The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, November 01, 2000, Page 6, Image 6
pAGE 6 _ Wednesday, November 1,2000
'Che 6amtcock
Napster cuts deal
with industry giant
to end legal woes
by Seth Sut^l
Associated Press
NEW YORK — In a deal that could
rescue Napster from legal limbo, Ber
telsmann said Tuesday it was teaming
with the Internet music-swapping ser
vice to develop a new membership
based distribution system that would
guarantee payments to artists.
The German media giant will drop
its lawsuit against Napster, make its mu
sic catalog available and gain the right
to buy a stake in Napster. In the mean
time, Bertelsmann will loan Napster
money to help develop the subscrip
tion service.
The move marks a sharp break with.
other members of the music industry,
which, along with Bertelsmann, sued
Napster for copyright infringement,
trying to shut down the free service on
which millions trade bootleg record
ings.
Through labels such as Arista, RCA
and Ariola, Bertelsmann sells records
by performers such as Britney Spears,
Whitney Houston, Kenny G and Car
los Santana.
The recording industry has strug
gled to find a formula for music dis
tribution that protects royalties.
In a joint statement, Bertelsmann
and Napster said they would “seek sup
port from others in the music industry
to establish Napster as a widely accepted
membership-based service and invite
them to participate actively in this
process.”
Bertelsmann owns BMG. The oth
er major music companies are Sony,
Universal, Winner and EMI. It was not
immediately known whether any of the
others would follow suit.
Bertelsmann chairman Thomas
Middelhoff said Napster has “pointed
the way for a new direction for music
distribution, and we believe it will form
the basis of important and exciting new
business models for the future of the
music industry.”
Bertelsmann, which also owns book
and magazine publishers as well as a
major broadcasting network in Europe,
has been ramping up its push into the
online world. It owns a major stake in
Barnes & NobIe.com, all of CDNow,
and numerous other Web sites.
Napster chief executive Hank Bar
ry called the deal the “right next step”
for the company. Barry had said re
cently the company was thinking about
charging monthly membership fees to
users.
Napster has taken off since being
founded last year by then-college fresh
man Shawn Fanning, snarling college
computer networks and sparking
public debate over whether intellec
tual property can be protected in the
dawning Digital Age. The company is
awaiting a federal appeals court rul
ing on whether it can continue oper
ating pending trial in a suit filed by the
recording industry.
Several other online music sites,
led by MP3.com, have embraced such
subscription models. None of them use
the wildly popular peer-to-peer file
swapping method employed by Nap
ster. ,
MP3.com was also sued by record
ing companies for copyright infringe
ment, but has settled with all but Uni
versal.
Whether fee-based Internet music
delivery services will be viable remains
to be seen. A number of software pro
grams freely distributed on the Inter
net, such as Gnutella and Freenet, al
low users to swap bootleg music without
the need for a central server clearing
house of the type Napster provides.
Campaign
from page 5
man was running for president. But
those kind of folks forget that when
you’re a governor, you have to lead.”
Bush’s performance wasn’t all se
riousness, though. He joked about his
tendency to muff lines and mispro
nounce names. “Too bad all the world
leaders aren’t named A1 Smith,” Bush
said.
When Leno put on a Bush Hal
loween mask, the governor said, “That’s
scary,” then donned a Gore mask. “This
is more scary,” he said.
Bush told his California crowds he
will upset Gore in the state, which is
crucial to the Democrats. Jimmy Carter
in 1976 was the last president elected
without winning California, and before
that, it was John F. Kennedy in 1960.
The governor tried to identify him
self with Reagan, who went from the
Sacramento state house to the White
House, on the experience question and
by likening his proposed across-the
board tax cut to Reagan’s of 1981.
Sen. John McCain, who as a pri
mary rival had himself questioned Bush’s
readiness, called the Democratic
challenge to the governor’s experience
“the latest sort of desperation tactic.”
“I promise you, I know, that this
man is fully prepared,” McCain said.
Bush was seeking votes in San Jose
before flying north to Portland and then
on to Seattle.
New Zealand scientist proposes
new theory on mad cow disease
by Emma Ross
Associated Press
LONDON — A veterinary scientist has
proposed a new theory for the origin of
mad cow disease, saying he believes it
likely came from a wild animal commonly
found outside Britain that was chopped
up for cattle feed in England.
Roger Morris, a professor of animal
health at Massey University in New
Zealand, has spent years investigating
about a half-dozen credible theories of
how British dairy cattle could have
contracted the disease, blamed for the
deaths of 81 people so far.
