The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, February 04, 2000, Page A3, Image 3
Investigators recover second
Alaska Airlines ‘black box’
by Matthew Fordahl
Associated Press
Los Angeles — Investigators found
the second “black box” recorder from
Alaska Airlines Flight 261 on Thursday,
quickly locating the devices that could
tell them why the plane flipped upside
down and plummeted into the ocean.
Navy crews off Southern California
recovered Flight 261 ’s cockpit flight da
ta recorder. It should show the positions
of the plane’s controls and whether a
problem with the horizontal stabilizer
was merely a symptom of a larger failure
that led to Monday’s crash and the deaths
of all 88 aboard.
“That will tell the tale,” said William
Wbldock, associate director for the Cen
ter for Aerospace Safety Education at
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University.
The MD-83 jetliner’s other “black
box” was recovered Wfednesday. It records
cockpit communications and showed the
crew had problems with the horizontal
stabilizer, a device on the tail of the plane
which keeps the aircraft level.
It captured the voices of the pilots
trying to gain control of the jetliner as
it rolled, flipped and spiraled nose-first
into the water, confirming what witnesses
saw.
“The crew made references to being
inverted,” National Transportation Safe
ty Board Chairman James Hall said in
Washington, referring to the contents
of the recorder.
The Navy used an underwater robot
to locate the boxes about 200 feet apart
and roughly 640 feet beneath the surface
of the Pacific.
The remotely operated submersible
Scorpio 1 found the boxes in the debris
zone, about 10 miles off the Ventura
County coast within 20 hours of each
other — the cockpit voice recorder on
Wednesday around 5 p.m. and the data
recorder around noon Thursday.
From the beginning the investigation
has focused on the horizontal stabilizer
because the pilots had reported problems
with it.
Jammed or out-of-control horizon
tal stabilizers have led to at least a half
dozen emergency landings but never a
crash of a commercial airplane, federal
records show.
A review of problems involving the
device over the last 20 years show jam
ming is rare but has never driven a plane
totally out of control.
An Associated Press examination of
aviation records found that at least 20 in
flight problems with stabilizers were se
rious enough to be reported to the Fed
eral Aviation Administration or the NTSB
since 1979.
In two-thirds of those cases, the flights
peached their intended destination. Oth
ers made emergency landings, includ
ing an American Airlines MD-83, which
returned to Phoenix minutes after tak
ing off Tuesday.
More than a half dozen involved jets
made by McDonnell Douglas, which al
so built the MD-83 that crashed off South
ern California. Five of those cases in
volved planes with stabilizers mounted
high on the tail, like the MD-83.
Trouble similar to what Flight 261
pilots reported never before led to a crash
in the United States, according to experts
and aviation reports.
The stabilizer, a wing at the tail end
of an aircraft, is designed to adjust — or
trim — the up-or-down angle of an air
craft’s nose. The device’s movement,
controlled by two motors, is restricted
so that the plane does not react violent
ly
“It’s like the small corrections you
make in the steering wheel going down
the freeway. Unless you’re really hand
fisted, people don’t feel all those small
corrections,” said Capt. Steve Roach, a
pilot union official who flew MD-83s for
three years.
If the horizontal stabilizer starts mov
ing on its own — something called run
away trim — pilots can usually stop it by
pulling circuit breakers and using other
controls. In most cases, it will stop be
fore reaching an extreme angle.
In most aircraft, including the MD
83, a jammed stabilizer can be overrid
den by moving elevators attached to its
trailing edge and controlled by pulling
forward or backward on the yoke in the
cockpit.
If it jammed at an extreme position,
the pilots must exert more pressure on
the yoke but still should be able to main
tain control.
“I have flown it in the simulator with
the fully runaway trim, and that’s quite
a handful to fly,” Roach said. “It’s out of
limit for the autopilot. You’re handfly
ing it and having to maintain a consider
able amount of pressure on the controls
to keep the plane straight and level.”
