The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, October 20, 2000, Page 5, Image 5
101E (Bamecoci!
State Department teaches workers
how to prevent further security lapses
by George Gedda
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Paper shredders,
State Department employees are told,
must trim classified documents down to
slices no larger than 1/32 inches by 1/2
inches. Disposal can also be achieved,
they are advised, with machines that that
can “pulverize” secrets into powder. Safes
storing sensitive materials must weigh at
least 500 pounds, wliich are too heavy to
be carted off.
James D. Tromatter makes these
points tirelessly in briefing after brief
ing as part of the State Department’s in
tensified efforts to keep employees se
curity conscious.
Since May, about 9,000 employees
liave heard the message from the amiable,
yet no-nonsense Tromatter, who gave up
his Army career four years ago to become
a security expert at the State Department.
Attendance is mandatory.
Secretary of State Madeleine Al
bright’s goal is to end a string of securi
ty lapses that have plagued the depart
ment, the result, many in Congress believe,
of a cillture that is inattentive to securi
ty requirements.
There was the case of the Russian spy
operation a year ago that involved use of
a sopliisticated eavesdropping device plant
ed in a seventh-floor conference room.
The Russian who got caught listening to
the device outside the State Department
was sent packing last December. Who
planted the device remains a mystery.
More significant is the case of the lap
top computer with highly classified in
formation that disappeared around Feb.
1 from a conference room in the Bureau
of Intelligence and Research. It was al
leged to have contained highly classified
information about amis proliferation is
sues and about sources and methods of
U.S. intelligence collection.
The lapses left Albright feeling “hu
miliated.” At a meeting of State De
partment employees, she dispensed with
the ambiguities so common to her trade.
“I don’t care how skilled you are as
a diplomat, how brilliant you may be at
meetings, or how creative you are as an
administrator, if you are not a professional
about security, you are a Mure,” she said.
Less than three weeks later, Tromatter
began his series of briefings, which con
sist laigely of reminders: Top secret ma
terial is always covered by a special sheet
that identifies it as such. Use red “secret”
labels on computer disks that have been
used on classified computers. To hand
carry top secret information requires a
top secret clearance.
Copying of top secret materials must
be carried out by a “top secret control
olficer.” Secret and confidential materi
als can only be copied on designated ma
chines. Since the briefings began, Tro
matter says reports of infiactions are down
by about 20 percent.
‘I don’t care how skilled you are as a diplomat,
how brilliant you may be at meetings, or how cre
ative you are as an administrator, if you are not a
professional about security, you are a failure.'
Madeline Albright
Secretary of State
Tromatter, a native of Williamsbuig,
Va., says the most common security in
fraction involves leaving a classified doc
ument uncovered on a desk.
He says that of the various threats the
Department faces, none is greater than
what he calls “sigint,” or signals intelli
gence. It involves the intercept by unau
thorized persons of classified materials
sent by facsimile or telephone.
The security lapses did not go un
noticed on Capitol Hill.
“It is obvious that the Department
lacks a professional environment that is
sensitive to security concerns,” said House
International Relations Committee chair
man Benjamin Gilman, R-N.Y.
“There is not sufficient awareness,
or sufficient attention, to security” at the
Department, said Porter Goss, R-Fl., chair
man of the House Intelligence Commit
tee.
It hasn’t been easy for Albright to
overcome these perceptions. Not long
after her speech to Department employ
ees, Sen. Rod Grams, R-Minn., a mem
her of the Senate Foreign Relations Com
mittee, complained that six foreign ser
vice officers nominated for ambassador
ships had committed a total of 62 security
infractions, including one with 22 on his
record.
To Grams, it seemed hard to recon
cile Albright’s warnings about the need
for vigilance with coveted promotions
for people not always attentive to secu
rity issues.
Grams held up the nominations for
months, but then allowed them to clear*
the Senate after extracting further con
cessions from the State Department on
employee accountability for infractions.
Congress kept up the heat on the ad
ministration this week by approving a bill
that subjects government employees to
up to three years in prison for willfully
disclosing nearly any classified informa
tion.
The bill was passed despite warnings
that it gives the government a blank check
to criminalize any leaking it does not like.
U.S. representatives quarreling over
record $40 billion education budget
by Anjetta McQueen
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — The partisan bat
tle over how to spend a record $40
billion education budget heated up Thurs
day with President Clinton making a trip
to Capitol Hill to boost the Democrat
ic plan and House Republicans portrayiiig
the administration as throwing money
at unproven programs.
At a rally featuring schoolcltildren
from North Carolina, Republican
leaders stud the White House declined
offers of $3 billion to $6 billion more
for education in exchange for giving
schools more leeway on spending.