Until now, scrapie, a brain-wasting
disease found in sheep, has been the prime
suspect because of its similarities to bovine
spongiform encephalopathy, or BSE. But
Morris said his research indicates it is less
likely the outbreak was caused by cows
being fed scrapie-infected sheep.
Morris said he is investigating a list
of about 15 suspected wild animals, but
would not specify them until his research
is published in a scientific research
journal sometime next year.
“There are a range of wildlife species
I see as potential sources, but I’ve not yet
come to a conclusion on which species
it’s most likely to be,” he said in an in
terview this week.
Dr. Hugh Pennington of Aberdeen
University in Scotland, who has researched
the disease, said Morris’ theory was just
one of a number of credible theories of
the origins of the outbreak. Pesticides and
bacteria have been ruled out as the cause.
Experts say while pinpointing the ori
gins of mad cow will not help the British
control the human form of the illness,
variant Creutzfeld Jacob disease, it is im
portant for heading off future outbreaks
elsewhere around the world.
An independent committee com
missioned by the British government pub
lished a report Thursday that also down
graded the idea that mad cow disease
originated from scrapie. But that group
reached a different conclusion, questioned
by some experts, which says a genetic
mutation in a single cow was responsi
There are a range of wildlife species I see as potential
sources, but I’ve not yet come to a conclusion on
which species it’s most likely to be.’
Roger Morris
Professor of Animal Health, Massey University
ble.
“I rank that low. The genetic muta
tion theory is even less likely than scrapie.
There’s no evidence for it at all,” Mor
ris said.
Morris said he theorizes that a wild
animal carrying a version of BSE specif
ic to its own species somehow arrived in
Britain, was captured and its brain and
oigans ended up in a batch of feed given
to about 1,000 dairy cows in the south
west of England between 1975 and 1977.
About half of the cows then became
infected, he said, adding that the infect
ed cattle ended up in other parts of the
country before being recycled as cattle
feed in 1981, spreading the disease.
BSE has an incubation period of about
five years. The first cases of mad cow dis
ease were identified in Britain in 1986.
Scientists believe humans caught the dis
ease by eating processed food containing
the infected brains and organs.
Scrapie, BSE and variant Creutzfeld
Jacob disease are all types of illnesses
known as transmissible spongiform en
cephalopathies. They are all fatal and re
sult in a mass of sponge-like holes in
the brain.
Scrapie was the only other similar
disease known to infect farm animals, and
waste from slaughtered sheep was used
in cattle feed, so scientists focused on in
vestigating a link between the two dis
eases.
Western Europe
continues to be hit
by storm system
by Chris Fontaine
Associated Press
LONDON-A storm system raging
across Western Europe continued to
wreak havoc in the air and sea Tuesday,
bringing down an Italian military heli
copter and sinking an Italian cargo ship
loaded with chemicals.
Storm-related deaths rose to at least
15, with six confirmed dead in the he
licopter crash and one Danish rescue
worker drowned while trying to help
the crew of a German cargo ship caught
in a North Sea storm.
Eight people, four in France, three
in Britain and one in Ireland, were killed
by the storm Monday, mostly in traffic
accidents involving fallen trees.
A second ship, the Italian tanker
Ievoli Sun, foundered Tuesday off the
northwest coast of France, a day after
its crew members were rescued from
the stricken vessel.
The boat was carrying 6,000 met
ric tons of styrene, isopropyl and methyl
ethyl ketone. Environmental groups
warned that the chemicals, especially
styrene, could cause serious ecological
problems if they leak from the ship and
get blown toward the French coast.
Styrene, used in the manufacture
of plastics, is highly toxic and causes
cancer in laboratory animals.
“There is a potential for a serious
marine pollution incident here,” said
Paul Johnson, a Greenpeace Interna
tional scientist based at Exeter Univer
sity in southwest England.
In Italy, a military police helicopter
crashed off a Tuscan island overnight,
killing at least six of the officers aboard.
A search was under way Tuesday to
find two other people aboard, includ
ing a prisoner being transported from
the island of Capraia to Leghorn, on the
Tuscan coast.
The helicopter crashed just after
takeoff, in a violent storm.
“I didn’t hear any explosion be
forehand,” port official Maurizio Capo
mandirola told the ANSA news service.
“Only a sort of crash when it ended in
the water.”
Off the west coast of Denmark, a
rescue worker fell overboard and
drowned and another was seriously in
jured while trying to help the crew of
the German cargo ship Faros.
The eight-man crew gathered in a
lifeboat, but it capsized. All eight even
tually climbed aboard a rescue dinghy
from the Danish ship.
Fierce storms had barreled across
western Europe on Monday, grounding
flights, cutting power to thousands of
homes, stranding ferry passengers and
snarling road and rail traffic.