Though horizontal stabilizer prob
lems are rare, regulators last May gave
airlines 18 months to inspect hinges con
necting parts of the tail for signs of cor
rosion. An error during manufacture can
cause the hinges to rust more easily.
The Alaska Airlines jet that crashed
had not yet undeigone the inspection, but
10 of the MD-80s in the fleet did and
showed no usual corrosion, said airline
spokesman David Marriott. Records on
other airlines’ fleets were not immedi
ately available.
Rod Mar KRT
A memorial to the victims of the crash of Alaska Airlines Right 261 stands on the beach Feb. 1 at La Janelle
Park in Oxnard, California. All 88 passengers and crew died when the plane crashed January 3L
GOP establishment
gets jitters after Bush's
New Hampshire defeat
by Ron Fournier
Associated Press
Washington—Republican strategists,
elected officials, fund-raisers and other
early backers of Geoige W. Bush are ner
vously sifting through his stunning defeat
in New Hampshire and demanding a
change in tactics from their troubled front
runner.
The GOP establishment, heavily in
vested in the Texas governor’s success,
has a case of the jitters.
“You’ve got to believe it is hard to
get through to the ‘202’ exchange to
day because the lines are buzzing about
this in Washington," said Nelson Whrfield,
former press secretary for 1996 nominee
Bob Dole.
th “I’m bleeding for the guy right now,”
said Rich Bond, who was an operative for
the candidate’s father, former President
Bush. “Most professionals will tell you
Bush will prevail,” he said, but the shock
of an 18-point loss “should give one who
cares about politics and, in my case,
George W. Bush, great pause.”
With McCain passing up Delaware’s
primary next week, South Carolina’s Feb.
19 contest has become critical for both
men. Bush’s formidable lead in state polls
evaporated overnight with the news of
his New Hampshire finish, according to
two sets of South Carolina surveys re
leased Thursday.
“The prop-wash of defeat is going to
be around for a while,” Bush told re
porters Thursday, adding a thought for
the second-guessers: “Tell them to hold
fteir breath because they’ve got some
body who’s about to win the Republican
nomination.”
Interviews with more than a dozen
GOP leaders across the country, most of
whom support Bush, underscored the
party establishment’s strong belief that
the Texan eventually will win the nom
ination, given his formidable resources
and lead in most national and state Dolls.
Yet several troubling themes kept
cropping up:
• The sense of inevitability that
cloaked Bush’s candidacy is in tatters. “I
think if his odds were 20 to 1 before New
Hampshire, they’re probably 10 to 1
now,” said Bush fund-raiser Ted Wfelch.
“He needs to pull things together, and he
will.”
• He must be more critical of Mc
Cain. “Bush is going to have to get up
and fight,” said Rep. John Kasich of Ohio,
who dropped out of the presidential race
in July and endorsed the Texas governor.
• He must convince voters that he is
prepared to be president. “I think that
Governor Bush has really got to bone up
on a tremendous number of issues,” said
Sen. Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania, who
has not endorsed a candidate but said the
Bush team suffers from “an inevitable
sense of complacency.” Exit polls show
that one-third of New Hampshire Re
publican voters did not think Bush had
the knowledge needed to serve effec
tively.
• He needs to be more spontaneous,
because McCain shines by comparison.
“I think he was overhandled and over
scripted,” said New Hampshire GOP
chairman Steve Duprey.
• Endorsements don’t always help,
and maybe hurt. McCain’s staff and some
Bush advisers believe the father’s back
ing of “this boy” diminished the candi
date in the eyes of New Hampshire vot
ers. “The endorsement strategy needs to
be shelved,” said Scott Reed, Dole’s 19%
campaign manager who is not tied to a
campaign.
Some Bush allies pointed to former
Vice President Dan Quayle’s endorse
ment in South Carolina on Wfednesday as
evidence that his political team still does
n’t get it.