Clinton and the Democrats have in
sisted money be set aside to hire
teachers and build schools. They met
increased resistance Thursday.
“I don’t know that we can resolve
this issue in this Congress,” said Rep.
Jolin Porter, R-Ill., chaimian of tire House
Appropriations subcommittee that over
sees education spending. “This might
have to be sorted out by the American
people.”
With vetoes and his party’s popu
larity ai the issue, Clinton lias succeeded
in recent years in forcing Republicans
to compromise on new teachers and
school construction. On Thursday, less
than three weeks before national elec
tions, he prepared to rally around De
mocrats who are faced with cutting a
deal with Republicans who have won
increased public approval on the issue.
“It’s a fight with no fighters,”
Senate Minority Leader Tom Daschle,
D-S.D., said Wednesday, complaining
that Republicans are unwilling to dis
cuss compromise.
John Czwartacki, spokesman for
Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott, R
Miss., said Clinton and the Democrats
have been unwilling to deal: “ Wfe could
have been out of here Oct. 1.”
Black Democrats are accusing their
own party leaders of not putting enough
attention on improving education for
the poor.
The education bucket is part of three
spending bills being negotiated by law
makers and the White House for the
budget year that began Oct. 1. Leaders
planned a fourth temporary spending
bill Thursday to keep agencies going.
Democrats are battling for specific
money to hire new teachers and repair
crumbling schools. Republicans still want
to give states the option of spending the
money on other programs such as spe
cial education and reading lessons.
Clinton and the Democrats could
use a showdown to brand the GOP as
the foe of popular priorities such as new
teachers and after-school programs. Re
publicans could use a low-key com
promise over a big public fight that re
minds voters the GOP once advocated
abolishing the Education Department.
“The Republican leadership is run
ning out the clock,” said Joel Packer, a
lobbyist for the National Education As
sociation teachers union.
Bickering over education is hardly
new.
Last year’s education budget passed
only after a deal dial allowed new mon
ey earmarked for teachers but gave states
leeway to spend some money on other
programs. A key federal education
law, parts of which expired last year, has
not been renewed.
The last major education bill Clin
ton signed, in 1999„expanded an ex
perimental program that exempts states
from some federal rules if the states show
improved learning by children.
Congress will have to answer for
the lack of progress, said Rep. Major
Owens, D-N.Y.. a member of the
Congressional Black Caucus, which
wants the debate focused on the poor
est schools.
“We are trying to do a get-out-the
vote campaign, and we are empty-hand
ed on education,” he said. “In the
endgame, very unusual things happen.
It’s time for them to happen in our fa
vor.”
Greenspan says nation’s good economy
might be affected by rising energy costs
■ High oil prices
could still cause
surge in inflation
BY JEANNINE AVERSA
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Federal Reserve
Chairman Alan Greenspan said policy
makers will keep watch on surging en
ergy prices to make sure they don’t spoi
the nation’s economic good times.
On Wall Street Thursday, stocks were
recovering some of Wednesday’s losses
By late morning, the Dow Jones indus
trial average had gained 88 points and th<
Nasdaq index added 172.
While the recent surge in oil prices
wliich ltit a 10-year liigli of $37.80 in Sep
tember, hits not produced higher overal
inflation, Greenspan cautioned that risk
remain, especially given the “politica
difficulties” in the Middle East.
“Even though the intensity of oil con
sumption is markedly below where it wa
30 years ago, it still has the potential ti
alter the forces governing economic
growth in the United States,” Greenspai
said Thursday in remarks to a monetar
policy conference.
“Policy-makers will need to be oi
the alert for oil-driven, indeed energy
driven, risks to our expansion,” Greenspan
said.
When crude-oil prices spiked last
month, President Clinton announced
he would tap the government’s emer
gency petroleum reserve to help offset
soaring prices.
November crude futures, which had
pulled back nearly 10 percent this
week following a suige sparked by Mideast
violence, gained 49 cents to $33.48 a bar
rel in trading on the New York Mercan
tile Exchange Wednesday.
Greenspan said that in the short run,
oil prices are heavily influenced by in
ventory levels. Those levels have dropped
significantly since decisions by the Or
ganization of the Petroleum Exporting
Countries in 1998 and 1999 to cut pro
duction by more than 3 million barrels
a day.
Since that time, OPEC has boosted
1 production to what are now record lev
' els, but Greenspan said hoarding by wor
1 ried distributors and consumers may be
limiting the impact of the increased pro
duction.