The aftermath of severe gusts and
heavy rain continued to plague
Britain on Tuesday with train services
delayed, roads closed and river flood
warnings remaining in force.
Nearly 30 rivers in southwest Eng
land were at risk of severe flooding, of
ficials said.
Most of the country’s transporta
tion system was expected to be back to
normal by midmoming. Railtrack, the
private company that operates Britain’s
rail network, said about 1,000 trees had
been cleared from lines in southern Eng
land alone.
Aryan Nations leader
files for bankruptcy
to pay court verdict
■ Richard
Butler owes
$5.8 million
by Nicholas K.
Ger a nios
Associated Press
COEUR D’ALENE, Idaho — The
leader of the Aryan Nations has filed
for bankruptcy, days before he was to sur
render his 20-acre compound to satisfy
a civil rights lawsuit.
Richard Butler, 82, was vilified on
the streets of Coeur d’Alene during the
weekend and denied use of a hotel for a
news conference. On Monday, he listed
assets of about $300,000, mostly in the
land and buildings of the compound,
against liabilities of more than $5.8 mil
lion, his share of the $6.3 million lawsuit
judgment.
Under the Chapter 7 bankruptcy fil
ing, his assets are to be liquidated to
pay his debts, said Norm Gissel, the at
torney who represented Victoria and Ja
son Keenan, who were attacked by giards
outside the Aryan Nations compound.
The compound was scheduled to
be turned over to die Keenans this week,
but Gissel said that likely will not hap
pen because of the filing.
“It means justice is delayed, but
not denied,” Gissel said.
The Keenans were chased and shot
at by Aryan Nations security guards near
the group’s compound in 1998. Jurors
ruled on Sept. 7 that Butler and his or
ganization were negligent in selecting
and overseeing the guards, who assault
ed the Keenans after they had stopped to
search for a dropped wallet near the com
pound’s entrance.
The bankruptcy filing came on the
heels of Saturday’s Aryan Nations parade
through downtown Coeur d’Alene. The
parade drew about two dozen marchers,
who were shouted down by hundreds of
protesters in what may have been the last
hurrah of the Aryan Nations.
Directly behind the marchers were
two city street-sweeping trucks.
“It was a symbolic move,” Police
Chief Tom Cronin said. “We swept them
out of town.”
After the parade, Butler tried to hold
a news conference at a room he had rent
ed in the Coeur d’Alene Inn. But hotel
security and police officers blocked the
door to the hotel.
It was another bitter pill for the Aryan
Nations to swallow. Once ignored, if not
exactly tolerated, the Aryan Nations in
recent years has faced rising opposition
in Idaho. Attacked by politicians, busi
ness and religious leaders, Butler and his
followers have found themselves ever
more isolated.
Butler held a final news conference
Saturday at the compound that has
been the group’s headquarters since the
1970s. He has already moved out, so there
was no electricity. It was dark and cold
in the church.
A stained-glass window behind the
pulpit, which showed the Aryan Nations’
shield and swastika symbol, had been shat
tered by a vandal’s rock.
Butler railed from his pulpit against
the trial that cost him his home.
“A lot of people know it was a rail
road job,” Butler said. “You know it, and
I know it.”
“They were able to steal a man’s
property,” Butler said.
Relatives of EgyptAir
crash victims congregate
for one-year anniversary
by David rising
Associated Press
NEWPORT, R.l. — Relatives of the
217 victims of the crash of EgyptAir
Flight 990 gathered Tuesday, the first
anniversary of the disaster, to dedicate
a memorial whose rough-hewn sides
symbolize their pain.
The granite memorial stands in a
seaside park in the city where families
went a year ago after the Boeing 767
plunged into the Atlantic off the Mass
achusetts island of Nantucket.
More than 500 relatives, friends
and dignitaries attended the memorial
service, which began about an hour late
as buses brought people to Brenton Point
State Park.
Some mourners held flowers and
some cried as a chill wind whipped the
tent shielding them.
National Transportation Safety
Board Chairman James Hall arrived ear
ly and spoke with family members
before speaking at the ceremony. Rhode
Island Gov. Lincoln Almond ordered
all state flags flown at half-staff for the
day.
In Egypt, independent religious cer
emonies also were held Tuesday to
mourn those killed when the plane
crashed about an hour after taking off
from New York en route to Cairo.
There has been no final determi
nation of the crash’s cause, but there
has been speculation that co-pilot
Ganieel 0-Batouty deliberately crashed
the plane. Egyptians have vehemently
rejected that possibility, instead favor
ing theories that a missile or mechani
cal failure were to blame.
The granite monument is roughly
hewn on three of its four sides, sym
bolizing the families’ difficult journey
since the crash.