BtTsh’s own surveys suggest that South
Carolina voters, long tom between the
Texas governor and conservative Steve
Forbes, now lean toward McCain.
They argue, however, that the family’s
political legacy in South Carolina and the
state’s older, more conservative voters
will turn the polls around once McCain’s
momentum subsides.
The answer, they say, is to sharpen
the distinctions between Bush and Mc
Cain, particularly on taxes, campaign fi
nance reform, abortion and the Arizo
nan’s claim to be a political outsider. Bush
hit McCain on all but abortion in New
Hampshire, but one adviser said surro
gates, direct mail and TV ads will be used
in South Carolina to reinforce the dis
tinctions.
The political team was debating how
to calibrate the attacks.
Bush accused McCain on Thursday
of practicing “ Wellington-style politics.”
His campaign spotlighted veteran Thomas
Burch, who told one Bush cjowd that
McCain “foigot us” after returning from
a Vietnam prisoner of war camp.
The Texan also plans to turn to his
fellow governors for support, though their
ranks include Bush allies who are still
baffled that his New Hampshire team did
n’t take advantage of political troops they
dispatched to the state.
Oklahoma Gov. Frank Keating said
Bush must show voters “that he has
just as much character and integrity as
McCain.”
Massachusetts Gov. Paul Cellucci,
a strong Bush ally still convinced Bush
will win, said, “I think his message will
be sharpened now that he’s out of New
Hampshire and that message must be that
George Bush is the outsider, not John
McCain.”
Gore: Better prepared
for Congress than
Clinton was in 1992
by Sandra Sobieraj
Associated Press
Los ANGELES—Asked to defend the
administration’s spotty record of work
ing with Congress, Vice President A1
Gore suggested Thursday that his re
sume makes him better prepared for
the White House than Bill Clinton was
in 1992.
Democratic rival Bill Bradley, work
ing the other end of California, kept up
his focus on differences between Gore
and himself. At a San Francisco rally,
he said national health care “has been
a part of the Democratic platform for
50 years” and is “one of those issues in
this campaign that distinguishes me
from A1 Gore.”
Gore, he said, “doesn’t have any
• plan to get to universal health care.”
Bradley’s hopes fora spectacular
bayside rally with the Golden Gate
Brieve as backdrop fell through because
of ram. Instead, more than 1,000 peo
ple jammed a restaurant to hear his re
marks.
Gore was in southern California
with Gov. Gray Davis, touring Digital
Domain and inspecting the firm’s
special-effects technology being used
to put together “The Red Planet,” a
W Kilmer film due in June.
Gore noted with a bit of envy:
“Must be a fun place to work.”
Californians, he said, “will have a
very decisive voice in picking the
Democratic nominee.” The state, wliich
holds its primary on March 7, has 367
of the 2,170 delegates needed to clinch
the nomination.
In a question-and-answer session
with employees, film editor Bill
Brier told the vice president he was dis
appointed with the Clinton-Gore ad
ministration’s record with a resistant
~ -
Democrats see page m
Bauer to quit GOP race
by Ron Fournier
Associated Press
Washington — Gary Bauer, the jani
tor’s son who served in Ronald Reagan’s
White House and mounted a presiden
tial bid of his own, has decided to drop
out of the race, a source close to the con
servative activist said today.
The official, speaking on condition
of anonymity, said Bauer plans to an
nounce the move at a news conference
Friday morning.
Bauer is a well-established social con
servative who fared well in presidential
debates, needling front-runner George
W. Bush on abortion and China policy.
He also had some success raising money,
primarily through a large network of small
donors built during his work as a con
servative activis&n Washington.
Bauer had trouble carving out a con
stituency in a crowded field of GOP con
servatives.
He could not climb above 1 per
cent in the critical New Hampshire pri
mary. With his wife Carol at his side, he
conceded that contest Tuesday night, and
said the voters of New Hampshire “have
not endorsed me but without hesitation
I endorse them as being great citizens.”
