The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, March 01, 1963, Page Page Two, Image 3
Will Finish
Semester
The news story was a very
small one in the morning news
paper, but it told of a big event:
George W. Tomlin, Dean of Stu
dents and Activities at the Uni
versity of South Carolina, was
resigning his duties as Dean to
return to teaching.
Four years ago, George Tomlin
made the transition from full
time teacher to administrator.
He brought with him an ample
supply of patience, knowledge,
and an interest in the welfare of
students as people. He needed
them all . . . for the job he held
is, at times, a thankless one.
Besides his qualifications for
the job he held, Dean Tomlin
had other attributes that were to
gain him the respect of students
and faculty alike: A personal
conviction of honesty and in
tegrity. Students were fortunate
to have a man like him; the Uni
versity was well-served by him.
He has been honored by many
organizations - and Wednesday
night with IFC's Man of the Year
award - and he has been
recognized with various honors
both scholastically a n d pro
fessionally.
A man of his calibre will be
sorely missed in this sensitive
position. It is, perhaps, idle
speculation to wonder why Dean
Tomlin is leaving this position to
return to teaching. The very
suddenness of his resignation
leaves m a n y questions un
answered.
Dean Tomlin resumes his role
as educator with the satisfaction
of knowing that his was a job
well done. It will be a difficult
thing to fill his shoes and match
his strides. He now will spend
a semester in advanced study to
prepare for a return to a regular
teaching schedule.
We can only say that in any
endeavor he chooses, he deserves
the best, and we can safely pre
dict that he will continue to have
the best interests of the students
always uppermost in his thoughts.
-dwb.
By ROBERT KOTEY,
Secretary of the Ghana Student Ui
Written for "The Stud<
ITH HAS BEEN my unhappy lot t(
formal leader of a group of 2
dents - all of those Ghanaians st
Bulgaria - who have been forced
to interrupt our studlies and to set
in which to pursue thenm. It was a
which we and almost all the oti
dents in Bulgaria have taken, but w
protection in the face of a patte
racial dliscrimination, when dlenie
organize an All-African Students1
very lives were threatened, it was
sible for us to remain in the count
My own experience began when
scholarship to study in my chosen fi
and my government, which has woi
ship agreements wvith a numberc
ments in both the East and the XM
for a position in Bulgaria. In De
number of Ghanaian students -
selected solely on the basis of edu
cations - flew from Accra to Soi
higher education.
W E HAD COME with open mi
beginning we were filled with
received a friendly welcome from
people, and we were placed in the sai
the same rooms, with our Bulgat
dlents. We set al out the formidable
ing the Bulgarian language in ordle
be able to understand our textbook
Early in the year, however, we I
ence sonme difficulties. We had co
to study, and not to live luxuriously
ditions turned out to be not nearly
had expected -- not as goodl as th
versity studlents in G;hana itself.
happy at being cramped four in a
only 14 by 9 feet, with four beds a
the middle with a chair at either
studying very inconvenient, as son
had to sit or lie on their beds in orc
living allowance came to only ?24
?18 of which had to go for food
little over for books, recreation, trai
supplies.
W E HAD ALL arrived in tropic
Ing and were given no allowa
clothes, so that simply trying to ke
cold Bulgarian winter posed a real
ship.
We brought our problems to the
TUniversity authorities, who replied
Dean f Studeni
-(Photo by MlcGrail.)
Dean George W. Tomlin, Jr.
Self: 'Severe Blow'
Dear Editor:
On Tuesday, February 26, 1963, The State newspaper
contained news of the resignation of Dean George W.
Tomlin as Dean of Students here at Carolina. It is need
less to say that his leaving will be a severe blow to the stu
dent body of U.S.C.
Dean Tomlin has always placed great faith in the Caro
lina student. During the past four years he has been a
champion of the rights of students to exercise authority
over their own affairs and has worked tirelessly to providt
us with the things necessary for the building of a responsible
system of self-government.
I am certain that I express not only my own feelings,
but also those of the entire student body when I offer a
sincere "thanks" for the service that he has rendered. I
am sure that as Professor Tomlin, he will continue to be an
effective voice on behalf of the students at Carolina.
Sincerely,
Wn. Osce Self,
Student Body President
A GACC)cocGI
CROWING FOR A GREATER
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA
Member of Asociated Collegiate Preea
Founded January 30, 1908, with Robert Elliott Gonzales as the first
Editor. "T he (amecock" is published by and for the students of the
University of South Carolina werkly, on Fridays, during the college yeas
except on holidays and duruig examinations.
