The gamecock. (Columbia, S.C.) 1908-2006, December 17, 1954, Page Page Two, Image 2
Letters to the Edit
Who's Wh4
McElveen,
Deear Editor,
Every year one or more de
serving people are not listed in
Who's Who, and every year some
indignant senior feels he must
write the Gamecock expressing
his, or her, concern. The present
method of selection is far from
perfect, and I'm sure any con
structive suggestions would be
appreciated. The author of the
article in last week's Gamecock,
however, is apparently not too
well informed and was a bit care
less with his remarks. So, I
must make a feew comments.
In the first place, if my con
cerned friend had read the whole
article instead of just looking at
the list of names, he might see
that both students and faculty
composed the committee. Ac
tually, the faculty made the final
selections using nominations from
the studEnts. It would be unfair
to leave it to the faculty entirely
because they don't know many of
the students personally. Conse
quently, they couldn't judge per
sonality and character.
In regard to his question con
cerning the kind of academic
record considered, I believe the
people selected were above aver
age scholastically. However, that
is not the prime factor in my
opinion, even though I am very
proud of him for not sacrificing
his "high academic standing."
But the things which particu
larly annoyed me were the state
ments regarding the student
noninating committee. I hap
pened to be on that committee.
purely by virtue of office. Yes.
I am grateful to say I was
named for the honor, but I'd like
to make it very clear to you that
my name was not included on my
list of nominations, and I'm sure
that was true generally. Further
more my selections were based
on my knowledge of the people
involved, not on their fraternity.
Perhaps I am too resentful of
"Friend's" inferenices to make
sense right now, and can talk to
him more logically later if he
cares to discuss it further.
My name is not "Withheld by
Request," and lie can find me at
the address below.
Dan McIntyre
Ten. 22, Rm. 2
* * *
Comrade McElveen
Dear Editor,
Comrade Ben McElvcen is try
ing to create a problem where
none exists. Walter White has
<aiid that no one but a person of
low mentality would d1esire to
alttend( the University of South
(Carolina. Certainly then, any
Negro who appIlies for admission
here does so without White's
end1(orsemenlt. Since W a I t e r
White is the unconteste'd rep)s
resentative of Negro opinion, it
is evident that everyone is satis
fied with th tau quo except
lIen McElveen.
What then is the reason for
McRiveen's sudden agitation? I
can find no sensible reason for
it. If he is trying to elevat.e his
soul or something of the sort,
what kind of a soul does a man
have who would gladly subhject
his fellow students to what would
he a highly tense, even explosive,
situation to satisfy his own prim,
smu~gr standards of morality? Is
it possibh. that he just wants to
irritate his fellow students? He
would he doing most Negroes no
lavor b)y inciting them to attend
this school. The standards are
CROWING F4
UNIVERSITY OF
MIesber of Associ
Foundd fanaryv 30, 1908, wIti
editor, "fbe. Gscoe" La pubi
Uaiversiy of Somth Carolina we
ear es ende and dui
by colma
efl er. of 'rb. Onsecock.
endee.eet. The right to edit
EDITOR ..........
MANAGING EDITOR
BUSINESS MANAGER
ASSISTANT MANAGING)1
NEWS EDITOR
CAMPUS EDITOR
SPORTS EDITORS
SOCIETY EDITOR
FEATURE EDITOR
CIRCULATION MANAGER
ASSISTANT BUSINESS M~
BUSINE
Kat Anthony, Carol
STAFF R
Bertha Gardner, Doina Hal
Babb, Dianne Woodside, Son
Derhamn, Louise Matthews,
Herbert Bryant, Wray Davis
hart, Carol Shockey, Pat Loni
COLU
A1 Tison. T. E. Brown,
or
5 Selecto
Tison Drav
high and so is the percentage of
failures.
One is lEd to wonder what
induced Ben McElveen to enter
what he considers such a "back
ward," "asinine" and "stubbornly
prejudiced" university. Surely he
was aware of these features
when he entered!
