The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, June 07, 1979, Page Page 7, Image 7
I
A
Allen does it ag
By David Baker
Entertainm?nt Editor
I'm hesitant to call any movie the best movie of the year
when the year isn't half over, but I honestly don't think any
of the year's upcoming films will come near to topping
Woody Allen's Manhattan.
Allen has taken the comedy of Annie Hall and the
seriousness of Interiors and blended them together to form
what will undoubtedly be remembered as the definitive
movie of the 1970s. Had it been made in the 1990s, it would
have set off a wave of nostalgia reminiscent of the nnp spt
off five years ago by American Graffiti.
The film opens much the same way as Annie Hall, with an
Allen monologue. In Manhattan, the monologue combines
views of both the romantic and the repellent aspects of life
and love among the intellectual set of New York City. As the
words flow so pursuasively into the viewer's ears, his eyes
are treated to some of the most glamorous and exciting
shots of the Manhattan skyline ever to reach the screen.
By the time the all-important background music (George
Gershwin's "Rhapsody in Blue") builds to its neardeafening
climax, fireworks are seen exploding over
Contral Park and it's nhvinns whirh nf uiou/c nf No%u
York Allen has chosen to explore more thoroughly.
Indeed, love or the disintegration of love is practically the
centerpiece of Manhattan's every scene. Whether it's in the
scenes dealing with the betrayals of his lesbian exwife, Jill
(Mervl Streep), or in the scenes dealing with his affair with
17-year-old Tracy (Mariel Hemingway), Allen's Isaac
Davis comes across as a man who is almost terminally
consumed by a passion he isn't really sure how to deal with.
NOT KNOWING how to handle such emotion makes Isaac
seem selfish and sometimes even cruel towards the women
in his life, and his bizarre sexual oredicaments are eohopd
by his best ffiend, Yale (Michael Murphey), who can't
resist ripping off a little on the side even though he is
supposedly happily married (to Anne Byrne).
The real plot of Manhattan is put in motion when Yale
attempts to normalize his life by ending his affair with
Ill
I A
?r: ^ :':'y St mJ&BSBB&I llB&HlBl
jtwMLi^*.".. .Jappllpfl HB QMSi |Hi _ wk
J
[ i|r|r|. ....... t:^^^B:|..^^^i|^j^j^iite^j||i8|&i^jgtflajf|jij|iiiijttBl^fltti
"71 " T1
ain ? 'Manhattan
journalist Mary Wilke (Diane Keaton). By pushing Mary
and Isaac together, Yale hopes to get off the hook with
IVTiirU anH holn Icoir* Allf nf Uio 4-1* ?4
....... j ui.u nvi(/ iouuv >/ui vi mo cuiv,auii:iit wini 11 ctuy ctl
the same time.
Isaac's quick affair with Mary is Manhattan's highlight.
As always, the interplay of Keaton and Allen is nothing
short of masterful, but the strange thing about their
relationship in Manhattan is that Keaton's character is not
an instantly likable one.
In fact, Isaac first sees Mary as being quite obnoxious.
When the two first meet, Mary insults everything Isaac
holds dear (including Ingmar Bergman). Mary's conceit
and condescension are immediate turn-offs for Isaac, just
as Isaac's "lack of good taste" are turn-offs for Mary.
When their second meeting turns into an all-night talk
session, however, Mary and Isaac find themselves immensely
attracted to one another, though neither
ackriowledaps what i?i Hanrw?nino
n - - ? r'l f->- '
THE FIRST DISPLAY of affection from either of the
soon-to-be-lovers comes after another long talk (this one at
the Hadyn Planetarium), when Isaac tells Mary he wanted
to "fling her down on the lunar surface and commit interstellar
perversion." Naturally, after an admission like
that, the pair are soon rocketing off into love's tender bliss.
The bliss doesn't prove to be a lasting one, though, as
Yale soon decides he wants to win Mary back.
Allen's and Marshall Brickman's script keeps each of the
love affairs completely believable at all times, even when
no dialogue is used. One marvelous scene features Allen,
Keaton, Murphy and Byrne together in a theatre balconv.
As the show progresses below them, the looks in each one's
eyes tell more about his or her character than dialogue ever
could.
Allen's use of Gershwin's music in the background and
Gordon Willis' stunning black-and-white cinematography
also contribute to the movie's strong cohesive structure.
The performances of Allen, Murphy, Byrne and Streep
grow surprisingly richer with each viewing, but it's Keaton
1 V V -
anu rtemingway wno taKe Manhattan's top acting honors.
A m
Wk y_;': i L' ' \ l:^BB^ij^^y* '^"jv'?'''
B? .;'. ;v. WH :rA~^t y] \ < j
I ^ SBHK'
,|I ? | - "V,V" 1 'S'
' is year's best
Hemingway's statuesque (she's nearly six feet tall)
beauty and model-like features make her seem every bit a
woman, while her raspy little voice is there to remind
everyone that she's still not quite an adult. This attractive
combination of incongruities, along with the sweetness and
vulnerabilitv sho nrniprts malcps: kaar'c infntn^Hnn
I? - j-w.w, v- u iiauvu(ui\/ii ill!
Tracy into something special for every person who witnesses
it.
But, as usual, it's Keaton's blazing presence that makes
Manhattan worth seeing more than once. The smile and
humor that made her my favorite actress work overtime
here, making sure that everyone is able to see that beneath
Mary Wilke's shrill exterior lies an interior that's every bit
as lovable as Annie Hall's. Keaton's performance in
Manhattan should be the one that wins her recognition as
ftho finDot O rnc C urA?Lrin/t +
HIV Iiuvai uvu voo w v?i rv I lift, lUVldjr .
SECOND ONLY TO KEATON in my affections is Sally
Field. Enamored as I am, though, even I/udn't expect the
petite dynamo to single-handedly save one of Irwin Alien s
disastrous disaster movies. Surprisingly enough, however,
Field does iust that in Allon'Q RovnnH
0 --- . jvhm % ?v m vnt m\fii rill"
venture.
As Michael Caine's love interest, a role which most other
actresses simply would have been content to walk through,
Field gives Nelson Giddings' script a delightful comic slant
that practically makes the picture a tongue-in-cheek take
off of itself.
Caine evidently saw what Field was doing with her role
and decided he would treat the movie in a lighter vein as
well. By doing so, he comes off almost as good as Field
herself. The rest of the cast members (Telly Savalas, Peter
Boyle, Shirley Jones and Karl Maiden) are either so ill
-J 1 * 1
iidiurem anu evu or so wiae-eyed and weepy that one constantly
yearns to see them go down with the ship.
Without Field and Caine, Beyond the Poseidon Adventure
WOUld surelv h;?vo boon hr?rrf?nH^uc hut writVi
consistently entertaining and often involving. It would be
interesting to see the duo work together in a film more
deserving of their talents. If they can be this good under
Irwin Allen, they'd win Oscars under anyone else.