The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, June 21, 1989, Page 2, Image 2
iPress freedom
Decision against foundation
\victoryfor mass media, public
1 1 -> r ?
wii June ij) >uii ^iiLUii vuui i j uugt v^aiui ^uiuiui niaui a
important ruling for press freedom in South Carolina.
The judge said that a USC organization, the Carolir
iResearch and Development Foundation, is subjeet to the state
;Freedom of Information Act.
The ruling may have ended a long battle between the found;
tion and the media organizations who brought the suit, tf
-Greenville News and The Associated Press. The foundation h;
10 days in which to request an appeal of the ruling after the o
Ticial court order has been released.
; The news organizations filed the suit in 1987, claiming th;
Isince the foundation had received more than $28 million i
public money since 1984, then its records and meetings shoul
be open to public scrutiny.
I
The AP requested documents pertaining to the foundation
receipt or expenditure of public funds, receipt of royalties froi
patents or copyrights obtained by USC since 1981, a list of pe
sonnel of people who work for the foundation and are also pai
by another government body, and Internal Revenue Service 9S
tax reports since 1981.
The organizations also argued that because the foundatic
shares staff and faculty with USC this makes it a de facto publ
body.
Connor said she agreed with the news organizations. In ht
ruling she wrote, "The Freedom of Information Act defines
public body as an organization supported in whole, or in par
by public funds and requires disclosure to the public of the a<
ii\ities of such a body.
The Carolina Research and Development Foundation ht
placed itself in that category by accepting or expending publ
money."
The public money that the foundation accepted should remai
in the public domain and not be hidden behind the foundation
claim that it is a private, non-profit organization and therefoi
not subject to public accountability.
The News and the A. P. should be commended for their figl
to open up these records. Despite what Board of Trustees Chai
man Michael Mungo said at Thursday's board meeting, the:
news organizations did have the public's interest at heart.
The FOI act was not written for the press. It was written f(
the average citizen. Citizens have a right to know how the foui
dation is spending public money -their tax dollars.
1/ \
/ v . / r1 *?. V r"> f? ^
LH IMA 2) EU(UK?V.
WJELL/UJE'VE FIUAULY
RESOLVED THIS .
J^EMOOEAOy ERAP!
YES. .. BUT
U1HERE ARE ALL
THE EHl LDEEM T
I f\S? A 1 I
<Z) wen
The Gamecock
Best Non-daily Collegiate Newspaper, Southeastern Region
Society o f Professional Journalists, 1987-88
hditor in Chief
MARY PEARSON
t'op> Desk Chief
TODD CHRISTENSEN
Assistant Copy Desk Chief k ? -^T\l
I'AMME EADES I \ ^ \ J
News Editor II J J
RON BAKER 7**
Features Editor
CAREN CAMPBELL
Sports Editors
1)1 BRA JORDAN Assistant Production Manager
D R. HAYNES RAY BURGOS
Photography Editor Advertising Personnel
EES ALVERSON Advertising Manager
Gamecock Advisor MARGARET MICHELS
ERIK COLLINS Campus Representee
Director of Student Media TERENCE GREEN
I D BONZA Account Executives
Production Manager IERRENCE MANIGUAI I
LAURA DAY LORRIE YON AS
Letters Policy I /he Gamecock will |r> lo prim all letters received. I.illers should be, at a maximum. 2511
300 words long. I lie writer should include lull name, professional title if an employee with I S( or ( olumi
resident, or vcar ami major if a student. An address and phone number are required with anv letters sent. C*u
editorials should not exceed 500 words. We reserve the right lo edit letters for shle or possible libel. I
(uumcock will not withhold names under anv circumstance.
Mamie?vavvtv?*vay5Z>4>/
i if
ln
re
" Public shoulc
se
At some point, one must wonder if there is a
conspiracy among certain state and federal
[1_ lawmakers to utterly destroy local governments
and to endlessly deceive the public.
The S. C. General Assembly was expected to
decide this week on a bill which would give county
gqyernme^ts the power to euact an additional 1
percent safes tax, which woifld lower property taxes
and supplement county revenues. At press time
Tuesday, nothing new had come of the battle as
might be expected from such a progressive
legislature as our own.
The local option sales tax has been a controver
sial issue for several years, and a battle is presently
raging between the House and Senate on how mucf
of the revenue generated by the tax should be usee
to roll back property taxes.
Essentially what is happening here is politica
brinksmanship of the worst sort. While loca
governments nationwide are drowning in the fun
7 ding cuts of the Reagan years, members of th<
S. C. Senate are moving to put in place a tax whicl
will cut property taxes, but make up for the los
with a sales tax. This will never benefit loca
governments in any appreciable way.
The voters of South Carolina should know tha
the government does not intend to create a new ta:
which will generate less money. This is no zero-sun
tame. The local option sales tax is not designe<
solely to relieve the costs of property taxes, but als<
to provide more tax dollars to pay for the function
of local government.
If the government were only seeking to brea
Education fu
_ Wanted:_ Visionary, psychic or fortune teller.
Must have experience and be willing to Work foi
peanuts, poor health package. Apply at State
Legislature.
Knowing the future is, by most accounts, im
possible, but making reasonable predictions aboul
the future isn't quite as difficult. And there seem;
to be no one in more dire need of a quasi-reality
break than the leaders of South Carolina.
? For example, The State recently carried a story
about Gov. Carroll Campbell's interest in attracting
a major airline hub to South Carolina. Abou
$50 million would be used as incentive to attraa
the airline. With an airline hub comes increased in
m*m dustry and a stronger economy, Campbel
mm? said.
Time for a reality break, governor.
