The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, April 05, 1989, Page 3, Image 3
Free speech
State lawmakers should defeat
bill banning bumperstickers
South Carolina lawmakers are considering a bill banning socalled
obscene bumper stickers. The General Assembly should
learn from the problems other states have encountered with this
type of legislation and send the bill down to defeat.
For some reason, Americans have a profound love affair with
putting stickers on their cars, telling everyone what is on their
minds. In their own way, these bumperstickers are a part of the
right to free speech ? one of the most precious rights Americans
have.
The controversy over bumperstickers began a few years ago
when the messages began to grow more suggestive, although
many have always contained double entendres (especially certain
USC stickers). In fact, some of these messages include fourietter
words that would not be allowed to air on radio stations.
Many people have said they are offended by these stickers and
want to see them made illegal.
In response to these complaints, S.C. lawmakers are considering
the bill that would empower police officers to stop cars that
display a sticker deemed obscene bv the officer. The driver
would then be subject to a fine or some other punishment.
The bill carries the implication that police officers should
serve as arbiters of good taste. But what is distasteful to one person
might not be distasteful to another. Police officers should
not be asked to do something that not even the U.S. Supreme
Court can do ? define what is obscene and what is not.
Florida has a similar law and has run into a series of problems
because of it. The first person pulled over for having a
distasteful sticker had the message "Russia Sucks" on the back
of his car. It was later revealed that the man had fled communist
Cuba and that the sticker was his small way of protesting the influence
of the Soviet Union in his homeland. He asserted that he
had the right to display the sticker and that the Florida law
violated the Constitution. I
S.C. officials should expect similar difficulties. Any vaguely
worded bill regarding free speech possesses inherent problems,
and this proposal is no different. Perhaps lawmakers can find a
compromise with a bill spelling out certain words that could not ^
be included (such as the "seven dirty words" that govern radio). b
Anything beyond that would entail a serious encroachment of rr
freedom ? something no American wants. a
li
" NAM - IT IVOULPM'T BE" PRACTICAL" ?
/ e<
j-j
g<
ai
U
The Gamecock s
" u
Best Non-daily Collegiate Newspaper, Southeastern Region ev
Society of'Professional Journalists, 1987-88
Editor in Chief Photography Editor ^
andy bechtel teddy lepp
Managing Editor Datebook Editor ^
jeff shrewsbury jan phillips h;
Copy Desk Chief Graphics Editor ^
kathy blackwell michael sharp ^
Assistant Copy Desk Chief Comics Editor in
caryn crabb tracy mixson (c
News Editor Graduate Assistant
MARY PEARSON ROBERT STEVENSON P'
Assistant News Editors Adviser ar
KELLY C. THOMAS PAT MCNEELY tM
SUSAN NESBITT Director of Student Media ^
Features Editor ED BONZA
TODD MINES Advertising Manager xv
Assistant Features Editor MARGARET M1CHELS
TOMMY JOYNER Production Manager '
Sports Editor LAURA DAY
KEVIN ADAMS Assistant Production Manager m
Assistant Sports Editor RAY BURGOS at
CHRIS SII.VESTRI Assistant Advertising Manager a?
BARBARA BROWN **
fa
Letters Policy: The Gamecock Hill lr\ l<> prinl all tellers received. Idlers should he. al a maximum. 250 |?
500 nurds Ion);, t.uesl editorials should nol exceed 5IKP words. V\e reserve Ihe ri|>hl In edil tellers for sixle or nC
possible libel. The (nunecocb nill nol withhold names under an? eirrumslanee. 3P
^^he
Hilt
V V i
4"?VV
wvvvvv
M fcTtf iTi k% n
[ 'VVVVV
hrd kTi ri iTi ^ fcT4
rvvvvvv
kTi ik J kTi kJ kj u
wvvvvv
WTi kTi ItI iTi It4 ItJ
wvvvvv=
ri lT414 lTi fcT4 lT<
5 *MMP.lf.1 f 1
^4I7J iTikT41 i!Tii>J
1 /1>, >, ? t > i?i *,
* ? t I ' ' 1 1 ' l ZHH " i : i T"
_.V 1' 1' '' 11'' '' ' ' ' ' .-H .
Freedom at sts
I wish to address the deeper implications of the
isitation issue, the issues hinted at but still unarculated.
The matter of the morality of student
ehavior is the surface issue; farther reaching and
lore signit icant are the questions ot maturity
nd responsibility raised by the debate.
The true issue is not sex. It is not morals,
ability for AIDS cases or a real or imagined
ublic mandate. It is rather that of liberty and
jsponsibility for South Carolina's population agi
18 to 21: whether we are to be treated as
dults or as children.