An inscription in gold lettering on
a black background reads: “In loving
memory of the 217 family members
and friends lost on Egypt Air Right 990.
... May God’s eternal light shine upon
them.”
The final phrase, “They are not
gone from us,” is inscribed in French,
Arabic and English.
On the ground before the monu
ment are 217 bricks etched with the
names of those who died.
“There’s nothing beautiful about
it,” said Jack Afonso of Riverside Stone
Co., who created the monument. “This
is to commemorate the dead.” Beyond
the monument is a panoramic view of
the ocean, the sound of the waves lap
ping against the rocks a few hundred
feet away.
Five coffins of the unidentified
remains recovered from the crash site
have already been buried in the Island
Cemetery. A sixth was to be buried Tues
day in a private service for the families.
Israel attacks Arafat s headquarters
as retaliation for killings of 2 Israelis
■ No casualties
reported in latest
round of violence
by Sergei
Shargorodsky
Associated Press
JERUSALEM — Israeli helicopter gun
ships rocketed command centers of Pales
tinian leader Yasser Arafat’s movement
in the West Bank and Gaza Strip overnight
in retaliation for the slayings of two Is
raelis, presumably by Palestinians.
In the wake of the tough response,
Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak worked
Tuesday to build a political alliance with
the ultra-Orthodox Shas party, while
prospects faded for a partnership with the
hawkish Likud faction.
For several weeks, Barak had sought
to bring Likud leader Ariel Sharon into
his crumbling minority government. Con
tacts broke down Monday night, after the
prime minister refused to grant Likud a
veto right over future peace talks.
An angry Sharon said Barak could no
longer be trusted.
“Apparently, he is not fit to lead the
country,” said Sharon, whose Sept. 28
visit to a contested Jerusalem shrine was
cited by the Palestinians as a trigger for
Israeli-Palestinian fighting.
Since that day, 143 people, the vast
majority Palestinians, have been killed in
gun battles and rock-throwing clashes.
Israel unleashed its helicopter gun
ships late Monday, in retaliation for a
deadly shooting attack on an Israeli se
curity guard in an Arab area of Jerusalem,
and the stabbing death of an Israeli resi
dent of the city’s Jewish neighborhood
of Gilo.
Arafat said the helicopter raids would
not shake the resolve of young Palestin
ian activists, “these children who
throw the stones to defend Jerusalem, the
Muslims and the holy places.”
In Nablus, the largest Wfest Bank town,
Palestinians shot in the air as they heard
the roar of helicopter engines, but
failed to prevent the gunships from send
ing two missiles into the Fatah office in
the city.
Israeli machine gun fire also damaged
the temple and offices of the biblical
Samaritans, followers of an offshoot of
Judaism. About 600 Samaritans live in
two communities, one in Israel and one
in Nablus.
Samaritan leaders said Israeli troops
were aware of the location of the shrine
when they opened fire. “This is a sa
cred place and they should respect it,”
said temple caretaker Fathi Abu Hassan.
Col. Raanan Gissin, a spokesman for
the Israeli army, said Israel fired warning
shots first in order not to injure civilians.
Gunships also strafed Fatah offices in
the West Bank town of El Bireh, injuring
five people, witnesses said. Israeli aircraft
also flew over die Gaza Strip, hitting com
mand outposts belonging to Force 17,
Arafat’s elite bodyguard unit, and Fatah
offices in the towns of Khan Yunis and
Rafah.
Barak’s chief police adviser, Danny
Yatom, said the rocket attacks were in
tended as a warning to Fatah, whose gun
men have taken the lead in shooting at
tacks on Israeli targets. “We are trying to
signal to the Palestinians that we know
who is responsible,” Yatom told Israel
army radio Tuesday.
Monday night’s attack was one of the
most intense in 34 days of fighting.
The Israeli military has said it is chang
ing tactics and going on the offensive
against Palestinian gunmen, deploying
special units trained in guerrilla warfare.
Deputy Defense Minister Ephraim
Sneh said Israel officials “do not want to
broaden and deteriorate the conflict,” but
instead seek to restore calm and return
to the negotiating table.
“What we are doing in the battlefield
right now stems from this strategic goal,”
he said.
Israel’s chief peace negotiator, Gilead
Sher, has said President Clinton has put
together ideas for reviving peace talks,
and that Israel was willing to consider
them. Clinton spoke to Barak for half an
hour by phone Monday night.
The president has invited Barak and
Arafat to Washington for separate talks,
though no date has been set.
One of the obstacles to a resumption
of negotiations has been the political in
stability in Israel, exacerbated by the
reconvening of Israel’s parliament Mon
day after a three-month recess.