The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, May 15, 1970, Page Page 2, Image 2
ByA MVKAY BRABHAM JR.
TheRe%Mr. Drabama'l editor of the
C. United Wetiodit Advooate.
I am complimented by your reprinting im
The Gamecock (Friday, May 8) my
editorial "The Voice of the Pennle" from
the South Carolina Methodist Advocate of
February 26.
The question of free speech and a fro
press and the right of dissent, all dealt wit
in that editorial, is more than ever befor
us now. Events which have taken plac
since May 8 on the University campu
illustrate this.
There is an old saying which constantly
comes back to me. I do not know its origin
but-history and experience have enshrine
it because of its truth: "Whom the god
would destroy, they first make mad.'
Believers in one God can still accept th
basic idea, that destruction comes wher
the mind is gone. We appear to be caughi
up in such a time as this, when those whorr
*ve think would be our friends turn againsi
-is in fear and fright if we speak the truth t
.hem.
Enou,
Enough is enough.
Governor Robert E. McNair has i
stand, everybody has seen it. So lei
of the University be. We no longer
National Guardsmen and the near
officers-and a 9 p.m. to 6 a.m. cur
two nights have been peaceful. (
inconvenience students, Irritating I
longer needed restrictions will n
situation any better. We think r,
enforcement to normal would spi
plete return to normal on campus
Perhaps the Charlotte Observe
mood best in a story yesterday:
Lawless
Several nights of gung-ho enforco
and order on campus have given ser
many students of the lawfulness of n
Carolina law enforcement.
There have been many charges
such as unprovoked beatings and
invasions of dormitories call for
sideration. Governor Robert E.
asked for an internal Investigation
agencies potentially involved. Yet
that department--the Highwdy
already admiled that he is confli
men will be found innocent. Go
vestigation as the government hav
too impressive.
We feel that the best way to air
and counter charges is that an indel
undertake a study of the matter
testimony and offerings from al
Hopefully, the truth could be sifte
An ideal group would be the At
Liberties Union affiliate in the sta
also be interested in their considi
Constitutional aspects of the sham
arrested and sent to the state Di
Corrections. We consider this to be
before conviction, much as is Un
Dietzel urges
Let's
ByvPAULIElT'4EL
Gsuest Columnist
Most of us are sick at heart over
the recent events that have taken
place at our fine institution. Many
things that we see are difficult to
believe but some of the things that
we read become a little more
obvious each day. Have you
read: "A. Corrupt the young,
get them away from religion. Get
them interested in sex. Make them
superficial, destroy their
ruggedness.
"B. Get control of all means of
publicity and thereby:
"1. Divide the people into
hostile groups by constantly
harping on controversial matters
of no importance.
"2. Destroy the people's
faith in their natural leaders by
holding the latter up to contempt
and ridicule.
"3. Always preach true
democracy but seize power as fast
and as ruthlessly as possible.
"4. Create unnecessary
strikes in vital industries, en
courage civil disorders, foster a
lenient and soft attitude on the part
of government toward such
disorders.
"Sl. By elaborate argument
cause the breakdown of the old
moral virtues: honesty, sobriety,
continuence, faith in the pledge
word, ruggedness."
is thin quote describing what we
have been reading in The New
Vork iPaily News. The Akron
. BeAeon ,Journal, or ear own State
* Kte'4rd No. These are excerpts
tak' fromn the file "Commnist
ibdes for iteveoeten" which wore
.labwed In Dluwseldert. Germany
a7 nav of sma. aso.ever, they
atders
le ave
This is especially true if we tr
thin line which tries to distinguish I
justice as opposed to persecuti(
speech as opposed to inciting to rio
of assenibly as opposed to treep
destruction of property, or even
those whose love for country and G
them to heed "thou shalt not kill
posed to those who seek to use oppo
war as a source of national confut
possible de-Aruction, strife and
enslavement.
e All of this leads me to say thi
e hoping that the students on the Ui
s campus are taking a hard look at a
issues as you attend classes un
supervision of the military.
Such circumstances must
mixed feelings - forboding of thi
state mixed- with thanksgiving tt
are there to protect life and propez
those who appear to regard neithe
imagine that these men in unifc
disturbed too: possibly as brot
fathers of students, they are cor
anxious, fearful, for the life of ou
and of students on the campus, eve
life of the University.