At 18, a U.S. citizen assumes all of the duties,
ut only part of the privileges, of that status. At
8, we may vote, be conscripted, be executed by
te state, start a business and marry. We may
yen have sex. Yet despite the full range of these I
;sponsibilities, under age 21 we are still minors 1
i important realms. The drinking age, for exam- i
le, was raised several years ago because of i
runk driving among those between 18 and 21.
efore this, it was 18, ever since the passage of ;
le 26th amendment in 1972 ? just after the 1
ietnam War, in which most of our soldiers were 1
aunger than 21. i
But few parallels here may be drawn to the ;
rinking age law: The arguments for public <
ealth and safety used to justify that legislation i
re not possible with the visitation issue. By baning
overnight visits, there is no prospect of i
:ducing pregnancy, disease or any activity that I
Letters to the
Felton brings
> year, the G?
h m -4- * * r
UII lu umiie ^aa 8' 1
~ since the woi
George and I
0 the editor: here). He has
Reading the sports pages these players to play
ays is a bit like reading the police and has, in sh<
>g in Washington, D.C.: Drugs, men's basketbt
iolence and corruption have become For me, hov
) common that we hardly take son is even r
otice when an athlete, coach or pro- Felton the coac
ram falls under suspicion. Felton was to
Pete Rose is suspected of gambl- academic recoi
ig. Ben Johnson is stripped of his players enrolle
3ld medal for steroid use. Sports Humanities a
?ents are on trial for extortion. The From that firs
niversity of Oklahoma is branded proven to me
> a regional campus of the than four year;
klahoma correctional system. The dent athletes. 1
illowers of University of Kentucky up to their poti
asketball wonder what violations the court, to
ere not committed by their diploma in h
aaching staff. Clemson fans wear memories of pi
lirts proclaiming USC as "the basketball. H
niversity of Steroids and Cocaine" players, and th
/en as a magistrate reduces the deal about the
larges against two Clemson football We are fort
layers for fighting with a security Felton here a
jard. season recentl;
And so it goes. Lost in the midst of many great si
1 this are those individuals who thank you, Co
ive both the skills and the moral
>rtitude to be successful without
jandoning their integrity. One such College of Hi
dividual is Nancy Wilson, who
ok over our women's basketball
ogram during a umc ui luuuuu .<
id has turned it into a consistent na- mIj\01V
anal power. There is also Randy
bleman, voted "National Diving
oach of the Year" for his efforts WJlTl
ith the USC diving teams.
Another such individual is George To the editor:
;lton. Wearewritii
Coach Felton has brought excite- pie know that
ent back to men's basketball here closest of frien
Carolina. Carolina Coliseum is Recently, an
tain a place where opposing coaches not only affe
id teams dread to play. Carolina others. My rc
ns are no longer yawning in the close friend wii
ands as they were a few years ago; * at any time. Th
)w we are screaming at the action offered to tho
id wondering what level of hell is you can trust,
ime for the Metro officials (I know However, th
KR7 W!
ffiMBS fa
\Sv ps:
/\ "A .WVJ
row tw
'.'i'i'. . *.11.**'
THE TOWERS COMPLEX
ike in battle o
K. Benoit
Guest * I
Column J *
Rep. Mike Fair considers immoral. It will only i
turn the dorms into barracks to be avoided when (
the sexes decide to mingle. The only real argument
has to do with Fair's own conception of c
morality. f
Perhaps most unsatisfactory has been the c
absence of any position on this issue from our f
president, James Holderman. Any stance would (
oe better than none. Holderman has the correct 1
'hetoric to make this a first-class university, but i
in agenda to back it up will have to include the c
:oncerns of students.'After all, aren't we the 5
eason for this state-supported institution? >
When society sends one message, but govern- r
mental and community leaders proclaim another, 1
Droblems are inevitable. Dualities of this sort ex- 1
editor
never say that in that it is hard to trust anyc
say it for him). This days, even a friend. This '
imecocks made the stole some identification c
54 for the first time She went to the highway dej
rid was young (and and had a false driver's licer
were undergraduates in my name. She used my n
KrAiioht in OVOpI 1^?nt folco irlontifiootmn r>r\r
uiuugiii i" vAvviivin iciiov, iuvwui ivauuii iw ta;
a challenging schedule amounts of money with ch
:>rt, put fun back into had stolen from a place of 1
ill here at USC. The money has been recove
vever, Felton the per- the "friend" is supposed!
