The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, January 19, 2000, Encore!, Page 6, Image 20
Special to The Gamecock
Jim Kuning (John C. Reilly) and Claudia Wilson (Melora Walters) become love interests
in P.T. Anderson’s “Magnolia”
'Magnolia' gets mixed reaction
by Patrick Rathbun
Gamecock Critic
“Magnolia” has been described as a “near mir
acle,” and this may be closer to the truth than ac
tually being wrong.
This film is up and coming Director Paul Thomas
Anderson’s third effort (“Hard Eight” and “Boogie
Nights”) and his grandest undertaking to date.
Anderson is extremely successful in most directo
rial aspects of the film, but lacking in others.
For example, Anderson brilliantly inter
twines the lives of several idiosyncratic characters
living in the San Fernando Valley, but has issues
in editing (Sorry, P.T., but there’s no excuse for
three and a half hours).
1 ne ensernme cast oi tne mm serves co sirengui
en its narrative. Most of the gang from “Boogie
Nights,” including William H. Macy, Philip Sey
mour Hoffman, Julianne Moore, John C. Reilly,
Melora Wallers and Philip Baker Hall, all return
with memorable results. The mere return of much
of the solid cast from “Boogie Nights” tells us there
must be something special about tins director. Tom
Cruise and Jason Robards round out the cast with
terrific roles. The movie’s acting is definitely not
its weakness.
And through nearly three hours of the film, I
thought "Magnolia” was bound to go down in movie
history. Its stories or vignettes are Altman-esque
and I’ve heard comparisons to both “Nashville” and
“Short Cuts.” I’d describe Anderson’s collage of
imagery and narrative as works of art, with much
intricacy and even more potential. I sat captivat
ed, unable to blink for the first two and a half hours,
and after the final hour 1 was speechless, unable
to express the range of emotions I went through in
the theatre.
So, Anderson must have been at least semi-suc
cessful in his endeavor because I know I felt
many emotions during the film, and I never had the
urge to walk out. Keeping my attention for three
and a half hours without any hint of confusion is an
accomplishment in itself.
I know “Magnolia” accomplished another es
sential movie requirement. The movie is still in the
back of my mind now, so it did what we ask of
movies: “Magnolia” forced me to take its messages,
queries and themes home with me. It wasn’t just
entertaining for its theater duration, its complexi
ties circled through my mind again and again, weeks
(and possibly months and years) after I saw its cred
its roll on the screen.
I am not one to shy away from epics, but I can’t
understand why directors choose not to do any cut
ting when the same message could’ve been deliv
ered in much less time.
I would recommend seeing “Magnolia” because
its strong points are just too good to miss. Even if
you aren’t a big fan of “Boogie Nights” (I wasn’t),
you should still see it. The wonderful acting by it
self is enough reason to see the film, and Ander
son’s genius interweaving alone is good reason, too.
I would also recommend preparing yourself for the
unordinary if you intend to see it.
At the end of “Magnolia,” a few conclusions
came through to me. The first idea is that Ander
son’s future looks extremely bright, and the sec
ond thing is that if he wants any of his future films
to be remembered as “miraculous,” he must learn
how to edit.
Ratings:
Patrick Rathbun: 3 of 4 stars
Kenley Young: 2
Robert Fleming 3 1/2
Kevin Langston: 2 1/2
'Cider House' opens its doors
by Boyd Fulmer Jr.
Gamecock Critic
In an adaptation of his book, John Irving pre
sents the story of a young man trapped in his own
world. Dr. Wilbur Larch (Michael Caine) runs the
orphanage in which Homer Wfells (Tobey Maguire)
is bom. As Homer grows up, he receives a thor
ough education from Dr. Larch through helping
him run the orphanage.
Dr. Larch tries to provide a good life for the
orphans while struggling with his own downfalls,
such as an addiction to ether.
Dr. Larch provides “good night you princes of
Maine... you kings of New England” every
night, illustrative of the same meticulous manner
in which he runs the orphanage.
As he grows older, Homer struggles with him
self every time he has to help perform an abortion.
As he lives in the orphanage, he becomes well-ed
ucated in what he does, yet he dreams of seeing the
world.
This chance is provided by one of his patients,
Candy Kendall (Charlize Theron), and her ser
viceman boyfriend, Whlly (Paul Rudd).
As he leaves with them, they take him to see
a tew ot tne tmngs ne nas never
seen. Homer gets a job on an
apple/cider farm where he en
counters the crew that will teach
him much about the simple ways
of life.
The ending of the movie is
foreshadowed in the simple ques
tion asked by Mr. Rose (Delroy
Lindo), the head of the season
work crew: “What exactly is your
business, then?”
In this movie, Irving tries to
ask the audience several questions.
He touches on the abortion issue,
which is revealed through Homer’s
everyday battle^ on whether he
should handle the next patient or
the next film splicing.
He draws on the 1930s legal
conception of this problem and what an average
person would think.
Irving also delves into the issues on the effect
of young men leaving for war and how this would
affect the everyday lives of those who care for them
the most.
During Wally’s absence, Homer looks at
Candy as the most beautiful person he has ever
seen. He is immediately forced to deal widi his lack
of emotional growth in dealing with women.
Every part of his life, up until she arrives, has
been centered on taking care of the children in the
orphanage. This is one of the pivotal things that
Homer ponders throughout the film.
This movie is one everyone should see at least
once. The way it unfolds made me want to find
out what else Irving had to sacrifice in making this
movie last just more than two hours.
In that time, Irving is constantly jumping from
the orphanage to the cider house. This allows the
audience to see the effect that Homer is having in
both “worlds.”
Rating:
Boyd Fulmer Jr.: 3 of 4 stars
Special to The Gamecock
Tobey Maguire plays Homer Wells in this story of growing
up.
'Next Friday' leads box office
by David Gearman
Associated Press
Los Angeles
The friendly mouse has given way to the neigh
borhood bully.
“Next Friday” starring Ice Cube as a man on
the run from a vengeful bully, bumped off the reign
ing box-office champ, the mouse tale “Stuart Lit
tle” according to industry estimates Sunday.
The sequel to the 1995 film “Friday” took in
$14.5 million Friday through Sunday. The movie
has grossed $19.1 million since opening Wednes
day. “Next Friday” drew well among 18-to-25
year-old white crowds, too, said David Tuckerman,
head of distribution for New Line, which re
leased the movie.
1. “Next Friday” $14.5 million.
2. “Stuart Little” $9.7 million.
3. “The Hurricane” $9.1 million.
4. “Girl, Interrupted” $8.2 million.
5. “The Green Mile” $7.5 million.
6. “Galaxy Quest” $6.6 million.
7. “The Talented Mr. Ripley” $6 million.
8. “Supernova” $5.7 million.
9. ‘Toy Story 2” $5 million.
10. “Any Given Sunday” $4.8 million.