The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, February 08, 1963, Page Page Two, Image 2
QuoV
Three voices on the subject of Communism
have risen above the hubbub of constant con
troversy to pinpoint a question of our
time: is the denial of an opportunity to
representatives of the Communist party to
speak on American campuses academic cen
sorship or does it conform with principles of
the Constitution?
The Lecture & Information Bureau of the
U. S. A. Communist Party has released a
nationwide letter asking college newspaper
editors and student councils to invite repre
sentatives of their party to speak at forums
of the student body either in lectures, by
participation in symposia, or in debates.
It also states during the past year Com
munist spokesmen addressed more than 30
colleges and universities which were at
tended by approximately 75,000 students and
townspeople. The colleges and universities
included Harvard Law School, University of
Chicago, Brown University, Columbia Uni
versity, Stamford, Temple University, Up
sala, and others.
Quo vadis-to the left?
The Lecture Bureau says this proves that
students wish to hear the Communist view
point from bona fide spokesmen. "Students
in their search for knowledge apparently are
not satisfied to learn about communism from
anti-Communists. They desire a fair ex
change of opinion on the supreme problems
facing our country, with all viewpoints rep
resented, and they reject the widespread
practice of denouncing Communism without
affording the Communists an opportunity to
be heard," the release states.
Even though the Communists believe there
is such a widespread desire to hear their
speakers, they still state they have been de
nied this opportunity in many cases. Non
registration of party members under the Mc
Carran Act is one reason used to deny the
Communist speakers. The courts are yet to
rule on the theory of the party that registra
tion would deprive the Communists of their
rights under the First, Fifth, Eighth, and
Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution
and that the enforcement of this law would
establish a "precedent to destroy every
vestige of American democracy," and that
registration compels "perjury, self-incrimi
nation, and a false confession of guilt. .. .
Communists are not foreign agents, do not
commit acts of sabotage, espionage, or de
ception, do not seek to hide their views."
The last point we will concede.
That Communist speakers have been pre
vented from appearing on certain campuses
is certainly true, but speakers sponsored by
-Hayes
Can State Af
W HEN Harvey Gantt was private schools
peacefully admitted to Clem- turn provide comn
som College, many South Caro- existing public sc
Jinians hailed his entrance as the Neither in the
beginning of a new era of dress nor in the
progress for this state and her there been any
people. Indeed, if this was the race issue. Howe
beginning, it should be said that and analysts of s
the culmination of any such have concluded tl
progress is in the very distant vious intent of ti
future, plan to provide
But was Gantt's entry actual dividual circumv
progress or mere realism? Grant- pulsory school de
ing that progress is a relative flERHAPS the
term and that in the case of rGeneral Ass
South Carolina realism might be now that integral
considered commensurate with South Carolina
progress, it would appear that and appease the:
this state must prove herself in a device as this ti
other areas before she can be con- gram. Surely
sidered as entering into a pro- should realize tha
gressive era, nothing for whici
One case in point is the tuition ashamed. They
grant plan now before the Gen- evitable and for
oral Assembly. This proposed they accepted it i
legislation would permit South rational behavior
Carolina to provide tuition grants neesr for th
to parents who wish to send their their integrity b
children to private non-sectarian the people of this
schools. Such a program would a plan is devise
be financed by a fund of one mil- grade the educat
lion dollars drawn from the this was the cas
state's surplus revenue, such a plan tho
A s FIRST outlined by Gover- and why has it n
nor Russell in his "State of by most of the ol
the State" address, the tuition if they must end<
grant plan appeared to be a pro- gram, then at lea:
gram to upgrade South Caro- the honesty to pre
lina's educational system by en- it really is -- a
couraging the establishment of step federal decre
%f GAA#cot
CROWING FOR A GREATER
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROI]
Member of Aosociated CollegIate Pres
PnddJanuary so 1905, with, Robe,t Eliott Censal,
. feCameeekisb h~II.hed by and for the sta
ni'epyoSm th CoIIna weeh1y on Friday, during the
'ret holbIm idays and in smnans. it, i
mooou0r7 thoe o T..am enek." "The Cam.t
ED ITRO R..........O.. O
MANAGING EDITOR.. . ... . DEN
BUSINESS MANAGER......... . . . EMIL
adis?
the American Civil Liberties Union, the Na
tional Student Association, and others have
also been bypassed.
