The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, March 14, 1980, Page Page 3, Image 4
Grievai
By Teresa K. Weaver
Gamecock Staff Writer
A second USC faculty member
denied tonure and then reinstated
by the State Employee Grievance
Committee said he has not ruled
out the possibility of filing a libel
suit against the university.
Philip M. Zeltner, an assistant
professor of philosophy, was told
his job would be terminated at the
end of this semester. The
grievance committee, however,
said USC dismissed Zeltner
without proper cause and without
evaluating his job performance.
The 33-year-old professor, who
received the 1978 AMOCO Outstanding
Teacher Award, said he
doesn't believe the case is over and
that USC will continue to take
uuuuii against nc onu uuicia gumg
through the state tenure system.
"IF I'M put out of my job, I'll
have no cnoice but to try and
recoup my damages, because I
would have lost my job unfairly. I
have no immediate plans to do this
right now," he said.
/j^" ^vv
Hii
- !- Xvy^pW^jtlW^IBppwiy
1^. (>i 1^ K-f
jMH9
James Branham collapses <
exhibition in the Russell Hous
ARA esta
chanqe h
ARA Fbod Services has change*
semester. The correct operating
listed below.
Capstone Cafeteria will serve
through FYiday. Lunch will be av;
a.m. to 2 p.m. Dinner will be ser
to 7 p.m. The grill hours are Mot
D.m. and from 5 to7 p.m.
THE CONVENIENCE STORE
from 5 to 9 p.m. The Gamecock S
on weekdays and from 2 to 9 p.m
Breakfast and lunch hours at F
Capstone's but dinner will be
through Thursday, and the cafet
on Saturday and Sunday.
The Sidewalk Cafe is open b<
through Thursday ana irorn / au
South Dining Hall is open fr
through Thursday and from 10 3
TOP OF CAROLINA serves st
Sunday from 11 ;45 a.m. to 2 p
open from6 to9 p.m.;
Wade's Place in Wade Hampto
p.m. for lunch on Monday throi
sday from 4 30 to6 30 p.m. fordi
ice comn
Zeltner said he has not been
scheduled to teach any classes
rtnrin0 thp fall 19R0 semester.
USC history professor Michael
Smith was the first to successfully
appeal his dismissal through the
state tenure system. He had been
terminated as of Dec. 31,1979, but
was ordered reinstated by the
greivance committee as of Jan. 1,
1980, on the same grounds as
Zeltner.
THE DECISION concerning
Zpltner is Dart of an on-going
dispute between USC and various
state agencies about who should be
the ultimate authority over job
decisions involving university
faculty.
The grievance committee, acting
under the authority of the state
Budget and Control Board, has the
power to reverse any order of the
university pertaining to employment
matters.
Two recent opinions from the
attorney general's office stated that
university faculty personnel
" - U I I U..
mailers snouiu utj iianuieu uy mu
? GAMECOCK
after stabbing himself at a billian
;e Ballroom Wednesday night.
iblishments
ours again
d its operating hours several times thi
; hours for eating establishments ar
breakfast from 7 to 10 a.m. Monda
ailable Monday through FYiday from 1
ved Monday through Thursday from
-? ml n ** m l/v O /I
may inruugii liiurauuy, / a.m. iu??i
: will be open Sunday through FYida
nack Bar is open from 9 a.m. to 10 p.n
. on weekends and holidays'
tussell House Cafeteria are the same s
served from 4:45 to 7 p.m. Monda
omq mill ho nnon fmm Q a m to 2 DTI
>Vtia TT IIJI \/|/?/* was* ? ? r
;tween 7 30 a.m. and 3 p.m. Monds
a.m. to 2 p.m. FYidays.
om 10 30 a.m. to 6 30 p.m. Mondt
0 a.m. to 1 30 p.m. on FYidays.
udents Tuesday througn fnaay ana c
.m. On FVidays, the restaurant is ah
n Hotel will be serving from 11 a.m. to
igh FYiday and Monday through Thu
inner.
. 1 m
uttee reii
IM^pS^-3 |Sg||s|^^BTC^;::
' W^
Philip Zo/tner
Budget and Control Board's per
sonnel division. The opinions sak
that faculty members should b<
considered as state employees an<
Ac
H/f 0*1 \ r*
1TJL CJL11 111
By Leroy William!
Gamecock Staff Write
A man stabbed himself accic!
argument at a billiards exhibitio
Ballroom Wednesday eve
USC Campus Police said Jame
not a USC student, stabbed hims<
after he drew a knife on an unid
pushed the open blade back in!
during a program featuring f,
Minnesota Fbts. He was later t
from Lexington County Hospital.