If McElveen feels that he
would benefit personally from
association with Negroes on a
cultural plane, I suggest that he
transfer immediately to either
Allen or Benedict University. I
am not altogether convinced
that he would be accepted as an
equal there, but I believe that
he would find the experience
highly illuminating.
My belief, incidentally, is that
the "Separate But Equal". doc
trine is best for South Carolina
at the present time.
Bill Bolt
Dear Sir:
I see that Ben MeElveen in his
column has seen fit to reopen
the sore question of desegrega
tion. I hope that I may be able
to disinfect, if not heal, the
wounds.
MeElveen seems to be quite
sincere in his opinions, as he
should be. Though his views are
interesting, iteration and re
iteration, repetition and more
repetition, do not constitute
proof. He fails to show how the
few facts he cites prove that the
university should end segrega
tion. All change is not progress.
He professes to be "broad
minded" and "foresighted," two
admirable characteristics, yet he
heaps all manner of printable
abuse on those who have an
honest difference of opinion. Is
this fair?
I agree with McElveen's idea
that it might be wise to have
the students dide the question.
I suggest that a poll of all the
students should be taken to
determine their views. The poll
last spring by the Gamecock
showed that about three-fourths
of those who answered by mail
favored segregation. MeElveen
says that if the majority does not
agree with him. "they must step
as ide." If the majority does
agree with him, I believe that
they shouhl be permitted to re
main, nevertheless, being "en
dowed with life, liberty, and the
pursuit of happiness," by the
I)eClaration of Independence.
Though I hate to say this, I
would like to venture one opinion.
I consider this article one of the
%%orst examples of racial bigotry
(violent and intolerant opinion),
that I have seen lately. I am
sorry to have to say this.
Sincerely,
John Harllee
Trison's Column
D)ear Editor,
Not only has Mr. Tison been
"left at the starting line while
unconsidering sinners go charg
ing down the race track of sue
eess," but I dlon't think he knows
which way to run. It's unfortu
nate' that so-called Christians
dlon't seem to have the vaguest
idea of where Christianity starts
and where it leads to.
-A goodl Christian is one who is
Christ-like. From this we catn
see that there isn't a good Chris
tian in the town of Columbia. So
we leave off any adjectives; do
the best we can and call our
selves Christians.
Starting from this premise I
~coc&L
)R A GREATER
SOUTH CAROLINA
aged Coliegiate Press
Robert Elliott Cosnales as the fbst
shed by and for the students of the
ekly, en Fridays, during the eollege
-Ig ez==mlnntlons.
aitt ad letter writers are not neces
Pnblihinag does not entitnte ae
BILL LEGGITi
JACK BASS
D. J. SALLEY
t,DITOR Betsy Ehrhardt
Patsy Penney
Carolyn McClung
Bobby Alford, Mike Lovejoy
Joanne Carnes
Dew James
Al Tison
ANAGER Billy Bruce
SS STAFF
Shockey, Jack Bourne.
EPORTERS
le, Margaret Bauknight, Carole
Ia Riffle, Myrna Ritchey Clare
Barbara Driver, Kleran .'rihey,
,Sue Furbeck, Mary Alice Car
gmire, Kat Anthony.
MNISTS
:tan MElveen. o aheron.
Defended;'.
C ..
7 Criticism
would consider it reasonable for
someone who calls himself a
Christian to read the Bible and
get a few basic concepts of what
it mean; to'be a Christian.
After reading Mr. Tison's edi
torial, I came to the conclusion
that he has a very poor knowl
edge of how a Christian should
act, think or be.
He states, " . . . how can a
man rightly consider the people
who will be lojing money . . .
when he is selling stocks on the
exchange in order to retain faith
in himself, since his success de
pends on his ability to make
money."
In other words, "dog eat dog
and every man for himself."
Christ says, "Are not two
sparrows sold for a farthing?
and one of them shall not fall on
the ground without your Father.
Fear ye not therefor, ye are of
more value than many sparrows."
