The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, November 21, 1974, Page Page 11, Image 13
The Paul Winter Consort at the Coliseum
0KCIS
BY CHUCK CROMER
AND TERRY DUGAS
Of The Gamecock staff
As we approach Thanksgiving holidays and so on
afterward the inevitable final exams, we may find this
week to be one of the last to afford any time for us to
relax.
Nevertheless, the spectrum of entertainment and
cultural activities continues to be varied.
If relaxation is what you're after, there's no better
way to begin this week than with the insane comedy of
Steve Martin. A regular on the Tonight Show, Martin
will keep you wondering how he escaped from a mental
hospital. His last scheduled performance at USC begins
at 8 p.m. tonight in the Golden Spur.
At the opposite end of the spectrum is a symposium on
the works of the 1971 Nobel Prize in Literature winner
Pablo Neruda. The symposium begins with an opening
address, "Pablo Neruda: The Voice of Chile," at 7:30
p.m. tonight at Capstone. At 8 p.m. Friday, a reading in
Spanish and English of Neruda s poems will be given. A
round table discussion will be conducted at 11:30 a.m.
Saturday. Sponsored by the Department of Foreign
Languages, all events are in Capstone and are open to
the public.
Neruda, who died last year shortly after a coup top
p led the Allende regime, had been the Chilean am
bassador to France, and was widely acknowledged as
the greatest living South American poet. Robert Lowell
shared this appraisal, calling Neruda a "weighty and
great poet." A new selection of his poems, Five
Decades, was made available in a bilingual edition
earlier this year by Grove Press.
For those whose interest tends toward rock music,
possibly the last band to play In the Spur this semester
will be Kinfolk, Monday and Tuesday nights. The band's
material Is characterized as Southern rock in the
"Allman Brothers tradition." One wonders why many
semi-original bands classify their music as being in the
Allman tradition.
Winter C<
a great d
BY CHUCK CROMER
AND TERRY DUGAS
Of The Gamecock Staff
The Paul Winter Consort arrived
in Columbia Monday night amidst
high expectations fostered by four
superb albums and an outstanding
concert here four years ago.
Unfortunately, the evening proved
to be a great disappointment.
One reason for the disillusion
ment was we expected far more
than a five man group could
I deliver. The intricate blending of
dissimilar instruments which
makes the Winter Consort albums
so good is achieved with two ad
ditional members, a string player
and a brass and wind instrument
player.
The five man Consort could not
keep up the delicate interplay of
sounds while using David Darling's
cello to dominate the compositions
and intimidate the other in
struments.
Fortunately, Darling was the
best musician in the group so his
dominance was at least bearable.
Unfortunately, Paul Winter was
nothing short of terrible on sax and
I oboe.
Winter, as his albums and
reviews testify, is one of the finest
musicians in America but on
Monday, he did little more than hit
sour notes and skip entire
passages.
The keyboard man, Robert
Chappell, was equally weak in his
instrumentation, playing the
harpsichord, Fender electronic
piano, pump and pipe organ that
sounded like a cross between "a
cello and duck." He, like Winter,
played wrong notes and skipped
others.
The percussionist, Tigger
Benford, was unnoticed most of the
night as his drums were dwarfed
by the tympanies of his fellow
percussionist, Ben , Benford
played an occasional cow
bell or wood block but, by and
large, he was - not effectively
utilized by the group.
Carriel played, besides tym
pany, an Indian drum set and a
base marimba. The marimba,
used in place of a conventional
base, was often far too noticeable,
masking the softer sound of the
cello a ebars
The- Cliseum set the official
attendance at 756 and most people
were apparently familiar with the
type of music played by the Con
sort. The two sets were intended to
stir different emotional responses
from the audience.
Music Department
presents trio
The USC Department of Music
will present the USC Piano Trio in
concert at 8pm Tuesday, Dec. 3, in
Fraser Hall.
The concert Is open to the public
free of charge and will feature the
Beethoven "Archduke" trio op. 97
and the Brahms trio in e op. 87.
The trio is made up of John
Bauer, violin; Lucien De Groote,
cello; and John Williams, piano, all
of theUSC Music faculty.
fsort pro
Lisappointi
The first det was intended,
basically, to entertain and to show
the ability of the Consort to adapt
traditional musical styles to their
own form. In the first set,
Hungarian and Brazilian folk
songs were combined with Bach
chamber variations and classical
guitar work. Even a Gregorian
chant was adapted for cello and
percussion.
The first set, however, only
pointed'out how desperately the
Consort needed its other two
members as Carriel's marimba
boomed over the other instruments
and Chappell's guitar work was
painfully bad.
In the second set, the Consort
attempted to introduce a spiritual
rapport with the audience similar
to that of the Mahavishnu Or
chestra. The Consort called at
tention to the plight of endangered
species by combining the calls of
animals with instruments.
The attempt was noble and,
occasionally, highly effective.
However the Consort included
Nam June Pa1k, internatssafly I
the USC Department of Art en Thi
and discuss his werk at 12:3S and?7
Sloan College. The dewumstrata
public. A Korean-bern writer, min
presented his first video exhibit i
artist In residence at The Televish
In New York ty.
Ovides
nent
over ten "animals in their
presentation. The audience was
invited to chant along with the
Consort during the close of the
number. Bu t the mood of the
audience was too frivolous for it to
be effective.
The highpoint of the evening was
the final song of the second set,
"Minuit," an African tribal song.
It was only in this number that the
Consort achieved any cohesiveness
in instrumentation. The song
opened at a slow, flowing pace and
slowly built in power and tempo as
each instrument was highlighted
and then blended with the others.
The Winter- Consort will neyer
be the powerful group it was in the
past without the addition of a
second brass man able to play
oboe, sousaphone, and Prench
horn, and the addition of a string
player who can play guitar, lute,
and sitar. Without these, the
Consort is simply a group of
musicians who are musically
expert except when they perform
*4
known ple.eer ofiGs. art, will visit
ariday and Friday. Paik will show
:3S p.m. em 'Thursday in reeam83e
as and discussions ae epea t. She
Icia., teacher and techmieiam, Paik
Glermamy in 1963. Hie is cearmUty
a Laboratery et WNr kne 13