University of South Carolina Libraries
1|J TUESPA^ORN.?, MAHC.r ?JjfiiM ^nV * ? V id .(<?) N.B TlW 40 J-ewf 6W> li U nVmit n fo?< dtredM TSfr^ .fpi? riXjlK ftuUicrtlxf rrtpprtiiillv ln(or^i?iUb |o* JL Cotmfc ""???? ylciolijr, tfill j.tf IwMj. Mjflovert (tyt iiow#Jrt'lo\y iht BU? 4jiTI1m< ?11n>v?* ?. MiflUV nnrt C?on?Uni??^ AjWH Cflt'Mfri! iiM .WMirMttpb J*H nn?nn?r? Mtrfim Mitftv!*f;ici?n?il wltli^m Irtjdrliipc litisIt dcr?L?'jilif.rn tint* llyi <1 Kn<l tbcrttf to look li ?HsW?.. 'Alii $6ufttiy-'jwtiw \vTll lit thankfully rolveJ,tiiH>punctually*Mu?leul-iVt;* V ?.<'>.>?????. /v ).-'i ^SHflkgfincy oKjfmrK-'ATB. ?TATI'.M4KKNlt<VA!tK. WJi Ftbruotft, Ififif,. 7 Wnnw ?f??irtljijpt to Me. rliiiriliVV\tf <?nr?fJornimity n?i die il?ol.? ol. ? Ill# Until:,tli') Intnilrri? (lirxunntl dol T^y amlcton WrEmd Jliirltic tnmraiUt WW? ' it 7 WFTOMWiHPWW1 'W^yya ?? '????.v-.'V-' .? -?:??: <-s S ? $/ M?fr; >j. . .1^1 ? .I'li.lV. ? Vll .1 f * !lfc - m I mas. ?V ' ? ????*???m tStif i?*?, nrhtnr JrSfr m^sm& h>a<l lendinc from ikc>h>tm<v4l??o CdyinMij., ? "ft ? ?.'j ft'1'*' ? ?PBKoiiars ?1H*YKD n ms r<i Mnwn niwen issxssm. ?:iiutin ?irjirftn?i rivor^nno witcvih .*jw wmut MteriiilBtM samssBRB pH&fiWW Junuury 15 / ? A$? fl If W, To OHiLadios! $L ????"?. ? ?f ' '?>'>w>.?.^'t'.'i;v>-'^..-!'x1 >'""">|'?fj'.5. '$', Columbia.?In Equtiy '-'W.? ? -CU-: '# *. aaa wittifn three n^nthl from itie pub1ir.*tlon of then Nov. J0. . *10 St.nlo of 8onc)i Carolina. Jot# iHjatoit > . j, ? ; n. > Attachment \ f||''IIK ritlntinr in tlits m<? h*vlnj* mA hri dtf? . dl rUrnUoti lit the, oflite of thn. Clerk of l!i> <Wv of Common FHw* for>. Ab!?*Ym<M))?tH?tt nn?l ?h#r,^>er^nrf:*hl neither tvlfr m?mU6r n?y hnowhu itItlrt the Ifirtlti rtMiiUmi(?. Order cd tbut li? do |>I?M or demur to tho fkmet w ? !t? n our yeftr nnd n <Ur? or Jfidtntont will turn tered fi#dn?iMm t>y ?wnnj)t., ^:4 /v \|A8. WAflDtAW, C. V. |\ ClffV, OfM ) . .. At.rftrt. lWJO. < Stftlo of South-Carolina, jlnrnvtLLtibisfnicr, K Cdnnor, i y*. > Attach#***', milB ^feitlir tavljMlllft' id* dreUrntlwn In > Jk.i ??*?? ?!#*?, (tt lfiff Cferfcvom? oil till! twenty ZwMk I'm for Atityvtll* liver wife nor nfe .Jn^ment V,!"v %/i 101, the committeo im \n>fiiiMhoil businew, of wjdch liti li.xl itic (lotar of being chnir nun, him oHami\!ly^fflflm?hc(l not to ro?, port the preamble arid rejolutions of hi? Into collciiguo (Iff^rrolenut) Ono^nio. live, Mi - 1-. ?uid, <tbleb bad influenced him "'(in nn apprehension tlv^t ho might iiivji'lniffvlf open to IW* ffcVy imputation of hnving pot up n jflmlit for the more purpoioan5 playing n\nikt; in it, rit' what over expend to (lift Jwf itic?* of tho^Onn try,'?f which loo I bfl/rieglPCttMl, tV^?]jhi?|*trcmrt ihnrtncM of tho , ?CMion. llVit'j^otliur, and more Iflorionf motive, ytftyr hl? scino ol> truth? which hn (Ii4 (lot UW^tO mroiv, byt of wliicli life \vn? nfrunt the future experience of the jouthcrh ?tqtei'i?ioi(hl ioroe upon thcm th?ePrivictlbo moronnd more strong* (y Wflff ?illr?!mly too Into t0 exp0*tuh>tc nnd to rir^o %vitl? >Tiiy hope of cm^t^thM tlio dnv \Vn* forever gono by, wtypn (tie resolution* of n stnto, flouth oh{ip fotonvic, wouM?ho blioiihl iw? n ~ decided influence over die . vf Oils nation; end the iriowuiS?