The opinions expressed by colamnists and letter writers are not
necessarily thome of " I he (amecuck." "The Gamecock" encourages
Letters to the Editor, but all Letters must be sigued. Publishing doce
not constitute an endorement. The right to edit or withhold from
publication any letter is reserved.
-Al
hanaian Student
no way out of four difficulties. We later appealed
lion in Bulgaria, to the Minister of Education, who told us that he
t"would do something to help, lie never (lid, howv
.ever, and eventually we were forced to turn to the
serv a~thein-government of Ghana, whicn s.s mrpa. .sed with us
3 Ghanaian stu- and provided us with an additimral living allow
udying in Sofia, ance of ?10 a month.
k' new cutiesA PARTICULARLY ugly incidlent occurredl in
painful dlecision ILAugust, 1962. Half a dozen Ghanaian studlents
er African stu- missed (dinner at the hostel (lining room andI went to
hen denied police a nearby restaurant, the "Chuchuliga." '1 her'e was
rn of consistent music playing, andl one of the Ghannians asked a
d th rigt to Bulgarian girl in the restaurant to (lance with him.
dnon thengh o As they were (lancing a young sohtlier wvent up to
clearly ~n pour the girl and asked her: "Is it not a shame for you
clerlyno 1)5-to dance with . . . ?" The Ghanaian did not want
Iyplidfo. to make trouble, so he returnedl to his table, but
Ieadrie ecormcs just as he was about to sit dlown another Bulgarian
ked out scholar- boy pulled his chair out from behind him, and he
f other govern- toppled onto the floor. Before he co'ild even get
est, selected nme back on his feet another Bulgarian 'inacked( him
whoer 1h1, a over the head wvith a chair, and he fell over un
wober, ee conscious. By this time the Ghanaians were furious,
cational qualifi- andi a general fight ensuedl between the dozens of
i obegin our' Bulgarians who were in the restaurant and who
pouredl in from the streets and the handful of
Ghanaian studlents at their table.
nds, andl in the Surprisingly enough, the Bulgarian po'ice wvho
high hope's. We were so seriously outnumubered, that the police re
runny Bulgarian but left the place inmmeditately. It wats only when
me hostels, ev~en the Ghanaians appeared to be holdling their own
-ian fellow stu- against the Bulgarians, dlespite the fact that thmey
task of master- were so seriously outnumbered, that the 1,lice re
that we might turned and broke up the fight. They made no ef
3 andi lectures, fort to find the young Bulgarians who had startedl
egan to) experi- the fight, but rather arrested only the six Ghana
me to Bulgaria ians. Four of the six were wounded in the fight,
but living con- and they were released by the police the next (lay.
50 gtood as we At the request of the Government of G;hana they
ey are for uni- were immediately flown back to Accra. The two
We were un- who were not wouInded, however, wetre kept in jail
'oom which was for one full month before their case came before
nd( one table in any kind of court for a hearing. The only wit
endl. It made( nesses called were Bulgarians, none of whom h-ad
ie in the room themselves been arrestedl.
er to readl. Our NE OF TH E students, George Anmah, was s n
a .onh fly Otencedl to one year in prison andl the other, E.
antIthisleftA. Attiga, to three years. As a result of pressure
sportation, and from the G;hanaian government they we're released
al weight cloth- cr mn h fia tdnsrmiigi
ice to purchase Blai.W otne ohv oego red
3p warm in the aogteBlainsuet n epe u h
economic hardl- Bugra goenettonosesosam ot
andhe hoam abut us, incidethi lraed much con
cteto o h lude that it was being supported from "above.
that there was Pirtnatyerteewr nl e fia
s Georg
A
H AVING established that uni
versities, particularly state
supported universities, w e r e
undergoing a slow but decided
change, we are ready to ask the
question: of what value is a de
gree, anyway?
The cult of degree-worship has
arisen in many areas of today's
business world. This is true, par
ticularly in our huge distribution
complexes where the actual
development and manufacture of
the product is secondary to the
profit picture.
As an example, take soap. Now
we all supposedly use soap, and
there can be no question but that
the marketing, advertising, and
distribution of soap and soap
related products has long over
s h a d o w e d the production or
manufacture of this particular
item.
W E HAVE, then, the problem
of establishing arbitrary
criteria for the mass of clerical
and service personnel necessary
to distribute this common prod
uct. More and more, the trend is
toward requiring the college de
gree as the first ticket to mem
bership in the ranks of our
fantastically spiraling numbers
of white collar workers.