nore impressive than dealt with by the autl
:h. The first time I met However, the damage dom
review with him the roommate and me was n
d of every one of his physical, but mental. My cr
?d in the College of financial reputation was rui
nd Social Sciences. most of all, my roommate an
t meeting, Felton has had a hard time trusting e
that he wants more closest friends since this
i eligibility for his stu- occurred,
hie wants them to live Our point in this letter is
ential both on and off students that bizarre things
leave USC with a can happen to anyone. Be
and as well as the who you trust no matter hov
laying big-time college friend you think they are.
le cares about his
at in itself says a great Ann Marie I
man. Business f
unate indeed to have Allison
it Carolina. For the Journalism f
y ended and for the
easons to come, we 111? ^ 1
ach Felton BlaCKS liaV'
Larry V Hudson ODDOrtllllitj
umanities and Social vrrvl ******
Sciences
To the editor:
y-, ^ 4 1 am compelled to u
vfHC HO I Gamecock as an outlet
_ frustrations regarding Steph
^OrtllV ^'n's 'etter referring to the
J medallions. This is an a
situation for me because 1 at
yet I find Driffin's accusatio
tg this letter to let peo- ly without foundati
sometimes even the provocation,
ds cannot be trusted. Let me try to present this i
incident occurred that that will not be racially inclin
:cted us, but many of all, it is almost discrimina
lommate trusted her him to say that the medallioi
th access to our room belong to us blacks. Just as
is is a courtesy usually black Americans, there ar
se whom you believe Africans. You should be we
these white people, for they
is friend proved to us trying to understand black
MH
as
vvw
a'VVV!
T<kTikWi
4'VVV
TJ?T4kTlkT <
'VVV
41. JMV4
0 T
r1:'" =
V??[
-* m:
m &
ver visitation
:>lain many of the difficulties we face today: the
ipread of crime, substance abuse, wife beating,
he obsession with sex. It is evidence, more than
mything, of immaturity.
In Western Europe one finds countries similar
o our own, but without many of the problems
ve confront. Teenagers consume alcohol and
lave sex at 18, if not before. Sunbathing topless
)n beaches is accepted and indeed normal. Con;equently,
there is less mysticism and suppressed
"ascination with these subjects than in the United
states. The policies of these nations lack the
lypocrisy and the contradiction of condemning
vhat society encourages. This straightforwardtess
makes a difference, too, in such critical
ireas of policy as AIDS, teenage pregnancy and
Jrugs.
All of this is to say that the visitation policy
lebate involves more than the acceptability of
parents and trustees in premarital sex. It has to
io with whether young adults may decide actions
or themselves and assume responsibility for the
:onsequences. More generally, the issue
lighlights the deeper problems of mixed signals
n our society. Students, trustees and all concernid
should consider this matter carefully,
students, make yourselves be heard if you don't
vish your rights to be slowly eroded. And Board
nembers, consider this: Morality should not be
egislated and maturity cannot. But it can be
egislated away.
ne these and culture. Besides, you can't tell
'friend" me that all the blacks who wear such
>f mine. things truly know the meaning
5artment behind them. The medallion is only a
lse made symbol and can be applied with many
ame and representations just as the rebel flag
ih large has its own. Moreover, without proecks
she of or actions behind the symbols, the
business. medallion will just be another trendy,
red, and materialistic object that will last until
ly being something else comes along,
horities. Secondly, it appears that Driffin
s to my has an attitude problem. 1 agree with
lot only him that in many aspects blacks and
edit and other minorities have been exploited,
ned, but I know most people don't know that
id I have many of Elvis Presley's songs were
wen our stolen from black blues musicians,
incident And I do feel that black history needs
to be included in today's education,
to warn However, most of the things that
like this we've been exploited in have been in
careful the past, long ago, before our time.
v good a That is the problem with most people
of any race. They live in the past
and are obligated to everything their
JiMashe ancestors went through. Just as great
reshman people, history and events come from
Mooney the past, so does the hatred, the wars
reshman and the evil people.
We as blacks have many oppor_
tunities to become better individuals
C if we only take advantage of them.
, That includes things we are not used
|0W to ? different cultures, music and
people. We'll never get people to
understand black people or black
history until we can make an effort to
se The understand what they are about. We
for my may not agree with it or like it, but as
en Drif- long as you can accept it or apAfrican
preciate it, we'll be much better
iwkward people.
n black, Finally, 1 must ask Driffin if
ns utfpr- Africa is so much ours as vou sav.
on or why don't we go back and claim it?
Or are we too comfortable in our
in a way own society to enter a third-world
ed. First country? In the simplest of terms and
.tory for by the most convenient definitions,
ns solely practice what you preach or wake up
i we are and smell what you're shoveling,
e white Peace,
lcoming
may be Reginald Smith
history Journalism sophomore