The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, January 19, 2000, Encore!, Page 5, Image 19
p1 / Movies
111'
'Hurricane' fails to stir things up
by Meredith Davis
Gamecock Critic .
In the performance that is said to be Denzel
Washington's finest to-date, ferocity, entrapment,
and an earnest portrayal of boxer Rubin “Hurri
cane” Carter’s life doesn’t quite entrance the way
it should - because the film is left lacking.
“The Hurricane,” directed by Norman Jewi
som (Moonstruck), tells the true-to-life story of
Carter’s battles with court, prejudice and his own
psyche as he is wrongfully accused, at the peak of
his athletic career, of committing a horrific triple
murder late one evening in 1966. The film centeis
around a young, black inner-city kid who has been
temporarily taken in by a Canadian commune about
10 years later (notably Liev Schreiber, “Scream 2,”
and John Hannah, “Sliding Doors”), so they can
nurture and educate him in the country. At the
moment he achieves literacy, he finds Carter’s au
tobiography and becomes enchanted with the sto
ry and the man, prompting the commune to make
it their life’s work to free the jailed boxer.
Ihe story itself is intriguing, glossed by Hol
lywood to make it unbelievable. Carter had been
denied two state court acquittals before this group
of white folks entered his life to revolutionize a
high-profile court case and risk their money and
safety for a man they hardly knew. Even the re
al-life publicity blitz that featured Bob Dylan’s song
“Hurricane” couldn’t make the jury and the courts
overturn the first verdict; this we know. So, the
audience who is unfamiliar with the story sits in
wonder, asking, what makes these people think
they could?
This movie encompasses nice silent shots, but
“Dead Man Walking” did the whole “The jailed
one allows a stranger into his heart” sequence in
a more understated fashion and with much more
vindication, making it a stronger delivery. This
movie isn’t about understatement; it’s about con
trived moments, like when Carter loses his tough
guy facade and starts hanging up pictures of his new
quasi-family (the Canadians and the kid) in his
jail cell. Even if this did happen, make us believe
it!
The movie just didn’t set up scenes subtly; it
doesn’t have any features comparable to such a
master of this art as “The Shawshank Redemption.”
It’s certainly not at that level, due to the lack of
understatement, the tool which separates the good
from the best. Not to fault Washington, because
his portrayal of the fight scenes (for which he lost
35 pounds - his body was ripped), the prelimi
nary 90 days he had to spend in the infamous prison
“hole,” and the ability to age with believability, all
make him worthy of at least another Academy
Award nomination.
Oscar-worthy and cash-worthy also encapsu
late the soundtrack to this film; it’s phenomenal at
the very least. It takes on a life of its own, espe
cially during a quick, moving black-and-white tele
vision excerpt of American slavery shown in one
of the slower scenes.
The bulk of the film’s success lies here, in the
many technical aspects showcased that polish a
film. It does everything Lee’s “Summer of Sam”
aimed to do, but didn’t, emotionally involve the
audience in a re-enactment of an incident so well
remembered of a particular time in America. This
movie demands a clear time frame for its audience,
and Jewisom delivers. He shows us consistency in
year transition and physical age changes, but these
elements would be empty without the music.
“The Hurricane” makes for fine fist-clenching
during the fight scenes; the boxing spotlights are
invigorating.
To end on an unpopular note, Washington may
have been ill-cast for this part. He’s just simply
too beautiful and too good. “Hurricane” Carter
is shown in the light Jewisom wants us to see, but
an article in The New York Times tells us that a
major discrepancy in character portrayal (again, in
the writing, not the acting) disallows us to see the
boxer in an accurate light, and instead one who is
portrayed as, well, an almost pristine Denzel - with
fighting gloves, a temper, and a racial grudge added
to the mix.
This film is worth seeing to some degree, but
might fool some moviegoers into thinking it tells
the full story. Truly, what it fails to do is resist the
Hollywood cliche of taking a life story, giving it
hyped-up star quality, and selling it to us, before
wrapping it up .and taking it to the Oscars.
Rating:
Meredith Davis: 2 1/2 of 4 stars
Robert Fleming: 4 of 4
Kevin Langston: 4 of 4
Courtesy of Universal Pictures
Once a promising boxer, Rubin “Hurricane” Carter's (Denzel Washington) dreams are
destroyed when he is sentenced to three life sentences for a crime he didn’t commit
wvnitjf vr wnircftMi riLiunti
Carter (Washington) meets with (from left) Sam Chaiton (Liev Schreiber), Lesra Marlin
(Vicellous Shannon) and Lisa Peters (Deborah Unger) who are determined to prove his
innocence.
'Supernova'
super waste
of money
by Duke Taylor
Gamecock Critic
Help! Is there a lawyer out there who’s inter
ested in doing pro bono work for me? I want to file
a class-action lawsuit for the millions of people
who suffered the harsh mental strain of this no plot,
no brainer, wannabe, wanton random nudity, sci
fi D movie.
D for don’t waste your money, don’t get sucked
in by the Oscar-winning trailer, and please don’t
even glance at the title while you’re in line at the
theater.
I find it hard to believe that millions of people
had to go hungry so that $75 million could be wast
ed on staffing this misguided high school science
project.
Character development was nonexistent and
half the cast was dead by the movie’s end any
way. After seeing La Bamba in junior high, I thought
Lou Diamond Phillips was the man. But Lou, come
on, you could’ve done commercials or something,
anything but this movie.
Several components worked really hard to make
this movie really bad. The fust component was the
writers, David Campbell Wilson and William Mal
one. The second was the actors, and the third was
plot development - come to think of it, I’m not ■
sure it had one.
Usually, after seeing a bad movie, I make a
sly remark like, “Whoever made this movie should
be shot,” but I’m not sure I’d be willing to let
that happen with this movie. If everyone affiliat
ed with this movie was shot, then we’d never get
to hear an explanation as to why this movie had to
be made, and damn... that trailer was so alluring,
too.
Look, I just want to wash my hands of this trau
matic experience. If anyone knows how to con
tact the director so I can get my money back. I’d
appreciate your help.
As always, though, I feel obligated, even with
bad movies and misguided science projects, to sub
mit a positive remark. Despite the random regen
erative properties of the vampire-looking alien and
the interracial floating sex scene between Angela
Bassett and James Spader, the movie had some
unique special effects.
The alien’s fluorescent oib reminded me of the
pink rock candy my friend made for me in junior
high home economics. I still contend, though, that
the greatest special effect would be to make this
movie disappear.
Rating:
Duke Taylor: 1/2 or 4 Stars