The concern is not with occurrences of this
kind on the Carolina campus but with the
overall connotation implied by the second
voice, Professor William W. Van Alstyne of
Ohio State University Law School, who says,
"Campus censorship in 1962 easily rivaled
that of any previous year. From coast to
coast and particularly in the Midwest, stu
dent bodies were quarantined from a variety
of political heresies."
Quo vadis-to the right?
Should students be quarantined from
"political heresies" or should "freedom of
expression" throw campuses open?
University of Oregon president rejected
the demand to bar prominent Communist
Gus Hall from appearing before the student
body, stating: "If our university deviates
from the policy -- freedom of expression -
it has followed, it will be placed in the posi
tion of being a second-class institution in the
eyes of men and women who truly under
stand the role of a university. It would be
giving up its birthright." He was honored
for this stand by an award from the Ameri
can Association of University Professors.
We agree with the president from Oregon.
Any other policy in the form of expression
of any kind - reflects a skepticism of stu
dent intelligence and fear of the appeal of
today's social critics. Both are contrary to
the imperatives of a free society.
And the third voice on the pro and con
Communist front comes from Professor
Frederick H. Hartmann, specialist in inter
national relations. In the University of
Florida campus newspaper, Prof. Hartmann
says he believes it was unwise to prevent
Communists from running openly for office.
"Our driving them underground conceals
how little support they have and suggests
fear on our part that they could gain an
office legally," he says.
The final Communist argument is that
Americans are given opportunities to speak
in Communist countries with only "blatant
prowar views excluded." Since Communistic
tenets rest on a bloody revolution, this same
principle applied to their speakers would
eliminate all.
But if American campuses and America as
a whole attempt to "legislate" the Com
munist party out of existence, simply by out
lawing it, we may one day find that in
reality we are not as immune to their
theories as we thought.
Quo vadis-from here?
Mizell -
ford Grants?
vhich would in crimination at public expense,
petition for the and further cripple our educa
bools. tional system.
Governor's ad- iS T HE tuition grant program
bill itself has Iof such a primary nature? Al
mention of the ready Georgia and Virginia have
ver, journalists similar plans that have proved to
bate government be less than satisfactory. In
iat it is the oh- Georgia, where the program is
le tuition grant financed from a contingent fund
means for in- of only $300,000, there is some
ention of com- indication that the abused plan
segregation- will be dropped altogether. In
members of th'e Virginia the program is said to
embly feel that be working, but it has been as
ion has come to sailed by professional educators
they must face and the cost of its operation has
public with such grown to over three million dol
iition grant pro- lars a year.
the legislators It is obvious that the very cost
t they have done of the tuition grant system would
they should be be a tragic financial waste to this
ecepted the in- state. Our public schools are now
the most part understaffed and their teachers
vith dignity and are so poorly paid that in many
It is not now schools the teachers are incom
em to sacrifice petent or unqualified. The tui
'trying to tell tion grant program would, in ef
state that such fect, create a third school system.
Imerely to up- Since the cost of dual school
onal system. If programs has retarded the educa
3, why was not tional progress of this state for
uight of before, generations, the ramifications of
ot been adopted the creation of a third system are
her states? But apparent.
>rse such a pro- FINALLY, the tuition grant
it let them have scheme is entirely inconsistent
sent it for what with the traditional dedication of
device to side- South Carolina's legislative lead
'e, promote dis- era to a policy of fiscal paralysis
(sometimes referred to as "fiscal
responsibility"). Already many
of our state agencies are poorly
operated because of an apparent
lack of funds. Many progressive
and worth-while programs are re
fused by the Budget and Control
Board because they say that all
worth-while projects cannot be fi
nanced - we must put first
n--ke rea things first. While it is true that
~,, -South Carolina has a surplus of
ee mnee revenue, it is regrettable that
..." when there are so many impor
NNC ER tant things to be done, the Gen
LNN CXER eral Assembly cannot distinguish
NIS MYERS between the necessary end the
V REDDING "trivia."
