The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, April 06, 1979, Page Page 5, Image 5
By Michael Gooding
Qarrwcock Staff Writer
South Carolina may soon become
the nuclear waste dumping ground
of the world, according to Mirhapl
Lowe of the Palmetto Alliance.
About 80 percent of the nation's
low-level radioactive material is
brought to South Carolina for
storage, Lowe said, but if a
proposal submitted to Congress in
1977 is passed, the state may soon
be receiving large amounts of
high-level radioactive material
from other countries.
Submitted by President Jimmy
Carter and the U.S. Department of
Energy, the proposal calls for
countries importing American
nuclear technology to sell
plutonium and other nuclear byproducts
to the United States. This
would prevent these countries
from using the materials to
manufacture nuclear weapons,
said David Berick, Washington,
D.C. representative for the Environmental
Policy Center. These
highly radioactive materials would
thf?n hp stnrpH in fho Tlnifa^
~ ? WW. vv. u?v V1UVVU UIOV^O
at a site selected by the federal
government.
The U.S. Department of Energy
is currently considering Barnwell
Riley opj
new m
Staff and Wire report!
Gov. Dick Riley said Thursday 1
oppose any further construction of r
energy plants in South Carolina unt
nuclear cycle is complete."
In an interview on NBC's Today
Pilm; Dfiirl ?
i%uvjr o?iv4 11^ iiuimo iuu many uuctii;
questions remain in terms of s
transportation and recycling of r
wastes.
While Riley said he would not starn
way of completion of five nuclear
plants now under construction in
Carolina, he said he would "oppo:
further construction of nuclear plant!
state."
ml - ? * 1 -
ine governor saia, nowever, he tc
state government "has the situatior
control" in terms of its ability to r
conditions at the four existing plants.
Because of South Carolina's "lc
perience" in dealing with nuclear <
Riley said the state is adequately
l ii.. u?:? i lit- i -
uaiiuie any puuui; iituiim, iriomioi
evacuation problems.
South Carolina was one of the firsl
to use nuclear energy and gets about
its electrical power from that sourcc
nuclear waste is also stored in
Carolina than any other state.
Riley was interviewed along witl
Jim Thompson of Illinois in the wakt
nuclear accident this past week at the
Mile Island plant at Middletown, Pa.
The Pi
nuclear c
as the Away From Reactor, AFR, v
storage site. E
"Barnwell is the most attractive s
. site," Berick said, but the r
Department of Energy is also s
considering sites at West Valley, c
N.Y., and Morris, 111. c
Tf Rornuroll ic '
At i^utun\;ii to ocicviUU, UCIWIXU V
1,000 and 1,500 metric tons of spent b
fuel (plutonium, uranium and v
other nuclear fission products) "
could be brought to South Carolina h
by 1987, "but that is a shot in the
dark," he said. c
Berick said a major problem r;
with the proposal is "it doesn't s\
prevent someone from taking fuel C
out of the reactor." A foreign s?
country could return only a portion p
of the fuel, then use the rest for pi
nuclear weapons," he said. hi
"What's the difference between T
building 200 bombs and 800 A
bombs," Berick said. fc
The federal government has not
done adequate studies on en- w
*
' -; ; N $.
i
u
I i
Nuclear plant b
loses build
iclear plant
Riley said earlier in an int<
he will Charlotte Observer that he f<
luclear called for" in nuclear deve
il "the state.
"I don't mean that we oug
show, we're doing now," he said,
swered pause in terms of new p]
torage, processes. We should look at
luclear consider snfpfv faftnrc a?
V ,MVVVtu MI
liabilities."
i in the Riley said during his
energy governor this past year that 1
South about South Carolina's grov
se any nuclear waste storage site.
3 in the permanent plans for waste c
any more nuclear generati
iels the constructed.
i unaer Riley admitted there is lit
nonitor can a50Ut the broad iss
power.
"It's a national problem, a
>ng ex- ^ a natjonaj problem," he
eihl tn want it to be South Carolina's
. "There are no plans for a si
ring or nuclear plants in South Cart
Brown, press secretary for Hi
t states
half of Brown said although the n
i. More in Oconee County was design
South and Wilcox, the same contra
Mile Island plant, the two \
ferent. The parts which
i Gov. malfunction at Three Mile Is
5 of the identical and there's not th<
s Three procedures between the tw
said.
Si
almetto
lumping
ironmental impact, accordinj
lerick. Aspects such as ti
portation risks, amounts
adioactive material to
tored,methods of storage
osts of the project should
onsidered, he said. The
iornmental impact study tha
eing conducted by the
ironmental Protection Age
doesn't even address the issi
? j
e saia.
"It would be very difficult," f<
ountry to build a bomb from
adioactive waste, Tom Grah.
pokesman for the U.S. Ai
ontrol and Disarmament Ager
aid. "They have very c<
rehensive safeguards,"
revent anyone from obtain
igh-level uranium or plutonii
he International Atomic Ene
gency establishes the safegua
>r nuclear plants, he said.