The reasons why a degree has
become almost required are va
ried, and not always candid. But,
not being especially concerned
with the why of this inordinate
emphasis on a degree at present,
let us delve into the effect of
this phenomona.
Where there is demand, there
is supply. The demand is for a
degree, regardless of whether or
not the possession of the degree
materially affects the perform
ance on the job. This distinction
had to be made, or else I would
have doctors, lawyers, engineers,
and other professions descending
on me in great wrath . . . but
this is an obvious distinction be
tween situations where a degree
is an acknowledgment of com
petence in a technical or special
ized field, and where it is not.
W H ERE this aforementioned
cult of degree worship
comes in is that many businesses
Fricans Leave Bulgar
In Bulgar
Store thtanm 300 Africain stu
dents stud(I,ing in llulgarians
uiv~er?.ities annisouniced their ini
tenltiona to lealve that coun1tr
this week, chairging racial dlis
eimmintat ion ansd politial hatraiss
mentlt by the Baulgarianu govern
menit --aund meis%aiged a plea to
Western unIiversities aind na
Stional unsions oif atudtenits to find
palaices for themi to conit inue
their studies.
Upon)1 rceipit of te appeaCl,
the Un;iitedl States5 Naitionial Stu
denit Associationli, thle Amnericanu
nuation,al unsion of studenuts wjhichi
was susspenidedt fromi tihe Cairo
hln campus)il is.193960, isn.
fornm the (Colleginte P'ress
Service*. thmat I SNSA is inaumgua.
raitinig ant "African. Fr eedloma
Fsundi" to meett the needsI of
lie 300 stutdenits, helping to puay
for t ranssportatin and p,laingsi
1s numy51 ats posib%le ins U. S.
snive-iiie.. I SNSA, ma con
fedlerainu of the -sudent gtov
ernments of mnore thian 400 Ui.
S. luiversitieUs, wiill a,k its muem
hers schooL' to conussict funsd.
rasisinig dives" for thet studen.ats,
I -t.N'tA internamtional vice-pre'si
tdeint Don,. Smaitli of the UJni
.,ersity of 'Texas told (:1'S,
TFhe studtents chairged
thle 11au gasriani governimnt with
thiwairting their aittempjts to form i
-mi AIll-Africa Stident I :nion to <
repjresenst alh African stuadenats inii
tihst countshry. 'To support their
teinmtif raciunh udiscriuimsstion a
by thle lhealgarinn, goivernmenut, <
the. studtensts stay thnst Arnsh stu-t
denits stu.ding in the counitry<
we're allowed to form anm simtilar
organiuzamtion.(
I SNSA casled thme deci,ion of
tIhe sti'uens to heave iuhgasrias
"'a heavy lowi alt rasin in s the'
Conni,it lc." The NSA saidl
tinast rona ribli ution to the fuandI
can lbe senat to the I SNSA nia.
lional oiffice, at 3.157 Chstnuss J
St., l'hiladuelpshian 4, h'ensysl.
vania.
e Tomlin
-Dave E
cademic Ch
or occupations - which are
honorable enough - have suc
cumbed to "image upgrading"
urged upon them by their pub
licity men (or human engineers,
as they now like to be called),
and adopted the arbitrary re
quirement of a degree without
the corresponding need f o r
demonstrative proficiency. It is
shallow . . . it has led us to the
era of the cheap degree.
At the beginning of this series,
a statement by Dean William
Patterson was called "revolu
tionary." In effect, Dean Patter
son said that one of the aims of
the stiffer academic provisions
was to direct into other paths
those not suited for college work.
He publicly said what many ed
ucators have said among them
selves in years past . . . and that
is why the statement was called
revolutionary.
T HE cffcct of the cult of de
gree worship is to engulf col
leges and universities with people
who are not suited to academic
life, who overload our already
strained facilities, and whose
best interest is truly not served
by the financial strain of four
years of college.
B EFORE venturing further,
the argument is sure to come
up: "But college is a place to
mature and find one's self."
Granted, but is it serving that
purpose to many? Are extra
curricular activities a reliable
gauge?
Those who think that they are
might try this little experiment:
Take a Garnet and Black, pub
lished any year in the last decade,
and turn to any page of the
graduating senior section. Now,
count the number of seniors who
have gone through four years of
college with two or less extra
curricular activities to I i s t.
Actually, the figure averages out
to about 40% of the senior class
... and that is calculated on the
generous side to allow for typo
graphical errors, mistakes in com
piling, and what-not.