* Sit Iho^vornmpot Ht Wiwbinghuij -lnt( ovmi?bo entertained with any r.ort ">.?* re* thostyito wliir.io hands the sceptre NiiiI tW^honcefWlluthoii l?nst r0,??niv|1?lc romo/Wtinnccs and com pl/dnts would {$ro!^uly ?crvo only to invito ii rebetlttonl'.of injfflU# confessing tlio ^hbiio f^vtikh^ouMftotresjAl it. Ocntlci ninn, therefore, he wa*Mriiid were in the m$m l'K>i wft till* Uitfciitsion wpuW bo JiveliwVbut not for ariy rekfisfa ifoj htd<ut?ed'? h \Yn*"iiralerthelnfldi bnco;of mi% fevljn# and opinion? thwho *" '.tron1ili.it tl?^si> Willi tlio obsorvu: ftKejjfWPIli !?l ?n?!jio..U? reftiy oof fliVt SpoiiUer. .. , -; '.7,1 I'cotnraltteci Mr. Legirc m*iin hiivo rbmhikod, t^vt tiio#c!.^vlip'l tllfl- Mil" innitu Hilt of popular derj.imntlhn ;it ,tli^ n;imc time ih it, whether ?ighl. 01 nrOeg, Uffcj* 'would he firctty sure of lu-infc (rt tjio '^ijjirity 9t the present <1i.y. 7i'lte fuderol goVe^nment h i I, in ????-? respect, CViry ndvjn.hlgc over those of the sjates It ?V?f tt VOry ili.ihinj; object of contetiv plation. lj: wielded ull the energies rirtd resource.* 6f tlio nuti in, ttnd penned tO cjrotffc?, heciuue it dire t?:?l Ami controlled (horn. It wn.i crown <1 with tlio phiry of .the country in War, ami ej^ri the hlcifsed Influence* of jounce feonied; tfry cirianiito fioirt it. \N hiilever tho rfmnwn *?f the nary. nml ttjriiV (lin course of tlio nrtny lind dono to elevsfte tlio n.itinnijf eh a rac.tef ~ wliiit/sver ennobling ii:i:t louching recollec tion* the recent history of 'hi* country'tif fordqd, to kindle the |?;itri'?tJ*m ofiho peo pie, nml to in*firo tlicm with', rt Ibfty pWde. '^U.Opnspireuto nuikothe federal govern ment, the only rcpriwnUivo of,the poo plc iu their foreign rel dioii*, un'l in the er&Vt Interest* of pence mid wnr?-thovoh? jo.ct of popul.ir enlhusiauu and admiration. Such tvere the topics upon which the! SllOnker'liad dwelt. What had he and hi*', friends, v.-ho stood up for the right* of the I stains?t/ie j'fti'/ |tat <?. tii ft gentleman from Newberry (Mr. Caldwoliy hwl coo TerniitUO??ly iiillod them?whnl hrol thoy to oflor, thi\t wn? calculated to strike iJlo iniajtination* of men? Nothing^nbidjuto ly nothing., Tliny cotihlonly *ny, that tlnu ophtndid projectsi, which \lrflrfj lho Order of tho ?hvj, ntid which wofd turroumled *vith nllurerftentii ehouuli ft ull kimh to on t^uro UiO jKjpuliit ity ot any adnnnintratioa, | Hud should ho hold enouili to undertnkc Ihew, wiiuhl btf ac<;o;iiph?he?|'rtt tho 0] penio of the conMitutioii, ami would offd (n? he eoncftived) nothing short of o riy^ lution in tho governinoot, and it tvon^l vory Well, if their poor tlfitii toyfm - thenii were not troi.trd, n< tho rtj#phenU of iomo person* who thought witlt him on thfttfi|1>jeoti hud heen??