As we see it
gh is ene
"Nobody wants
nade a tough exams. Most of t
the students They have had eni
need the 600 enough of the v
ly 200 police campus radicals.
few. The last feeling that pretty
'ontlnuing to killed."
I'hem with no
ot make the The governor P
eturning law that any more o
,ed the com- tinued occupation
whether the wave
r caught the whatever else,
situation.
law enfo
?ment of law porary or permar
'ous doubt to they are found in
luch of South them. There alsc
state with bond pC
made. Some political prisoner
uncalled for spiracy charges
serious con- spiracy charges I
McNair has as the "Medieva
of ohe of the A thorough st
the head of needed. Perhaps,
Patrol--has local law et
lent that his procedurers.Pert
ternment in- would be the fir,
e never been changes. We hop
the challenge.
the charges,
pendent body
-taking any S
I concerned. Wednesday S.(
d out- said that the Ca
nerican Clvii safest Diaces to
te. We would night the young
~ration of the Bobby, Linda Hi
iing of those to spend the nigi
apart,mnent of (The younger Mc
a punishment in Mississippi.)
iversity tern- signed out togo t
cure pr
could just as easily been quotes
from liitler's "Mein Kamph"
' which no one bothered to heed
early' enough>.
Radical revolutionists have not
always been .Communistic. The
exact same "happenings" were
carried to their carefully planned
conclusion by Ultra Right Facists
Revolutionaries at the University
of Cordova in Argentina over 50
years ago as a prelude to Peron's
'iron-fist" takeover of that
government.
You students of history know
that the Communist Manifesto for
world domination describes the
takeover in three steps:
I. Conquer Europe
2. Conquer Asia (To prevent
this 2nd step is why we are in that
area.)
:1. America. (But of America,
the manifesto says, "We will never
have to fight for America. It will
rot and decay from within and fall
to us like an overripe fruit." It has
happened over much of the world,
hasn't it?>
Hut the reason for this column is
to let you all read a letter I
received Wednesday morning, the
1:3th.
"*lyeart Sir:
"It grieven me deeply to sit down
amnd have. to write such a letter as
this. I pray that you in your
position will attempt to do
soumething to make me and my
fellow men leet better.
"Il'irst, congratulations are due
to vone and ('ouch McGuire on your
fine seasons. Not being a native of
the ate. but I have since taken up
a residence at Numter and want to
express my concern to what Is
happeningr to all or st of the
Const
Dad the They, too, may be havir
)etween under the impact of
n, fre distinguishing between t
A,.right given a commitment to
ass and destruction, and those %
between makes them critical but nc
Dd leads the system of government i
' as op- live.
sition to This, I would hope, is th
ion and students are taking at
national between just such points
Obviously, the campu
tt I mightily since I studied I
iteIsam Davis College in the
iversity Professors Meriwether, Wi
11 of the errell. Bonn, and others.
der the the facts of history up to
changed.
oroduce Ii those years, one could
e police power of totalitarianism I1
iat they was to erupt shortly in Wc
'ty from nature and force of Comn
r. I can its brute religiosity as it so
>rm are of the minds and hearts of i
hers or defined. And the agonizi
icerned, Americans to lay hold o
r nation world in revolution 200 yea
,i for the to write that freedom into
preserve it in a land callet
ugh
to study for the upcoming final
ie students want to go homq.
)ugh of the gas. They have had
iolence and rhetoric of the
They have had enough of the
soon, somebody is going to get
as made his show. We think
the same, whether the con
of the campus and curfew or
of arrests for conspiracy and
:an only again imflame the
rcement
ent suspension of students until
iocent of some charge against
seems to be problems in the
sting for anyone approaching a
Another problem is the con
made yesterday. Such con
tave been generously described
I crime of crimes."
Jdy of all these questions is
it wov.1d restore confidence in
ifordement and judicial
iaps, it would not, but that
;t step to making any needed
e the ACLU affiliate will take
est place
.Governor Robert E. McNair
rolina campus is ''one of the
be.'' Tuesday and Wednesday
woman lavaliered to his son
rtman, signed out of her dorm
its in the Governor's Mansion.
Nair is stationed with the Army
Last night Miss Hartman had
her home In Hickory, N.C.
-oblems
cole4ge campuses back there. I
hiave' with me at the present both
v'esterdav's and today's papers
Stars and Stripes telling us how
had things are hack on the cam
It is a mighty sad story and
hiard for. people of my age of 40 to
.swallow. I have seven children of
my owln which I figure at least
three or four will attend the
I'niiversitv of South (Carolina. a
privilege I was denied due to my
parent(s and my financial con
dliions.