Extra-curricular activities are
no reliable indicator of finding
one's self . . . and should not be
viewed as such. It does, how
'ia ells(
students -- from Mali, the Sudan an
Bulgaria, andl there was, therefore,:
ill-African studlents' organization
Ghnaa studlents arrived last yearx
elves all in the same hostel, andi
.ogether and exchange views we fori
StudIents' Union, of which I was ele
We neve'r thought to ask the permis:
zhorities to form such an organizatioi
to feel that thxey were prep)aredl to deC
>n individual national bases.
W E H AD gone to Bulgaria to st
gage in p)olitics, and we hadl in
resistedl the formation of an all-Afi
'ion fox' fear that it might be invol
It was only when we became convinc
Africaxn organization in Bulgaria nec
Lo do with politics that wve agreedl to
Wh len in November and D)ecembe
Look definite steps towvardl the orgai
All-A frican Students U nion, wve had
Lives in mind. First of all, we wis
neans by which we A frican studIent
>ur interests in the absence of p)olice
ook after our welfare in the face of
ng conditions. Secondly, we wished
aizi/ation which could b)ring us toget
pirit of pan-Africanism. We fell
'arious national leaders are now fig
ill of A frica, as students it was
x(ccele'rate this realization in anya
l'huirdly, we wantedl to foster frieni
he Bulgarian youth and the A frican
B Y DECE'MBER wve had dlraftedl a
our AASUJ -- which, with the p~
tud(ents from 22 countries, reprere
'voic'e of A frica" - andl had elected
>fficers, headed b~y Tetteh Tawiah of
lent of p)hilosophy. When the Ur
'ormedl we invitedl two indlividluals to
he G;hanaiaxn A mbassadlor andl, as a
vill toward the Bulgarian authoritie:
>f Education. We were su rprisedl
here'after' Tlawiah was cal led biefor<
if Eduxcat.ion and( toldl that we wouli
xand the U Inion because it was agai
1Idles'' of Bulgaria. 'Phis was all the
hxorities ever said, then or latex',
trange way this genuinely pan-A fri
vaxs "'against our principles.'"
We d Id, howe'vex', hear' rumoours ihr
ies felt thait the' A A SU was intei
oliti'cal orgaxnizaxtion hostile to
overmnment. We thex'efore sent a del
finixste ox f ducat ion tox p)resent hin
f our coInsttutionx and to explain 0u
ins. 1 U' t ookt iher. 0 t ,.m ti;n;, ht .i
Resigns
Iledsoe -
ange: Part
ever, seem strange that with 40%
of the seniors devoted (evidently)
to academic pursuits alone that
USC's academic rating is not
spiraling skyward. It is spiral
ing, all right - ask the petitions
committee in which direction.
H ERE is the problem facing
us today: economic, popula
tion, and status pressures are
forcing more and more people
into colleges which can't - in
deed, should not - handle them.
The University has attempted to
unilaterally remove some pres
-Last in
College Ty
Elitor's Note: From the All-Star
College Primer, Illustrated Epub
lished by the Grooves of Academie
Press.
THESE students are participat
ing in an organized bull ses
sion. It is officially known as a
GRADUATE SEMINAR. They are
doctoral candidates, and most of
them intend to be professors
some day.
They learn many academic
skills at the seminars. These
skills are called methodology. The
smarter candidates have wives
who are employed so that these
candidates can concentrate on
their methodology.
EXAMPLES of methodology
are: How to form a clique.
How to exhibit superior knowl
edge. How to reply indirectly to
a critic. And how to prepare
footnotes.*
The methodology of obtaining
a fellowship is also important.
It teaches the fundamentals of
requesting a grant and pulling
strings to get it. If an applicant
is offered two fellowships he
learns how to play one college
off against another. This is very
important. It is basic to his fu
ture advancement.
A DOCTORAL candidate must
prove his scholarly ability
by w r i t i n g a dissertation and
defending its conclusions before
a faculty committee. A disserta
tion is a document based on re
search that is original, with con
)fExodt
d Guinea -- in merely asking us
so needl for an HrLE NEXT th
.When wej 6 Tetteh Tas
we found our- (expulsio from
nI ordler to sit with having beei
ned the Ghana failedl to take an
ctedl secretary. evr student
4ion of the au- kinishka) which
1, and we came when the'y are
il with us thus classes, and in e
signedl. It was tr
dy, not to en- tion, but this wi
the beginning obtain a textbool
-ican organiza- the early part ol
ved in politics, obtain it one mo
ed that an all- was not sufficie
dI have nothing Bulgarian text.