Carol
Greeks bearing gifts . . . it's 1
pre-rush week ... RE Week dis
plays and convocations . . . plus
crowds at the various local coffee
shops . . . Professor in History
Department remarking on ham
mering noises in Currell College:
"We waited long enough to get a
new wing, now we're waiting to
be able to lecture in it" . . .
temporarily bare display oases in
LeConte College . . . University
policemen busily ticketing cars
over-parked in front of Business
Administration building ... Stu
dent wryly commenting on over
time parking ticket: "I can re
member when it cost more to run
a car than to park it" . . . dis
gruntled students being turned
away from Duke-Carolina game
for lack of field house space....
Slater System Bingo-the num- k
ber system in the Rusesll House
Gamecock Room ... Law School 1
seniors with coats, ties, and ex- e
pressions of deep learning . . . %
the University's new property: t
more gray hairs for Joe Barnes
... a record number of students
on academic probation . . . latest
fad at Freshman Girls' Dormi
tories: knitting (and the needles
come in handy on some dates,
too) . . . "veteran" NROTC
upperclassman instructing fresh
man on how to keep lint off of
blue wool uniform: "Use scotch
tape and stay away from white
sweaters" ... prospective rushees
evaluating fraternities . . . Bee
Jee Garrett, trying to gather ma
terial f o r t h e forthcoming
"Crucible," Carolina's literary
magazine . . . Student Senate de
bating re-admission of Senators
who had "over-cut" - a foregone
conclusion to a perennial problem.
(They all were re-admitted) , . ,
Ted Ledeen: many tasks, much
patience, and a quick smile . . .
Freshman girls with their white
cards - midnights at last!
Carolina Cheerleaders at bas
ketball games . . . beefcake on
parade: Undrawn blinds on men's
dorms . . . The "Gallery," Polit
ical Science Dep't and Journal
ism School annex . .. sign inside
USC Post Office: "Next to the
verb 'to love,' the verb 'to help'
is most beautiful . . . cokes and
other forbidden goodies on win
dow ledge of (censored) dormi
Letters
Feb. 5, 1963
Dear Editor:t
Enclosed is a letter written to
me by the President of the Uni
versity and a letter received by
him from a "Gamecock" officer
apologizing for what Dr. Jones ]
terms "the rather distateful front
page of the 'Gamecock' " of Janu
ary 1, 1963. It seems to me that it
would have been to the credit of
the editors to admit that a mis
take had been made in the prep
aration of that page. Instead, my 1
letter concerning the questionable
taste of the front page was used 1
as an excuse for a rather violent
diatribe against me and those
who would dare have views op
posing those of the editors.
Not only was the "reply" not
a reply to my letter it was proof
that the "Gamecock" itself is
guilty on those charges made in
the reply - of taking sides, of
viewing what its side does as
news and what the other side does
as propaganda or mere ravings
of immature extremists, of hav
ing a head-in-the-sand attitude in
refusing to recognize that there
is another side. This "reply" was
extremism at its worst. It seems
to indicate that the editors have
a chip on their shoulder, and are
afraid of criticism.
President Jones agreed with me
that the reply was unfa-ir and
that the honorable thing to do
was to admit the error. This was
concurred in by a faculty mem
ber of the board of publications.
In a personal conversation with
the editor about the front page,
nothing was said about the letter
to the President. Apparently the
plan was to keep it hidden from
the student body if possible. The
honest thing was not done and I
feel that it is in the best interest
of Carolina that these facts be
madle known to the students so
that they can decide just who it
is that It guilty of distortions.
Yours very truly,
Ben Boyd
Editor's Note: Mr. Boyd refers
to a , letter written by Dennis
Myers to Dr. Jones explaining for
mss
Dave Bledsoe -
ia Glirr
ory . . . Cold winds and knee
locks, sure signs of winter at
,arolina . . . Graeber Jordan:
WUSC's man-in-a-hurry spark
plugging the attmept to make
VUSC's reception oampuswide
.. Big question in girls' dorm%
ories - who drives the Jaguar
edan? ... USC version of Rus
ian roulette: crossing Green
treet against the traffic
>lans for a new infirmary
;ign in University Bookstore:
'Book prices are set by Pub
isher" (Nominated for the "Oh,
,eah?" award for 1963) ... Pink
ards on Russell House bulletin
board advertising 'for sale' items
. . new crop of BBOC's (Big
leards On Campus) ... big at
endance at Morality plays dur
ng RE WEEK ... Student Body
resident Osce Self, busy about
ampus with Student Government
. . ever-present impromptu
ridge clubs in Gamecock Room
. . tryouts for "The Miracle
Worker" . . . an ever-growing
kyline of an ever-growing Uni
rersity . . . Carolina students
raveling to Clemson to see bas
:etball game - lots of cheering,
out we still lost . . . physics stu
Paper and
c tu t
I Jones youforeatincerain
ecica Montet of rontpagsie
Sroel whic Mr. Boyd' mae pub-o
ast week.