"I fly combat missions nearly
everyv nite over here, and we do get
'dhnt at. but we are all a bunch of
dedicated people. We know we
have a job to do and we are trying
our. best to do It so that we don't
have to live under Communism
back there. If you could explain to
these54 young people what we are
trying to do for their benefit, it
woutld give me great satisfaction.
"I want them to know that
rii.tingt gets them no place. and if
we dhid it. what would they have.
We are over here to protect them.
bmease we want to do something
14or IIur counitrv. Their turn is next.
I 'diall retire one of these days. I
honpe. hbut onlyI Godw knows if I'll
make~ it hack to di. so with my wife
andi children. I am praying that
vonl will pass this message on to
anyv and all available news source
that youg may hive.
I don't mind the kids of today
%licking up for what they think is
right, bust let's do it in an orderly
lashini. nt by horning and rioting.
They all pay taxes - if not. they
will. It's their money that they are
itninin unch thingrs to. So far nothing
itutioi
qg a hard time, hope of mankind"
this crisis, consciousness.
ose who have We were still hop
revolution and depression but bef<
,hose cynicism Daucha, and Ausc
it destructive of Hiroshima and Nag
ander which we Vietnam - and Cat
University.
a hard look that With this hope I
the difference the promise of An
:f view. grew, and my awar
has changed of that promise incr
dstory there in protests: protests a
1930's under our society, agains
ienefeld, Childs, laws; against the
But I doubt that rights on the part of
that time have political, police, or
they attack their F
see the growing color, or dress, or
ri Europe which I have protested
rid War II. The society which cau
iunism in all of degrade human life
ught to lay hold human flesh as a co
nen was clearly place. In the pulpit,
.ng struggle of waves, standing in
f freedom in a and chain gangs, I
rs ago, and then the dignity of huma
laws that would or human personal
l the "last great find meaning and
FRIMNLY
STUDENU~J OCUPWI
5XCEP TME PLML AN
WHICH AR Mike!'
MW%"MA6 AMe0A ^EP./ l4 At
SLetter
B oard
Dear Mr. Wannamaker:
For the past year 1 have served
on the University Discipline
Committee as the male student
sanely
hadt about University of South
('arolina. and hope nothing does
happen there.
'I'll he hack there In August and
am looking forward to me and may
wife coming to all the home games.
.lust hope I am able to get tickets,
butt guess I'll chance that when I
get there.
"I wanit to thank you for taking
the time to read this letter. even
thoutgh my penmanship Is very
IIEHW along with my spelling. I just
pra v~ my children are able to enjoy
such'l a fine institution as we have
at ('olumsbia.
UISAF. Box 61214
API' San Francisco !MisfO"
Yes, Sargeant Dutcher, I cer
tainly agree with that last line,
only I would add, "we have a great
Uiniversity ramily of faculty, ad
ministrators. and students." We
don't always agree, but that is
normal. We all share in wanting
- 'peace" in our country and around
the world. The Communists
s(cream for "peace," too; but
pe'ace to them is what there is atter
they have completely taken over
the count ry.
Since the recent controversy in
The t;amecock. may I throw some
loutr-letter words at you, men and
women or Carolina. Like: (Work)
tor the i(sood) or Carolina; (Help)
14o Cutre ssome or our problems in a
'Sane' manner.
As for myself, I sincerely
'I lope> (sod willing, that I shall be
Ahles to do my (Duty) to our
< Vine ) Universit y and our great
State.
1, whei
was burned into my been deniec
In all of I
eful then, in a time of viction that
we the world knew of as a Saving
1witz, and Lidice; of of forgivene
Fasaki, and Korea and the power o
nbodia and Kent State that life cou
all mankind
learned to appreciate But all of
ierica. As my insight context of w
eness of the corruption greatest po
eased, I began my own the Ame
gainst the injustices in Today, "I
the inequities in our heart: thal
disregard for human corrupted tl
those who wield either that men ha
economic power, when the law; thi
ellow-men because of denied the I
lifference of belief. of Rights;
against the sins in our democratic
e men to hate, or to to overwhel
by buying and selling economical
nmodity of the market as we knov
in the press, on the air- War.
hospitals, in jail cells, And, it is
have sought to lift up have corru;
i life, to extol the worth and caused
Lty, and to help people democratic
;ignificance which has enemies of I
E AMEN FRM
AN OFM(E
|D THE &NRKJA ,
181 RKD./ Cr. WouLs. MO. (,t.
ignores
representative. The committee is
made up of one administrator, six
faculty members and one student
either male or female, depending
on the particular case).