’ “In the short run, the price of oil,
1 as that of all commodities, inevitably is
influenced importantly by inventory lev
1 els, especially when stocks become crit
ically short,” Greenspan said.
Energy prices shot up 3.8 percent
1 in September, the biggest advance since
June. In the first nine months of the year,
gasoline prices rose at an annual rate of
22.4 percent mid heating-oil costs at an
annual rate of 49.4 percent.
Even with these increases, Greenspan
noted, “To date, die spillover from the
surge in oil prices has been modest.”
The Federal Reserve has raised in
terest rates six times since June 1999 to
slow the economy and stave off inflation.
Greenspan did not directly discuss the fu
ture course of interest-rate policy in Thurs
day’s speech.
The Fed on Oct. 3 passed up the
chance to raise rates for a seventh time,
but cautioned that the increase in ener
gy prices “poses a risk of raising inflation
expectations.”
In a separate speech, Fed board mem
ber Laurence Meyer said Thursday that
soaring oil prices, while contributing to
short-term inflationary pressures, are like
ly to decline by spring.
“If the expectations in futures prices
for oil prove correct, we may soon be
treated to an extended period of decline
in oil prices,” Meyer said.
Despite higher energy prices, con
sumer spending has remained firm,
Greenspan said in his remarks. General
ly, when consumers have to shell out
more for more expensive gasoline, heat
ing oil and other energy products, they
have less to spend on other items.
The U.S. economy is in its longest
ever streak of uninterrupted growth, with
unemployment at a 30-year low and in
flation largely in check.
Even before last week’s escalating vi
olence in the Middle East, oil price pres
sures had been strong, Greenspan said.
“This largely owed to the possibili
ty of a politically driven removal of a sig
nificant part of Iraq’s 2.5 million to 3 mil
lion barrels a day from global markets
at a time when there exists so little avail
able world excess capacity to replace it,”
Greenspan explained.
Greenspan also said growing federal
budget surpluses have been an important
source of national savings, reducing up
ward pressure on long-tenn interest rates.
He wondered whether that would
continue.
“I believe most of us harbor doubts
about whether the dynamics of the po
litical process, some of which have been
on display in the current budgetary de
liberations, will allow the surpluses to
continue to grow,”he said.
Greenspan also noted the strong suige
in productivity growth, which has helped
to keep inflation in check. But, as in the
past, he cautioned that the strong pro
ductivity growth rates experienced in re
cent years inevitably will slow.
American businessman
accused of spying in
Russia losing hope
by Nick Wadhams
Associated Press
MOSCOW — An American busi
nessman accused of spying in Russia has
lost hope he’ll be given a fair trial and
probably will limit his testimony to a
prepared statement, his lawyer said
Thursday.
Edmond Pope, discouraged with
the first court session held Wednesday,
may read a 40-page statement he has
written and then keep silent for the rest
of the trial in hopes of getting it over
with quickly.
“I think he wants this whole night
mare to end as quickly as possible, and
when there is a verdict, to then plan his
next move,” Pope’s lawyer Pavel As
takhov told The Associated Press.
Pope, a retired U.S. Navy officer
from State College, Pa., was arrested
April 3 by Russia’s Federal Security
Service on charges that he tried to
buy plans for a high-speed Russian tor
pedo. He faces up to 20 years in prison
_•
11 WIK1VIVU.
The court turned down several de
fense requests Wednesday. It refused
Pope’s appeal to replace his Federal Se
curity Service translator with an inde
pendent one or give him more time to
read his indictment. Astakhov said Pope
hadn’t been able to study the indict
ment thoroughly, and said Pope told
him the document was so poorly trans
lated it was incomprehensible in places.
“How can you prepare for the court
trial when you don’t know exactly what
you are indicted for?” Astakhov said.
Pope says he’s innocent, and the
United States has called repeatedly for
his release from Moscow’s Lefortovo
prison. Russian officials have accused
U.S. officials of meddling in their legal
system.
Astakhov said Pope was also furi
ous that his Russian associate, a uni
versity professor named Anatoly Babkin,
was not on the list of prosecution wit
nesses. The defense has asked that
Babkin testify because he helped Pope
in his search for unclassified naval equip
ment designs.
“We hoped that the court would
be fair, but after it made these decisions,
Edmond realized prosecutors wouldn’t
have to prove his guilt, but he would
have to prove his innocence,” Astakhov
said.
Pope will make a final decision
on whether to testify by Friday, when
the trial is set to resume and Judge
Nina Barkina will read the 26-page
indictment against him.