If Miss Monteith is an agitator,
Arhy haven't we heard more about
aer in the Columbia papers? I'm
sure many students would agree
~hat her picture was thought
provoking.
How does Mr. Boyd know so
much about Miss Monteith and
ber ability to serve the Uni
versity????
"Forced integration" must be
Mr. Boyd's synonym for the Uni..
versity policy of education for the
people (white, black, or what
ever) of the State.
Don't forget the fact that "The
G~amecock" represents Carolina
(crow, crow -- white cocks only)
and its student body.
Finally, life is like a sewer.
You get out of it what you put
into it.
So are Mr. Boyd's~ archaic re
marks.
Signed,
Ted Narrow.
Dear Editor:
On reading the February 1st
issue of "The Gamecock," I noted
two statements on the subject of
the integration controversy with
which I should like to take issue.
The statements are (1) "the
'Gamecock' does not attempt to
'Lake sides' " and (2) "The Game
cock" will not be a sop to any
one's distorted viewpoint of a
situation.
Both statements are commend
able newspaper policy if followed,
but one need only have followed
this year's version of "The Game
cock" to appreciate fully their re
markable inconsistency. In regard
to the first statement, "The
Giamecock" is quite obviously tak
in- sirdes both in the pat s
pses
dent attempting to ascertain hov
much force would be necessary t
pull o u t a parking meter
(Answer: too much, especially i
the Campus Security and Dete<
tion officers are watching.) . .
signs of a changing academi
world - diapers hung out to dr
in University Terrace ... studer
nurses in their canary yellov
uniforms . . . a fully accredite
School of Nursing . . . "Game
cock" photographer posing a re
luctant anonymous coed for a pic
ture of fraternity pins on blous
. . . Dr. Babcock looking for
word to describe flap over regis
tration . . . raccoon collar coat
and beehive hairstylings: und
form of the day for Carolin
c o e d s (personal opinion -
yeechh) . . . language barrie
in Tenement 20 has been double
- another Australian has move
in . . . Dr. Barr performin
"Wizard of Oz" electronic demor
stration in Physics 22 . . . con
fused AFROTC cadet salutin
Angel Flight Captain . . . sti
dents emerging from faceles
names and nameless faces int
citizens of the Carolina Con
munity.
Pins . .
ANA
-(Photo by Gaskins.)
S' AQ . 4
inegatonhove recently a)
peared on the pages of the newi
paper with at least an equal nun
ber of pro-integration editorial:
The point I would like to makei
not THAT "The Gamecock"i
taking sides, which it certainl
has a right to do, but the mar
ner in which "The Gamecock" i
taking sides.
The extensive use of invectiv
utilized by the editorial staffi
becomes a newspaper with th
reputation of "The Gamecock.
To illustrate, from the editorii
p)ages of "The Gamecock" (Fel
ruary 1st), those favoring segr<
gation are "a hard core of resisi
ance" who want to live in
"sheltered 'Southern' world," whi
will persecute those who befrien
Clemson College's first Negri
Harvey Gantt, whose collectiv
heads are in the sand, who ar
immature, blinded 'by emotioni
distortions, seeking relief in ey
tremism, and whose letters
"The Gamecock" are not worth
of a reply.
By contrast, those who agre
with the present newspaper polic
in favoring integration (agai
from the editorial pages of "Tli
Gamecock") are "the leaders of
new age," "living In a world<
change and progress," matur
responsible, and so on ad nai
scum. Such invective and abut
is a cheap and unworthy form<
Polemics, unfair to those againi
whom it Is directed, reflectin
unfavorably against those wli
use It.