Matt. 10: 29, 31.
Again he says, "And why take
ye thought for raiment? Con
sider the lilies of the field, how
Lhey grow; they toil not, neither
do they spin: And yet say I
unto you, that even Solomon in
all his glory was not arrayed like
one of these." Matt. 6:29.
I wouldn't worry so much
about being a success, Mr. Tison.
If I were a Christian I'd take
Christ at his word and trust him
to take care of me. Now I don't
mean by that that you should sit
back and do nothing; (1o your
best and He'll (1o the rest.
Mr. Tison also asks, " . . . is it
worth while to ask for forgive
ness for things that we can't be
sure are sins.
Wouldn't it be more Christ
like to worry about whether or
not we have remembered to ask
forgiveness for all the sins we
,have committed ? I can guaran
tee Mr. rison, as well as anyone
else reading this, that they have
sinnel innumerable times this
very day. For instance, one of
the commandments given us was
that we should love the Lord our
God with all our heart, and with
all our soul, and with all our
mind, and our neighbors as our
selves. Which one of you have
(lone that this day?
You may say, "What's the use
of trying at all?"
Well, that's part of being a
Christian. It would be absolutely
hopeless if it wasn't for Christ.
In John 3:16, 17 it says "For
God so loved the world that he
gave his only begotten Son, that
whosoever believeth in Him
should not perish, but have ever
lasting life. For God sent his
Son into the world not to con
dlemn, but that the worldl through
him might be saved."
I could go on, Mr. Tison, and
quote the entire Bible to you,
but I wvouldl much prefer that
you readi it yourself. You sound
like a crazy, mixed-up kid when
you say, "Howv can one enjoy
college' and follow such exacting
rules ? D)oes it include dlrinkjng
beer? Glad, sounds awful !"
Your p)rob)lem is a lot bigger
than that!
Sincerely, -
Robert Karl
l)ISCwise at D)OWN BEAT'
POPU1LAR: Leroy Anderson
"Sandpaper Ballet" (Decca)...
Old1 shuffle beat with new gim
mick . . . makes for easy listen
ing; Tony Martin-"My Bamn
bino," "Restless Heart"...
(RCA ) "Blambino" is grade A
lullaby material; Judy Garland
"Have Yourself a Merry Little
Christmas," "You'll Never Walk
Alone" (Decca) . . . "Christmas"
is simply and tastefully done.
JAZZ: Dave Brubeck-"Dave
Brubeck at Storyville: 1954"
(Columbia 12" LP~ CL 590) Per
formance all the way through is
magnificent; Kid Ory-"Musk
rat Ramble," "When the Saints
Go Marching In" (Good Time
Jazz EP 45092) Authoritative
version of "Muskra,t" by the man
who wrote it.
(CLASSICAL: L,eonardl Bern
stein-"Symphony No. 6" by
Tchaikovsky (Decca DL9718 12").
Bernstein conducts the Stadium
Concerts Symphony Orchestra of
New York. Robert Casadesus
"Piano Concertos Nos. 24 and
21;." by Mozart (Columbia
M14901 12") Casadesus with Col.
Symphony Orchestra, George
Szell conducting.
"Here comes Smedley, no
on his exam."
JACK BASS
Who's Who
DeservinA
An unidentified someone made'
some rather biting remarks
about the selections of Who's
Who in last week's Gamecock.
He had some good points, too,
but was way off base on other
points.
We can't agree with him at all
in half-accusing the students
named to the committee of push
ing forward their own names.
These studcnts were chosen to
help with the selection purely
because of offices they held, of
fices of honor and trust. I doubt
very seriously if any of the five
put their name on their lists of
nominations.
But there is a question of
which officers on campus should
submit lists. For example, the
"Y" had two votes with the YW
and YM being represented. On
the other hand, none of thv three
men's honor organizations were
represented, although A 1 1) h a
Kappa Gamma, woMen's honor
service sorority, was represented.