*, tlio tloiplcnWe (pdhhtlng and werd cntchjog of rrten, who** under.itnnrling^ wet enough to nppfeci.ito \^l?r pfenomption to oppono, ' ' ttrit geutloinen, l?o fftW, floH with the Immense ndi -Litel nivt^tnfition.; T1 Kpir wny to fMk otheif *?r < M ?i& rricp iiv^ipiuv ipiili iTiwrmny U? umjiiuiivi, HV iwlced whether tho*ar who wore'for con verting tho present Hystem Into what would ho in ?fleet n comolidfxted government, by arming It with to miiny additional power*, Hml cngitglng ft tit the pnwuit of Romany now object^ thought Ihtyt the southern iiOn ofcerlnln opinion* there, upon .ceitain soidect* of jloop and vital interest here? H< ftfthl ho could give fhe committee n ppcci mch oftho>o opinion!?ho would remit he t no oxtriict ?Voni n disoourio pubit*h<id nomn iir.-u ngo in n northern city l>y nmnn, ns ho bciiovcd.of loiter*andof talents, a teacher ofyouth ftqa ft preacher of tl.o gospel of tf^Acn. m driV Mr. l.t'gnrc ro;id nil ,0f$ tract from ii sornion of tlto Uov. Protestor I/-??. contfuhingflomc very offensive rind inlliimmntory nviiti!rB,conccr;.inKtho in?ti. lutiofiM ot tho Southern Stutou.] When tliny saw su<& effort* miulO to poison ttiQ miti4.t9 of oii'o pnrt oft ho A met lean people i?$;)lnft nneiher?whort they .know -that nupli opinions/ were inculcated in v sOtrio j parts-nt least, of tho northern state.*, in a studied and ayitcmuUc manner, nud that tho1 ripo^loi And |>fOiK^indirtls of tho snme ana. ftiifiiipy nridjacoyinlcul crecd, wore every *vl?at hini ilto Houiliorh'siAies tV>V pcol from a government ? t|iiit should boi iin.fr-r llio inlloetiee nrid direction1 of 4Xicl? -non, ifif wcifj dijflorfld to jrn'pddjbin uny.wnv Wfiatovor with the Internal concornj.of the iiAW.it \Vhaii ho re,* Mted, .had t>? .?sport whO'n.-'pttW n?en; nad tlio'forming ol {rami* opinion. in tho inpst papulon*; rind ppwoi ful plirt of; H|i? confederation rind tho u':.inii?t* np pfyhft VoiiM? wtio .worn nt somfr iu)<tV6 & to dl?c$tV4t* ftw^tfrcs-^men, .SIr. !.. said; tvliripo nvnwcd hostility to <0tithorh interest* rind'. iniliiutioy, wn* onlycqnullpd Uy tliC pVcAiirT)ptiions^B| Wore so um<;h heated upon these suhjcCfn ? (or it tva* charity to consider them as f.mat ir.s-r t hat Jhpy rtdemdd to bo altogether rccklefi of the nruipe.^idiie evils, which their doctVltie?*l)Hn somanl f.'M n tendency to producri throughout the vyhole cduntry, frriin,tbe I'otom^ctb tho Mississippi. ilOsidd, honover, ho djd not mo in toijtit tiuiate that such werdnt present, tlio,opiiv ion* m\<l fcolings.of n majority ol the peo ple oftlio uorthrifrn state?, or oven ofiifty considerable porlionof them. lie certain*! |y hoped?-he was willing to. believe, tliuy! Mero not, but. who could #:iy what t'hOjf wnuhl bcoojno-iti'.tho cour.'c ofa fow your*, and.he.though!that ftriy .one who would look buck rit what had heort Oio progress of opinion upon this subject-, within Ilia last* thirty Vears.tyouM seo good ren?on for.rin* ticipat mg the worst for the sou them states. At all events, one tbiny wns V0*y plniti from tho considerations which ho had sug gested, ili.tt there was deep wisdom in the jealousy entertained upon tfriji sutyecf, by some of the lending men la those state* in *07 and '?tt?tbat the same jealousy ofcght now to animate alt those who think (at ho trusted tho majority nt leant, of the com* mittpo dw) that flouthern right* ami south* eru jmercsts could be unlo only under thii di?fio*tal and control of southern govern* (ifonts. 