Efe may be counting on the good
will of Russian President Vladimir Putin,
who hinted on CNN’s Larry King Live
last month that Pope could be relumed
to thp TInitpH ^tutpc pvpn if ronvirt
ed.
The defense’s one victory on
Wednesday was that Barkina agreed
to a medical examination to determine
whether Pope, who has suffered from
a rare form of bone cancer, is fit to stand
trial. It still wasn’t known if the judge
would agree to Pope’s request that he
be seen by an American doctor.
Russian doctors already have de
cided that Pope is fit to stand trial. As
takhov said his client was losing weight
and had vision trouble.
“What can I say, he’s a sick man in
prison, and in my opinion, he’s get
ting sicker,” Astakhov said!
Six other prisoners are in Pope’s
cell at Lefortovo, and Pope is suffering
from secondhand cigarette smoke, he
said.
Pope worked for the Applied Re
search Laboratory at Pennsylvania State
University. He later founded CERF
Technologies International, a compa
ny specializing in studying foreign mar
itime equipment, and traveled to Rus
sia dozens of times.
Pope’s supporters and family say
he was seeking information on an un
derwater propulsion system that is at
least 10 years old and has already
been sold abroad.
Independent counsel
issues final report
on travel office firings
by Pete Yost
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Independent
Counsel Robert Ray challenged Hillary
Rodham Clinton’s testimony and crit
icized “uncooperative” presidential
aides in a final report on the 7-year-old
controversy over mass dismissals in the
White House travel office. The re
port became an instant issue in the first
lady’s Senate race in New York.
Ray concluded that Clinton gave
“factually false” testimony, but he de
cided not to prosecute her because he
could not prove she intended to de
ceive when she denied having a role in
the May 1993 purge of the travel of
fice. Ray said Clinton might not have
even known her contacts with presi
dential aides had instigated the firings.
Bill Powers, chairman of the
New York state Republican Party,
said the prosecutor’s report “once again
makes us question” Clinton’s believ
ability.
“We believe that character counts
in public service,” said Clinton’s Re
publican opponent in the Nov. 7 elec
• Inn Dnn Diol/ T nun
Clinton’s lawyer, David Kendall,
called the prosecutor’s conclusions
about factually inaccurate testimony
“highly unfair and misleading.” The fi
nal report “recognizes she may not
have even been aware of any influence
she may have had on the firing deci
sion,” Kendall wrote.
Also, the White House noted Ray’s
report found evidence of financial ir
regularities at the time of the firings in
side the travel office, which handles
travel arrangements for the White House
press corps.
“The report recognizes thai Mrs.
Clinton was rightfully concerned about
the financial improprieties in the trav
el office,” White House press secretary
Jake Siewert said Wednesday.
Outside auditors in 1993 identified
at least $ 18,200 in missing checks and
improperly recorded or unrecorded
petty cash transactions in the travel of
fice.
Locked in a tight race for the
senate, Mrs. Clinton dismissed die find
ngs during a campaign stop in Syra
:use, N.Y. “Most New Yorkers and
Americans have made up their minds
ibout this,” she said.
Ray singled out a number of for
mer White House aides for engaging in
“serious resistance” to investigators’
questions about Mrs. Clinton’s part in
the firings, declaring that “witnesses
were uncooperative in this office’s
investigation.”
Ray cited fomier White House cliief
of staff Mack McLarty, ex-deputy chief
of staff Harold Ickes, Lisa Caputo, Pat
sy Thomasson and Jeff Eller. Caputo is
Mrs. Clinton’s fomier press secre
tary, Thomasson is a fomier deputy of
David Whtkins, who fired the travel of
fice employees, and Eller is a fomier
deputy press secretary.
McLarty insisted he had been
“completely forthcoming and truthful
at all times” with investigators, who
asserted that McLarty had given
varying accounts of a conversaUon with
Wr^ Plintnn
Ickes told prosecutors he had no
memory of a two-hour meeting eight
days before the travel office firings with
Hollywood producer Harry Thomason,
a key figure in the controversy. At the
time, Ickes was a private attorney.
Ickes told Ray’s office he had “no
idea” where the meeting with Thoma
son was held, that he did not “recall
who was there, if anyone,” what city
it was held in or what was discussed.
Prosecutors said Eller claimed a
lack of memory more than 200 times
in less than two hours of grand jury tes
timony.
The continuing White House e
mail controversy also played a role in
Ray’s final report, with the prosecutoi
saying computer messages receiver
in June this year could have been usee
to refresh the recollection of Eller hat
they been available during the inves
tigation. Because of a computer prob
lem that the White House failed to dis
close, thousands of e-mails were nevei
turned over to investigators.