AKG should gct a vote because
it can help recognize just who is
outstanding and deserving enough
to be honored. For the same rea
son, Blue Key, ODK, and KSK
should have gotten a vote. Not
jnst to get some of "their boys"
Frank Sina
Down B(
Frank Sinatra swept the male
singer sweepstakes in the 19th
"Down Beat" Annual Readers'
Poll by the largest vote in the
history of the selections. Just a
few short years ago practically
forgotten and unsung, the former
Tommy Dorsey bandsinger is
now back on the heap again. Now
on Capitol llecords he has had
several hits this year, along with
many successful albums and his
Academy Awvard winning per
formance in a nion-singing role in
"From Here To Eternity," along
with his television shots, have
all added to the tremendous
build-up wvhich even exceeds that
which he had in the early '40's.
Stan Kenton took first place in
the Hall of Fame classification
which found Duke Ellington and
Benny Goodman runners-up. In
the second-year-in-a-row running
slot Ella ,Fitzgerald won the
female singer plaque andl Stan
Kenton took another award for
the jazz band. Dave Brubeck not
only won the small combo hat
again, hut also won the Top Jazz
P'ersonality along with coming in
second to Oscar Peterson in the
p)iano classification. Lee Brown
repeated in the dance band divi
sion while The Four Freshmen
swept the Vocal Groups. Top
Pop Female Personality rightly
went to Rosemary Clooney andi
Lucy Ann Polk, and Tommy
Mercer again won the top band
singer roles. Ruth Brown won
the R&B Top Personality andi
Perez Prado, Top Latin-American
Personality.
Making up the 18th All-Star
hand are Chet Baker, trumpet;
Bill Harris, trombone; Charlie
Parker, alto sax; Stan Getz,
tenor sax; Gerry Mulligan, bari
tone sax; Buddy D)e Franco,
clarinet; Oscar Peterson, piano;
Ray Brown, bass; Johnny Smith,
guitar; Shelly Manne, drums;
Terry Gibbs, vibes; Art Van
Damme, accordion; andI arranger,
Pete Rugulo. Miscellaneous In
strument headings were won by
Don Elliott, mellophone; John
Graas, French horn; Bud Shank,
flute, Candido, bongos andi Oscar
Pettiford, cello.
POP NEWS-For what is
believed a first, the winner of
the "Down Bat" sngwrting
w; let's ask him how he did
Overlooks
r Student
in but to see that deserving stu
dents who may not be active in
the "Y" or student government
-not be overlooked.
The other five votes belong to
the student body president, honor
board president, and deans of
men, women, and faculty. YMCA,
YWCA and AKG votes make a
total of eight.
But in last week's letter, the
nail was cracked on the head
when Nameless said, "Actually,
most of the students are worthy
of such an honor. Then there
were a fcw who weren't."
There was at least one senior
on this campus who should not
have been left out and probably
more. This particular man is
currently president of a men's
honor fraternity, has headed
several important planning com
mittees in the past, has grades
in the top 10 per cent of his
class, works over 15 hours a
week, holds a high elective post
on campus, and is past president
of his fraternity. He was not
named to Who's Who, however.
We do not question the integ
rity of any of the selectors but
do feel that representation is
poorly distributed.
tra Sweeps
tat's Poll
contest, an ex-GI, has been
signed to a major recording com
pany, not as a composer, but as
a performer. Glenn Vandall, who
has been singing under the pro
fessional name of Tommy Rock
well for the past six months, was
pactedl by Joe Delaney, general
manager of Label "X," RCA sub
sidiary, last month as a singer
...Les Paul and Mary Ford are
taking a European jaunt. Cou
ple's four-day-old daughter diad
Nov. 29 . . . Guy Lombardo is
filming a television series of 39
with guest stars called "Guy
Lomibardo and His Royal Canad
ians" . . . Mood music is really
coming into its own with RCA
reporting more than a million
copies of its Mood series sold
last year . . . Pete Rugulo broke
up) his orchestra, after a very
promising start, because of lack
of work but may re-form if he
hits with a record or two . . . Lee
G;ordon andl Benn Reyes are
bringing Nat Cole dIown under
into Australia for his first tour
there, starting Jan. 4 for twc
weeks for a reported $40,000.