Lowe said about 75 percent of
orld's nuclear waste will
eing constructed,
r i
my
S M
jrview with The KT .
eels "a pause is Nuclear (
lopment in the Urcew^
Three Mile
[ht to stop what dletown, Pi
"but I mean a P f<fsor,s
lants and new c Cathey>
our options and Savannah _
id assets and Savannah F
a careful se
the east coa
campaign for Cathey s?
le was worried *? ?verybod
ving role as a Commissioi
He called for situation wi
lisposal before Harrisburg
ng plants are Ronald E<
in pnncip<
a fail-safe
tie a governor wrong, tlx
iue of nuclear automatical
shut down
nd I want it to system left
said. "I don't understand
problem." beenpossibl
nitdown of any Edge said
)lina," Marion industry is h
ley, said. faulty parts
industry, wl
uclear facility concerned w
ea oy BaDcock "Somehov
ctor for Three industry is
)lants are dif- what they sa
caused the joints of the
land are "not upon the int<
5 same set of said. "I don'i
r> nlantc " ka .,
"uovemrri
liquor can a
<o Rllay, pag* 6 which are n
State:
g groun
g to brought to Barnwell if
ran- is approved by coi
of Barnwell is chosen s
be storage site,
and The Palmetto Allia
be concerned with currer
en- at the Savannah Rive
t is said. The plant is loca
En- well and Aiken count
ncy cupies a chunk of Soi
le," roughly the size of Sal
It is owned by the fe<
ara nment and some of t
this are under military
am, where materials an
'ms tured for nuclear wai
icy, Ted Harris of the
3m- . Alliance. The plant coi
to inoperative and thre
ing nuclear reactors, two r
jm. plants in operation an<
rgy water facility, Lowe sa
rds The plant also has i
for low-level waste a
the farm" where high-leve
be stored. The tank farr
/
/
<y'
Si
in Jenkensville
ISC prof
uclear ei
By Mark Platte
Qamecock Staff Writer
energy is still the safest enei
pite the recent incident at I
i Island Nuclear Plant in M
i., Leconte Cathey, USC phys
aid.
a former employee of l
River Nuclear Plant, said I
5lant was constructed only af
;arch for the best type of land
St.
lid, "It should breed confider
Itr ' ' fVin f Mi?/\1/\? m II .1 ~ i -
ijr, uiai me mitit'di neguiaix
i was able to control t
thout allowing panic among t
(Three Mile Island) employee
ige, USC nuclear physicist, sa
il, allnuclear plants should ha
system and if anything gc
e plant should shut do\
lly. The plant in Harrisburg c
but the failure of the cooli
them with no backup. I doi
that because that shouldn't ha
e," he said.
the problem facing the nucle
iow the government can preve
? from being produced by tl
lich Edge said he feels is on
ith profit.
/ or other, we have to ensure tl
straight, that thev are doi?
y and that they are x-raying tl
plant," Edge said. "It depen<
?grity of the industry itself," I
t know how it can be resolved.'
ient inspectors of either meat <
tfford to get by with produc
ot up to par occasionally, bi
contains 21 n
liquids, Lowe
Lowe said
? 4"^ cerned with
J waste is buri
^J[ I is radioactivi
placed in poh
are then stor
:he proposal last 50 years,
igress and Lowe also j
s the AFR Nuclear Fuel
located eighl
nee is also bia. This pla
t conditions containing i
r Plant, he said.
Led in Barn- Currently,
ies and oc- transported
th Carolina decision to p
jda County. for commerc:
leral gover- currently bei
he reactors nuclear reac
operation, running out o
i manufac- The Ocone
heads, said Seneca has I
Palmetto storage faci
isists of two "within the
i operative Lowe said,
eprocessing Lowe said t
1 one heavy considering t
d. to "storage p
burial site reactor near
id a "tank extremely h
1 liquids are Lowe said,
n currently an estimated
/
essors c
lergy sq
the trouble with the nuch
gy you can't afford to let one
he it does, then you have
id- Harrisburg," Edge said,
ics Both professors agreec
currently being brought t
he virtually harmless becai
he for such material, I
er disagreement as to the
on these wastes.
"There is no way that
ce can hurt the state of Sou
ry someone were to cut
he Cathey said "There is v<
he that happening because o
5. tanks around the materi
d, layers of security," he sai
ce "The amount of dang
es waste in South Carolina
1 a r
in oui ii we were to nave a
id that's very possible, a c
lg which carries the waste c<
i t radioactive particles esca
/e Both Edge and Cathey ?
material under the ve
*r probably catch any wast
it ground. Cathey said this
ie once it runs into the grou
ly there is no way to del
escape unless a vessel wei
TU ~ O ? - *%
ic- i uc oavannan uiver ]
ig manufacturer of materi;
le nuclear weapons under t
Is the Dupont corpora tio:
le Cathey. "Dupont made th<
' even down to having the p
>r take off their shoes becau
s soles would strike a sparl
it said
lillion gallons of these
;said.
the Alliance is conthe
way the low-level
ed. He said the waste
e for 500 years and is
/ethylene bags, which
ed in drums that will
?aid the Westinghouse
I Division has a plant
t miles from Columnt
produces fuel rods
iranium pellets, he
no fuel rods are being
because of Carter's
ostpone reprocessing
ial uses. Fuel rods are
ng stored on sight at
tors, but, "they are
f room," Lowe said,
e Nuclear Station at
this problem and its
; 1 : 11 i? r i i
nines will ue lull
next nine months,"
When this happens,
he Oconee plant is
ransporting the rods
ools" at the McGuire
Charlotte. These rods,
igh in radioactivity,
remain deadly for
250,000 years.
....
laim
r i
jest
ear industry is that
bad joint get by. If
a situation like in
I the nuclear waste
o South Carolina is
lse of the barriers
but there is a
oossible esrarn1 nf
the nuclear waste
th Carolina unless
open the tanks,"
?ry little chance of
f the four layers of
al. These are four
d.
er of the nuclear
is not very great,
n earthquake, and
rack in the vessel
[>uld result in some
ping," Edge said.
.aid there is a clay
?~ ^l~ ? - - ? ??
wnicn will
e running into the
gas cannot escape
nd, but Edge said
tgermine gaseous
*e to crack.
plant has been a
als in the use of
he supervision of
n, according to
at plant the safest,
eoole who entered
ise the nails in the
c in the plant," he
Sm USC, page 6