During the past year I have
made a number of observations
which in light of the present
situation I feel should be placed
before the students.
F"irst I would like to make It
clear that I do not aim my
criticisms at any Individual
member of the committee. For the
mnost part, they have passed
judgemnent in an open-minded and
sincere way and have genuinely
attemplted to disregard any outside
pre4ssulre placed upon them.
I maintain that the structure of
the committee itself and the rules
under which it operates (or rather
the lack of rules) are prejudiced
against the student. The mere fact
that the total student represen
tation has one vote in eight is a
glaring example of this. It has been
my observation that many faculty
members are simply not able to
relate to the student to the same
dlegree that another student is
c'apable of.
Another major complaint is that
there is no clear, institutionalized
procedure for determining which
cases will be heard by the
l)iscipline Committee and which
cases will be handled by the ad
ministration. Tlhere- seems to be a
general adherence to an unwritten
rule that major cases are to be
handled by the Discipline Coin
mittee and minor cases are han
(dIed through "ot her " channels, but
the decision as to which are major
cases and which are minor cases is
lelt entirely up to the ad
ministration.
41ne of the few concrete
%Itatements which the c'ommittee
hasm been'I able to refer to Is that
tae'mnIt in TIhe Statement of
Studiment It ights anid itespon
'sibilities which denls with student
sspe'nsiobn. In a few words, it
state's clearly the right of a student
to, appear before the I)Msclpline
4'omfmiltte'e before he can be
'useamte from- .hool.
re d ov
them- knowr
his, i have had the firm con- The
if these people could know God rebel
God, know Christ as a source cynici
ss, and know the Holy Spirit as sicker
God to change human destiny, bed foi
Id be different for them and for gover,
-. today
this has been done within the But,
hat I have considered to be the leave t
litical revolution of all times weave
rican Revolution. wat
have a great sorrow" in my left? f
it is' true that men have Weo v
ie promise of that Revolution; Who s
ve used the law to circumvent
it men have made laws which courts
reedom guaranteed in the Bill derei
that men have used the ,,
process to bribe the electorate, Ar
m their opposition, or even to Amer
ly enslave a part of the nation dignit
was done following the Civil mank
tragically true, that those who freedc
ited the law, perverted justice, will s
others to lose faith in the come
process have been the worst I a
reedom which our country has will f
brothe
Stepp back
Panic m
bring sc
By CARL STEPP
Associate Editor
Now is no time for finger
pointing, nor for hysterical
scapegoating.
It is a time for restraint. There
are lives at stake.
It is a time for cooperation to
bring sanity to campus. It is time
for lowered voices, deliberate
actions, and conduct which will
allow the termination of the
curfew and the dismissal of outside
police forces.
Wrongs still exist at the
University and elsewhere. Ex
cessses are plentiful. Brutality has
outraged many moderate students.
But solutions will not come under
the irrational atmosphere on
campus. Panic solves nothing.
Only when the troops are gone, the
crowds dissolved, will review be
possible.
Then we all can examine the
faults, blames, negligences and
grievances. We can examine them
with clear heads and soft voices.
We can examine them, hopefully,
with no stains of death on our
consciences.
justice
Even this statement has been
interpreted by the administration
not to apply to "temporary"
suspension, which is suspension
until such a time that the case can
be brought before the full com
mittee. Such questions as the
removal of a student from
University housing are not con
sidered to be within the realm of
concern of the committee.
In reference to the recent by
passing of the Discipline Com
mittee and the formulation of a
different committee through the
Board of Trustees to handle the
cases of the students who were
arrested in the Russell House, I
would like to make a few com
men ts.
Thei4 action of the Board of
Tru~istees represents a deliberate
attempi to circumvent the
established disciplinary system
which they had approved, and
shows an adament disregard for
jlustice by the Board of Trrustees.
The4 action wats a flagrant violation
ofr the Statement of Student Rights
andi Rtesp)onsihilities. When I
discussed this with a member of
thme admlinistration, I was told that
the Statemenit existed at the
"plea sure"~ of the Board of
Trumstees anid that they have the
power to alter or eliminate it at
anvi time.