JAZZ BEATS-Two memorial
sessions for the late Hot Lipr
Page raised $5,000 for his family
. . . Stan Kenton's first discovery
for Capitol Records under his
plan for discovering talent is the
Al Belietto Trio, which he re
cordled in Chicago . . . Gus
Cousinaeu has joined the Muggsy
Spanier group as drummer..
Also on the changing front Gene
Krupa replaced Teddy Napolenr
at the piano with Bobby Scott ..
Candido has been added to the
Sarah Vaughan, Count Basle
Erroll Garner, George Shearing
andl Lester Young package whicl
starts on tour Feb. 11 for r
month . . . With Phil Urso re
placing Russ Freeman In the
Chet Baker combo, it's hopefu
that many of the old Gerry Mul
ligan arrangements will comi
forth again . . . Epic Records i
coming out with an "Epic ii
Jazz" series this year includinj
a Bunny flerrigan Memorial al
bum among others . . . Osca
Peterson Trio will do back
groundl music for the animate<
film, "Finlan's Rainbow," now I1
prodluction . . . Duke Ellingto1
has been set for a European tout
starting the end of February o
DEW JAMES
Coeds In K
ResembIeW
THE LATEST FAD, namely
knee-socks wearing among co
eds "Just ain't got it" according
to an unofficial poll of the men
who look at 'em on campus.
As a representative of popular
male sentiment, we quote Jack
(Christian Dior) Bass, noted
authority on women's wearing
apparel, from North (Yeah
that's a town): "These 'long
johns' make co-eds look like war
orphans . . . considerably so when
their altitude reaches above the
nether regions of the skirt."
However, the Northman does not
frown upon knee-sock wearing
with Bumuda shorts. This time
of year seems a bit chilly for
Bumuda shorts.
* * *
It must have been a Christmas
tree . .. It was last Monday and
raining. We were on our way to
our 2:00 o'clock class when down
the walk we heard such a squeak
ing, we immediately halted and
started peeping. And there it
was-a co-ed with a cedar, all
of two and a half feet long. This
didn't trouble us too much, but
the squeaking did.
On nearer view, we saw that
she pulled behind something re
sembling a grocery cart. In it,
packages. Maybe she was play
ing Santa Claus to her big
sisters. She looked like a
pledge.
T. E. BROWN
McCarthy
Is Propaga
In answer to Mr. Steve
Roberts, self-named "True Amer
ican," who last week took issue
with this author about the other
"True American," Joseph Mc
Carthy, let us begin with congra
tulations to him on being, at any
rate, a true and perfect disciple
of Mr. McCarthy. We extend
these congratulations because it
is quite evident from his letter
that he has become a complete
and helpless victim of the egoti
stical and emotional propaganda
which we attacked in the column
that so aroused Mr. Roberts.
Taking Mr. Robert's stand
paragraph by paragraph let us
say first that regardless of his
disbelief in the American system
of bringing criminals to justice
there are some others besides Joe
wvho are fighting Communism
while at the same time maintain
ing the-basic American principles
of liberty andi due process. At
Mr. Robert's request we name
a fewv such as Mr. Eisenhower,
Mr. Hoover, members of the
FBI and the Justice Department.
Thus far these are the ones who
have been most responsible for
the jailing of Communists.
Mr. Roberts urged that we not
make a hasty dlecision about Mr.
McCarthy and claims that those
who are not "prejudiced against"
McCarthy have thought the issue
out thoroughly and therefore
come logically to his support. We
should ask Mr. Roberts if in
making his decision for Mc
Carthy he has bothered to list
extensively the methods usedl by
McCarthy in his so-called fight
against Communism. After mak
ing such a list we should dare
him to venture over to McKissiek
Library andl draw from its
shelves several books: one giving
a history of Hitler's rise to
power, one covering Mussolini's
dlictatorship, and one relating
the methods usedi by the Coin
munists in gaining control in
Russia. This author made such
a comparison almost a year ago
and the parallel between Mc
Carthy's tactics and those of
Hitler, Mussolini, and Lenin (and
his successors) was surprising,
to say the least. It easily dlecided
the issue for us.