form one. given him permis
r of 1962, we ing of his examni
dization of the In spite of the 01)'
several objec- Tawiah, we woul
hed to have a full imphIlicattions 4
s could dlefendl fact that the V
p)rotection and A mlak of Ethiopi
inadequate liv- i ng that he wool
to have an or- by the regulatiom~
her in the true that the actions
that i.f our on the personal
hting to unite rather on the h<
our (duty to ment to the for?
vay we could, would unite all th
dIshi p betwveen On Saturtday',
s. to leave Blulgariai
constitution of orde spr 51 ead son.
articipation of at the hostel and
Ientedl a true 'rime~ Min0ister's
a list of seven reinstate.ment of'
Ghana, a stu- withd rawal of th
ion had leen and to insist up,)
patronize it -- the reprIesentativt
n act of goodl When we arrived
, the Minister toldl by a man11 u
when shortly Hualgarian~ Koms(o
the Minister that the l>rime M
I have to dis- he wouIld mneet u
nst the "p ri n- Monday morn ing.
Bulgarian aut- were elected to
that in som 'rime Minister, a
can movement A ft(er they had v
hours withoot a a
it the authori- the sec retaiiry to
ided to be a he was prepa redi
he Bulgarian The( seven studtien
egation to the report to us w"hat
i with a copy committee oif the
r' non- political case( shiould lbe prc
mdel no reply. (Sc.
III
sure ... but it will not be able to
handle the job alone.
There are other measures
which the University could take,
and there are measures which
could be adopted by the secondary
schools as well as labor and
business groups which have a
direct concern with the problem.
T H E concluding article, "Aca
demic Change: Part IV,"
which will appear next week,
deals with some possible solu
tions, plus steps that could be
taken by USC.
Series -
pes: No. 3
clusions that a r e not. The
Methodology here is to avoid
challenging the findings of pre
vious research by any member of
the examining committee or his
friends.
If you are a dotoral candi
date, shade your dissertation with
ambiguities. Then write Ph.D.
after your name and design a
project that will bring you a
post-doctoral fellowship for study
in Europe.
*Tii, . n fotnots.e. I'e hard to read, isn't
I f I hapt part of the ieclnigne. Here are
"I.n' e nuark * *..: . Copy
thern and . t.etn elcwhere in this primer
for fnol ete of your own. These abbrevia
tion, will ai ho help: et al.. op. eit.. ibid.
I . tIehsn for referene.e to leadinlt works and
anlhriticr,r - e .g.. .MS(;uJffr'a Render, The
o efhd o/ 11:. A. A. Milne. and Dr. Seus
l4 show oun are acquainted with the litera
tore in thi. fichd.
JS
o ee hi /atr
ng w knw ws ta nFbur
hisprfsosadecuessg
satisfired with atndner of
ter casevTaih' Heooks.hagde
irretar in ladsses and exaina
hs becaussohe hand beentuna tossg
Cwhich was out of stock during
his course and wvas only able tQ
ithi before his examination, which
it for~ him to master a difficult
IIis professor had quite naturally
sion in adlvance to dlelay the tak
intion to the next academ*nic term.
'ious falsity of the charges against
I not have been convi ned of the)i
>f his case had it not been for the
ice-Plresidlent of the AASU, Mr.
El, 'was alsoi warnedl the next morn
'1 le ex pel led if he dlid not abide
of the Uiniversity. We knew then
>f the authorities were not based
condluct of the two studlents but
stility of the IBulgariaun govern
nation of an organiziation which
A frican studtlents in the country.
eel,ruary 9,e Taw'eiah was5 ordered
within 12 hours. As news of the
e 15i0 A frican students gathered
walked dlown Lenin Street to the
,jffice. JVe wished to demahlndl the
lawiah in the University and the
n deportation ordler against him
>n reecognitionl of the AASU as
volice of the A frican students.
it the Miinistry, however, we were
ho said be was a leader of the
intl ( You ng ('ommnilist League)
Imste r was not available but that
ith our rtSepresentativ,es 9 o'clock
Over thle weekend, seven students
(en'iesent our i position before the
rid thbey arr ived pr'omiptly at 9.00.
'ai tedl at thle oiffice fo five full
espotn se, a manai who saidl he was
10~ Pime Mliister t old themi that
0 see thbem onliy bitter. int the dlay.
s then returnred to the hostel to
hadie hatppenedl, andl the executive
A A SU met. ti plan ,iust how our
sentedl to thle Prime Miniiste.r.
Ieourh ntfexi wec.)1