The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, August 31, 1988, Page 3, Image 3
Abuse
Legislators who sent editor
to jail abused justice system
"Anybody who is afraid to speak the truth and stand fc
justice, just doesn't deserve to be free."
James Fitts
Edito
The Voic
A man was "put in jail in South Carolina this summer for ex
pressing his opinion.
Does that bother you? It should scare the hell out of you.
Jim Fitts, editor of The Voice, a Kingstree newspaper, wrot
an editorial saying two legislators had stolen something from th
citizens of Williamsburg County.
State Rep. B. J. Gordon and the late Sen. Frank McGill ha<
Fitts arrested, and Fitts spent two nights in jail.
Later, he was indicted by a grand jury who decided there wa
enough evidence for a trial. But Fitts never got his day in court
The lawmakers said they were vindicated by the indictment am
asked that the charges be dropped.
How they arrived at that conclusion we'll probably neve
know. A grand jury decides there is enough evidence to have
trial, not if there is enough to convict. It doesn't make sense
Either the two lawmakers do not understand the criminal justic
system, or they had other reasons for dropping the charges.
Perhaps the fact they would have lost in court was prominen
among their reasons.
First, there was definitely no criminal libel, because both o
the legislators were alive at the time it was published, and Fitts'
article caused no breach of the peace. The state of Soutl
Carolina was not hurt by Fitts's editorial. The two legislator
may have been injured by the article but that was for a judge t<
aeciae in a civil case.
Second, while Fitts made strong statements about th
legislators, they are public figures and public figures have t<
prove there was actual premeditated malice on the writer's part
In other words, Fitts would have had to sit down before h
wrote the article and thought, "I know they aren't thieves, bu
I'm going to call them thieves because I hate them and want t<
hurt them."
That wasn't the case. Fitts was writing a column on electioi
day, trying to encourage debate.
And if Fitts had been able to take his case to court, he ma;
have been able to win on the best defense possible in a libel sui
? the truth.
The State newspaper printed a series of articles detailing hov
Gordon used funds from a mental health center of which he wa
director for personal use. If the allegations, which are now beinj
investigated by the state, turn out to be true, then Fitts may wel
have printed the truth. And he may have gotten off scot-free
But ho one seems to be making too much of a fuss about thi
fact that these two legislators used the criminal justice system fo
their personal vindication. As the People's Court likes to tell us
if you have a problem with someone, don't take the law int<
your own hands, "you take them to court."
Civil court.
To use the criminal justice system against someone for per
sonal vindication is an abuse of that system. Charges should no
nave oeen orougnt against Mtts out against uoraon ana mcuiii
*IT CAME FROM OUTER SPACE*
The Gamecock
Best Non-daily Collegiate Newspaper, Southeastern Region
Society of Professional Journalists, 1987-88
Editor in Chief Datebook Editor
STEPHEN GUILFOYLE JENNY SHARPE
Managing Editor Graphics Editor
SON HA MICHAEL SHARP
Copy Desk Chief Comics Editor
WAYNE YANG TRACY MIXSON
News Editor Adviser
HAL MILLARD PAT MCNEELY
Assistant News Editor Graduate Assistant
STEVE PRADARELLI TT ^ w ,
MARY PEARSON Director of Student Medid
ED BONZA
Features Editor Advertising Manager
SUSAN NESBITT MARGARET MICHELS
Assistant Features Editor Production
CHUCK DEAN LAURA DAY
Photography Editors RAY BURGOS
BRIAN SAULS Assistant Advertising Manager
TEDDY LEPP BARBARA BROWN
Letters Policy: The Gamecock will try to print letters received. Letters should be, at a maximum, 250 to 300
words long. Guest editorials should not exceed 500 words. We reserve the right to edit letters for style or possible
libel. The Gamecock will not withhold names under any circumstance.
jl.
>r L
f
i
a
3
e
3
e
t
3
Gamecocks n<
^ Time to talk football, I guess,
t It does start Saturday.
And with football comes the hot chicken, the
V cold beer and a rocking stadium. And now, for the
s first time in a while, USC has its best chance of
equalling or exceeding its 1984 schedule.
That's right, you heard me right. USC can equal
1 or exceed its 10-2 record. I'm sure many of the
football pundits out there are saying, "What a
e fool, what a stupid jerk."
r But I know the people out there who don't care
one bit about football are probably saying, "What
' a fool, what a stupid jerk."
3 Can't win, but anyway. . .
I ISP needs inst twn thinffs Thev need a team
that can play as professionally as last year's, which J
they already have in most of the positions, if not all s
of them. But they also need a team that can play i
with the emotion that the 1984 team did.
Emotion and professionalism. Some people say ?
- you can't have both. Wrong. The Bears had both I
in 1985. The Giants had both in '86. The Redskins
had both last year, and all those teams won the
Super Bowl.
Or, to consider college football. Miami had both 1
last year. Penn State had some excitement the year r
before. The list goes on. v
I remember the '84 season. It was a damn good c
Benson's reje<
Oh, sad day! Robby Benson rejected me! He just
took my life inside his cinematic hands, squeezed
and yelled, "Cut!" Benson decided I wasn't fit
enough to be in his Hollywood class, and I'm suffering.
I'm pained. I'm lost. Thanks, Robby!
I'm talking about the interviews this past Friday
for his film-making class. Once I got there, I scanned
the other interviewees, and to be truthful, they
looked really star-struck, young ? virtually inexperienced.
I smirked, "What on God's earth do I
have to worry about?" I reclined ? waiting for the
man of the academic school year (my future) to
arrive.
n^Li i ~ x* i : ii..
ivouoy came anu gave a unci pep lain., uasicauy
telling everyone not to take it personally if they
didn't get in. I wanted to say, "Robby! Be real!