Bauer has struggled to even make a
dent in national polls, and finished in
fourth place in the Iowa caucuses, ahead
of only Sen. Onin Hatch of Utah, who
has since dropped out of the race, and
Sen. John McCain of Arizona, who did
not campaign in Iowa at all.
“Gary is having a news conference
on Friday. That’s all we’re saying about
it,” said spokesman Tim-Goeglein.
He would be the sixth Republican
—DresidentiaLcandidateto drnn out.
News Briefs
■ Seton Hall to place
sprinklers in 2 dorms
South Orange, N J. (AP) — Seton
Hall University has announced that it will
install sprinkler systems immediately in
its two dormitories that lack them, in
cluding one where a recent blaze killed
three students.
Three 18-year-old freshmen died in
the Jan. 19 fire at Boland Hall. No charges
have been filed, though The Star-Ledger
of Newark reported Wednesday that in
vestigators believe the fire was set.
University spokeswoman Lisa Grid
er discussed the sprinklers Wednesday,
but referred all questions about the re
port to the Essex County prosecutor’s
office. Executive Assistant Prosecutor
Charlotte Smith said her office would not
comment on it.
The newspaper said investigators be
lieve'the fire, which injured more than
60 students, may have resulted from a
feud between a group of students and non
students who were in the building the
night of the blaze. It said they had not
concluded whether the third-floor lounge
fire was started as a prank or an attempt
to harm someone.
A student resident adviser had asked
three visitors to leave Boland Hall less
than an hour before the fire broke out.
Investigators said they believe one of the
three remained in the building, located
on the campus of the 9,200-student Ro
man Catholic university.
■ U.S. fighter planes
strike Iraqi air
defense system
Ankara, Turkey (AP) — U.S. war
planes bombed an Iraqi air defense sys
tem in response to artillery fire Thursday
as they patrolled a no-fly zone over north
ern Iraq, the U.S. military said.
The U.S. planes hit a site near
Bashiqah, about 250 miles north of Bagh
dad, the Germany-based U.S. European
Command said in a statement. All of
the planes, based at Incirlik air base in
southern Turkey, left the area safely, the
statement said.
The incident was the eighth con
frontation between U.S. jets and Iraqi
forces in northern Iraq this year.
■ Blair threatens to
disband North
Ireland’s cabinet
London (AP) — Britain will strip pow
er from Northern Ireland’s fledgling
Protestant-Catholic administration with
in days unless the Irish Republican Army
promises to disarm, the government an
nounced today.
Northern Ireland Secretary Peter Man
delson said he would introduce legisla
tion Friday transferring power bachito
London from Belfast. But the process
would take several days and could be
stopped if developments warranted, he
emphasized.
Mandelson’s statement was delivered
to the House of Commons in London and
watched closely by politicians in Belfast
and Dublin. It was designed to buy a lit
tle more time for those struggling day and
night to defuse the crisis that is on the
verge of derailing Northern Ireland’s peace
process.
As Parliament heard the announce
ment, Irish prime minister Bertie Ah
em left Dublin for southern England to
discuss the peace process with British
Prime Minister Tony Blair.
“We cannot partially implement the
Good Friday agreement,” Mandelson said.
“It is all or it is nothing.”
■ Woman gives birth
to triplets for 2nd time
Baltimore (AP) — Defying odds of
about one in 50 million, a woman has giv
en birth to triplets for the second time in
less than two years.
Crystal Comick, 19, who was not us
ing fertility drugs, gave birth Tuesday to
her fourth, fifth and sixth children at
the University of Maryland Hospital. Doc
tors say Comick and her babies should
be able to go home in a week or two.
Comick and her fiance, Richard
Williams, 22, said they were in shock
when they learned they were having
triplets again.
“I was at work, she called me... and
said we’re having triplets. I said, ‘No,
you’re lying, stop lying,”’ Williams said.
The children, Ariel, Tyler and Tyree,
were in stable condition this morning in
the hospital’s neonatal intensive care unit.