The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, April 02, 1973, Page Page 8, Image 10
All Major Drug Compa
FTC: Drug
From The Charlotte Observer
"Today there is still nothing faster .. .
nothing more effective . . . than good old
genuine Bayer Aspirin," says the
announcer in one of Sterling Drug Co.'s tele
vision commercials.
"A combination of pain reliever and a'
sedative provides greater relief than either
medication alone," says a commercial for
Cope, another Sterling headache remedy,
which uses aspirin as a pain reliever.
"Your headache deserves extra strength
and you deserve gentle buffers," say the
ads for Sterling's Vanquish, which contains
buffered aspirin.
"In relieving pain, buffered aspirin isn't
any faster or gentler than Bayer," other
Sterling commercials insist.
If this sounds contradictory to you, it
sounds the same way to the Federal Trade
Commission (FTC), which included such
inconsistencies in a series of compaints it
officially filed last week against Sterling
and two other major marketers of aspirin
or aspirin-combination pills.
Ad Admissions
If the FTC has its way, the companies
would have to devote 25 per cent of their
advertising budgets over a two-year period
to admitting such things as:
"It has not been established that Anacin
is more effective for the relief of pain than
aspirin ..."
"Bufferin will not relieve nervous ten
sion, anxiety, irritability, or enable persons
to cope with the ordinary stresses of
everyday life."
"It has not been established that Excedrin
is more effec.tive for the relief of minor
pain than aspirin or any other nonprescrip
tion internal analgesics...."
"It has not been established that Bayer
Aspirin is more effective for the relief of
minor pain than any (standard) aspirin.
REFEI
SGA Constitution
Article IV The Judicial
Section 2 The Supreme Court
D-2 Powers and Duties
"Original Jurisdiction of the S
involving a student governme
all cases in which a residence a
the Student Government of the
and all election disputes resul
this Constitution."
D-2 shall be amended to read:
Court shall include all cases ir
who has been impeached anc
government may be a party acj
government of another resider
D-6 shall be added to Section
Cour t shall have appeliate juris
ing from the elections conduc
BACKGROUND: The Senate p
revision board to handle elet
petitioning quicker and less ari
jurisdiction to the board and
board they have the right to a;
need for this type of Board I
the supreme court together, I
court has already.
Article lil The Legislature
Section 3 The Election of Stu<
flies Involved
Ads Need(
And so on through a list that includes
Sterling's Bayer Aspirin, Bayer Children's
Aspirin, Cope, Vanquish, and Midol;
Bristol-Myers Co.'s Bufferin, Excedrin, and
Excedrin PM; and American Home
Products Corp.'s Anacin and Arthritis Pain
Formula.
Worse than that for the companies,
perhaps, is the commission's demand that
in all their advertising the companies stop
referring to mysterious ingredients like
"the strong pain reliever doctors recom
mend most" or exotic "mood brighteners,"
if they are talking about plain old aspirin
as they are in all the complained-about pro
ducts or about caffeine as they are in Ana
cin, Cope, Vanquish, Midol, and Excedrin.
Bristol-Myers would have to stop assert
ing that Bufferin and Excedrin are faster
or more effective than aspirin. American
Home Products would have to stop saying
that Anacin is more effective than a recom
mended dose of any other painkiller.
Claims that Bayer is better than any other
aspirin or that Anacin is recommended by
many doctors could not be made unless they
were true. The FTC is already satisfied,
the complaint said, that these and many
other claims are questionable or not based
on "reasonable" evidence. Sterling and
Bristol-Myers said they would defend the
accuracy of their advertising claims.
American Home did not comment.
Long Legal Battle
All this may add up to an Excedrin
headache for the legal departments of the
three drug companies, but it doesn't mean
fast, fast relief for the confused consumer.
The FTC has been locked in languid legal
battle with the same companies over
similar advertising claims for more than
a decade. Even if the FTC's latest effort
is successful, commission staffers predict
it will be three to five years before it
changes any of the commercials on which
each of the companies now spends at least
WENDUM
APRI
upreme Court shall include all cases
nt officer who has been Impeached,
rea government may be a party against
government of another residence area,
ting from elections conducted under
"Original jurisdiction of the Supreme
ivolving a student government officer
all cases in which a residence area
iainst the Student Government or the
ice area."