~ Look at these people! Robby, they have portfolios,
?i glossies that don't look a damn bit like them.
Resumes, Robby!" I wanted to ready Robby for
the tears of rejection, but I didn't. I remained silent
and reclined.
Several fellow interviewees tried talking to me,
asking what I thought Robby was looking for I
^ perked up and said, "me," sort of chuckling. After
that, I silenced and hoped they could see that I was
exercising discipline, preparing myself for the interview
and to be the backbone his class was obviously
going to need.
I walked in (dramatically) where Robby was conLetters
to the
i mm i i r
*1X? 1 Guilfoyle v>
Guilfoyle angers demmng ai
Southern. L
Southerner jrsss
you want ti
To the editor: would be m
I am not an avid reader of The "Get-rid-of
Gamecock because of its liberal pride ourse!
slant, but I do occasionally look are Southeri
through it from time to time to read university. I
the sports and comics. titude is om
My comments concern the our state,
editorials of Stephen Guilfoyle. I
have never read such petty, immature You don'i
and bigoted editorials as the ones our universi
Guilfoyle writes over and over again. university's
I can recall the most bigoted editorial like our dis
The. Cp-pilot.
eed to play vv
Guilfoyle
itar to be a freshman. Whenever Mike Hold was
;ent into the game, we all knew something was gong
to happen.
The '84 team, though, was a team really built on
motion. Last year's team members were much
jetter athletes who played professionally. But the
84 team has USC's record for the most wins.
Which then do you think is more important?
The players have to enjoy the game. And they
lave to keep the crowd in it throughout. I
emember one time when mv buddv Dannv Smith
vas flailing his arms into the air trying to get the
:rowd into the game. But he did it by himself. And
ction just liki
ducting his interviews, giving him a firm handshake.
All the time, I was humming the tune to Ode
To Billy Joe. Toward the end of the song, I even
sang a few lines (while he stared at my face, probably
thinking of how it would look on the big
screen) "... a year's gone by since we heard the
news about Billy Joe, brother married Becky
Thompson ? they bought a store in Tupelo. . ."
He nodded with obvious pleasure, so I slipped right
into my rendition of "Looking Through The Eyes
Of Love" ? the theme from Ice Castles. When I
finished, tears welled up in Robby's eyes, and I
knew trom that point 1 had touched him and made
a friend. Honestly, I felt like hugging him, but I
had sense enough to realize that I was dealing with
editor[
'rote in the spring con- fessors. I feel sure that
1 Southerners for being cent insulting exhibitio:
.ook, pal, nobody asked day issue of The Gam
e down here ? that was overlooked by Rol
. I feel confident that if because he knows how
d go back to Jersey, we from the North act" ai
ore than happy to start a is a bigger person tha
-Guilfoyle" fund. We don't mean that in a
Ives on the fact that we though. I have read yoi
tiers and take pride in our more than two years r
-iowever, your cynical at- never seen anything pos
e that pollutes the air of them. The only good
having you here is the c
knowing that one day y
t like us; you don't like to that great state of n
ity; you don't like our New Jersey,
president, and you don't
languished visiting pro- Public administra
ith emotion
the crowd didn't really perk up much more than it
already was.
In '84, the whole squad did that as it took the
field ? the defense patting the offense on the back,
jumping up and down as they took the field. And
later, the offense would rush onto the field in the
same way.
They were having fun.
The bruising "50" defense was like that some
last year. But it has to be the whole team. The
special teams should be almost trembling with excitement
realizing they are where so many long to
be and didn't make it ? on the field of a college
football team.
I'm not criticizing. This team can play with all
the professionalism of last year's and forget about
emotional play. But I know what I want to see as a
fan. I want to see players having fun, trying to
make me have fun.
If they keep us in the game when the going is
good, it's almost certain we'll keep them in the
game when the going is bad. I leave when we're
ahead by 20. But never when we're down by 3, or 7
or even 21.
I'm a foul weather fan in the fair weather, and a
fair weather fan in foul weather. But that's the
kind the Gamecocks need. I'll stick around as long
as I'm needed.
: Hollywood
show buisness her? and how easily rumors got
started.
Close to the end of my interview, I turned the
tables on Robby, asking him a few questions. I
tried my damndest to get some good dirt on some
major stars so that I could sell a story to People
magazine (for a lot of money) like that Columbian
did with Donna "USC" Rice. I elbowed Robby
and grinned, "Come on, what is Jodie Foster like?
Have you ever seen her naked? What is Paul
Newman's biggest fault?" I assured Robby he
could trust me and that I would never tell
anyone,so. . .
The interview ended. I shook my new best
friend's hand, and he told me to "take it easy" and
to "stay out of trouble." I stopped at the door,
turned and said, "Now, Robby, you know me better
than that, don't you?" He laughed and dropped
his head, shaking it lightly. I laughed also, then
left.
Hours later, I returned to check out the list
posted to see who got into Robby's class with me.
When I read it, I wasn't listed! Robby didn't
choose me! I fell to my knees, crying wails of unfairness.
Was it jealously? A mistake? Did someone
mark my name off the list? Did he reject me
for my best interest ? not wanting to hold me back
or anything? I had my first taste of show business,
and it was sour as hell.
n?n the?Mon- SMllg aTOUnd,
ecock will be # ?
,by Benson just wondering
you people o O
nd because he
in you are. I To the editor:
literal sense, I was sitting around my room the
ur column for other day wondering why so many
low and have columns written in The Gamecock
iitive in any of begin with "I was sitting around the
thing about office the other day wondering what
:onsolation of to write for my column. . . ."
ou will return
nedical waste, Paul Graham
English senior
Michael Ardis Tim Sheehy
ition graduate Media arts junior