TOM OTTS, Russell House
tournament, which was sponsor
Columbia, was originally going
Golden Spur. Since crowding
problem there, he said, the even
ballroom.
Otts said the incident hat
Ballroom. "I don't know why tl
didn't take him (Branham) into
and call for an ambulance," 01
taking him into a lobby and draw
t*-:I o IJiiccoll UniKr
I 1111 V, 1 UV. Ml , a 1UIOOV11 ? ??
event was open to non-USC s
original plan to have them ad
: guests only. Otts said that some
. community were invited to atten
Since Minnesota Flats was to
1201
1576 J
JUMP II
*
s
; | 20% oh
" s off famous i
1. r
Nothing
m R r'
? N Thursday,
1 M/vnre If) .
ir- | u bwwb ** -w
* y?J * i^3
i nr<
should have the right to appeal to
the state grievance committee.
USC has filed a suit asking for an
order exempting faculty members
from State Personnel Division
regulations and barring them from
appealing dismissals in the state
grievance procedure.
In the suit, USC contends that
non-professionals do not have the
experience necessary to evaluate a
faculty member's performance as
well as his peers can.
FRANCIS BORKOWSKI, USC
provost, said the Zeltner decision
"was not unexpected. The basis
for the reinstatement is the same
used in other grievance cases, so it
was certainly not unexpected."
The reinstatement action of the
grievance committee further
complicates university tenure
procedures, Borkowski said.
Policies established by the board of
1 trustees state tnat auer a ceriam
3 period of time a professor is
* granted tenure. The grievance
cidentally stabs hit
iured in B?
F
3 nament, Otts said
f started showing i
lentally during an also a factor in th<
n in Russell House Crocker said 2
ning. tournament, whi
!S Branham, who is was completely g
elf in the right thigh Crocker said
lentified person and tendance were u
to his pants pocket students were w
amous pool player redneck types th
neated and released Crocker said t
program of pec
behavior. Some
director, said the shouting.
ed by Budweiser of
to be held in the GAMECOCK f
was going to be a man he assumed
t was moved to the Kept putting nis n
photographing th
my camera anc
)pened inside the photographer) Dc
he university police big guy with a Bi
a room, assist him, tilm and then foll<
ts said, "instead of Pace said he
ingacrowd." something happ
' employee, said the in the man's w<
tudents despite the a side door, lie
mitted as student's Newman, anoth<
members of the local took the film and
d. Mark Lawson,
appear at the tour- had no comment
f Outlet
%
K) Blossom
iunnyside Dr.
ATfiS CDDIKI
^ 1 w ^ 0%111
?ALE *
: our complete stock
name junior sportsv
j Held Back ?
Everything Gc
^ -J CMIdiv^MU
ri euuy, ?iuiui muj vh
- 6 Monday - Saturd
rvf/iorAir
LT1COOV/1
committee, however, takes no
stance on the tenure situation of
professors who are dismissed and
then reinstated.
"The question is, if rein
siaiemeni occure, uwa icuuit
automatically follow? ' We clearly
have two points in conflict,"
Borkowskisaid.
BORKOWSKI ADDED that he
doesn't expect the Zeltner decision
by the grievance committee to
have any affect on the lawsuit USC
has introduced.
"I think it (the decision) will have
very little effect. I think the suit
? 111 J Un ntim Koctc The
Will MttllU till HO VJ VY 11 t/tuio. anv
outcome of the lawsuit may well
affect this decision and any other
grievances that are pending,"
Borkowski said.
If USC's lawsuit is successful,
Borkowski said, he is unsure
whether the decision in Zeltner's
case will be immediately reversed.
"I have no way to speculate on
that There is no wav to trv and
foresee what the courts are going to
ascertain about the case," he said.
mself
allroom
I, word got around and more people
ip. He said the free beer served was
e large attendance
:0 kegs of beer were served at the
ch started at about 7 p.m. The beer
;one by about 10:15 p.m.
primarily the non-students in atnruly
during the program, while the
ell-behaved. "There were a bunch of
ere." Crocker said.
here were incidents throughout the
iple screaming and general rowdy
people had to be told to refrain from
)hotographer Russell Pace said a
I to be a Budweiser representative
and in front of his camera lens while
e incident. "I took the film out of
i gave it to (fellow Gamecock
ive Roback." Pace said. "Another
Lisch shirt saw me give Roback the
>wed him into the Ballroom."
followed the man "just in case
;ned." He said another student got
ly and Roback took the film through
1 ?1 r:i Unmn,
>DacK men nit? nun iu i>uii>
?r (Gamecock ) photographer, who
locked it in the newspaper officc.
of Budweiser of Columbia said he
on the incident.