2 of Article IV to read: "The Supreme
fiction over all election disputes result
ted under this Constitution."
assed several bills creating an election
tion matters, making the process of
'ibigious. The referendum simply gives
even if petitioner is unhappy with the
>peal afterward to supreme court. The
as arrisen in that it is difficult to get
mot to mention the load the supreme
lent Senators
onsistenCy
$50 million a year.
The same companies, and the makers of
St. Joseph Aspirin, were charged with false
advertising in a 1961 FTC complaint that
mentioned examples like Anacin's "fast .
..fast ... incredibly fast relief," the claim
that "Bufferin acts twice as fast as aspirin,"
and Bayer's "fastest, most gentle to the
stomach relief you can get."
This legal effort failed and was aban
doned in 1967 in favor of an attempt to
impose a general rule forbidding false
advertising of headache remedies. The
legalizing of this rule-making procedure
had to be fought to the Supreme Court.
The High Court finally gave the FTC the
go-ahead in 1970. Three months later the
commission decided to abandon the rule
making effort in favor of the case-by-case
approach and began investigations aimed
at another batch of company-by-company
complaints. That investigation resulted in
"proposed complaints," translated into offi
cial complaints last week.
First Witness
Attorneys say it will probabjy be another
year before an FTC "administrative law
judge" hears the first witness on the com
plaints. His decision will probably be
appealed to the five FTC commissioners.
Their opinion should emerge about 1975.
That decision may be appealed to the U.S.
Court of Appeals and then to the U.S. Sup
reme Court.
If the FTC successfully jumps all these
legal hurdles, the commission will then be
free to ask the Justice Department to pro
ceed against companies that continue to vio
late the restrictions that the FTC seeks in
its complaint. The Justice Department may
file suit in a U.S. District Court. If the com
pany loses in that court and later loses its
appeal, it will face fines of up to $5,000 for
each violation.
TO BE H
L 18
Paragraph C "The Student Senators of Si
officers appointed by them in the legisla
in good conduct their respective offices f
the inauguration of the President in the
of the new President the following spring
Paragraph C will be amended to read
Senators of Student Government and all
in the legislative branch shall maintain in
tive offices for a term of one year.
BACKGROUND: The cohstitution was writ
tions for certain senate seats (Ex. off camp
dum simply clears up the period of time a
The referendum will be held Wednesday
the referendum you must present your
who will check your name off on a comn
the referendum ballot on a sheet of pa;
will be open from 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Polls will
(1) Russell House-Golden Spur for
residents of the Roost, Preston, Woodros
married students housing.
(2) Capstone
(3) Bates
(4) South Building for South Tower, S<
Quad rang le.
(5) Towers
The election commission urges everyone
18 APRIL!
Spring Thing
Activities Open
As the warm weather engulfs us
all, students come down with a com
mon disease known as Spring Fever.
If you want a sure cure for this ail
ment, take part in Spring Thing '73.
Activities are open to all students
and most of them are free, accord
ing to Michael Tucker, co-chairman
of the special events committee of
the University Union, in a direct
attempt to involve everyone.
Activities for Spring Thing '73
will run April 5-7 and include con
certs, an all-night coffee house with
student acts, comedy entertain
ment, a luau and a student auction
in which students can sell anything
they wish.
The schedule for Spring Thing '73
is as follows:
Thursday: 2:00-7:00 craft fair on Russel House
patio
5:00-7:00 luau in front of undergraduate lib
rary
7:00-8:30 "Silver-nan" on the patio
8:30-9:30 Portable Circus (satire-comedy
group) on the patio
Friday: 7:30-12:30 concert in Township
-\uditoriu'n featuring Brewer and Shipley.
Ji'nmy Spheeris. and Silver-nan - $1.50 for stu
dents
12:30-4:00 a.n. coffee house in the Golden
Spur in the Russell House
ELD
udent Government and all
tive branch shall maintain
>r a term of one year from
spring to the inauguration
ts follows: "The Student
>fficers appointed by them
iood conduct their respec
en prior to having fall elec
us freshmen). The referen
senator will serve.
18 April. To participate in
I.D. card to a poll worker
puter sheet, then sign for
er at the polls. The polls
be located at:
ill off campus student and
v Tenements (Horse-shoe),
>uth Building and Women's
to vote in the referndrum,