'fell me not of confidence, wild Mr. I.r^aro, jlicrc is no such word <n poli tics imd erpccially in the uOliticl of it free people. Tho whojo analofiy of 0t)r>j(0* vcrninont, U against it. What is tlio fun: damcnUt nrlnclple of thtl government? As. is that no frisn shall make tho l^w, yifok not to bo inject to tho lnw? rind that overy distinct interest u to be fiilly repreftkftted ore hot tho state courts, tho jtulpcea Ich aro ?U swoin to maintain thst con ion, and presumed to bo honest iW . i. ,f< <- W *rW) ?. . v.vyi 91; ^ >T P? ~ f/ .P I iW" ??V?nt?/lHoeon(MSfiloii?' Mmm 3W&&&0HRS3S down before the nmjoaty of tho law with us profound: an homage, wild yielding to it Almost M ready nbij implicit on obedience, fit limt ever boon oxtortedfcytji- j^l^J duijpotmri. >Af?l <i nil forbid th mwfyor ?ay; ptMmmrfy of tldrigs nt Obce, to beheflcinli cf tilings nt ooce, ?obehe(l. Hut He thought itcOuld be cosily that the excellehctes of otyr nnd.ovrn its theoretical' ' ^y from t ho fact thrift; w<i* republics, end hot; a gig ' * ' mm mdrdmioiprK try* vylierc it wpuhl lmve ions of* one part ofib MihjocU. tlin'oi cnt f? oin thoieofiM 't tlSvfttoy were now becoming: iu tli onlybo? uiMhoy wore now becoming * ii holding wd norv?l.wo holding ?l <:one?lrtiibly imil owft Vehement^ on mnltcru llu? latter And hero Ue AaiflV remark, that whOn lie j?i?o|t4re? m 'coijRqii<l?tioi).>'he'<Ua- not^mctn WMt, jbat Ijbftro rn* danger Ipflt the ftide^l' tf>r veynmonti n? such, should ?widlow upt<?tf ;tlf0 '* vri imi'.in, nu iuui, ?ii?uiu an.nnny u|? tlm Kile government*; bqt WhM-tyiwmi *n* (p ho approhondnd was, le?t h majority of 4lie ?tales, or the more power/MtW#, <houU attempt to lr*ji|?i** uuon the right* ihould attempt to JrjMjmft* upon thu right* ofotbor#;rA?o?w/^f/^w(^Hfi;?'N??i, whioUihiB committee would Horc.dvo wan ,.-' quite M ilifip.f^ '^ tUj^ig In ?* mo.t conruimnbi. (o il., ifw jl.roi He.aMW.IiJoro.M point* had been very much abridged by.i _ *pecth, of tbo gentleman from Yorfc,2W*; Smith,) who opened tlie debate, efcTI.ed brought into it, w usdal, ? great ma?* of information. Iteremlndedthe commiUco pf.n curious fact which had been hife*^ fitod by ft gehtlcmnrt from Keridtaw (Mr. Nixon,) from Vftjiei* Secret- Jo u ronl oHho Convention- Thin w? the #e??rlit of*#, Charles I'incknoy, lo the justne*. offftrfefa all tho delegate* had assented, that the powers they hmt reeved fi;om the states, weiiit no roHher tmfi'ie reform tlil?olderf tidies t*f confalerHtion/hndnot to build Op n new government. Ho said *lic samo thing was plain from the constitution Itiejf ?from the precise nod painstakingenume. . ration of certain powers, which if tbo reasoning on' the other side were correct,, Itftd been more labor lostr~the nvwt u** meting end nugatory Wtfmi u?at dould tftlmtflW. fie M !io7fo.,bt hirmelf ' that the present government differ* froji| . the eld confederation, not' In the ** Of its powe^iut ohly in their tfflctf I do, tho>ftiwet wodld ho the same now | voytd haVe been then' (frUKjhe " iopiion. of. comtteMliil tegutji , iefttjli It tvoultt $* different p VtueMioii was liou> itS.Wg^ citrricdMhto eflfcetj Jfi', onty difference bet?fr^ - jsjt^la exWpUon jai " i ' Imp I yJt.-,