The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, March 14, 1974, Page Page 7, Image 7
Ennis Rees
Flawc
BY DAVID HAVIRD
Sometime ago I was at a party
and the wife of one of the more
distinguished faculty members at
the University asked who the
English professor was who wrote
poems for children. She was
referring to Ennis Rees whose
Selected Poems was published
recently by University of South
Carolina Press.
Whether Rees' poems are indeed
"children's poems" or not is
debatable--I have mixed feelings
about it. Many do sound juvenile;
and it seems to me at least
disconcerting to write in the
contemporary idiom of con
temporary things. We are all
familiar with those things whic
are part of the "current scene"--I
doubt the contemporary idiom car
afford any really new images
which might alter our viewing o
them.
Poems of this kind compris(
maybe one-third of the volume.
Despite the often puerile quality o
the verses, the extraordinar;
sensitivity of Rees cannot bi
denied. If one finds it the least bi
unbelievable that a 49 year-ol
man still can be fascinated by
small girl dreaming of a tragi
"hide-and-seek" and "ring
around-the-roses," circus dogs, o
common restaurant vignettes, the
one must read these poems. At th
very least, they are honest.
I am tempted to wonder hoi
much British poet Robert Grav(
influenced Rees. Probably Ree
would deny Graves any influenc
at all. Yet many of these quie
Re
At 10
1,100
PAIRS Cul
400
PAIRS H
Will be put on
and each hour
S .50 on thear
shop, the bette
10 A.M.-11 A.li
11 A.M.-12 No4
12 Noon-i P.M
I P.M.-2 P.M.
i221 Ma
d But E
unpretentious poems do recall
Graves'. Both poets emerge
proclaiming the poet's obligation
as a defender and preserver of
form. Yet, whereas Graves has
created a personal though esoteric
mythology from which all his
poems spring, it is not evident that
Rees has. Graves' puerility may
be appreciated on that level; Rees'
often seems mundane.
Included in this remarkably
handsome volume is an ex
ceptionally long poem, "Daze".
Though told as a third person
narrative, the poem explores the
experiences of a girl from her
viewpoint, ending in affirmation.
But it is not the narrative content
which makes this ambitious poem
succeed--and it does. Rather it
succeeds with its precious lyrical
grace, and the subtlety of the
rhymes and assonance. "Daze" is
a beautiful poem, a poem of
language--it is not the end
necessarily which delights, but
rather the journey there.
t "Snakes and Butterflies," the
i other singularly ambitious poem,
e is an overly lengthy, confused
. exposition of "the roiling sub
r conscious". Is it supposed to be the
n '70's answer to The Wasteland? If
e so, it needs the editing of Ezra
v Pound or at the very least the
,s breakdown sensibility of Eliot.
s Rees' distinction is perhaps not
e as an original poet but, like Ed
t, ward Fitzgerald, as a translator.
al Sale N
1 A.M. Sat. March ]
(Saturday Only)
Values to $18.00
'fed Baggies and SI
V alues to $26.00
igh-Style Double I
sale for $5.95 and $14
on the hour the price
maining sale items...t
r the bargains.
I....5.95 & 10.95 2 P.M.-3 P
m...5.45 & 10.45 3 P.M.-4 P
.....4.95 &9.95 4 P.M.-5 P
.....4.45 &9.45 5 P.M.-6 P
in St. (Next To Caroll
at selection of high stsi
[onest
The verse translations of Fables
from Aesop are a genuine delight
many are indc'ed anthology pieces
to be read alongside Mother
Goose. Again, one is reminded of
Robert Graves, at least during his
early period of composition, when
he wrote fairy tales. Here, Rees is
an equal.
If this review has sounded
something less than favorable
overall, it is because I have
examined Selected Poems in order
of the poems' arrangment in the
volume. At last I find Rees'
translations from Homer's Iliad
and Odyssey. These final fifty
pages are worth the price of the
book.
Rees' translations of the com
plete Iliad and Odyssey were
published by Random House in
1960 and 1963, respectively. Not
being able to read Greek, the most
I can say is that to my mind, from a
poetic vantage, these are the finest
translations of Homer available.
What Rees has done, while still
maintaining the integrity of the
originals, I suppose, is to create
new poems. At this point, he and
Edward Fitzgerald join ranks.
Ultimately , with Selected
Poems, we are able to see the
uneven, but presumably
representative work of a seriously
flawed poet who nevertheless
erupts with occasional shimmers
of brilliance and who remains in
our minds innocent, honest, nearly
betrayed, and almost always
amazed.
).12
16, 1974
lacks
$5.95
Enits
$10.95
).95 respectively
will be dropped
he earlier you
M..35& 8.95
M..3.45 & 8.45
M....2.95 &7.95
M....2.45&7.45
nal Theatre)
le sportswear.
F' .
Jimm Cox plays the clown, TouchE
Shakespeare's delightful comedy of
pastoral romance is running through
p.m.
Chinese M
A Sever
BY TIM WILLIAMS I
Entertainment Writer
Last year the Philadelphia Or
chestra toured the People's
Republic of China and performed
several works by Chinese com
posers. Among those played was
the "Yellow River" Concerto.
After listening to Eugene Ormandy
and the Philadelphia Orchestra's
long-awaited "Yellow River"
Concerto album (RCA). I am
forced to conclude that Chairman
Mlao's cultural revolution has met
a severe setback, if not total
defeat. 1
To begin with, "Yellow River" is
so trite it still sounds bad after
interpretation by Ormandy. When
not engaging in out-and out theft
from that capitalist, Franz Liszt,
the concerto utilizes some of the
cutest, most overworked themes
in the annals of music. t
The only hiehpoints are provided
by pianist Daniel Epstein who
negotiates some of the more
complex melodies with inspired
Jim G
i Keg 0
Discount Wii
Your One Stor:
Now St
Deli Sandwiches
Kilbourne & R
Ph. 7&
tone, in the USC pi oduction of
love, "As You Like It." The
today in Drayton Hall at 8:15
"
uisic:
e Setback
irofessionalism. God only knows
what the source of his inspiration
ould be--it surely wasn't the
nusic.
Following close on the heels of
"Yellow River" is another venture
into mediocrity, called "San Pei."
It sounds more like variations on
Mussorgsky's "Gopak" than the
"Chinese workers' and Peasants'
March". The strongest asset to
"San Pei" is that it only lasts about
a minute and a half.
"Stars and Stripes Forever," the
kmerican march, survives
)rimarily on it's own merits, for
)rmandy has neglected the hardy
mnergy of the march and left only
he melodic line.
"The Pines of Rome" almost
aves the album. On "Pines of the
/illa Borghese" Ormandy sheds
iis reputation as a slow conductor
mnd moves forward at his lyrical
)est. "Pines Near A Catacomb" is
:onducted with a unique, eerie
nystery..
rady's
Nails
1e and Beer
Party Center
rrving
& Draught Beer
osewood Dr.
~-5397