ICollegiate
Add "Hazards" of
Night Driving...
LO)S ANGELES - (.'CP) -..
Tintedl automobile windshieldls
can be a significant haza'd to
night driving, according ithainz,
SHaber, UCLA professor :n trans
portation andi traffic fnginner
,ing.
r Studies have ind cated t ont
nee Socks.
arOrphans
On the subject of St. Nick
We were in journalism lab the
other day seriously discussing
the errors in the latest ed%on
of "The Old Proof Press,' ex
perimental journalism school
student newspaper, when the
relatively normal calmness and
quite of the classroom was en
vaded by hearty peals of laugh-*
ter from the jolly old elf, lurking
in the halls. The bold fellow
wandered with no hesitation into
class with a package for the
dean, and made his exit with as
much noise as he entered.
. . C
JUST TOO PRETTY-Accord
ing to "The Bulletin," State
Teachers College student news
paper at Emporia, Kan., Miss
Joan Gavin, frcshman at .Kan
sas University, has complained
because 1,200 male !IVents
gather daily for whistlin ses
sions as the beauty passes going
to,her 1:00 class.
The president of the student
council at Emporia State offered
Miss Gavin relief from the "em
barrassment and humiliation" by
extending to her an invitation
to transfer to his school. In the
invitation, the president said men
from Emporia State liked to
look at pretty girls but beauties
were not a rarity on his campus.
"In other words," the president
said, "you will be appreciated,
not conspicuous."
Supporter
ada Victim
There are several fallacies in
Mr. Robert's letter which we
must correct. It has been only in
such totalitarian countri. as
Communist Russia that the inno
cent have been thrown into prison
in the hopes of scooping up the
guilty among them. This is not
and never will be a practice of
freedom-loving nations. It is a
standing principle among demo
cratic Americans that' it is much
better to let a number of guilty
men go free than to jail one
innocent person. Mr. McCarthy
does not agree with this because,
as his actions have shown, he is
more interested in the headlines
than in defeating communism.
His appetite is never satisfied
until his victim, guilty or not,
has been drawn and quartered.
Mr. Roberts says that unless
we cultivate more men like
Senator McCarthy and give them
a free rein and full cooperation
we shall become a province of
Russia. To quote Mr. Roberts,
"The average person becomes
sick at the thought of being
under Red rule." Frankly, the
thought of being under Red rule
for some of us is not much more
sickening than the thought of
being under the rule of Mr. Mc
Carthy. Essentially Joe is a
fascist using communism as did
Mussolini and Hitler to rise to
power.
We only hope that it. aver
falls upon Mr. Roberts to be
pe.rsecuted by McCarthy or by
one of his dlisciples for beings
"too true an American." After
all, between the claims of the
KKK and Mr. McCarthy to the
right of being called the guiding
principle of true Americanism,
who knows who is "True" and
who is not? But this is natural
for both of these, for fascists
always claim their country is
their number one love. Mussolini
was the "True Italian," and he
fought communism; Hitler was
the "True German," aml he
fought communism; McCarthy is
the "True American," and he
fights communism. Strange coin
cidence, -we should say (or is
It?), that all three of these have
such similar personalities, but as
the saying goes, "Birds of a
feather flock together."
Clippings
ity at night as nmuch as 415 per .
cent, he saidl.
Trhis is ot only hazardouis,
under ' litions '? low bright
ness e ' y poorly reflecting
targets and'. ,ackcgrounds but it
is also a problem ',r night
driecrs, he said.
Presently the or" . ':ine #
of tintedi windshiel.
ity to absorb radiant 'r it on not