ocean just off the
coast of'Papua New Guinea Thursday,
generating a tidal wave that crashed
ashore and damaged a supermarket
and other buildings.
There were no immediate reports
of injuries, but communications were
cut with Rabaul and nearby Kokopo,
the two towns in the area of northeast
Papua New Guinea where the tsunami
hit.
Japan’s Meteorological Agency
said the undersea quake registered 7.8
magnitude and the U.S. Geological
Survey put it at 8.0.
■ Amtrak picks up
speed with 150 mph
Acela Express train
WASHINGTON (AP) — Amtrak’s
new 150 mph Acela Express bullet
train represents America’s most seri
ous effort yet to draw travelers back to
the rails.
The train enters regular passenger
service Dec. 11 between Washington
and Boston. If it succeeds as an alter
native to crowded highways and con
gested skies, the snub-nosed train
could be a first step toward European
style high-speed train travel elsewhere
in the United States.
If it fails, however, Acela Express
could be the swan son? for Amtrak,
the federally subsidized railway that is
under orders from Congress to become
financially self-sufficient by 2003. Am
trak is relying on the service to earn
$180 million a year.
■ Government
unleashing flies to
combat fire ants
WASHINGTON (AP) — The
South’s newest weapon against the
dreaded fire ant sounds like something
out of a sci-fi thriller: An insect whose
larvae eat the heads off their prey.
The Agriculture Department plans
to elease hundreds of thousands of
tin i ant-eating flies in the South and
po-sibly in California, where the fire
ar s have now spread.
USD\ says the gnat-like phorid
f) es, imported from Brazil, pose no
k irm to anybody or anything other
t‘ lan fire ants. “It is a self-sustaining
' locontrol,” said Richard Brenner,
' 'ho leads a USDA research team in
. lorida.