It is obvious that in a situation
such as this justice is a mockery.
Tlhe reason behind the formulation
ol a new committee seems to be a
lear on the part of the Board of
TIrustees that the regular
D)iscipline Committee would tend
to) be "too lenient."
Thel, next stepl by the Board may
we'.ll be the regulation of certain
othier type4s of cases such as those
inv~olving drugs to its "special"
committee. There is no reason to
believe that this new found power
will not he used in any came in
v'olvinig ain individual which the
Board of Trustees finds "of
This is the cheapest kind of
political and social repression and
is not relatted in the least to justice.
r wnn(;la uRnaSuNn
ie go?.
1.
;e are the people our youth today
against. These help to produce the
am upon which youth has fed and
ed. So they have provided the seed
r those who rebel against our form of
unent and seek its destruction
when all is said and done, if we
he Constitution of the United States,
s Bill of Rights, where do we go?
form or kinds of government are
(ing, emperor, dictator, or council?
4il guarantee your rights and mine
ch a day, if law is swept away, if
lose their meaning, if men rule by
and fiat, if state legislatures, and
ngress are abolished?
e-men have corrupted the
can Dream, the promise of the
ican Revolution, the hope for human
y and human freedom fpr all
ind But if American liberty and
im go, it will be the last that mankind
.e of them for many a generation to
There is a more excellent way.
n still hopeful that this generation
id it. live it, and give new meaning to
rhood, freedom and human dignity.
ill not
lutions
As tempers flared this week,
liberals blamed conservatives'
inflexibility they felt lead to
trouble. Conservatives charged
liberals with permissiveness.
Neither, perhaps, was entirely
right.
At this point, however, several
observations are in order:
---is keeping school open proper?
The faculty and administration
feel it is. To shut down, they feel,
would be an admisssion that the
University can't solve its own
problems, an invitation for the
hard-core reactionaries to force
repressive measures. It would cost
the majority of students their right
to an education, the result, they
feel, of "a handful."
Many, if not most, students are
for shutting down. With every day
that cooped-up students become
more frustrated, that overworked
police become more tired, the
probability of serious injuries and
deaths increases. Studying is
impossible, fear is rampant,
rationality is gone, they say. And
they contend that it is not worth
risking lives to keep school open.
Only history can tell who is right.
Obviously, many persons are
laboring valiantly to prevent
mayhem. Yet their work can be
foiled by one fool policeman or one
outraged student.
---The faculty has been
tantastic. They, as individuals,
deserve the deepest thanks for
their efforts to keep calm and to
encourage students.
---What is needed vitally is trust.
A t this point, students by and large
are skeptical of the state
authorities, the USC ad
ministration. the trustees, the
police. There is almost no medium
for mutual respect. This helped
create the campus unrest, and it
has helped prevent its solution.
---Perhaps state officials could
view more seriously student fears
or gassing and beatings. Despite
any denials, it is a provable fact
that police entered dorms, gassed
dlorms, and hit students inside
dorms. Trhere are witnesses
without end.
Tfhis is not time for cop-hating.
Tlhey are under pressure and here
to help. But neither is it a time for
aiuthorities to reject the obvious
evidence of excess. That excess,
perhaps more than anything else.
has fueled campus tensions.
H-igher authorities---in their
otfice safety---may not feel the
tension, the fear. They may not
know, first hand, of the problems
(Certainly no officer who goes into a
dform and beats a student will then
meekly report that to his superior.
superior.
But cooled tempers and less
dramatic action are needed, both
for students and officers. Both
<('ontintued on Page :1
The Gamecock
The Gamer,ock is published tri-weekly
during the fail and spring semesters with the
exception of University holidays and exam
periods. C'hange of address forms, sub
scription requests and other mail items should
be sent to Drawer A. UsC. Columbia, s. C.
2525W. subscription rates are K6 per year or 63
per semester. Bulk copies are 66 per 100. The
tiamerock this year received 637,00 from the
student activity fuad entitling full-lime
students toea subscription to Uhe paper. offices
of The Gameteck are in Reems 306 and 316 of
the Russell House en the University campus.
Phases are 777-SI7U. 777-4246 and 717-4336.
.Weeud class postage paid at columbia. S. C.
The editor in chief is Jim Wanaaaer.
Although the Gamecock Is pubUohed by the
University of South carolia., the opinions
publIshed herein de net necessarily represent
theae of the University. the studeat body or the