If the rationale for integratio
is so deficient that its proponeni
must resort to name-calling I
present a forceful argument, the
It is questionable whether or n<
the rationale is even worthy c
consideration. Further, It Is bt
simple courtesy to accord respet
for those whose views are dli
ferent, such courtesy being a tru~
appreciation of the constitutioni
guarantee of freedom of speecd
In view of the above Illustration
the issue arises with reference t
the second statement, whethe c
Exchunge
Corner
"Four years of college and
she's with that stupid banjo."
That's a father's reaction, re
ferring to a senior at the Jni
D versity of Southern California,
Los Angeles.
f "That stupid banjo is really a
stupid guitar," Elaine Gealer
pointed out to The Daily Trajon.
C Miss Gealer, who has performed
V in various Los Angeles clubs, said
t she chose folk singing as a career
v because it has more job oppor
tunities than comparative litera
ture, even though she has main
tained a 3.3 grade average in the
English studies.
e
a Students Get A Break
The Legislative Council of the
College of Arts and Sciences at
E m o r y University, Atlanta,
Georgia, has lifted the limited
r cut regulation affecting freshmen
d and sophomores effecive this fall.
d The Emory W eel quoted Dean
John C. Stephens of the College
as saying the faculty feels stu
dents are mature enough.
The Case of the Unwanted Socks
Gail Minnema, junior at Hood
o College, Frederick, Maryland, had
her suitcase stolen in Baltimore
after spending a weekend at
Johns Hopkins University.
The thief was apprehended after
he peddled Gail's Jewelry and
while he was trying to sell the
suitcase. She recovered most of
her clothing, but one article was
not discovered until the court
hearing.
Someone noticed Gail's knee
high socks on the feet of the thief.
The coed quickly decided she
really didn't want the socks re
turned to her, reported Hood
College's Blue and Grey.
A Gateful Father
Lyrchburg College, Lynchburg,
Virginia has received a $2,000
check from a Japanese business
man who is grateful for the way
his daughter was received at the
school.
The Critograph, campus news
paper, said the check came from
Takeo Kagitani of Kobe, Japan,
whose daughter, Hiromi, grad
uated from the college in 1959.
The college president, Dr. Or
ville Wake, had this to say about
the gift: "It is a marvelous
demonstration of person to per
son international diplomacy and
is particularly exciting from that
point of view."
Et Cetera
.not "The Gamecock" is becoming
na a sop to a distorted viewpoint ...
that of the present editor.
- Signed,
- Al Moses
U. S. C. Law School
5
s Dear Editor:
y In reference to the letter writ
- ten by Mr. Ben Boyd, I agree that
s it is very unfortunate that a let
ter of this type must be
e answered, but I applaud your
[1 honest and responsible stand on
e the matter.
Mr. Boyd has again proved
Ii imself to be an impressive wielder
Sof words in his condemnation of
"The Gamecock's" so-called "bad
taste," irresponsibility, and lack
a of "sane and rational journal
o ism."
d .However, I find that Mr. Boyd
6, is in no position to judlge what is
e or is not good taste. During this -
e year's orientation program, I, a
bl freshman, was afforded the p)rivi
-lege of being in a group led by
o Mr. Boyd. In one of the lecture
y periods, he began a vital discus
sion on the history of the Uni
e versity.
y During the course of the talk,
n while dwelling on Reconstruction
e (lays, he found it necessary to
a make a clever generalization
*f about all Negroes, than and now.
~,It was met with much laughter
and after this all interest in the
e history talk was diverted into the
.f breathless wait for Mr. Boyd's
t next witticism.
g This very personal, trite, andl
o prejudiced statement caused Mr.
Boyd's white-superiority complex
n to shine biliously vivid. The
s comm'.snt was completely out of
o ple.ce and in the poorest of taste.
n He has in this incident and
t with his rather fierce letter that
f insults the intelligence of "The
t Gamecock" staff, sunk to a ne(w
t low level to use his own wordIs
-in biased and irrational ab)use.
e In a burst of human indigna
LI tion, I might say I hope this
.gifted bird will not continue to
;, crow so Inanely.
0 Sincerely yours,