The Commission on Higher Education continue;
to stack the funding formula in favor of school;
with high undergraduate enrollment. At the sam<
time, the CHE has cut back programs at smalle
two-year schools that offered advanced programs
in effect, preventing the growth of the institution
All this and more implemented by a commissioi
of 19 people, only two of whom have any ex
perience as a college or university staff member
George Brightharp of Trenton and CHE chairmai
William Whitener of Union.
Time for a reality break, commissioner.
USC President James Holderman has proposec
increasing the size of the freshman class as a mean
of gaining more funding from the state ? fundinj
Letters to the
Writer expresses 1 s 2 ,1
m commit te
rage about China 0%%%
l>ia . . u .
lo the editor: ment tha
1 wish to express my outrage at the co'c' ^'oc
weak and irresolute response by the George
MR LIFE FC
^ 0^10 SO^
1 be aware of s
Ron Baker wMft PWm
" m *
! _____________
1
1 even in this deal, they would just leave the property
taxes in place and not go through all of this trouble
in the first place.
1 Furthermore, the rollback will actually only be
effective for one year in the Senate version,
- because local governments will be allowed to "roll
i property taxes back up" after the first year the law
s is in effect. This essentially means that there is no
1 guarantee that homeowners will benefit from the
bill for more than one year,
t The voters should also know that local govern*
ments need increased revenues. Those conseri
vatives like Sen. Glenn McConnell, R-Charleston,
i who incessantly complain that welfare recipients
a are looking for a "free lunch," need to realize that
s they themselves do not deserve a free ride from the
people of South Carolina by not paying the taxes
k necessary to keep garbage collected, fires exnding
must be
Christensen
i desperately
needed for faculty raises and equipment
purchases.
> While this move would increase funding at USC,
s the distribution per student would be the same or
; smaller than the current distribution. USC's actual
r gain would be thousands of students not afforded
; the level of attention they now receive.
Yes, time for a reality break, USC.
"? Thfl nmklam i c *-r?/~vr-o \\/ i A OC H t H C\ n A nVfTTTP
' 1 IIV, pi VJUHlll 13 II1UIV, YHUVjpi VMM n?v*?l "'V
seems to realize. Gov. Campbell seems to think
: that our economic future depends on more
i business traffic. The CHE seems to think the key to
effective education is regimenting under-funded
undergraduate programs. And USC, desperate for
1 funding, is actually considering a massive inducs
tion of students into an already overcrowded
I institution.
g f* oi l ol military aid to 1
%JL M (L\JJL should never have armed
first place. Communists f
time and time again that
ernment to the atrocities lx t,ustecld
by China s communist ^ few recent examp
How can we maintain brutal crackdowns in 1
relations with a govern- Tbilisi, President Ge
i murders its own people in should cut off all aid an<
lC" the repressive Chinese G
Bush has called for the cut If Americans want t
,./ / HZ
tales tax issue
tinguished, and streets patrolled by policemen.
Another feature of the local option sales tax battle,
one which cannot be ignored, is the proposal to
exclude grocery purchases from the tax. In fact,
this feature should be a part of the bill, and should
apply to all sales taxes.
Sajes taxes are regressive by nature. For example,
states have tried to lessen this burden on the
|poot* by exempting food and small clothing purchases.
South Carolina should follow suit by not
insisting that the lower socioeconomic classes pay a
larger percentage of their income on food because
of the money-gathering efforts of a local sales tax.
Still, the most important fact about the local option
sales tax is the plight of county governments
and their need of funds.
For county governments to perform their duties
to the public in an acceptable fashion, they must
have more money. The Reagan administration's
cutbacks and the trend in state funding toward insufficiency
leave localities with few options.
Counties can pay more for services such as garbage
collection and fire protection individually or
live without them. Or they can raise property taxes,
which are almost as generally despised by the
citizenry as income taxes, or generate revenue in
some other way (e.g., the local option sales tax).
The State quoted Sen. John Land, D-Clarendon,
Tuesday as having said, "We tried to get a sense of
the Senate, and we found out we don't have any
sense." This is probably more true than Land
knows.
top priority
The real key to the future of our state is quality
education. USC realizes this, but is powerless to
act. The CHE realizes this, but doesn't seem to be
willing to do what is necessary to improve our
situation. And the state legislature, as evidenced by
their lack of funding of higher education, doesn't
appear to see our future at all.
Short-term solutions such as higher business
traffic may reap rewards in a short period of time.
An additional investment of $50 million in higher
education is a true investment in the future ? an
investment in the technology of tomorrow and the
leadership to apply it.
Education receives much less attention in South
Carolina than it actually deserves. Our universities
are being forced to compete with less expensive,
more highly-funded institutions in our region. The
universities aren't to blame.
They are unable to offer salaries competitive
with other universities in the Southeast ? truly
amazing, considering USC's proposed tuition increase
will rank it the third most expensive university
in the Southeast.
Students, universities, commissioners and
legislators alike need to realize that education is the
real investment in the future of both the students
J .L.:. TL- U.,t tko
Unci IIICII MitlC. 1 lie CUSIS may ytcni uigii, ulu liiv
cost of poor education is much higher.
Fifty million dollars can finance one major
airline hub or about 2,500 college-educated South
Carolinians, one or two of whom might start their
own airline. Which would you rather have?
China. We cause of freedom, we should send aid
them in the to the freedom-loving students in
lave proven Beijing ?not to the dictators that opthey
cannot press them.
May the Goddess of Democracy
les are the reign forever.
Beijing and
orge Bush
j trade with
overnment. Janice I.raft
0 serve the USC graduate